The shrimp was amazing And the Cedar Planked Salmon was delish. Please add more potatoes to your Clam Chowder otherwise it would have been chefs kiss. No pics I was hungry read more

Extremely disappointing experience. The service was painfully slow and the staff came across as very impersonal. It took almost 30 minutes just to have our order taken, another 30 minutes for soup, another 30 minutes for the calamari appetizer, and yet another 30 minutes for our main dish, which was just a lobster roll. What should have been a simple meal turned into an unnecessarily long and frustrating wait. What made it worse was that our waitress didn't seem apologetic at all about how long everything was taking. In fact, she appeared much more attentive to the table next to us, who she seemed to know personally, while we were left waiting most of the time. To add to that, the water we asked for never even arrived. The experience ended on an uncomfortable note when we went to pay. Our card was flagged for possible fraud (likely because we're not from the area). While my husband was already pulling out cash to pay, a man wearing a beanie and chef jacket stood there in a pushy manner insisting we call the bank immediately while he waited. Between the extremely slow service, lack of attentiveness, and the uncomfortable payment interaction, the entire experience was frustrating from start to finish. Save yourself the trip and the time -- we should have listened to the reviews before making the drive. read more

See all

I've had this place bookmarked for a while! Today was the day my friend and I visited for lunch. We both got the lobster roll lunch special. $24? Yes please! We were also able to get it whichever way we prefer, hot or cold. We both went with hot! I added a cup of soup to mine for $6. I went with New England clam chowder. Both my lobster roll and the soup were very good! Service was great today (2/18/26 at 12pm). I don't remember our waiter's name, but he was great. I would definitely return and try some other things off their menu! 5+ stars! read more

The Cull House - Soup and lobster roll - Seafood Near Me - Sayville, New York

Went here for my birthday with family and the food was horrible . Total tourist trap do Not recommend . read more

First time here for a quick light lunch. The Cull House is right by the Sayville Ferry , so convenient! The woman serving use was so polite and attentive. Thank you . The restaurant is rustic , with plenty of seating and it has a nice bar too. I ordered fish and chips off of the lunch menu . I was pleasantly surprised at the price as it was unexpected , only $15.00 ! The coating on the fish , which was cod , was so delicious , crunchy, crisp and not at all greasy. The fish itself was sweet and not fishy tasting . The chips were a surprise as I expected French fries but it was crispy bake potato pieces . They were absolutely delicious! I will definitely be back to try something else . read more

See all

Beware of MP on the pricing on the menu. Means Market Price right? Also means MANY PESOS. $62.75 for a lobster roll???? WTF??!!! Maybe that's market price in Nantucket or East Hampton! Ask what the price is ahead of time. Otherwise this place is nothing special. I could have got the same quality at friendly for 1/3 the price read more

Came here on a Saturday while family was in town for an early dinner. The outside looked a little run down but it was nice and clean inside. We sat down right away but staff was a little slow as we waited awhile to order drinks + food. Once things were ordered, though, everything came out in a timely matter. I think the only major disappointment was the food itself. Unfortunately, our baked clams were a little fishy and had too much garlic -- also, I'm pretty sure they served us a used lemon wedge which was off putting. As for the food, shrimp was undercooked and my chicken was definitely dry/overcooked. They forgot our baked potatoes and then when served, the plastic butter packages were INSIDE of the baked potato which is a little unsanitary. Not sure if I'll be back -- the staff is super friendly and hardworking but the kitchen just didn't do it for me. Good luck and I hope this pushes some improvements! read more

See all

Wow Went here years ago and mhh.. This time food service location affordability for families was exceptional Even shook owners hand! Local ..community..local.harvest Well.situayed to get off ferry and eat a scrumptious meal #lobster #hamburger #cocktails in a Beautifully furnished restaurant read more

Hidden Gem. I went for their lunch special on their lobster roll and it did not disappoint. Very good. I got the hot lobster roll and it was perfect. The service was very fast and the waitress was very friendly. My husband and I sat outside. The ambiance was perfect for us on a nice sunny day. I wish the parking was better. read more

See all

Ugh! My friends & I had a craving for seafood. Not worth the $$$ for such small portions that were tasteless. Besides all of that, we all ended up terribly sick for 2 days!! Stay away!! read more

