So cute! Very quaint and not a lot of indoor seating but also have a patio with lots of tables. So many flavors and toppings/sundaes! I recommend the cold brew peanut butter chip! CASH ONLY! And they have good portions. I'd def get a brownie sundae next time read more

The Ice Cream Place - Kids scoop of cold brew pb chip - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Block Island, Rhode Island

This place has a lot of flavors which is a plus. The homemade waffle cone was very tasty. Ice cream was good and service was friendly. It smells very good and there is a small amount of indoor and outdoor seating. read more

The Ice Cream Place - Moose tracks and strawberry waffle cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Block Island, Rhode Island

Situated just down the street from where we were staying, in a small strip mall lies The Ice Cream Place. Beautiful decorated with various colors, an ice cream theme throughout. There is indoor and outdoor seating available. The ice cream was pretty good. I loved the options of flavors. They had many unique flavors as well, some more on the surrounding area level. The portions were perfect as well. The staff was helpful. They were able to describe what flavors had what in them. Which was helpful since we were not from the area or have been to The Ice Cream Place. Bathroom was clean. No issues there! This is the perfect spot to sit down after a full day of walking around and checking out all things in the area. read more

See all

The ice cream is DELICIOUS! there is almost always a line at the door of ice cream lovers, but the experienced scoopers make sure it moves fast. The bakery items! read more

Great little ice cream shop on Block Island! Ice cream portions were good sized. There was a line, but it went fast. There wasn't much space to eat indoors, but there was an outdoor patio with some tables to eat at. read more

The Ice Cream Place - Sign - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Block Island, Rhode Island

Cash only still. Great spot. Def worth it if you have cash. Don't wait in line if you don't have cash.

This was legitimately some of the best ice cream I've ever had. They had SO many flavors to choose from, so I got the Chocolate Cookie Monster (which was crack!) and then the Graham Central Station. The serving was massive as well and felt reasonably priced for the heaps of ice cream I got. The service was efficient and we were in and out despite a long line. One thing to note is it is cash only, but that's posted everywhere so it's on you if you forget. Wish I could teleport back! read more

Great location with plenty of Ice Cream for everyone to enjoy...When I come to visit my old stompin grounds of Block Island I always come to visit The Ice Cream Place when I'm craving ice cream. The staff are very friendly and nice plus helpful when I need to ask a question about a certain flavor or what flavor taste very good. One of the best spots for ice cream it's worth coming to Ice Cream Place when your wanting to snack on when your visiting, traveling, walking and etc. Outdoor seating is nice and perfect when you're wanting to sit outside to relax, take your mind off the busy lifestyle from home, work and travels. Can't go wrong here! read more

Definitely stop by for ice cream! I got the oreo and my friend got the s'mores- both were delicious! My friend said the graham cracker base for hers was amazing- truly some of the best. The staff is super nice and the location is so convenient-- right off the ferry! Stop by for a scoop! read more

The Ice Cream Place - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Block Island, Rhode Island

See all

This is the best ice cream spot. When my five year old requested a Smurf milks Connor came through. When my husband accidentally left one of our bags at their shop Connor came through again. He had his cousin hand deliver our bag back to us at the Point Judith ferry. Will be going back when we visit Block Island again. read more

Really enjoyed my time at this small ice cream Shop! It was very refreshing to have a tasty ice cream on such a hot day on the island! I tried the " Cookie Monster flavor" and it was delicious! They also gave me a very generous portion for a great price! However, be warned that they do not take card and you have to pay in cash! The person serving us was also very polite, cheerful and kind! He made the experience at the ice cream shop that much better! read more

The Ice Cream Place - Cookie Monster ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Block Island, Rhode Island

See all

Delicious ice cream that is flat out rich in flavor and price, but you cannot put a price on ice cream happiness. Cute girls working their patooties off, unlimited samplings, just a fun laid back atmosphere that screams summer. It is a bit of a pricey spot for ice cream, but I can hardly complain because it is delicious and homemade. The smell of them making the waffle cones in the back is still with me even days after leaving Block Island. The lines do get long here, especially midday and just before most of the ferries return back to the mainland in the late afternoon. Consider, and then enjoy. read more

A staple on Block Island, we always make sure we hit this place up when we are visiting. It is a no-frills ice cream shop, but it has a lot of character and we enjoy looking at the historic Block Island pictures on the wall while waiting in line. Bring cash! There is an ATM just incase. read more

