This place just isn't good. I feel like I go here when I feel sorry for myself. The pizza is just regular pizza dough seems like it was premade or frozen and the cheese is just too much. The Italian grinder consisted of various meats that should have just been called bologna, sliced way too thick. When I got home at had to add more vinegar to it. Also no onions which I find weird for an Italian grinder combo. I guess I could've asked. I moved closed by I'll be back, but just cause it's convenient. The service window is nice I guess. read more

Teddy's Old Lyme Pizza Palace - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Old Lyme, Connecticut

See all

I promise to take pictures next time. Just know you should eat here if you like Greek style pizza!!

After trying to eat somewhere on the beach it was a disaster but I had this gem saved on here just encase. So we came right on over since we wanted to eat dinner tonight. Pizza was actually really good. Our son had fun eating here or I should say being here. Outside, divey kind of place, he could dance, play and bother no one lol. To bad he doesn't eat pizza and he's picky with his pasta so he didn't eat much but he had fun. You order from a window and get your food, simple. We're from Long Island so us liking pizza here is a huge compliment. I'd definitely recommend this place. read more

Teddy's Old Lyme Pizza Palace - a man standing in front of a restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Old Lyme, Connecticut

See all

Good pizza!! Friendly service! The online ordering was a nice touch. Great little spot to hit up while camping.

I Grew up in old Lyme eating, and hanging with my friends at the Pizza Palace. Teddy and his family were always very friendly to us local kids. They would let us chill there for hours on the cold winter days/evenings. Many times it would be 2-4 kids on a single large order of fries, and always using way more ketchup than should be consumed in one sitting. Thanks for the great memories "Teddys Old Lyme Pizza Palace." read more

Pizza was like school cafeteria pizza. No bathroom use, even for customers. And all while you get to sit next to a busy street, inhaling fumes from the vehicles passing by. read more

I stopped in once on a recommendation from someone about their chicken wings. I called in an order for takeout. I did not realize they were dry rubbed & baked. I thought they were good but not great. I actually really love traditional deep fried chicken wings, however horrible they are for you - (Fortunately I order them every once in a blue moon). Anyway, I tried a sub once, a year or so ago & it was fine but not memorable. I tried to give them another chance. Their food is not bad, It's just not REALLY GOOD. I am also concerned based on what I have seen, that their pizza dough is frozen Cosco or the like. It's just not a place that makes food that is compelling enough for me to return. read more

Tastiest food and lots of choices. Teddy and his team are the best and also friendliest in town!

Wings are soooo good! We love crispy, not wet wings and these were perfectly cooked! Pizza has a nice crisp (not droopy) crust and tasted amazing! Everyone who ordered a grinder said they were good as well-they ordered Meatball, Italian & Eggplant-Ordering is quick and easy on the app. It's all take out -which is fine. We don't mind that at all. They made dietary accommodations for our son which is nice. Would highly recommend! read more

Delicious Pizza every time. The price is very fair for the quality. I highly recommend this this restaurant. I've gone there whenever I'm in old Lyme read more

The food is ok. Friendly staff. Take out only. No indoor dining even though they have a dining room. Mid clean.

I tried teddys for the first time today. The pizza is solid greek pizza, but really small for a large. I thought they gave me the wrong order when i picked it up. The small salad was pretty small and basic, but they did have good creamy Italian. It's a shame the portion sizes aren't bigger. You would need 2 large pizzas to feed a family of 4 and probably have very little leftovers if any. It's also in a very tun down area, so many other businesses around it are shut down or dingy looking. read more

Teddy's Old Lyme Pizza Palace - a pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Old Lyme, Connecticut

Been coming down to South Lyme area for years, Teddy's is not only a staple and not to miss place the food is ALWAYS consistently good! Pizza wings subs you name it good quality ingredients! read more

Consistency in quality and service. Not much to chose from in Old Lyme so we definitely appreciate Teddys.