My hunny and I ate here once. That's it. Food was not worth what we paid. The food actually smelled funny. The restaurant itself smelled really awful. Won't be returning. read more

Went here last night and was highly disappointed. I started off with the Clams Casino (6) which were so small, nickel size. My husband started with 1/2 dozen Raw Oysters which he liked. All 6 of my clams (not including the breading) were the size of 1 of his oysters. For my entree I ordered the Tuesday special which was $28 for a boiled 1 1/4 lb Lobster which doesn't come with any sides. I asked for it stuffed with crabmeat stuffing and that added on $15. Not a big deal....however that Lobster was no way over 1 pound! It was very small. It was cooked properly, not chewy like some places I've been too that overcook them, too bad it was so small. My husband's entree was the boiled Captains platter $34 which he ate most of it except the Bay Scallops that were overcooked and rubbery. The Coconut rice and string beans that came with his dinner were delicious. We skipped on Dessert. Probably won't be returning here with all the other Seafood restaurants in the area to try. read more

To start off, the parking was a pain in the neck. There's is not enough parking for the amount of space they have in the restaurant and usually restaurants would then turn to valet, but they didn't offer that. The surrounding residential neighborhood streets had no parking signs all over. We were attracted to this restaurant because of its outdoor seating and variety of seafood. It also had a chill beach vibe rather than super fancy. The back patio was nice with a bit of a garden (bees were around sporadically). The food was ok, and the prices were affordable rather than outrageous,however, this certainly was not the best lobster roll on Long Island. The bun/bread the lobster roll was served on could've definitely been stepped up a notch. Regarding the service, our waitress and servers were nice and took our orders promptly, but the food took a long time to come out read more

The Cull House - Frutti di Mare CT Lobster Roll Maine Lobster Roll - Seafood Near Me - Sayville, New York

We took a break from dining here because our last experience wasn't so great but decided to give it another shot tonight .. 5 empty tables and we got sat in a walk way so close to the the table of 10 women behind us that the lady behind me kept hitting me every time she flipped her hair .. they were having fun which was great but we went for a quiet dinner and it was anything but that .. the tuna steak I ordered medium came out well done and dry .. I've been going to the Cull House sine before I could drive but it was way better in the 80's as were most things .. sadly we won't be back read more

Recommended! Had a wonderful experience here recently. We will return and we highly recommend Cull House. Great food, super super service, Casual atmosphere, near Fire Island Ferries in Sayville. Server was a 10+++, and the manager came to each table to converse with customers! A big plus! Really shows buy-in and dedication to customers and product! For apps we had some delicious Long island Steamers. Tender and flavorful, served with drawn butter and clam broth in an iron skillet. Really good! We also had a nice wedge salad, a crisp and snappy favorite of ours. Cull House got this relatively easy salad right. (Sometimes other restsursnt miss on the easy stuff) For mains we had a lobster roll and the broiled fisherman's platter. The lobster roll was "cold style" with sweet snd flavorful lobster meat in light mayo with a small trace of celery. Nicely done. The roll was a garlic buttered brioche style hot dog bun. An interesting variation to the traditional plain white bread hot dog bun. The lobster roll came with 2 sides. We choose coleslaw and coconut white rice. Both sides were nice and the coconut rice was especially flavorful. We also has a broiled fisherman's platter. The platter had a generous portion of bay scallops, shrimp, flounder, a baked clam and a crab cake, really good! it also came with our choice of two sides. We choose coleslaw and steamed broccoli which had a delicious bonus chipotle mayo! Really good! After we finished our meal, Our server brought us over a desert menu with a really nice selection of house made deserts snd desert drinks. Note: dont skip the deserts! Totally amazing! Super good! We had chocolate espresso bars and crem brûlée, both exceptional. So good, Id maybe even come here just for desert! Also consider Cull House for catering! They have a lobster bake shore dinner that i would consider for a party or event. Highly recommend, reasonably priced and casual. read more

See all

Very nice Mother's Day lunch. They had a gluten free bun for the lobster roll. Very nice portion of lobster. I like that they have a mocktail menu. I was unable to have fries due to cross contamination. I was happy to be able to substitute a baked potatoes. Mom said the fries were great! read more

See all

If you want to get a delicious good size Lobster Roll for a very affordable price during a 12- 3:30 lunch period you will not be disappointed. Classic seafood local staple with a relaxed atmosphere and nice friendly service whether you sit indoors or outside. Only had the Lobster Roll with some good tasty french fries but I'm sure the rest of the typical seafood offerings are good as well. read more

Always good food.... Lunch specials are a good value and good. We have going here for years, never had a bad meal.