A very fun destination with a lot of great flavors! Unfortunately, they do not care about contamination and use the same spoon for many different flavors. I always taste mint in my vanilla! It's not the end of the world, but there is no disclosure about contamination. My friend with a nut allergy spend the rest of the night worried about her safety. The workers often seem exhausted and unhappy to serve, but they work hard and get the job done quick. read more

This place is AMAZING. I went here every night. Their waffle cones are freshly made and fill the small shop with a mouth watering smell! The hot fudge was perfect and all the flavors of ice cream looked and sounded so good. I got peanut butter pie and muddy boots. Peanut butter pie was the perfect flavor for a chocolate and peanut butter lover! read more

The Ice Cream Place - Peanut butter pie and muddy boots ice cream in a waffle cone with hot fudge. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Block Island, Rhode Island

We have gone here for years. Best ice cream on the island, hands down! There is always a line. They have the best brownie sundaes! The brownie is always warm and fudge like. They have a good selection of flavors including sugar free and yogurt. Their walking sundae is also good and is made in a waffle cone! Servings are large. I have two tips if you are coming here: 1. Grab a table if you see one open because they have limited seating for the amount of people getting ice cream. 2. Bring cash. They do not accept cards. For a small cone and a regular sundae it is about $15. read more

Been coming here since I was born! Homemade Oreos are a must!! When they have them and the extreme chocolate is delicious!

Best Ice Cream on the Island......... Great taste, super creamy. Store made authentic with creative flavors. Try the COWABUNGA CRUNCH, there are so many ingredients, the attendant told us the read the sign, he couldn't remember "Too Many"!! Cowabunga Crunch: Vanilla Ice cream Toffee Bits Caramel Swirl Chocolate Chips Cookie Pieces Pecan = Excellence This is a cash only establishment *** read more

See all

The ice cream was good but the waffle cones were stale! We had the coffee brownie ice cream and it was delicious. Cash only so that was a bummer. Lucky we had some cash left! read more

The Ice Cream Place - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Block Island, Rhode Island

Super fresh, tasty ice cream. Highly recommend you stop by and enjoy a treat on the patio.

I love ice cream, and this was good, but the place is cash only (strike 1) and there was no a/c (strike 2). I thought I would pass out from the heat while waiting. The ice cream was good, but I'd imagine that you could find others on the island that are just as good... read more

The Ice Cream Place - Cappuccino chip w chocolate sprinkles - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Block Island, Rhode Island

It was fine. Nothing special. Tried the Oreo and peanut butter cup which was chocolate ice cream with peanut butter.

Great little ice cream spot tucked in the back. Friendly staff and plenty of flavors to choose from!

This is a timeless classic. Wonderful staff and management, great ice cream, and right in the heart of the harbor.

BEST ON B.I.!!!!! Price is hard to say since quality ingredients cost $$. But I'll say great value for your money. Waffle cones are GREAT. I usually get in a dish though because I can make a mess even at 57!!!!! read more

Decent ice cream, but nothing to write home about. Just your standard ice cream shop, but they also sell candy and chocolate on the side of the store. Ice cream flavors are shown on the wall, but the freezers may not have everything. They have a prime spot in Block Island, which is why touristy foot traffic is heavy, but there are definitely better ice cream shops around. Also, cash only, which is a small bummer. read more

The Ice Cream Place - Pistachio, and I THINK some sort of coffee flavor (don't remember). Pistachio tasted very fake. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Block Island, Rhode Island

Been to block island many times but never had the pleasure of stopping at the ice cream place until now! The staff, especially Josh, was extremely personable and very helpful when making the very DIFFICULT decision about what to order... it is difficult since there are so many good options! The must have is the mint moose tracks topped with their rich hot fudge. Already planning on coming back tomorrow!!! read more

Perfect place to end a day cycling. The lines are long but move fast. Honestly there are so many great, interesting flavor combinations. This past time I got a blueberry crumble which was divine. My fiancé got the ginger which had a very strong taste that was not overpowering Both delicious. This place never disappoints. I definitely would recommend making time to grab a scoop. It makes the ferry wait much more bearable! read more

Really underwhelming and sad as they talk up the homemade heredity of the place. It is a small place, CASH ONLY. I ordered vanilla ice cream with hot fudge and whipped cream. The vanilla ice cream and hot fudge was UBER disappointing, flavorless, and dismal. Super sad, there was nothing special or great about these two, i would say they tasted like the cardboard of ice cream. The whipped cream exceeded expectations and was incredible, I could of gotten a cup of whipped cream and this would be heaven. It tasted homemade light and so perfect. My husband's cake cone was stale, he ordered the cookie dough and said it was okay. read more

