I wasn't expecting great things as the recent reviews were not great. But so far, this is the best…read moremeal I have had in chama. We each got a hamburger, and they were immense. Well over 1/2 pound of meat each. They were on large buns, and the patties stuck over the buns all the way around and were decently thick. Neat was cooked properly and very tasty. The fries were also good. Hamburger and fries was $11. A very reasonable price for what you got. A rarely seen occurrence in chama. Our server was extremely helpful and friendly. The place doesn't look like much but gets the job done. Was clean and kind of norther NM quirky.

The service was good and so was the food. I had the cheese enchiladas and they were great. Lots…read moreof forestry people here due to fires. We all k ow, they know where the good food is located!

Very disappointing recent visit. The pizzas were burnt on the bottom and undercooked on the inside…read more We agreed that the lettuce-covered enchiladas weren't good, but the steak was. The sauteed mushrooms were also good. The service was at least as disappointing. They took our beer orders, but never served them. The restaurant was not super busy at the time, so there's no excuse. [Original 5-star review] One of two restaurants in Chama that I consider really good (the other is Outlaw BBQ). On our most recent visit, we had 3 pizzas: buffalo chicken (a special not on the regular menu), Yard Bird, and pepperoni. All were really good; the buffalo chicken was my favorite. I advise ordering, up front, everything you plan to drink. Having finished a great milk stout beer, and there being no sign of our food, I went back to get another and was firmly told to go to the end of the (food ordering) line. Before I got to order again, most of the beers, including the milk stout, had run dry. It was a half hour before I made it back to our table, but I did beat the pizzas.

Great spot in town! Keep in mind this is a counter service. For food, we enjoyed the pizza. Their…read moreservice was attentive and friendly and we loved the ambiance on their outdoor deck. And for those hesitant by the negative reviews of service, they have new management, so don't let that deter you.

I was only in town for one night and while scrolling around for where to eat, I saw some pictures…read moreof Dublin Crust and Brew's pizzas and thought that's what I'm having. While walking up to the place I hear live music playing. A handful of locals were hanging out and playing. I got the Dubliner Stampede pizza, which was excellent. Guinness on draft, a session, great pizza, this place is a gem! Chances are vanishingly small that I'll ever be back but I'll always remember it.

Our family has been looking for a place like this the past few times we have visited Pagosa! Family…read morefriendly environment and awesome outdoor space. They even offer blankets at each table. The staff are very friendly and the service is fast!! The BEST part about this place though is the pizza, seriously, SO good! Oh and there's self serve wine, beer, and cider! Cheers!

This was easily our favorite place in Pagosa Springs! The entire experience and vibe were just…read morefantastic. We started with the salads, which were phenomenal- absolutely huge portions and incredibly fresh. The pizza itself was spectacular. Even though the restaurant was pretty busy, the service was impressively quick and attentive, and the environment was great to hang out in. Before we left, we got some of their dessert dough balls to go--both the apple pie and the cinnamon flavors. They were absolutely delicious and the perfect sweet finish. Overall, just a wonderful meal and a great atmosphere. We will definitely be back!

We came here for dinner. The wait was about an hour. Which is understandable given the holiday…read moreweekend. Our server was great in taking our orders and checking on us, but to get the check on the other hand, that took a while. Onto the food. Our order got mixed up a bit. We got one pizza placed in front of us that wasn't ours, the other that got dropped off someone at my table didn't notice and started eating it. Then our original order was brought. Long story short we had a bunch of left overs. I personally got a calzone that was amazing and the size portion was huge. This is a pet friendly location so they have outdoor seating and sliding garage doors that can be closed. Overall it was a great feel to it. And we would def come back for more.

The pizza was sub par at best in my honest opinion, the hype was not real sadly. The thing this got…read moreme the most was the unprofessionalism of the woman working there. I cannot think of a place where I have been yelled at and harassed anywhere in my life before. It's a beat down old pizza shack where you can eat outside but there are many rules posted outside. Don't break any of the rules or you will be crucified. The whole environment and experience was disappointing. I will not be posting a picture of the mid grade pizza either.

This tiny little spot in Abiquiu doesn't look like much, but man oh man do they put out delicious…read morepizza. We stopped to grab a pizza and take with us to our accommodations. We stepped up to the order window and the woman took our order, and we sat outside at the picnic tables and waited about 20 minutes. We were handed a hot pizza box and we were on our way. As we drove, the smell of a perfectly cooked pizza filled the car. Once we got to our room, we sat out on our patio and enjoyed a perfectly cooked pizza. It was delicious! Don't expect much service. The woman was very matter of fact, was a bit more friendly when she brought our pizza out. But we weren't expecting much, just great pizza and Mamacita absolutely delivered.

From the first phone call to the pick up, the staff were friendly and respectful. The pizza was…read morecooked to perfection and the chicken wings were not great but decent. It was a great quick meal for our first night after driving 12 hours to town. Thank you PJP!

Food was not fully cooked. We had two pizzas. Neither was fully cooked. Took forever. I would…read morenot recommend.

What a nice pleasant & delicious experience from start to finish! Emma was our server. It was…read moregetting busy shortly after we were seated, but Emma was always checking in with us. I had "The Matty" pizza that was really good. My husband had a calzone & salad. Everything was excellent! Nice ambiance & very clean restaurant too.

The food, service and ambiance were fantastic. Lasagna bolognese was rustic and full of flavor.read more

This is the only place to go for fine dining and an incredible dinner experience…read more Service-spot on. We didn't have to wait for anything! If you needed it they were on it. Couldn't ask for better. Ambiance- quiet, friendly, calm, perfect for a quiet night out and good conversation. Food- the best I've had in this town and we've been coming through here for 15 years.

We always visit Alley House Grille when we're in Pagosa Springs. The food is always fantastic and…read morethe atmosphere has such a great vibe, especially in the bar area with the fireplace and outdoor seating. Bartenders JB and Luis make some of the best cocktails too. Definitely one of our favorite spots in town!

All 3 Food, Service was great and they have a super nice bar inside People were very nice and…read morehelpful.

If you go here to pick up an online order, make sure they have the order before you sit there…read morewatching people come and go for half an hour. The fact that I messed up the order is on me. The fact that we asked about our pizza, and got a blank stare 15 minutes ago, is on them.