On my recent cruise, we stopped at Cape Canaveral. I only had two stops on my agenda, Coco Beach and this cute little shop I read about serving some of the best key lime pies in Florida. After a sunny day at the beach, our group of eight walked to this shop and decided on buying a whole pie for $18 instead of two slices at $5 a pop. Certainly the better deal, but we also didn't want to regret later for not ordering enough. Well, it was a very good decision. We devoured the whole pie in one sitting like a bunch of starving hyenas seeing food for the first time in weeks. There was not a crumb left by the time we finished. The pie was as great as they say, and definitely one of the best I ever had. Just the right amount sour and tartness without being overly sweet. If I were to nitpick, then I would like a slightly thicker graham cracker crust. Not sure when I'll come back to Cape Canaveral again. However, if I do, this may have become stop number one on my list. You can find beaches everywhere, but an excellent key lime pies is a treasure you rarely discover. read more

See all

Some of the best places were the places we didn't even plan on stopping by, like this place. We just happened to stumble onto this little gem of a shop after visiting Ron Jon's main shop across the street. The word "ice cream" caught my eye, and even if it was late February, the weather was warm, which is strange, given a week prior to our arrival, it was freezing cold, so ice cream it was. There was a little line in the store, with only one man scooping ice cream for a bunch of people waiting (who was also the cashier). It was funny to see how people would copy each other with choosing the flavor; the lady in front said "sweet cream" flavor, and each successive person behind her said the same thing, even if they were not with her. I stuck to my guns and got the Key Lime Pie Ice cream, which was a great choice! Sweet, creamy and tangy, all the right combo! They also have candies, salt water taffies of all flavors, beer, alligator jerky, Tortuga rum cakes, key lime pies, a huge wall of hot sauces, and gifts. I ended up walking out with a bottle of hot sauce and orange blossom perfume roller ball, which was very nice. Prices were reasonable given this is tourist-town. read more

See all

Key lime pie amazing. Not just pie available. Several others items available like jerky, taffy, home made ice cream and more. Sit out front and people watch and enjoy some key lime pie. If you can't make it to Key West it's the next best thing. Now go get you some. read more

The Florida Key Lime Pie Company - Key lime pie. - Desserts Near Me - Cocoa Beach, Florida

See all

Excellent key lime pie! It's $18 for a whole pie, $5 for a slice. Definitely pricey but it's a great, refreshing dessert. Service was good and the store had a fun ambiance. Touristy, but still fun. Lots of drink options and other miscellaneous gift shop items. I recommend the stop! read more

The Florida Key Lime Pie Company - Key lime pie - Desserts Near Me - Cocoa Beach, Florida

Since we were in the area for Ron Jon and I love key lime pie, we stopped here. It's one of my favorite desserts! We were greeted as soon as we walked in the door. The place has jerky and many other things. We primarily wanted pie and ice cream. They have a ton of things lime flavored including the juice. The immediate standout to me was the salt water taffy! They had so many flavors that I've never seen. The only reason I didn't buy any is because I wanted every flavor. I figured if I bought every flavor, I'd start eating it and forget what flavor it was supposed to be. So with that, we got a slice of pie and a scoop of ice cream each. I got the key lime ice cream and it was delicious. My wife got some pineapple/mango/combo ice cream. It was also good. I'm only taking off 1 star because of the pie. It was good at first but had a weird aftertaste that I couldn't ignore. Not sure if my slice came from a bad batch of lime juice or what. It just wasn't good and because the name of the place has key lime in it.. I have to account for that. The next time I'm in the area, I'll pick up another slice in hopes that it'll be better. read more

The Florida Key Lime Pie Company - Desserts Near Me - Cocoa Beach, Florida

See all

Loved this place! I've never really had key lime pie before but this one was very creamy and refreshing. Even the baby liked it. We got a whole pie for $18, which I felt like was a great deal, but you can also get individual slices for $5. They had a wide selection of other sweets, ice cream and local beers- I recommend the Paradiso coconut ale. As a bonus, when we went there was a gator named Sweetie sitting outside the shop. See picture. read more