Came here last week with my husband in-laws. Our party of six was promptly seated in the back room. For an appetizer, we ordered fried calamari. It was good but did not have enough calamari rings. It had way too much "squid looking things" which we're not a fan of. I ordered penne a la vodka which came with a house salad. Salad was good but they had creamy balsamic dressing which I was not a fan of so I asked for oil and balsamic vinaigrette. My pasta came out on a skillet which I found interesting but totally lacked taste. On the other hand, my husband's lobster roll was the best he's ever had. Our waiter was fine but a little forgetful. Nice, though. read more

The Cull House - Seafood Near Me - Sayville, New York

See all

I was excited to try the lobster roll, which was very much hyped. Although it had a little bit of good flavor, it was overall the worst Lobster roll I've ever had: dry lobster, a pitiful amount of meat, a tiny leaf of lettuce the only thing else on the plate. I was expecting Cull House to do better since friends have recommended them. They've got to figure out the lobster roll--one of the easiest things to make. Onion rings were good. read more

Really great experience, Food really really good, top notch lobster roll but for me service is super important and Alexa just made our night. Every restaurant needs to clone this young lady. read more

The clams are plump & cooked to perfection. Waitress was friendly & made our visit special.

I was disappointed that the lunch special lobster roll did not come with anything other than the roll itself. There were no fries or cole slaw. It was not even plated nicely. read more

This IS the best simple seafood around. The lobster bisque is to die for!!! The lobster roll delicious! . I had the broiled captains platter perfect! The service is fantastic! Ambiance is a low key your local place to go. The only thing I didn't like ( was plastic silverware and throw away soup bowl ). But I hate it personal preference.... But sooo good highly recommend! read more

What a great spot! Fantastic drinks and one of the best lobster rolls. Service treated like you were a regular so friendly and perceptive of our needs. Ambiance is warm and gives you the feeling that you are on a harbor, which you are. View of the boat docks which make for a nice stroll after dinner. read more

Good basic fried seafood is not as commonly available on Long Island as I expected, being more used to towns in coastal North Carolina and on the Gulf Coast. So, I was pleased to find this place. Had the fried fisherman's platter - fish filet, clam strips, a few shrimp, tiny scallops, slaw and French fries. No hushpuppies this far north :-( Good service, even at 3pm after lunch rush is a distant memory and before dinner staff has arrived. Tasty, not soaked in grease. Flavor and quality of seafood is 4 out of 5. Acceptable, would stop here again. Price is more than stated on menu, but that seems de rigueor these days. read more

See all

Food was average (lobster roll lobster had a few cartilage pieces), mussels were pretty good but served w no bread, wine selection was good but not tailored to seafood which it should be. Service was average, ambiance was nice. Probably won't come back again tbh read more

My famiy has been faithful patrons at the Cullhouse for over 15 years. It's close to our house and we obviously love the food. The food rarely disappoint. However, the service this evening was absolutely appalling. The entire waitstaff huddled at the bar and not one came over to our table. The one busboy never offered water. Worse yet, not one member from wait staff even acknowledged our presence. There were only five other tables at this time so they were by no means busy. We waited 10 minutes. No one came. So we left. My wife thought to inform host that we are leaving because no one came to our table. Host said nothing. It's as if these lazy workers want to get fired so they can collect an unemployment check. Such a shame. We really used to love this place. read more

They really take the Covid situation seriously, plastic silverware, paper plates, salt and pepper served individually - I haven't seen that since Covid started so good for them. Also socially distanced tables. The food was very good and the waitress was very good too. We both enjoyed our entrees. We ordered a bottle of white wine and she brought over the holder to keep it cold. All good things! The inside is very basic, I felt like it could have been a clam shack establishment. That was the only downside for me. read more

The Cull House - Special on the night - Seafood Near Me - Sayville, New York

See all

Nice place especially on a nice sunny day! Love their Lobsters! Good and friendly service, specials menu is always something I consider as it is exciting. read more

