An absolute gem in Matawan. The bagels are fantastic -- crispy on the outside but fluffy inside. I really enjoyed the super cinnamon raisin, which was toasted with cinnamon and sugar in the exterior. It tasted great with the lite cream cheese, and they're very generous with the schmear. I also tried the bacon egg and cheese on an everything bagel, which was flavorful and the best way to start the day! It was great value, and the service was very friendly and fast. It made me happy to see it so bustling on a Sunday morning! The interior has some limited seating, and it's located in a strip mall with other interesting stores and restaurants. Would love to come back again! read more

See all

The ladies that were working over the weekend were beautiful and very kind to my baby boy. No problem making me hot and cold sandwiches and getting me bagels right away. Great service here. The problem is the bagels are just too soft. They are nice and big, and toast up great, but when you cut them they smush. Taste was great though, so for a single bagel, or bagel sandwich, yea- top marks, but for a bunch to take home or to an event, I'd keep looking. read more

Haven't tried the breakfast sandwiches yet, but a regular old toasted bagel with cream cheese is 10/10. Perfectly toasted but still soft and always a respectable amount of cream cheese. And they're so nice there. And they've always been pretty quick when I'm in there, even with a line of customers. read more

The Bagel Mania - Delis Near Me - Matawan, New Jersey

Yes another bagel shop review... Bagel Mania is a very small place located in a strip mall yet again. This one has 3 tables off to the left after you enter and only 4 carafes for your caffeine fix. Popular items here are those breakfast sandwiches for about $6 each. Everything seems to be extra for an add on. You won't have to double up on your order. Such as meat, eggs, cheese & or pork roll. Sandwiches are very hearty. My order was a pork roll, egg and cheese on a cinnamon raisin bagel for her. I went for a bacon, egg and cheese on a everything bagel. One can add hash browns for another buck. Total for 2 sandwiches, medium coffee and a newspaper $16.00. Come in before 10, even during the week if you can. Or just call in your order ahead of time. Bagel shop #4 in the area. read more

Despite the name, they don't just serve bagels here. This is a great little local spot to grab sandwiches, side salads, soups, some baked goods, and (of course) all different kinds of bagels and cream cheese spreads. I stopped by for a quick morning bite and got a made-to-order egg/meat/cheese breakfast sandwich. I chose the jalapeño bagel (with egg/turkey sausage/default American cheese), and it was a good solid breakast sandwich and very affordable at around $4. The bagel was super fresh, and I loved how the bits of jalapeños in it gave the sandwich a nice kick. Seating here is limited and the place can get chaotic with the amount of customers coming in and out. But if you don't mind a potential wait, this is a good place to pick up a casual bite. read more

See all

Shoutouts to Yelp for leading me to my new favorite bagel shop! Since moving out to California, I've been sorely missing a good Jersey bagel and I had a place when I lived in South Jersey but it was hard to find one in the Sayreville/Old Bridge area outside of Bagel Boy. Enter Bagel Mania, tucked away in a large, busy Matawan strip mall where they make bagels fresh and a mean breakfast sandwich too! Their bagels have a nice crisp outer and a chewy interior - A BAGEL DONE RIGHT! They also make a great pork roll, egg (they make them with 2 eggs), and cheese (+ salt, pepper, ketchup, if you like) for under $5. Well worth the time and $$! A dozen bagels goes for $9.99 and you sure know I packed those with me when I went back to Cali. I'll be back when I visit! read more

I never knew this place existed , but once I did, I had to try it. I've been noticing I'm that it's getting harder and harder to find a place that makes a good NJ breakfast sandwich, and am glad to say this place did not disappoint. Good food and coffee and a friendly staff. If I were to have an issue and it's small, just update the pricing on the menus board. I'm not a fan of mystery prices until you get to the register. read more

super friendly staff, delicious bagels, and excellent service! Will definitely stop back!