See all

I was back in Cocoa Beach on a cruise with Bama and we had to make a stop at the key pie company. It's still as delicious as I remembered, but sadly, so many of the key lime wine and beverage companies have gone out of business since my last visit they're no longer tastings of the beverages, but they still have a small selection available, as well as beers for purchase. They have a nice assortment of key lime products, ice cream, local goods and Florida specialties available. read more

OMG !!!! This is the "Best" Key Lime Pie I've ever had. This established has EVERYTHING from fresh Key Lime Pie, hand dipped ice cream, and just about everything you will find in an old country store. The man that waited on us was very friendly. PLEASE stop by and you won't be disappointed. DELICIOUS!!!!!! read more

The Florida Key Lime Pie Company - Key Lime Pie - Desserts Near Me - Cocoa Beach, Florida

The name could not summarize it any better. Although there are many other items that they do have in the store, one of the specialties is the key lime pie. We were already in the area and were interested in a sweet treat, and settled for something more local rather than ice cream, although they did also have ice cream here. We grabs two slices of pie and got herself settled outside. Having easy options for to go with excellent for us and within a couple of minutes we were eating our pie. Our slices were fresh, tasty and had that slight bit of tartness that makes a Key Lime Pie both refreshing and iconic. read more

The Florida Key Lime Pie Company - Desserts Near Me - Cocoa Beach, Florida

Came to try the key lime pie on a stick, which is a chocolate dipped key lime pie piece. I'm not a key lime pie fan but wanted to give this place a shot. It was really good! The store has a little bit of everything in the store. Quite a bit of taffy, different flavored soda/beer, jerky, tons of hot sauces etc. they also have quite a bit of political decorations as an fyi. They also close at 6pm everyday. I was lucky to check the hours before heading to this store. I was going to arrive later thinking that a dessert store would be open a little bit later than 6. read more

The Florida Key Lime Pie Company - Key lime pie slice on a stick - Desserts Near Me - Cocoa Beach, Florida

You forget what really good key lime pie tastes like until you get a really good slice of the real thing. Then every other one you have ever eaten pales in comparison. A mere shadow, not really even worthy of the name. I LOVED IT. Best I've ever had, even counting the slices I had down in the Keys. The store is frosty cold, the staff were helpful. I'll go back every time I am in the neighborhood. read more

This little store is all things Key Lime ‍..From Wines to Sauces to Pies and Ice Cream..I came in for some candies I had bought from here before, they didn't have them so I bought some others and not the same :( got a Key Lime ‍ Rum Cake too...Was going to get a slice of Pie but it looked dried out so I did not, if you love Key Lime this is your place....they have it all! read more

See all

This is the best place in Cocoa Beach for souvenirs! They have a variety of delicious food items and cute postcards. A unique find is their collection of political hot sauces and exotic jerky (bison, snapping turtle, python), which may not be for everyone but definitely adds an interesting touch. They also carry a fantastic selection of Florida-made wines, beers, and other locally crafted souvenirs. If you're visiting from out of town, I highly recommend stopping by. In addition to the souvenirs, they serve ice cream and, of course, key lime pie. For gifts, I picked up white chocolate key lime cookies, Florida orange peppermints, and snapping turtle jerky. Plus, they offer a 10% military discount! If you get the chance to meet the owner, he's a fun and friendly person to chat with. My top picks for souvenirs in the area are Florida Key Lime Pie Company, Cocoa Beach Winery, and Ron Jon Surf Shop. read more

Best pie ever! We have stopped by during our last two vacations to cocoa beach. They also have a lot of Florida made snacks, body care, and souvenirs to take home!! Great service. Fun ambiance. read more

Hands-down, best Keylime pie I have ever tasted!!!! Louie is a Key Lime Pie genius! It was the perfect blend of flavor and creaminess. The crust was proportionate to the filling. Absolutely delicious!!! Louie also makes the most unique ice cream flavors. Delicious!! A very friendly place. Thank you Louie! read more

The Florida Key Lime Pie Company - Desserts Near Me - Cocoa Beach, Florida

See all

Was super excited to try the key lime pie!! Untill I seen trumps face everywhere, in 2026 that is wild. I put the pie back and walked out, mind you was never greeted or anything... I will not support a business that loudly supports someone so hateful. I will take my business elsewhere. (P.S Publix key lime pie is the best, try there instead) read more