Homemade ice cream, yum! I had 2 scoops in a cup; one was Cotton Candy and the other was Peppermint. They were both delicious and really creamy. Our friend also had two scoops; Ginger and Pistachio. We agreed all the flavors we had were delicious. The line was long because it was hot, sunny day and they do practice social distancing. I would have given this place 4 stars but I will drop one star because I was disappointed that all spoons were in a cup where everyone reaches in and helps themselves. How many people left their germs in that cup? read more

Ice cream the ocean and Rebecca The Ice Cream Place is one one of the first places that catches your eye when you get off the ferry. Conveniently located on water street towards Rebecca, it always seems crowded during the summer months and along with Aldo's one of the most popular places for ice Cream on Block Island. Just a tiny place with some benches outside but the view of course is beautiful. The ice cream itself is pretty good but nothing really exceptional. If you put this place in the middle of some mall away form the ocean nobody would ever remember it. But being on Block Island and sitting outside and watching the ocean while eating your ice cream is what makes this place very special. read more

See all

The only reason that I give this place 2 stars, as opposed to 1, is the fact that ice cream can be procured for reasonable prices (given the island); they also make their waffle cones, apparently. That being said: the service was terrible. The people who work here, at least during the summer, were incredibly rude. I'm pretty sure that the ice cream is not homemade... There's another review that confirms this. In addition, they keep the ice cream far too warm. My girlfriend got a cone, on a fairly mild-weather day (not too hot) and it melted in all of 3 minutes. There are so many better places to go on Block Island, that are so close. Might as well avoid this place altogether. read more

The Ice Cream Place - 3 minutes after purchasing... In 70° weather. Clearly the ice cream should be kept colder. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Block Island, Rhode Island

A lot of people are giving this place a poor review because the ice cream "isn't really homemade" and they don't want to pay "premium prices" for something they can get from the store. First of all, they don't claim that their ice cream is homemade. Their waffle cones, fudge, brownies, etc are homemade. And who really cares anyway? There's no denying that this ice cream is SO. GOOD and most things are overpriced on Block Island anyway. The Ice Cream Place is located right in town and has a ton of flavors to choose from. We stopped by twice during our stay. I tried the Oreo and Party Cake, 1 scoop each time, in a sugar cone. I felt the price was very reasonable (it's cash only) and both flavors were amazing. Next time we go to Block Island, I'm definitely going back. read more

The Ice Cream Place - Their ice cream may not be homemade (their waffle cones, brownies, cookies and fudge are what's homemade) but regardless, it's REALLY good. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Block Island, Rhode Island

Good ice cream, good service. We tried cotton candy and party cake. They were both very good. They have many flavors to choose from. It is a cash only place and a small was about $4.30 with tax. read more

Go here rather than the other 4 spots right in town! Really great homemade creamy ice cream! About 12 flavors - many unique & obviously the classics too. Rich, dense & chock full of good ingredients like walnuts, cashews, Oreos, peaches etc. Thick rich hot fudge, real whipped cream not out of a can. I loved the double chocolate & the caramel salted cashew. read more

Tucked away to the left, under the arch and now the stairs lies a little ice cream shop....with amazing freaking ice cream. The black raspberry is always my go to(and it was wonderful)! But the star was the campfire smores! We have never had gram cracker flavored ice cream! Is was so wonderful. Mixed in was marshmallow fluff and cocoa bits! read more

The Ice Cream Place - Campfire smores and black raspberry. AMAZING! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Block Island, Rhode Island

We love this place. Nothing says summer on BI like the Ice Cream Place. Friendly staff, GREAT flavors, nice courtyard w seating.

Great and flavorful ice cream! But the service is eh. The workers seem to be unhappy and apathetic. I had to ask a couple of employees to speak up because I couldn't hear them (it was after dinner rush on a Monday night). read more

I LOVED this place! Their ice cream is sooooo good! I totally recommend the turtle sundae, it is huge but delicious. It is not expensive as I thought. Very easy access and close to everything in Old Harbor. read more

This place is still my family's ice cream spot, but...the quality has gone down hill in the past ten years. Don't get the brownie sundae - the brownies taste stale. And they no longer make chocolate whipped cream. They told us they'll be making some next week. Lame. If you do get a sundae, ask for extra whipped cream. Those are my thoughts. read more