This place has the best cookies I have ever tasted, they are very fresh and have so many different choices. The place is adorable and filled with cookies jars. The price is also $11 per pound which beats any bakeries around here that sell Italian cookies only. These cookies are always a hit with everyone I share them with. read more

The Cookie Jar - Hands down best Red Velvet cake and frosting I tasted! - Bakeries Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Sampled 10 different cookies and nothing really stood out to me. They are not bad cookies, but there are much better places to buy cookies at this price point. read more

I hate writing bad reviews but this was the worst bubble tea I've ever had, it's made with some powder and they barely blended it so there were still powder clumps throughout. I bought 3, for myself and some coworkers, and we all ended up throwing them out. Pretty disappointed. I kept the second star because their deserts are pretty good but I usually go to the new drop lane location for the deserts. read more

Delicious cookies friendly staff very wide selection. A must for cookie fanatics. Cookie monster would be proud.

Bought a cookie cake for my nephews birthday here and I was impressed at the quality as well as the taste. The Cookie was thicker than most typical cookie cakes that you would expect to get from a grocery store and the frosting didn't have a fake taste to it like some other cookie cakes you may have tasted before... only reason that I would give 4 stars instead of 5 is because I felt that for what it was they were a tad expensive but that's just my personal opinion. The cookie itself was good and I would most likely try them again even if it weren't just for a cake and maybe for some cupcakes or regular sized cookies! read more

Such a wide variety of cookies and sweet treats! My favorite are the jelly filled cookies. Clean environment and friendly servers! Would definitely recommend read more

OMG this is the best bakery we've EVER been to! Where do I begin? The flavors were unique. Definitely can't find raspberry brownies, guava jelly cookies, chocolate dipped rainbow cookies, at your average bakery. The employees were very nice and patient as we picked 1 pound of assorted cookies, which turned out to be like 1-2 of each cookie. The cookies were fresh, and definitely worth going out of our way for. Next time we're in Staten Island, were definitely stopping by! I just wish their online site had specific flavors listed, instead of a package deal. Thank you again for the awesome super yummy cookies and the great service! read more

Nice staff and delicious cookies! The cannoli creme filled ones are my favorite. Only sad thing is I'm dying to try one of their black and whites but they're ALWAYS sold out read more

I heart their double Dutch chocolate cupcakes with the super thick icing. It's just so chocolatey! Also like their red velvet cupcakes and it's always fun going into their shop because they have all these cakes lining the walls with lots of different themes like superheroes! And of course, love the cookies, that goes without saying!!! read more

cutest little place best sweets and I bought my mom an elvis cookie jar for Christmas one year! It's heaven on earth this place. I like to bring lots of cookies to my boyfriends house in jersey because his mom always adores them. she says they can't get cookies lite that there unless she has to make them. read more

The best cookies in Staten Island They have such a large assortment of cookies and each one of them are delicious. read more

COOKIE ZEN! COOKIE NIRVANA! Cookies cookies - you have never seen so many mouth watering cookies in one place before! My favorite is the giant homemade Oreo. OMG! When I serve them to guests their eyes just light up. I also love the light, buttery fruit cookies. Oh - let's not forget the macaroons (plain AND chocolate covered). I could go on and on and on about the different varieties, but you should really make the trip and see for yourself. But don't go hungry... Oh and before you go - buy a gallon of milk... read more

Best red velvet cupcakes ever! I've been coming here for over 10 years just for them!

I must apologize. I wish I had a picture to add, but everyone ate the delectables SOO fast! The cookies & mini pastries are amazing! They always come up with feature cookie(s), so you have to keep coming back for more. If you wanna shake, they got it. Wanna sweet gift WITH cookies, they got it! Also, you can order online for gifts if you can't make it in. I can't wait to try their sister shop next that sells the cakes! Til next time... read more

Extremely over hyped. While the girls who work there are very efficient and super friendly, pretty much every cookie or desert falls flat. Out of the pound of mixed cookies, maybe 3 or 4 were enjoyable. Just because it's smothered in powered sugar doesn't make it a good cookie. Cupcakes were pretty tasty. read more