Best key lime pie and the owner was so cool Cant wait to try our hot sauce we also got A must visit if in the area read more

Walked in really looking forward to trying their key lime pie. The workers didn't greet me or my group and we were the only ones in the store. We really didn't feel comfortable or welcome at all. Then we noticed Donald Trump memorabilia placed everywhere, so maybe that's the reason why? Not sure, but I don't have plans on going back. read more

Has the ugliest Trump poster stand in the back of the store... &I won't support shops with gross ice cream options... chocolate ice cream tasted like garbage read more

Super delicious key lime pie! Must stop here when in the area, you won't regret it. They also offer many other varieties of snacks from beef jerky, to hot sauces, ice cream, and more. The staff was super friendly and the shop is very clean. read more

See all

Cutest little shop with delicious desserts. The had unbelievable truffles as well! Very quaint and clean store. read more

The Florida Key Lime Pie Company - Gator outside - Desserts Near Me - Cocoa Beach, Florida

See all

Not a dine-in place, a laid back store that carries some excellent local products!! The gentleman who was working was extremely knowledgeable about all the products in the store. I loved the local hot sauce collection and bought a couple to take home. My father in law loved the key lime pie (slice to go) and he considers himself quite the connoisseur. He also recommends the local wines as he really enjoyed one of the dry white varieties. Unfortunately we didn't try the ice cream, but the flavors looked delicious and unique. Definitely a great stop!! read more

Big key lime pie fan here. First off you need to go on a weekend so you can meet Sweetie the gator outside first. I petted Sweetie the gator while she was getting her gator nails painted hot pink. Then we went inside and bought a slice of their signature key lime pie and some Key West key lime seasoning. There were other customers coming in just to buy a key lime pie. There were many key lime flavored items and even a key lime soda. I love this place. Plus it's a short walk and in the same parking lot from Ron Jon's Surf Shop. read more

See all

Didn't see the Trump cutout and merch until we ordered. Not a place I would spend money again.

Pretty good keylime pie. I tried it at a few places and this place definitely had a good one. I'd go back for sure. They have lots of other treats as well. read more

What a great place to visit! They have everything Florida from jerky to taffy to their delicious Key Lime pie! Jellies and local beers are also available. Good prices and a very friendly staff here. Definitely stop in! read more

If you want a mass produced key lime pie, this is the place. Publix makes a better pie. Take your money there.

Parking: plenty of free parking right in front. Service: they actually don't put most of their prices on their products. This place is pretty packed with tourist come in and out esp cuz it's right across Ron Jon's surfboard store. They do help out and are real friendly tho. Food: we got the gator jerky to try ($14). Interesting, some says it tastes like chicken. It just tasted like jerky imo. They have more than just gator jerky. A good amount of different jerky's including ostrich. We also got the key lime yogurt pretzels. The first few taste real good. But then the flavor gets kinda boring. It's nice cuz you don't end up eating the whole thing all at once. A few ppl also got the dipped chocolate key lime pie on a stick ($9). Would want to try in the future Def would come back when around the area. read more

I am a key lime fan, so anywhere that has a bunch of key lime stuff, count me in! This is a shop that has pie, ice cream, taffy, and plenty of other key lime and Florida based stuff. There's also a baby alligator that they have there some times (call for details). I happened to visit during an air show day, so the alligator was not there. I tried the key lime pie slice and a snickerdoodle key lime cookie. The pie was cool and the cookie was yummy (I appreciated the unique concept, it wasn't something I had seen before). I also tried some funky flavors of taffy (they easily had over 100 flavors). I'm not really a taffy person so I don't think I have much to report either way about that part of my visit. Staff was in a rush but helpful. read more

See all

Love this place. Great sauces!!! Highly recomend it. Great service here. Cool ambiance, love the layout.

This place is garb. Very unwelcoming. Just a bunch of packaged fake Florida made somewhere else, you can find this stuff at "Florida Wineries, Bealls Outlet, Or Bealls or Ross for cheaper. Small ice cream selection even smaller Key lime pie selection. Really sucks bc I been wanting to come here forever but they are rude and unwelcoming to say the least! read more

So many hot sauces!!! They have a Melinda's I've never seen on the shelf and the key lime is sooo good and great service.

