Very v noisy. Not what one would call great dining Also average to sad in the food department Service nice and fast. read more

The food was not good. I ordered the Chicken Cesar salad and there was more large croutons than chicken. And the chicken was tough. I did hear the chicken wings were good though! The waitress we had was friendly. So maybe I will try for a wing night and pass on the salad! read more

This is one of the hardest reviews I've ever had to write. This restaurant has been part of my life for over 20 years. I've celebrated countless milestones here -- more than 10 parties over the years -- and the staff always felt like family. Until now. I chose this restaurant for my baby shower because of that history and that trust. I booked with the new owner in early February and worked through multiple scheduling changes just to secure the private party room, away from the bar. I didn't ask for a written contract. After 20 years, it never crossed my mind that I'd need one. The day before my shower, I reached out with our final head count -- because no one had contacted me, which was already a red flag. That's when everything fell apart. I was told the room had changed and I wpuld be in the front right next to the bar. When I expressed my frustration, I was told I could keep the room but had to leave earlier than planned for the dinner rush. And when I asked why none of this came up in the six weeks since booking, the owner told me it was because my count was lower than expected and that he had passed on a 50-person party for mine. I was floored. After two decades of loyalty, I was made to feel like a burden at my own baby shower. I was never told there was a minimum headcount requirement. That should have been said upfront -- not the day before my event. We kept the room but I spent the whole party feeling rushed and unwelcome. Staff was already breaking down tables while we were still there wrapping up the event. The owners never once stopped by to say hello or acknowledge the occasion. And then I found out that our favorite chef -- someone who had been the heart of this kitchen for 25 years -- was let go for no good reason. he was part of the reason we always had our parties here. This place has changed in all the wrong ways. We won't be back, and I can no longer recommend it to anyone. I hope the new ownership understands what they've lost -- because it's more than just customers. read more

My son told me this place was good. So I went and the food was terrible. Had spare ribs that were tough. Never went back. Sorry

Solid food, good service, fair prices! Comfortable restaurant with nice specials. The German pizza when available is top notch. The prime rib and chicken parmesan are particular favorites. read more

Wow, same staff is wonderful, friendly and engaged. Food ok, nothing to complain about... owners, ugh... personalty of a goldfish. Say thank you, thank you for coming, nice to see you...enjoy your dinner... nothing but a blank stair. Personality is part of being a successful restaurant owner, engage and smile with a simple "thank you" cost nothing, but will pay dividends in the end. Much to learn! read more

Terrible service. We never had our order taken after waiting over a half an hour. Waitress hanging out at two tables talking with others and completely ignored everyone else. Got up and left, no one even noticed. Filthy inside as well. This place has really gone down hill. Much better places in the area. read more

Horrible service. Totally ignored by waitress. Waited well over an hour for our food. It was delicious when it finally arrived. Thank you to the hostess for taking our order. read more

Pizza and calamari are the best!! Always go once a week! My wife loves the penne pasta!

Great dinner! Kind & hard working servers. Had Chicken Portobello, YUM! Back room is spacious & our group of 5 all enjoyed our various dinners & drinks. read more

Food was really good. Sandwiches were substantial, even though I did not eat one however I was able to see them in adjacent tables. Service was superb. The waitress were attentive and friendly never overbearing. The restaurant was great it had both a bar section and restaurant with tables on the other side. It had a old time homely feeling. This place was great, service and ambiance was second to none. Food was good not superb; however the drinks were second to none. If you are nearby definitely stop by. read more

See all

Food - 3 Service - 5 Ambiance - 6 Pasta a little sour. French onion very salty. Overall I didn't feel the love. read more

Came to this place since it was close to our Airbnb. It had a nice ambiance, staff was nice and quick. For appetizer we had the ahi tuna which was a little too thick cuts but overall good. Appetizers were actually huge plates. Felt too full to even eat my main course meal. Mozzarella was thick with lots of cheese which is my preference. For main dish, the seafood linguini had a good amount of seafood but I wasn't a fan of the broth. It felt like they didn't season or anything to the water used to cook the seafood. The beef bolognese was okay. A lot of food, but missed out on the seasoning. Overall, okay experience. I would give them another chance but we were local only for the weekend. read more

See all

Refused to seat a group of people at 7pm wasn't that busy inside. Told us to go to McDonald's. Have been here many times over years never experienced someone so rude. Never again. read more

Went to wing night on a Tuesday and the wings were very meaty and delicious. A variety of sauces to choose from. I like the Thai. Waitress was excellent. Fun, organized and professional. The wings were very good, I look forward to going back. I was there for larger catered events in the back room which also had very good food and atmosphere over the last few years. The bar area and restaurant are always busy. read more

Always a great meal at reasonable prices. The staff is always friendly . Best choice in the area Mike C read more

First time vack here in a decade food was very good quality tas and portions were perfect had the tortilla soup and fish tacos probably the best tortill soup I have had in years fish tacos were all fresh ingredients perfectly done! My wife had the any strip steak and shrimp special she said it was good cocked just right! Will go back service was excellent and prices were reasonable. Would recommend read more