Menu is impressive, food is not. Pretty expensive for what it is. Salads were a joke. Pizza was ok. Portions were small which would be fine if the food was executed well. Overall a beach 'institution' but there are better. read more

This is just about the best pizza you will find nearby. The only problem is that they don't deliver. Break down and take a drive. read more

Teddy's Old Lyme Pizza Palace - My little best friend. - Pizza Near Me - Old Lyme, Connecticut

Stopped in for an impromptu dinner on the road. Interior is super cute. Warm, diner-like atmosphere decorated with flags from European soccer teams. Staff was very friendly and there seemed to be a lot of regulars there. The food was ok. Meatballs were pretty basic. Not anything special. Roast beef salad was pretty disappointing. Am I insane to be surprised when white iceberg lettuce forms the basis of a salad? It was also unexpectedly covered in cheese. Fries were decent but your standard frozen crinkle cuts. My husband got the 12" pepper steak grinder which he said was delicious and positively stuffed with meat. You can definitely do better for the money. read more

Teddy's Old Lyme Pizza Palace - Roast beef salad - Pizza Near Me - Old Lyme, Connecticut

Staple of Old Lyme...for generations! Teddy's most authentic OL experience you can have! Teddy is loved by all who know him and the greatest guy! OL a small town and we're all friend with one another- we keep it positive and super friendly ! Enjoy the ambiance and dont forget to try the rice pudding! Hopefully you'll visit for a quick lunch or great dinner and you'll love it as much as we have forever and will have a great story to go home with to share of your time here! read more

Ordered chicken gyro... Clearly marked on receipt got the beef kind of disappointed... Was really looking forward to having the chicken that's what I paid for and didn't get it read more

It isn't the fact that I live probably less than a mile from here that I gave it 5 stars. Nope, that's not it at all! The fact that I live the less than a mile away and the food is freakin' insanely delicious... yeah, that's the reason! I have been getting grinders there, ordered their eggplant parm but the other day, topped it all. (No pun intended)...you'll see what I mean in a minute. My niece was here visiting with her husband and three kids. When I asked them what they would like for dinner, I was instantly inundated with the reply, PIZZA!!! Oddly enough, I had never ordered pizza from Teddy's. That was a silly mistake!! We ordered one large cheese for the kiddos and got a little fancier with the one for the adults. We ordered sautéed onions, mushrooms, eggplant and chicken on our pizza...scrumdelicious!!! Ok. So obviously this is a glowing, high recommendation, especially because I used the word "scrumdelicious". I even spelled it right!!! read more

Ordered buffalo chicken pizza and a side salad. Side salad was fine, basic side salad. Honestly disappointed for the price. About $20 in total. There wasn't much chicken on the pizza.. was hoping for a little more! read more

This is just about the best pizza you will find nearby. The only problem is that they don't deliver. Break down and take a drive.

Tiny pizzas that are expensive! The place also looks like a highway billboard. Why not clean-up the facade and make it more appealing? It's worse than Coney Island! read more

Great Greek Pizza Diner. The owner and staff here are really great folks. Easy to talk to. The meat lovers pie was chock full of goods. The Greek style crust was spot-on. The place has a neat ambiance and is very clean. They have a lot of to go business so you can assume the goods are fresh. They have draft beer and wine. Not a bad walk from the beach. read more

See all

Honestly? One of the best pizzas I've had since I moved from Chicago to the East (sadly no positive pizza experiences in Pennsylvania yet). Two things that make this pizza great: the cheese and the crust. The cheese: gooey, stretchy and just salty enough. Everything you expect from cheese on a pizza. The crust: definitely on the crunchy side, with a nice yeasty, bready flavor. Not too thick and not too thin. (If you like soft, doughy pizzas, this one is not for you.) The menu overall is pretty straightfoward: pizza, grinders and pasta. Grinders are pretty good too, but don't get the large unless you are sharing or HUNGRY. The interior is nothing fancy - there's an old school counter and stool set-up, booths and tables, and it all feels a little like a diner/dive. There is beer on tap - looked like 3 or 4 - and several bottles to choose from, some mainstream, some microbrew. The quality of the food was unexpected given how inexpensive it was. About $10 for a small pizza, which would have been enough to feed two adults (unless you're both really hungry, then split the grinder). read more