Yep, it's definitely a legit key lime pie company! So many things KLP it's almost overwhelming, but also a wonder to walk around and see all they offer. But by far, you absolutely MUST try the Key Lime Yogurt Pretzels if you stop by. You MUST, you hear?! Sooooo good! Trust me, i know how weird it sounds and I felt apprehensive myself at first but so curious I had to try them, so please do the same yourself and thank me later by liking this review;) Oh, and I'd also get a slice a good ole key lime pie. That's pretty darn good too! They have ice cream as well and I'm telling you just so many other unique things to try. And across the street is the *original Ron Jon Surf Shop as well as Cocoa Beach Pier only a few minute walk, what more Florida essentials could you ask for? read more

See all

Not even gonna lie-- I came for the gator (Sweetie!) but left with some key lime goodies and met some great people! First off, a bit about Sweetie : she's a blind gator that was rescued by the business owner Louie and his friend , J.R. Sweetie was set to be put down and J.R. wasn't having it so the two worked together to save her . Now she lives a pampered existence and is an international celebrity (courtesy of TikTok) and regularly makes appearances at the store and other events around town . Her name suits her because she is indeed a sweetie . Louie and J.R. were so kind to indulge my love of gators and let me spend as much time with her as I wanted (even after they had closed). Their store manager , Amanda was also a sweetie - offering popular product recommendations and just being all around hospitable ! Now, onto the store . They have every kind of key lime product your heart could desire ! They also have a unique collection of locally produced products from hot sauces to beer. But do not miss the delicious key lime ice cream and the key lime yogurt pretzels - they are delish . Check out this unique place in Cocoa Beach . They are worth a detour! read more

See all

We stopped by and enjoy some key lime pie. The pie was tasty. They also had lots of can craft beer, jerky, and other snacks. read more

The Florida Key Lime Pie Company - Key lime pie - Desserts Near Me - Cocoa Beach, Florida

This is such a weird touristy type store. There were like three key lime pies in a freezer, uncovered not even in a clamshell pie case or anything just hanging out in the freezer, and they tasted freezer burnt and wet as well. Soggy crust, the pie itself was extremely tart but not in the way key lime pie should be. My kids described it as tasting like soap. Honestly I wouldn't have bought anything there once I saw the Trump paraphernalia everywhere but I wasn't going to punish my kids for someone's weird business choices. I was going to buy several bottles of wine but decided against it and just got what the kids wanted. If you're visiting from out of state you could get all this stuff at a Beals outlet store for cheaper. read more

Ok so we have been wanting to stop here for years and finally did today!! Partly because there was a gator sitting out in front but it is exactly what I expected a cute store with great treats! Their key lime pie on a stick dipped in dark chocolate was sooo good!! Definitely don't miss this place next time you come to cocoa beach!! read more

The Florida Key Lime Pie Company - Desserts Near Me - Cocoa Beach, Florida

See all

Great key lime pie. Best I've had here in Florida. Friendly guy behind the counter. Lots of taffy and lime flavored stuff. read more

The Florida Key Lime Pie Company - the key lime pie shop - Desserts Near Me - Cocoa Beach, Florida

After a day of beaches and shopping at Ron Johns Surf Shop, we needed some authentic key lime pie and had read up on this place. Upon entering we were hit with key lime everything, pretzels, candies, beer, jellies and ice cream. My wife got some peach habanero and key lime. The peach habanero wasn't spicy but had a Lil twang and delicious and the key lime pie was tangy, her words. My key lime pie was tangy and delicious. We also got some key lime pretzels, a key lime coconut bar and a Trump2024 chocolate bar. It was awesome speaking to a fellow MAGA Republican. Truly enjoyed our little visit and conversation. read more

Not really what we were expecting? We were expecting a store full of pies and other bakery items. It just seemed like another knick-knack shop with random touristy items. We ended buying 2 slices of key lime pie and a couple of candy balls. Both were subpar. If you want to save money and have better pie with more tart, just buy some from Publix or the local grocery store. Overall, just disappointed. Our recommendation: just keep driving. read more