I had Caesar salad with grilled chicken, the only thing authentic was the romaine. There was no garlic, no anchovies, no Parmesan cheese, there was vinegar decidedly not authentic. The chicken was nicely grilled, moist and tender. My partner had steak taco salad and enjoyed it. The ambiance was okay but far too dark. The service was okay. I gave it a 3 because my partner liked her steak taco salad. read more

***3 1/2 stars*** The Lamp Post Inn was the site of a post-snowtubing lunch on Superbowl Sunday. It looked intriguing/eclectic from afar, and it certainly was that. If you grew up in the 70s or 80s, you absolutely had a grandparent whose basement had wood paneling like this. It doesn't look like the dining area has been updated in decades, and I'm all for it; Jimmy Carter could have stopped here on a campaign swing. The booths looked especially cozy, but we had a party of eight, alas, and sat at a standalone table. Framed pithy sayings/aphorisms were all over the walls. There was a more modern/standard bar area further into the restaurant, but I enjoyed eating in my time vortex. We ordered a bunch of standard bar apps to start, which included mozzy sticks and tater skins. Both were excellent. I'm usually slightly positive (though not overwhelmingly so) on mozzy sticks. I think it's really easy to mess them up texture-wise, but these were perfect. Just the right amount of crispness without veering into unpleasant soggy territory. The tater skins were more like wedges than straight-up potato halves, which I was definitely into - better serving sizes, and none of the pieces were overdone. Also, I ordered a glass of wine that, I'm not kidding, was less than $5. This was not a Happy Hour - it was the normal price. Sussex County is such a delight. For my entree, I went with the penne vodka. It was tasty with a decent but not overwhelming portion (one companion commented that the appetizer portions were larger than the entrees, which seemed accurate to me - not really a negative or a positive, I suppose). Since I had accidentally gorged on the taters, I had leftovers (which held up well the next day), but you could easily eat this in one fell swoop if you're not being too naughty otherwise. Have I had better? Yes, but this was perfectly fine, just a little bland. Dessert-wise, a couple of us ordered the apple crisp ala mode and the peanut butter cream pie to split. The peanut butter cream pie was more warmly received, so I ended up eating most of the apple crisp, which was fine but also a bit tasteless (possible trend, given the penne vodka situation). It could have used something else to give it some zip, like caramel drizzle (which coincidentally the peanut butter cream pie had). The bathroom was an interesting experience. It was a nippy day (probably around 30 degrees), and the windows in there were wide open. I'm glad I didn't have to be in there for more than a minute or two, and I felt bad for any future visitors who had...a longer agenda than that. It was clean at least and pretty spacious - I changed out of my snow pants into jeans pretty comfortably in the stall. The service started off strong, and petered out over time, unfortunately. To their credit, the hostess/staff who greeted us when we came in didn't even bat an eye when I told them how many were in our party. We were seated promptly, and orders were taken almost as quickly. I think our assigned waitress changed midway through, which could definitely explain what happened with the service - honestly, I can't remember the last time that occurred and it DIDN'T have a negative impact. I even hesitated ordering dessert, knowing it would likely keep us in there for a while, but the devil on my shoulder usually wins those debates. We were probably in there for 45 minutes more than we needed to be, all told. Given that we were a large party, I'm honestly surprised more attention wasn't paid overall, and it definitely caused what was up until then a pretty positive review to hover more toward neutral. A shame. read more

See all

Came in for lunch this past weekend. We called ahead to make sure they were open. No reservations were needed and we were immediately sat outside on the deck. Our waitress was very friendly and the food was delicious. I ordered a turkey sandwich that came out HUGE. I wanted to make some sandwich modifications, which I could tell from her face though, this wasn't the place to do so. The sandwich I picked was still great. They don't have much of a selection on tap, but the beer was still good. Also the place just kind of feels like a bar. read more

I'm not really sure what has taken place. This was my goto favorite time after time, but last night was a huge letdown. I ordered Chicken Schnitzel with lemon butter sauce over Linguini. Dish came, bone dry cutlet, no flavor, no lemon sauce, totally bland. My girl ordered her usual seafood linguini, which too was bland and lack luster. We ordered, Linguini with butter for the child and it came no butter and warm. Again, my favorite when in town... The next table ordered the exact same dishes and they put half a bottle salt and the table behind us had the Shepard pie to which they were not pleased... perhaps a new chef? Perhaps truly an off night... not sure but be wary... read more

Love this place. Conveniently 10 minutes from where I live. I took myself out to dinner the other night and got a great special that they had on the menu. The service was so kind, despite me waiting like a knucklehead at the wrong end of the restaurant. They seated me quickly and the food was exceptional. I've never been disappointed, no matter what I've ordered! read more

The Lamp Post Inn - Herb seasoned chicken special - Italian Near Me - Sussex, New Jersey

Came in for dinner... the staff and food were very good. They even made some GF Mac and cheese for our daughter, which was delicious and truly made her day. I got the steak & shrimp special with pasta, and H got the Chicken fajitas. We really appreciated the courteous Hostess and waitress. We would definitely come back again next time we are in town. read more

See all

Food isn't that good I get sick anytime I go there. I've been gotten a salad and got sick. Not worth the time or money at all!

