Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Block Island Cakes

    5.0 (1 review)

    Block Island Cakes Photos

    You might also consider

    More like Block Island Cakes

    Recommended Reviews - Block Island Cakes

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Block Island Cakes

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Aldo's Bakery - Bakery case

    Aldo's Bakery

    3.8(70 reviews)
    1.5 mi
    $

    This is one of our go-to spots whenever we're on Block Island. It's become a nightly tradition…read moreafter dinner, and our 10-year-old absolutely loves it--she's been coming here since she was 3! The ice cream is always delicious, the employees are so sweet, and the cookies... OMG honey, they're massive. One cookie is big enough for four adults to share and still be happy. Another highlight is the little carousel out front--it's such a charming touch and perfect for kids. Between the treats, the atmosphere, and the friendly service, this place is a must-stop every time we visit.

    I was originally intending to go to a different shop for ice cream but since they did not take…read morecash, I stumbled upon this one. The ice cream/gelato prices were a bit high in my opinion, and I was not too impressed by the flavor selection or quality. I was sold on getting a peanut butter ice cream scoop but after looking at the tub physically, I decided against it since it looked like it has melted and been refrozen. Instead, I got a scoop of the cookie dough gelato. One thing I did appreciate is that it did not have chocolate chips. I can't believe I'm saying this, but it did have too many cookie dough chunks - I would say on average, 3-5 chunks per spoonful so I couldn't really taste the gelato as much. I should've asked for a sample beforehand. It also had a mild freezer taste which I did not like. I think one standard scoop ending up being around $9. There were a lot of people when I got there so it might have been just me who did not have such a great experience. They did have a couple benches and tables outside. Also, I believe they have a sit down outdoor dining area for their restaurant portion, and they had some live music going which was nice. In addition, when you first walk in, they have a LARGE selection of pastries and they all look tasty. This shop is very close to where the ferry picks up and drops off in case you are looking for a treat before hopping on.

    Photos
    Aldo's Bakery - Outside

    Outside

    Aldo's Bakery - Menu

    Menu

    Aldo's Bakery - Carmel brownie

    See all

    Carmel brownie

    Persephone's Kitchen - Egg sandwhich

    Persephone's Kitchen

    4.5(169 reviews)
    1.8 mi
    $

    In my humble opinion this is the BEST place on block island to get coffee and breakfast items. They…read morehave a few vegan options on their menu which is incredible! Wish they had more vegan pastries if course, I didn't get any either day I went. They had a vegan cow poke type cookie but I skipped it and went for the vegan just egg breakfast sandwich. Okay the blackberry syrup is TO DIE FOR I keep thinking about it! UGH I wish I could come here more. To say that this is a favorite of mine would be an understatement. Worth the line and wait, worth the money. Great service and vibes. Beautiful location!!!!!!!!

    Let's start with the amazing food!! My friend and I stopped in during a very very busy day…read more(Saturday during August!) and ordered sandwiches to go. I tried half of a Ti Penso and half of the Sun sandwich. Both were delicious but I loved the Sun, it was super flavorful without being heavy and was something I hadn't tried before. The Ti Penso was tasty as well, but definitely felt the Sun won out. The spot is super busy so be warned that the wait times (at no fault of the staff!) are extreme. We got in line at 12:15, ordered at 12:45 and got our food around 1:30. So overall waited over an hour for two sandwiches. However, I imagine if you came during a quiet period it would be a great place to sit inside and read!

    Photos
    Persephone's Kitchen - Inside the restaurant

    Inside the restaurant

    Persephone's Kitchen - Simple egg sandwich with arugula and tomato

    Simple egg sandwich with arugula and tomato

    Persephone's Kitchen - Quaint cafe with cozy atmosphere and warm and friendly staff.

    See all

    Quaint cafe with cozy atmosphere and warm and friendly staff.

    Montauk Bake Shoppe - Nice amount of jelly inside the  Croissant

    Montauk Bake Shoppe

    3.7(284 reviews)
    20.7 mi
    $$

    Lots of options in this grab and go bake shoppe. I've only tried the sweet items- none of the…read morebreakfast items, but we've enjoyed the things we've got. The cinnamon swirls are good but lean on the dry side without a ton of frosting. The apple crumb cake is delicious. Boston crème donuts from here my boyfriend always loves. Chocolate chip cookies lean a little thinner crunchier- like tates. I also tried their empanadas recently- plaintain and cheese- very greasy and not a lot of flavor. Service is prompt at the counter and they're always pretty well stocked. We'll be back for more sweets this summer.

    Cute little bake shop in Montauk Village! Upon walking in, I was greeted by who seemed like the…read moreowner. He recommended me the jelly croissants (which were sold out) and the cream croissants. I got a cream croissant and a crumb cake. They also had a huge variety of cakes and cookies, no Ice-Cream though (I checked the freezer!) The cream croissant was good. Flakey on the outside balanced with the perfect creaminess on the inside. The cream reminds me of Bavarian cream inside donuts. Must eat the day of so it doesn't leak onto the crispy outside. As for the crumb cake - one of the best I've had. It was still good the next day when I brought it home. What caught me by surprise was the amount of bees hovering over the pastries behind the counter. Thankfully, they were not flies. I also got one of each of the Montauk iced teas to try. I have not seen them anywhere else in Montauk. There are about 5-6 different flavors. Will definitely be back for the cream croissants, crumb cake, and to try other baked goods! Great service!

    Photos
    Montauk Bake Shoppe - Inside

    Inside

    Montauk Bake Shoppe - Jelly donut: interior

    Jelly donut: interior

    Montauk Bake Shoppe

    See all

    Block Island Cakes - bakeries - Updated June 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...