Where to begin ? This place it's just adorable. They have millions of cookies to choose from as well as cupcakes. They have coffee to perfectly go along with your delicious dish. There are tables and chairs you can sit on inside to enjoy your cookies. The staff is friendly and patiently waits as you look while drooling at the millions of cookies to make a decision. The walls have beautiful cookie jars all over them from Disney characters to farm animals I love lucy and many many more. Such a cute hidden place on Staten Island. read more

The Cookie Jar - Book club meetings - Bakeries Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Cookies. Cookie jars. More cookies. It's a pretty self-explanatory joint with some high quality baked goods; not a single time have I been disappointed, except for possibly not buying enough cookies. read more

The minute you walk in the door the delicious smells are present. Assorted, decorated cookie jars a line the shelves. You can never pick a cookie you don't love. Delicious read more

Seriously all I can say is the cookies are amazing! You can never go wrong with the seven layer cookie!

This has become a weekly trip for me! i love sweets but can do without them. this place has me hooked. chocolate lovers try NUTELLA DELIGHT. best red velvet cupcakes Ive ever had, and i don't even have a favorite. If you want to treat yourself, however small this is the place to go!. Also, one of the best ice coffees! and prices are very reasonable read more

Very cute and unique bakery. My kids love the choices of cookies. I personally love the wall of cookie jars and decor.

Very tasty cookies and pastries. Not super expensive but definitely more expensive than packaged grocery store cookies. Nonetheless they are totally worth it. Cookies are sweet enough without giving you diabetes, soft and succulent melt-in-your-mouth yumminess. These treats are definitely worth it. They're a nice addition to any party, gathering or meeting. read more

Service was prompt. However the two cupcakes I ordered were thrown in the box upside down. Employees were talking about how they couldn't wait to get out of there in front of customers and making bets on what time they would be finished cleaning and in my opinion that is unprofessional and unbecoming. The product is good, except the regular chocolate chip cookie was on the dry side. I certainly got my money's worth however. Prices are fair for my experience. I wouldnt mind paying more for a cookie that wasn't dry though. Three stars mainly because the double chocolate cashew cookie and affordable price per pound is a solid redeemer of an otherwise underwhelming first experience. I will come back if only for that particular cookie. read more

The BESt red velvet cupcake I have ever eaten. Both the cake and the icing was light and not sickly sweet. Just perfect. The cupcake itself was the perfect size, not a HUGE monster cupcake. Simple. Just sweet enough. Delicious. The smell of the place is like heaven on earth. The decor is delightful with an entire wall of cookie jars! Traditional Italian and French bakeries should watch out because I think this is the type of bake shop this borough really needs. Tons and tons of assorted types of cookies. Traditional favorites as well as things you've never had before. Nice cupcake assortment. Friendly service and best of all, the price. $10 per pound no matter what you choose. So you can mix it up and try all sorts of their creations for a very very fair price. The ONLY critisism I have of this place is that I didn't care for the coconut macaroon. Too cakey for my taste. I like a little bit more real coconut flakes in my macaroons. But other than that, Fresh, delicious, adorable, well worth stopping in! read more

Unhelpful. Told me to busy to help to place order on phone. 1st girl had no clue what I was even talking about. I guess they don't need the business. Sad read more

Best cookies! Found this place a few years ago when my mother brought a box to our house and OMG one was better than the next. We found ourselves taking a bite and saying to others "you have to taste this one". Kudos to the owner for running an amazing bakery too bad there is nothing even close to that in PA. Now, I pick up a pound or two whenever I'm on the Island, they're great to bring to parties and even better to bring home. I highly recommend stopping in and giving them a try. Oh and if you get stuck in a cookie exchange and don't have time to bake this is the place to go. You can fulfill your obligation without all the work or mess and they'll be a guaranteed success among friends, family and co-workers. read more