Wonderful family owned throw back pizza joint! Cold pitchers of beer, great thick pizza, the best greek salad dressing ever, Ms Pac Man sit down arcade game. We will have to stop here every summer! read more

Just stopped in on the way through for pizza to take home. Our first time here. The staff were very friendly and the place looked clean from what I could see in the short time I was there. We paid about $27 for a 3 topping large pizza and one topping small which seems to be about average price. Pizza was okay. It wasn't my favorite but it wasn't bad either. I just thought it could use a little more flavor and I didn't care for the crust at all. It was nice and cheesy for the most part but needed some more around the edges as it was mostly sauce by the crust. The didn't skimp on the toppings which is always a plus. I would go there again if I was driving through but wouldn't go out of my way. read more

See all

THE BEST GREEK SALAD. Teddy's should be a destination spot just to experience their unbelievable Greek salad. Teddy & Maria use only the freshest vegetables. The lettuce always crisp, onions fresh cut and the tomatoes firm and juicy. Plenty of fresh tasty feta. But what really makes this salad exceptional is their homemade dressing. Rich with herbs and seasoning, so unique! Ask to have the dressing pre mixed, delicious! You can add on Teddy's famous grilled chicken for extra protein. A small is filling lunch and a large would be enough for two. While Teddy's has always been known for their great pizza, their hidden gem is their Greek salads. read more

This is our favorite pizza in old Lyme. It's a nice family run business that is Greek style pizza made to perfection if you like this style of pizza. The owners and the service is excellent. They get a little crazy during the peak summer hours but the owners always keep a smile on their face and aim to please. read more

I've been stopping here after work every so often for their tuna grinder. My wife and I absolutely love it. Always the same....Delicious!

Love this place. I have been here for work for about 3 weeks now and I have had Teddy's for dinner 6 times now. Pizza, meatball sub, and pasta have been great and the wings are some of the best I have ever had. Love the Panko bread crumbs and the crispiness!! Great place and great service. Family owned and you can tell. Come to Freddy's you will be glad you did. read more

Great food and good people. Reasonably priced. Teddy has been a fixture for years in town.

This restaurant was VERY good! I had a meatball grinder (which I learned is pretty much a sub) and my boyfriend had a loaded salad with like ham, mozzerella, tomato, etc. My bread was very fresh and our service was good. I was very impressed! I finished off with tiramisu and my boyfriend got rice pudding. We both want to come here again! Compliments to Teddy for such good food! read more

See all

Excellent pizza and grinders with quick service and a very friendly staff. We'll be back to try some other items!

Teddys offers many menu options. The hard part is deciding what to order as all the food there is delicious.

I've been coming to Teddy's for about 18 years. My grandfather used to take my cousins and I here for lunch in the summers to enjoy some great food and even better atmosphere. I hadn't been in a while and decided to pick up a few pizzas for the family. The food was amazing, the staff was so kind, and I felt at home as soon as I walked in the door. We love Teddy and Maria and will continue to come here forever! Do yourself a favor and have the tomato, feta and oregano pizza- absolutely delicious! read more

Live down the street and this is my go-to place. Teddy and Maria are fantastic! Food is good (it's a pizza place people), they have slices whenever you want them, and a small bar and beer selection. Calzones are amazing! read more

Wish I could give 0 stars. The cheese on the pizza was wicked hard and I got an extra topping I didn't order... one long black hair.

Best cheesey fries on the east coast good people classic Greek style pizzas -. Zoombatz out

Teddy's is a great family owned restaurant. Love the Greek salad with chicken- meatball grinder- homemade soups-club sandwich with fries and more. Very friendly atmosphere and reasonable prices. You should go. read more