Great food and atmosphere. The staff was courteous. Every minute was enjoyable. The owner made his way around the room, making all feel welcome. read more

This was the first time we ate here. We found this place because of a local promo they have with the movie theater here. It was delicious. My husband and I are very particular when it comes to seafood places, but this was worth every penny. Not many placer serve mocktails, for those if us that don't drink, but it was welcoming to see that they have some here. Not very crowded for a Saturday night. The wait staff was very attentive. We will definitely be coming back. read more

We live in Nassau County and The Cull House is our go to spot for never fail fresh and tasty seafood. Sunday lobster madness is an excellent opportunity to enjoy the BEST, sweetest, tender, fresh whole lobster and great sides for great price ($27!). Everything is so fresh - and light! The fried shrimp appetizer is amazing. The best fries - crisp and flavorful and Ruths Potato Salad is yummy! Very friendly, professional service, comfortable dining room, pretty spot, nice views, cool vibe. Lots of great seafood options - and great options other than seafood. Something for everyone. Soooo good. read more

See all

First time visit. Stopped by for lunch while in the area. The food and cocktail were very nice. I'd come back. read more

See all

Took 20 min to see a server! The food was not good at all! Took forever to get a drink. The server when she had time for us was nice My dinner was 200 dollars not sure why it was so much . I had rice wit shrimp Lobster bisque was gross the meat taco was horrible the meat was raw I spit it into a napkin . Not going back Good luck read more

I came with my fiancé looking for steamers. We ended up ordering two orders of steamers, the oysters rockerfeller, and the seafood gumbo. Steamers were good which is why we ended up ordering another one. Everything else was pretty mediocre. VERY expensive overall. My fiancé says he'd rate the place 3.5 stars. I rated it a 4 cause I was mostly just looking for steamers and those stood out. Will come back again but legit only will be ordering steamers. read more

I heard such good things about this place but honestly was not impressed. The service was good friendly and attentive. Atmosphere kinda beachy that was cool. The food was not what I expected. We ordered 2 soups that were good but came in paper dishes which would be good if I was paying $6 for them which were $12 each. We shared a Lobster grilled cheese sandwich which was $36 The bread was cold and 2 slices of cheese not even melted. The fries were also cold and soggy. We both got a Pina Colada which was very good. Here's the thing. One sandwich 2 small soups and 2 drinks came to 95.47 ! Add the $20 tip and I spent 115.47 for us to share a cold sandwich. I guess I had high hopes . read more

This was our 2nd time at Cull house. Went once in late winter early spring. Wasn't great but thought we would try again. There wasn't many people there for lunch. I ordered fried shrimp and it was good. My husband ordered fish and chips. The piece of fish was literally 1.5 inches by 3 inches!! And super greasy! Not good. The service was nonexistent! There was maybe 2 other tables at most. No one came by to ask how our meal was and there was 2 wait staff there! Not going back. $60+a tip should've been a lot better lunch for 2 people! read more

As a local, I have been coming to The Cull House on & off for many years. Sometimes, the food and service is outstanding, other times it is mediocre at best. I can't give a higher rating because it's hit or miss. With that being said, my most recent visit was ranked a definite 5 out of 5. The food and service was spectacular! Located near the Sayville Ferries, there's a private lot for the restaurant as well as some street parking. The service is always unpredictable. During my last visit, our server was excellent. She continued to offer drink refills and was very friendly. At other visits, the service is slow and not very attentive. Maybe they have stepped it up, hopefully it's permanent. The prices are fair. For the area, the menu items are priced ok. This is certainly not a restaurant that is going to break the bank, but it may not be a cheap night out either. The food is always unpredictable as well. During my last visit, I was more than impressed. Over the years, I've tried a ton of menu items. I will be listing my favorites: Seafood Penne Alla Vodka, Steamers, New England Clam Chowder, Fish Tacos, Shrimp Tacos, Skirt Steak. Overall, The Cull House is a cute restaurant with a great location. I hope the service and food continue to improve!! I'll be back. read more

See all

Oh man this place was pretty bad... and its sad because for a place close to the sea you should be very good. We got the Broiled Fisherman's Platter was bland, uneventful, and honestly could of made something better at home (and it would of been cheaper too!). Thankfully no one got sick which is the next concern you get when having bad seafood experience. Will not be coming back again or recommending to others... read more