The bagels are excellent. I'm from Massachusetts and we don't have anything like these bagels at home. I always bring home a dozen when I pass by. read more

The food is great but the service is terrible. The owners are always kind. The young ladies there just don't give a damn. I also don't expect to see shirts with political affiliations on employees. I know this is Trump town but I'm just trying to get my bagel. Won't be back. read more

First time here and the sandwich is really made well. Lots of roast beef. Making it a men's meal style sandwich. Not sure if this was today's portion or normal. But she made it just right. The meat is fresh. Though disappointed with the soup. Taste can soup. They did excellent with the sandwich read more

The Bagel Mania - Roast beef and roasted peppers. Fabulous - Delis Near Me - Matawan, New Jersey

Good Food. Terrible customer service The girl working behind the counter just stands there and ignores customers

Not good. I like a good hole-in-the-wall spot, but this place seemed straight up dirty. Customers behind the counter for some reason?? Bit into something in my Pork Roll, Egg, and Cheese that had the texture of sand or something, something with a gritty crunch that had no business being in my sandwich, or my mouth (that's what she said?). Had to throw out the sandwich read more

The bagels are delicious the staff is friendly and the owners our hard-working and friendly great bagels that's coming from a guy that grew up in Brooklyn read more

Been getting bagels here my whole life and they never disappoint. Very friendly customer service & you get your money's worth. Can never go wrong with a sausage egg & cheese from here. read more

You're simply the best Better than all the rest Better than anyone Anyone I've ever met I'm stuck on your heart I hang on every word you say Tear us apart, no, no, no Baby, I would rather be dead...because Bagel Mania is simply the best. read more

On my way to NYC and stopped by here for a breakfast sandwich on a Saturday morning. Called to order but nobody picked up they phone. Got here and there was a line waiting to order and was greet by this young lady behind the counter after a while. She looked like she didn't want to be there with a sore puss on her face. Gave her my order of 2 bacon, egg and cheese on plain bagel. Waited for another 25 mins for my sandwiches, not sure what happened b/c customers that ordered after me received their orders before me. Anyway, the sandwiches were big and were good but the service left a bad taste. read more

This little place is amazing. Firstly, they make their own bagels! And second, they make a good assortment of cream cheese spreads. They have a small flat-top griddle that they make their sandwiches on, but make sure you either call ahead or make time in the mornings because they get busy. And that's for a good reason. The food they make is delicious. The coffee is hot, bagels are fresh, muffins/sandwiches are great, and the employees are always polite. read more

See all

I wouldn't recommend this bagel shop because the ladycat the counter is very rude to me and customers! Not acceptable in a business. There are many other bagel places that are better than this one. Don't waste your money here and on that bitch at the counter! read more

Born and raised in NYC, I know a great bagel from a wannabe. Have lived locally for 23 years, I've done my homework and found Bagelmania to be the best in the area. Their staff is also very friendly and helpful. They qualify as a 'joint' to me and my NY sensibilities. That is, They're not a fancy place; it's a bustling business with a great product - NY-style bagels. Breakfast sandwiches, grilled cheese, lunch sandwiches for the beach, crumb or coffee cakes, and coffee... they have what you need and are worth the stop. Enjoy! read more

I've been going to Bagel Mania for awhile now. The service can get a little hectic as the place can get really busy but it's worth it. The bagels are delicious as is the food. I highly recommend them! read more

I used to live down the street from Bagel Mania and went there many-many times. A great place for a bagel and coffee. Service was always good. The food was consistent and quality. Absolutely no complaints here. read more

The staff is so friendly and the bagels were quick! I hope I can make it in every morning to get my fill of bagels before I leave Jersey!

I'm a Staten Island transplant in Matawan-I've been looking for a local bagel place that knew what they were doing and I've found it. Not only do they make their own (delicious) bagels, but the service is fast and friendly. Their sandwiches are also really great, but I'm in it for the BEC. read more

This place officially sucks. I've been coming here for a while now and they have excellent bagels but the quality of the service is so bad that I rather eat a crappier bagel then have to deal with them. I truly feel bad for the management because they are good owners but their employees are terrible. They seem to mess up the order almost every time now and they are always fighting with each other making the customers feel very uncomfortable while they wait for the food to be made. I wish them the best of luck but I will not be coming back until they hire new people. read more

