I walk by Paddy's almost every day, and I've come to see what it is -- and what it could be…read more Paddy's leans hard into the dive / old‑school pub aesthetic, which I'm fine with. The atmosphere is rugged, familiar, heavy with regulars who know each other. That can be comforting, but it also means new people feel a little on the outside looking in. Their beers are solid, the vibe is strong (sports, darts, classic pub banter), and it has the bones of a great local hangout. But there's a resistance to change or warmth toward newcomers, which makes it feel like a place "for the in crowd." If they worked on opening the door just a bit more for first‑timers (friendlier service, small gestures of welcome), Paddy's could be even better. As is, it's dependable and characterful -- just not always inclusive.

I've come here a few times with my coworker who lives in the area. Always really friendly…read morebartenders/patrons. Very typical Irish pub/dive in terms of drinks and ambiance.

The platonic ideal of an Irish bar. The Guinness is probably one of the best in the city, the vibe…read moreis great, and all the food options are pretty solid. The potato wedges or popcorn with a ton of cheddar are great snacks, and the sandwiches are really good too.

Great pints, cool pub. No clue why non Irish music was blasting here, definitely negatively…read moreimpacted the ambience and turned us off from a repeat visit.

Was here for Saint Patrick's Day and it was bumping! Energy was at an all time high! It was a bit…read morechaotic but found a seat in like 10 minutes. The venue is pretty spacious they have a back dining area, a big bar when you enter and a full bar upstairs. There's a ton of televisions if you are watching sports as well. They have a pretty deep beer menu which I loved. The food menu is Irish influenced bar bites. We had the wings which were nice and crispy. The center of attention was the waffle fries nachos. You can't go wrong with a potato vehicle to fresh toppings. All and all great fun spot for sports and gatherings. Also this is a melting pot. Various ages, groups, backgrounds, saw a few families. All are welcome. One flaw is St. Patty it appeared that our waiter who was superb was the only one working so it was a bit of chase to close out.

Solid Irish pub....i have only been here at lunch (I don't go out at night much if I'm not blowing…read moretrumpet at a gig or rehearsal). In general, I like the mellow / peaceful vibes of outer borough NYC Irish pubs at lunchtime. McMahon's did not disappoint. Solid buffalo chicken wings & good burger. I am also post fries (I will try one or two of yours, but I don't need an order of fries for myself.), so can't comment on the fries. They also make a mean Caesar salad. The Caesar & buffalo wings are pretty much my metric for all Irish pubs. McMahon's would def be in the upper 50th percentile. There are a bunch of negative reviews for this spot on here for when they are very busy, on Barclays Center game nights and / or weekends. I feel like, if you read between the lines, it's people coming in groups when it's busy acting entitled. The staff at lunch has been nothing but courteous, w/ excellent service. Also, very clean inside, & food was good quality / fresh ingredients. There are almost no Irish pubs in this area open for lunch anymore at all - thank goodness this is a good one!

This is as casual as it gets. Typical American bar/eatery for grabbing a quick bite and a drink. A…read moregiant bar spans a quarter of the entire indoor space. If you want water, there's a giant jug of it on the counter. Help yourself to some plastic cups. Super loud ambiance, due to bar TVs and people talking really loudly. In such open space, sound carries. Prepare to talk really loudly and strain to hear your conversation partners. The background music was nice--all the classy rock, pop, and modern hits bringing you nostalgia from the better days. A few outdoor tables available, if you'd like to people watch in good weather. Service is fast, staff are very efficient. We got $20 ribs special and $18 chicken sandwich panini. I was surprised that both were decent. Fries were not too salty nor greasy and not heavy at all (surprise). Ribs were tender and fell off the bone easily. They were served in sweet BBQ sauce. Instead of fries, I got salad--which was just a few lettuce leaves from a pre sold supermarket salad bag, so be warned. Chicken panini sandwich was the unanticipated standout of our meal--massive chicken breasts that were tender and well grilled were nestled between tasty toppings. Overall, this was very filling (can be shared by two) and satisfying. Very cheese and saucy, which I also appreciated, as I can't stand bland food.

