1. The Castle Theater

1. The Castle Theater

0

New Castle, IN

Cancel

Open app

Search

The Castle Theater

3.5 (10 reviews)

The Castle Theater Photos

Recommended Reviews - The Castle Theater

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

6 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Great theatrical experience! Great! Wonderful! DELIGHTFUL! Clean. Popcorn is delicious!

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

16 years ago

Helpful 3
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Jay A.
1
19
6

10 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 2
Photo of Shi K.
1
39
2

14 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 1

11 years ago

This is the only movie theater in New castle. the inside needs a lot of updates.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Nancy P.
35
100
114

11 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

13 years ago

It would be nice if they showed movies over G and PG-13 ratings I'm sure they would have more buisness...

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - The Castle Theater

Verify this business for free

Get access to customer & competitor insights.

Verify this business

AMC Muncie 12

AMC Muncie 12

3.4(44 reviews)
20.4 mi

The reclining seating and cleanliness have me giving this Muncie theatre a 5-star review. We went…read moreon a weeknight so it was dead (and very clean...everywhere) and the theatre wasn't busy at all. I would have liked to have a seat not sitting next to someone, given that the theatre was empty and full of seats, but these were the only options that were given when we paid for our tickets (kinds thought that was weird?). That would be the reason for the 4-stars. We didn't get concessions but they do have the freestyle Coke machines so that's a plus! Thanks to Yelp, I'll check out movies on Tuesday night for just $5! Also, if you are a major movie-goers, subscribing to the AMC STUBS is a great value!

The Marion AMC closed & now as of the last 4 months. I go to movie at least twice a week. How many…read moretimes people came in 45 minutes to a hour into the film. Talking very loud like a film has not been playing. Just adults who don't know how to act in a theater. I have been threatened many times. My last time I filled AMC on everything in corporate. But they are only using AI now. I was going to try to get the manager someone cause the whole theater was screaming at kids who walked in 40 min into obsession. All of them high and everyone started yelling at them. I left and got body checked then threatened the whole way out to beat my a** and calling me gay hate names. The manager didn't do 1 thing but again just look confused. She could have walked them in like other theaters do. I mean DO NOT GO TO THIS THEATER. The amount of fights that are happening then they will use your A list member. I was the only one they had a name of. So I have horrific footage of it all. Which I will be posting on Reddit. Because people taking Children here. Think twice they will NOT PROTECT YOU THERE. I have seen so much in these last 4 months. Me & my partner & mother took a 3 week break. Hoping AMC would protect the people coming. Fights are happening 5 to 10 times a week. & it will only get worse & worse. You sadly can't trust AMC to protect you or your kids. Some of these people fighting is all they know. & if AMC did walk through this would happen far less. Called 5 different theaters & all of them do Walk throughs! Don't let film be ruined for you here. Just go Emagine Theater or Regal or the best DraftHouse. They have someone outside each theater. & if your late your not aloud in. That's sadly what has to happen because AMC only cares about trying to survive before they go completely bankrupt. But these smaller theaters Make Sure this does not happen. It's incredible the amount of people I have talked to who have told me insane stories about AMC Muncie. The theater is gone now Don't waste your time or energy. Going during the week won't even save you! Trust me!

Photos
AMC Muncie 12
AMC Muncie 12
AMC Muncie 12

See all

Living Room Theatres Indy - The grand stairs coming up from the lobby with the Pamela Bliss painted mural of Kong.