Bagelmania, my go to for breakfast! It is typically very busy. It is a tiny little shop and sometimes the line will lead out the door. I love the food. Everything I've gotten has been great. The owner/workers there are the best. So kind and make you feel welcomed. There are 3 small tables to the left when you first walk in, all connected (again, its a tiny shop) so keep that in mind if you plan on eating there. It's nice when its not busy, but if it's busy I would not sit there and eat because of the build up of people surrounding you. BUT a lot of people must mean it's good, and that's definitely true. It has been there for years and I hope it stays! read more

Phylis makes an exceptional Egg sandwich and from someone that has had many a sandwich working in NYC for years, this speaks volumes. I hope she gets the credit she deserves and could use extra help for all she does. read more

I'm officially done with this place. The service is horrendous. They don't write anything down. They rely on a troop of young people running around like their heads are chopped off. There's no organization behind the counter. It doesn't matter if you are the only customer in the place or one of ten. They will manage to make ordering and receiving your food a nightmare. The past three times I've been here there have been two incorrect orders, and one where they forgot to make my food, or gave it to someone else. The bagel makers know their stuff. They are delicious. It's just not worth going in to face this type of service. read more

I had a plain bagel with cream cheese. The bagel was chewy. The cream cheese was creamy, and the service was fast. A-OK in my book. read more

The Bagel Mania - Delis Near Me - Matawan, New Jersey

I was traveling back home from my fiancée's place, it was in the morning so by this point I needed a coffee and I could grab a breakfast sandwich too. There were a couple of people eating or waiting for their orders. It's not terribly tight, but it's not big in there. I ordered a pork roll, egg and cheese on a wheat bagel and a coffee. You make your own coffee at the bar on the side. The sandwich was ok, at best. The pork roll didn't have much of a taste, not terrible, but almost not there. The bagel though, was one of those big fluffy types. I'm more of a crunchy, kettle cooked guy than a large roll type of guy. It was ok, not great, not bad. The place did seem clean and the counter girls were pleasant. It's not a bad place to stop, I'm just not sure I'd do it often. read more

Another bagel place and this one is literally steps from home. Been here a couple of times already and a fan of their bagels. Staff is very nice and move the crowd quickly. I'll be there tomorrow lol. read more

They are always fresh . Yes they're busy but that's because it's the best spot to get the most authentic bagels around. I know the staff personally and they put a lot of work into making sure the food is always it's best. read more

I've been going to Bagel Mania for 10 or 15 years maybe longer simply the best unfortunately I moved to Florida and I only get to come up here and eat their bagels when I'm visiting family read more

I've been going to this shop for a long time. The bagels are always great. My only gripe with the bagels is that the everything bagels don't always have "everything" on them. I hate not knowing if their going to be good or not bc of this. Also, the service can be lousy. And I hate to say this bc the main owner is a very nice guy, but it's so true. It won't stop me from going there bc the bagels are great. read more

First of all they make the mistake by giving me the wrong sandwich so I come back to change it. The young lady there was nasty and upset that I came back, as if it was my fault they made the mistake. At the end, when I got my new sandwich I said thank you and got no reply. So I say thank you again and she looks at me and say "bitch people make mistakes" so first they mess up my sandwich taking time out of work day to come back and exchange it. Second I get called a bitch for it? Wow. Definitely not coming back here and I was just starting to make this my breakfast spot. read more

Fresh, warm bagels... Check! Jalapeño cream cheese... Check. Scallion cream cheese... Check. Friendly staff... Check! What else would I need for a great start to my day off? I'll be back! read more

So sometime recently, the health dept must've done some cleaning up in there. Employees wear gloves now as opposed to previously not.. Just hope the owner doesn't make your food, he doesn't abide by this glove rule.. Also, chances are they will get your order wrong.. Ordered a pork roll, egg, and cheese the other day.. the pork roll was on the grill for 2 minutes tops (GROSS!).. Most likely the last time I get breakfast there, plenty of better bagel shops in the area. read more

Basic bagel/deli joint nothing to completely rave about but I enjoyed what I ordered.

They NEVER write anything down when taking your order. Very disorganized. They have to ask you multiple times while you are there what your order was and sometimes it still comes out incorrect. They seem to never be able to handle a capacity of more than 3 people at a time. read more

Awesome bagels! This beats all the bagel places in the Matawan area hands down!