"A Rare Full English in the Wild"…read more You don't just find a Full English breakfast in Brooklyn anymore -- you hunt for it. You scroll endlessly through delivery apps, dive into brunch menus full of avocado toast and eggs benedict, and eventually resign yourself to pancakes pretending to be culture. But Black Horse Pub? It dares to serve one. And it nearly sticks the landing. ‍ Atmosphere Inside, it's shoulder-to-shoulder. Jerseys everywhere, football on the TVs, a kid playing games on a phone while someone in an Arsenal kit yells at the screen. Outside, I grabbed a rain-dampened table, and the waitress wiped it down for me without being asked. That may sound small, but in Brooklyn? That kind of service is practically extinct. Service Genuinely some of the best I've had in a long time. When I had trouble connecting to the Wi-Fi, she came over and typed in the password for me. Not handed me a slip of paper. Not pointed vaguely at the wall. Typed it in. When I assumed my second round of drinks (a shot of whiskey and a Magners) would take forever -- it was packed -- they showed up immediately. The whole vibe here is "we see you, and we got you." Wings Better than expected, and I already had high hopes. Perfectly cooked -- juicy, not overdone -- with a sauce that walks the tightrope between sweet and spicy without falling into sugary overkill. Balanced, addictive, and clearly not an afterthought. Full English This is what I came for -- and what most places in this city wouldn't even attempt. * Eggs: Fried just right -- golden edges, runny centers. * Mushrooms: Meaty, earthy, cooked with care. * Grilled tomato: Balances out the richness. No soggy mess here. * Ham: Lean, maybe a bit undersalted, but solid. * Beans, toast, and yolk all mingled together -- the kind of simple, hearty opulence that only English food can deliver when it gets out of its own way. * Black pudding: Absolutely excellent. Delicately rustic, no harshness, perfect texture. * Sausage: The only miss. Clearly not an authentic banger -- more like a basic breakfast link. And when you're this close to nailing it, that matters. In a city where it's nearly impossible to find a Full English done with this much effort and balance, that sausage doesn't ruin the meal -- but it does knock it down a notch. Would I come back? No question. Already planning to. If they swap in a proper sausage next time, it might just hit a perfect five.

First off the commissioner is a GREAT place to go. It is kid friendly but also great for adults…read more There are board games and darts to entertain! Their cheeseburgers are delicious and the service is phenomenal! It is such a cute and cozy bar and it is a must visit if you're in Park Slope! It is also awesome if you watch sports because they have tons of tvs and they are willing to take requests! I highly recommend it! -Poppy

Cool little bar my first time trying them from just walking in off the street with friends @10pm…read more The service was amazing very attentive the food and drinks came fast. I really wanted wings they ran out early so we didn't get to try them. But the food and drinks were decent.

Amazing place and when music the BEST place to go and have a great time. Locals are friendly,…read moreservice friendly and a great spot for youngins to hang in the back room!

Irish Haven is not just a dive bar... it was the perfect place for my brother's surprise party!…read moreFrom the moment I started planning, Matt ( owner) went above and beyond to bring my vision to life... The entire staff was so accommodating, the day of, Emmett and Nadine were so helpful, and genuinely cared about making the night special. The atmosphere was fun and welcoming, the drinks were great, and every single guest had an amazing time. I honestly couldn't have imagined a better place to celebrate. If you're looking for a spot that works with you every step of the way and delivers an unforgettable experience, Irish Haven is it!

It's tight , crowded and pretty much a local spot but they make the best pina coladas ! Also if…read moreyou're lucky enough to catch the music set it's worth the trip . It's young and trendy with everyone standing around listening to the band . There is an inside but we didn't get inside as it was too crowded . Take a listen !

Great hidden gem. Never too crowded yet s great place to meet up. Service is always on…read morepoint. If a snack is desired they have it.

Overall a decent old-timey classic bar without the grit/dirt of a regular dive. Unfortunately, the…read moreowner/bartender has a thinly veiled but overall apathetic borderline territorial attitude about the place, revealed by frustration when a paying customer has the gall to ask for a drink and thus commit the unspeakable sin of interrupting a service worker from his banter with the regulars. Decent drinks and ambience for a seemingly non-pretentious bar, unfortunately the lack of third spaces in NYC creates a culture of old-time-ry spiritual curmudgeons and ingroup outgroup dynamics among regulars not worth being around if you want to have fun. May be if you're Irish and/or older Gen Xer, you may have a slightly better experience. Despite its placement and weekly karaoke catering to a younger demographic, it's still a crotchety old-man bar at heart though perhaps not really malicious, just annoying and set in its ways... Better options: Adirondak, Hinterlands.

Shenanigans is a solid bar - looks divey, but without the dive attitude. I popped through before…read morethe Kentucky Derby and enjoyed a few drinks before pushing on. The drinks were nicely priced and the bartender friendly. As it was Derby day, they were even serving Mint Juleps! I hear they have a cool Karaoke scene and will need to check that out soon.

Held my birthday party there this past weekend and everything was amazing! People loved the venue…read moreand have been talking about it a ton! It was wonderful to have an entire (super cute) space, own bar and bathroom, and the drinks were delicious. And the entire event process was seamless. Highly recommend for your next event!

I came here with a friend on a Thursday night around 6pm. Almost the entire bar is occupied by arm…read morechairs and couches; it's incredibly cozy. Great vibe and would 100% come back. Four stars rather than five because I ordered an Athletic on draft, and it was incredibly flat.