With the holidays upon us, the Cookie Jar is my go to spot for any kind of desert. The have every kind of cookie imaginable, and a neat collection of cookie jars that would make a cool gift if you are going to someone's house for dinner. My personal favorites are the PB&J cookie, any of the brownie bites, and the raspberry cookie covered in chocolate. The store just smells like diabetes, and it's very difficult to make it home without sneaking a cookie or two from the box. The staff is always helpful, and they have a pretty efficient system for ordering. read more

There were so many appealing cookies to choose from I didn't know where to start. I have never been to a bakery with such an amazing selection. Then when it came time to eat them, none fell short of delicious! In addition to the great cookies, they have the best Bubble Tea that I have ever tried. read more

The best cookies I have ever had their brownie bites are awesome, and pretty much every cookie they have with Nutella in it I fall in love with. I wish this place wasn't so close to my house because ill probably become a fat pig read more

Great place for treats for just about any occasion, or if u want u can just sit and enjoy the aroma ;o) Cookies and muffins are off the hook and I've learned to love it more than Cake Chef itself! (Don't be mad) I still have much love and respect for the Cake Chef but the new, modern and clean space makes The Cookie Jar a winner for me! read more

Delicious cookies! And they have several gluten free options. The people who work here are also very nice and helpful.

The cookie Jar is a very nice establishment. Delicious cookies, Terrible customer service!!!! Danielle the manager of the place is driving customers away with her sarcastic and very nasty attitude. I am hispanic brown complexion and when I walked in I was given the look! Very disappointing. I live in the Silver lake area, Hispanic, 29 years in the NYPD, homeowner and tax payer. This place does not welcome minorities. read more

Thank goodness I don't live near this place- if I did, I'd be forty pounds heavier! They have a selection of cookies that I didn't know existed. Been there only once, and bought a $60.00 cookie assortment that was a big hit with the folks at the medical center. One drawback was the parking, or lack of it. Had to circle block twice, and I was about to give up and go to Dunkin Donuts. Glad I didn't. If you have plans to expand, you might want to get a place with a parking lot. But don't you DARE expand to Tottenville, or I'll look like Dom Deluise in a month! read more

Oh Yea-- cookies galore by the pound!! And beverages, brownies, cupcakes (I think they only sell a few varieties, but I'm not interested) and adorable cookie jars. I usually get some pine nut cookies, cherry/blueberry/chocolate chip and most chocolate cookies. Maybe even a linzer tart. Mmm. Just so good. read more

Cookie jar is a hidden gem. I am not from SI so I only get to have these sweets when I visit my bf's family. There are so many types of cookies. Love how they are not too huge and perfect. I love variety and eating multiple cookies without being stuffed from one huge cookie. They are buttery, chewy and so good. The basic chocolate chip, almond and pistachio are some of my favorites. But I've liked everything I've tried so far. Their prices are reasonable and the decor of the place is cute with cookie jars decorating the walls. read more

You want cookies this ia the place my only complaint is that there iss just so many that you want to order from its hard to pick a few out.

My kids love cookie jar. We frequent all 3 businesses from time to time, cake chef, cookie jar and piece of cake. The owner is always nice, the items are always fresh and the store is always immaculate. My kids esp love cookie jar bc of the large assortment of cookies. They love the chocolate covered 7 layer cookies and my husband has loved the elephant ears for years! A neighbor purchased a dinosaur cookie jar for me from here when I delivered my 2nd child and it is really cute. If you love cookies, this is the place to go. Also, their staff always works quickly to get you in and out. I can't say enough good things about all 3 establishments. read more

I love walking in to the smell of freshly baked cookies. Such a quaint spot with delicious treats.

Absolutely amazing ! A friend brought us a few different cookies. They were so delicious! The peanut butter and jelly were our favorite along with the rainbow with chocolate covered. We can taste the love! read more

From the moment you walk in, you'll know why I love this bakery: the aroma of fresh baked goods is unbelievable. The cookies are delicious - especially the rainbow ones - and their selection leaves little to be desired. Also their cupcakes beat any other cupcake in the city without question. Magnolia and Crumbs can eat their hearts out. The red velvet cupcakes here are absolutely heavenly and their prices are more than reasonable. Probably the least expensive pound of cookies you can get in the city. read more