Living Room Theatres Indy

3.9(152 reviews)
42.3 miChatham Arch

My spouse and I decided to class up our day date by catching a movie at Living Room Theater on Mass…read moreAve, which sounds like something sophisticated people do. We are not always sophisticated people, but we are excellent at pretending. We started at the bar, which looks the part completely. Elegant, well stocked, the kind of bar that makes you feel like you should be wearing something nicer than what you showed up in. I ordered an old fashioned, at which point the gentleman behind the bar admitted, with full transparency, that he was not actually the bartender and would need to Google how to make it. I genuinely appreciated the honesty. In a galaxy full of people who would have just guessed and handed me something terrible, this man chose truth. I thanked him, switched my order to whiskey and coke, and we moved on as allies. From there we headed to concessions and ordered the Take it to the Greek wrap, the La Bamba pizza, and fries with little bits of steak on top. The food was good. Not life altering, not the kind of meal that makes you grab someone's arm and say nothing, just nodding, but genuinely solid movie theater food that arrived at our seats without us having to do anything except recline and wait. The seats reclined. There were actual tables. This is civilized. We watched Disclosure Day, which if you have any interest in extraterrestrial or UFO subject matter is absolutely worth your time. Sitting in a reclining leather seat watching a film about potential contact with beings from other worlds felt appropriately cinematic, even if the leather on most seats has seen better days. Chipping and worn in spots, which is the one visible crack in an otherwise well maintained experience. The theater itself was clean, the concept is fantastic, and the overall vibe delivered exactly what a day date calls for. Four stars. The bar needs an actual bartender on deck and the seats could use some attention, but Living Room Theater is still one of the better ways to spend an afternoon in Indianapolis.

I wanted to see The Devil Wears Prada 2 but didn't feel like doing the regular movie theater thing,…read moreso we decided to try this place out for a more elevated experience. Glad we did! We went on a Sunday and found street parking pretty easily, but then realized the theater validates parking for up to 3 hours. Such a nice perk -- wish I knew before circling around lol. We bought our tickets online ahead of time, and when we got there I ordered the garlic cheesy bread and a drink at the counter. Total was around $15. The seats were really comfy and spacious, which made the whole experience feel worth it. The food came out pretty fast. The garlic cheesy bread was probably like a 5/10 for me... not terrible, but I probably wouldn't order it again. Overall though, really nice theater and I'd definitely come back for another movie night.

Photos
Living Room Theatres Indy - Entry view of the theater

Entry view of the theater

Living Room Theatres Indy - Popcorn & Chardonnay

Popcorn & Chardonnay

Living Room Theatres Indy - Chicago style hot dog and salad

See all

Chicago style hot dog and salad

Holiday Auto Theatre

Holiday Auto Theatre

4.5(40 reviews)
52.7 mi

Me and my wife went to go see Toy Story 5. Could not hear because someone in a crappy Honda Truck…read moreleft their loud engine running the whole time by the concession stand. Tried finding an attendant but could not find the guy on the golf cart that drives around checking on things. Literally could not hear the movie and it totally ruined the experience for us and others around us. It also smelled like weed coming from that car also. Not saying it's managements fault entirely, but they need to do a better job at going around at checking on things. Wife and me normally have a good time coming here, but that was uncalled for an inconsiderate. I'm a big tall dude, I didn't want to go up to them and have a fight break out because they would likely be intimidated by me. This was as of June 20, 2026. It takes one @ssho(e to ruin a cinematic experience like that. I get that that night was sold out, but please do a better job.

Stopped here over the summer with a larger group on a Friday night…read more We came and watched Elvis at the end of July and I think the second showing was Thor. The first movie started around 9, as the sun went down. By the time for the second movie it was almost midnight so we left, but if you can stay up late it's a great deal to stay and watch two! If you choose to turn your car off, make sure to bring an actual radio to tune in with. None of the apps have the specific station and you won't be able to hear much from your neighbor's car. It was a beautiful place to watch the sunset and once it's dark you can see lots of stars. I would recommend sitting in a car or on chairs because it is all gravel and it's harder to find a window to watch if you're on the ground. There are concessions and restrooms in the middle. You pay per person in the car for entry and if you bring your own snacks you're supposed to pay.

