I hadn't had Guida's since they closed down in Penfield... and I have come home to the promised…read moreland. I took a new job in the west side and my coworkers typically order from Guida's in Gates. Having tried their delicious pIzza in the office, I ventured over to Elmwood to check them out for myself... and it is fantastic! A large selection of lunchtime slices including thin crust wood fired, white pizza, Detroit thick crust and Grandma's pizza. All have generous toppings and are baked to perfection. The dining area is very nice and always tidy. Above average for a busy storefront pizza joint and I love the staff. Always a smile and a kind greeting. Watch the steady stream of huge slices and happy customers heading out the door at lunch time and you will know you're at the right place. My favorite in the west side.

Great menu amazing food wonderful service and the customers match the business. Its the real deal…read more Walking in the door is like walking into a different time. I don't have time to explain it, so try it yourself and see what you think. Ronnie

Greeat food and service. We ordered 2 pizza's margherita…read moreand antonia, and 2 pieces of lemon cake. Everything was very good. A little on the pricy side. But overall very happy with the quality of the food and service. There are a few booths so you could eat in house or take out. The total was $60.45 and I gave the girls a tip even though I picked up my order. Pizza places are tough in the summer. They all looked like they were working hard on a friday night. :) I would recommend and will return.

Got the Bronx bomber pizza, capones chicken wings and garlic knots, everything was great!!read more

stopped in for a quick bite and the service was amazing! Food was incredible you have to get the…read morenachos w/ pulled pork hands down best nachos i've had!! extremely cute place will be coming back again!!

The food is amazingly crafted, with generous portions and great beer to pair with. I can't think of…read moreone bad meal I have had here. The staff is super friendly and professional as well.

Great burgers! Reminds me of Tom Whals burgers. Cute little place. Fast and friendly service.read more

Haven't been here in a while, but the burgers are still good! They make them to order - well…read moredone, extra pickles, etc.. whatever you ask for. Note that they no longer sell meatball subs. Not sure why as they were good! Their prices are also getting high. 2 burgers, 1 order of fries and 2 small (and they are small) drinks ran us close to $23.00. Still delicious and would stop here as a "treat"

It was our first order from Caraglios, and we won't be back. We ordered a breakfast calzone and a…read morechicken parm sub. The calzone was tasteless and had very little meat in it, and the roll of the sub couldn't have been soggier if they dipped it in water.

Disappointing... Ordered a medium peperoni pizza the other night. Arrived 25 minutes after placing…read morethe order (as that's when they said it would be ready) and it wasn't even in the oven yet; they weren't busy! When I get home, we find that they used white sauce rather than pizza sauce - this wasn't what we ordered. OK, mistakes happen so giving them the benefit of the doubt, we tried them the next day for subs. We ordered a chicken philly and a pulled pork sandwich. The guy answering the phone said, "we don't have sandwiches". I asked, then why is it on the menu - he looked and said, "hmm, well I guess we do." I was told by one of the staff that this guy has worked there for over a year. Well, the chicken philly was horrid - the peppers were raw rather than grilled, the chicken was barely warm, and the sub had no flavor. The pulled pork was cold with bbq sauce poured on top. Obviously, we won't be going back.

Amazing food! Excellent service!…read moreOwner is full of character and cares about his place! MUST TRY!

Gave this place a try with a special, a medium cheese pizza for $10. Very tasty pizza with great…read morecheese mix and homemade sauce. Really good balance of flavors. This is our go to place now for pizza. Extensive menu; can't wait to try other items.

Menu is quite large with enough choices that everyone should find something they would like. There…read morewere six in our party and selections ran from finger food to burgers to comfort food. Everything was well prepared and tasty. Service was friendly but minimal. You order and pay (cash only, there is an ATM) at the counter when you come in and your food is brought to your table.

This is an adorable local restaurant to Spencerport. Perfect family restaurant. They seem known for…read moretheir burgers, hots, and garbage plates. But they also have breakfast, salads, wraps, and even a veggie burger and, spinach wrap as an option to any of their wraps. They have ice cream and soft serve custard as well. The Ambiance is all about Abe Lincoln and is decorated like an old log cabin, with outdoor and indoor seating. I had a the cheeseburger wrap, which was delicious, and a healthier option to their regular cheeseburger. It was very fresh, came with lettuce, tomato, onions, and mayo. The lettuce was super crisp, which was nice and satisfying. My hubs, had the regular cheeseburger and hot dog. He wolfed it down. The price was extremely reasonable, and the place was very clean and the staff friendly. I would definitely go back, and families looking for a fun night out of burgers, dogs, and Ice cream can't go wrong here. Plenty of parking.

Stopped here twice recently. Specific to both experiences, the staff are friendly and attentive…read more There is a nice selection of beer with Guinness and Rohrbachs Scotch Ale is also available. My first visit I went with the Cottage Pie. It was decent but it lacked depth of flavor. My second visit I went with the goat cheese salad. I really enjoyed it. Regarding dessert, there are nice options and unique. Stop by and I am sure you will not be disappointed.

We went to McColley's in Spencerport last Friday the 13th for dinner. The place was packed and we…read moregot 1 of the last tables in the back and to the side of the restaurant. It was nice there very rustic. So our waitress came to the table shortly after we sat down and took our drink and food order. He got fish he was happy with it and I got the veggie burger and tater tots everything was really good. And it was a nice night out. If you're in the area it's a good place to go.