Photos
Holiday Auto Theatre
Holiday Auto Theatre - Courtesy of the website

Courtesy of the website

Holiday Auto Theatre

See all

Emagine - Lobby

Emagine

4.0(71 reviews)
30.1 mi

This has become our favorite movie theater as of late. We saw Obsession and The Odyssey here…read morerecently. The seats are comfortable with reclining, heating and cooling features. Actually, I'm not entirely sure that it has cooling, but the button switches from red (heated) to blue (not heated). They recline really far back but still allow ample space for others to pass by without you needing to shift your position very much. I was disappointed that the concessions menu is not shown on their website. They give a brief description of the type of things that they offer, but not the full menu or pricing. At the concession stand, you can order and receive certain items immediately (such as candy, popcorn, hot dogs, classic nachos and drinks) but other items (like pizza and the ultimate nachos) will be delivered to your seats. There is also a full bar with an option to order a drink for now and one for later that will be delivered to your seat at a later time. That's pretty cool. In the lobby area, there is a player piano, photo booth and claw machine that dispenses rubber ducks (like the ones that Jeep drivers exchange). The drink area is where you will find condiments, napkins and straws. They have sodas and slushies. They also have lap trays that you can place into the cup holders of your seats for your food orders. They sit kind of high, but it's better than not having any type of tray or table. The cuddle seats are cute little love seats with an ottoman, but they are positioned on the first row (being the least desirable seats in the theater). I tested one out and you would basically need to lay down the entire time in order to see the screen. I didn't reserve those on either visit, but if you bring a blanket and your boo, that could be nice. The hot dog that I ordered was spicy. I wasn't expecting that, but maybe I should've known based on the name listed on the menu. I just wasn't "in the know". The popcorn is freshly popped. We weren't huge fans of the pizza though. It could benefit from being baked a bit longer. Surround sound is good. Lighting/contrast was good. In my opinion, it was a little warm in the theater, which drew my attention to two tiny ceiling fans located on either side of the theater. I'm not sure what their purpose is because they couldn't possibly be there to cool that huge theater. If you run hot, bring a personal fan!

Glad I didn't want concessions. The line would have been out the door if it wasnt wrapped around…read morethe lobby. The bathrooms could use some cleaning too. Sticky floor. That being said the prepay option for purchasing the tickets went well. $5 movies offered on Tuesdays with $1 processing fee so $6 total. They offer a way to order food and have it brought to you. I'm not sure how it works but I did see food being brought to seats.

Photos
Emagine - Entrance

Entrance

Emagine - Concession area

Concession area

Emagine - Bar area

See all

Bar area

Cereal Cinema - Hook, cereal and complementary cold brew! Couldn't think of a better relaxing morning

Cereal Cinema

4.8(6 reviews)
43.8 mi

Every film festival has unique features for which it's well known. Our beloved Indy Film Fest has…read moresome awesome options outside its annual film festival. These features include Cereal Cinema, a monthly special screening held at Newfields on a Saturday morning at 10am that offers a cereal buffet (coffee is available for purchase for the tired adults). Cereal Cinema targets the family market. For example, this year's films include Night at the Museum (April), Madagascar (May), The Neverending Story (July), Homeward Bound (August) and the list goes on. This is always a reasonably priced good time for the entire family. While accessibility at Newfields isn't quite 100%, it's surprisingly good and wheelchair users like myself can easily attend Cereal Cinema. The cereals are usually a variety - including gluten-free options. Indy Film Fest is still an entirely volunteer-run film festival. It's amazing what they accomplish, and it's a guaranteed good time for the entire family. I definitely recommend Cereal Cinema for families. It's one of Indy's true gems and a best kept secret. You'll have fun and the kids will be happy. Win/Win.

Cereal Cinema is hosted at the IMA Toby Theatre in the cooler months and the Athenaeum in the…read moresummer on the first Saturday of the month at 10am. For $5, you get to enjoy a family-friendly movie, the cereal bar, and relive the glory days of Saturday morning cartoons. I appreciate the throwback kids' movies like the Land Before Time, Mary Poppins, and Newsies - introducing the little ones to some cult classics that they're wayyyy too young to remember. I wish they had more healthy cereal options available (as most are Lucky Charms type sugar coma concoctions), but one cup of sugar overdose once a month won't hurt ya.

Photos
Cereal Cinema - Check in on the Yelp app & get a "Zing Shot" of Uel Zing cold brew!

Check in on the Yelp app & get a "Zing Shot" of Uel Zing cold brew!

Cereal Cinema
Cereal Cinema

See all

The Castle Theater - movietheaters - Updated July 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...