The food here is delicious. My husband is very picky and actually enjoyed everything. His favorite were the wings, they were crispy and delicious. Would recommend as their food is flavorful and cooked to perfection. read more

This place has been around for quite a few years. It is known for good food and drink. We had a gathering of 10 retired friends and were very, very happy with everything. The food was excellent and fairly priced, the wait staff could not have been better. We made the right decision to come here for the gathering. Sal and his staff are absolutely wonderful. Highly recommend this restaurant to everyone. They have separate dining and eating areas, but you can also get food in the bar area. Looking forward to coming back. read more

I would have given this 4 stars before COVID, as the prices, service and food are good. But the mask wearing is awful, and they seem to not care - even after I politely mentioned it to them. So, one star for not wearing masks properly!! read more

We stopped briefly at Lamp Post Inn in Sussex after spending an exhausting but very fun day at Crystal Spring Resort. This restaurant does not look very appealing from the outside but once inside you know that it will be great since right away you can appreciate that it is a local favorite. The atmosphere is casual and down to earth; we sat in the pub area of the restaurant where we were entertained by the merry and friendly chatter around us. They have a very limited draft beer selection and due to the fact that we had eaten several snacks during the course of the day and it was a day after Thanksgiving, we kept our food order small. My husband and I split an order of Spud Skins and Chicken Wings. The wings were amazing!!! Plump, juicy and crispy on the outside. The hot sauce dressing was just perfect, not too spicy complementing the meat very well! Both appetizers were very satisfying. We opted for soups as entrees, and my partner in crime had his favorite Onion Soup while I tried the soup of the day which was Cream of Mushroom. Again very satisfying and generous plates. If you are ever in the area, do not hesitate to give the Lamp Post Inn a try... You will love it!!! read more

The Lamp Post Inn - Italian Near Me - Sussex, New Jersey

See all

This is kewl place to hang out and have a bite to eat and a beer or two. Tuesday night is wing night, wings are pretty good definitely would eat them again. It's worth a try. It's definitely a casual atmosphere read more

Came here randomly with some friends and it was a great find. You would think this place was just a random neighborhood place but there is so much more to this place. When you first walk in it looked like an old Italian restaurant, but as you walk further into the restaurant you realize that this place is much larger and really nice. Their bar area is pretty large and they have high tables where you can eat in the area, plus they also sell bottled alcohol like a full liquor store. I always find that interesting when they do that in NJ. This place also had a band that night and it was really nice because I didn't expect one. They have a pretty large food menu and offer really deliciously looking specials. We started with their calamari, it was a pretty big order and it was fried perfectly. We also had their jamming fried shrimp or something like that and it really was not that memorable. We all ordered burgers. I had a standard cheese burger smothered with grilled mushrooms and it was huge and juicy (YUMMY). Their burgers were so big that I could only eat half of it, plus there were so much fries with the order. For a bar I found their drinks to be very light. So I switched to white wine and they served it in small red wine glasses. I thought they were giving me shots of white wine. They had a lot of great beer's but I am not a beer drinker. All in all this was really a great place for food and I would definitely go out of my way to go there again. read more

See all

Been coming here for almost 15 years. The food is always good and the prices competitive. One of the best pizzas in the area, big fat wings and fare ranging from bar food to quality dining makes this place is among the best in Sussex County. The decor may be a bit dated, but I like how it feels like coming home: comfortable. The only knock is that most of the menu doesn't rotate outside of a few specials. I can get the same crab stuffed chicken that I could a decade and a half ago. Some of the core menu needs to be changed, but as I said, a friendly place with satisfying food and reasonable prices. Tip: They run a $9 cheese pizza special during most weekdays. Get one. Super pro tip: Order it well done. read more

..... What happened to this place. Why does everybody have an attitude? I'm so disappointed in my last review. I should've went here a few more times food is awful. read more

Food has always been decent here, but the last time we dined it was so noisy that you couldn't even hear the person across the table from you. Overall a pretty average restaurant. read more

Awesome local restaurant that has been around forever. Friendly staff with a home town feeling. Large portions !!

On the last day of the month. Some of us from the sales team from the Auto mall go here for wings and beer. Best wings around.

Another great find while on vacation,... went here for my birthday dinner! Awesome and plentiful amount of calamari and we both had scallops which were the best tasting I've ever had! Service was exceptional as well! read more

The Lamp Post Inn - Scallops - Italian Near Me - Sussex, New Jersey

We stopped here with my son for a late lunch after some uneventful riding at Mountain Creek. This place is only a stone throw away from the ski resort. The menu is a no-frills American traditional with a touch of Italian American, but the food is tasty and the portions are rather hefty. Kinda rustic and unpretentious. The staff is extremely attentive and helpful. We felt like we were being cuddled. Also present is a fully equipped bar and the drinks are great. Finally, I certainly cannot complain about the prices, they are simply great. read more

The Lamp Post Inn - Italian Near Me - Sussex, New Jersey

See all

I will start off saying we were a large party. The waitstaff was wonderful in every way possible. With so many of us, I will only critique from my own POV. I ordered the French onion soup to start. Bread was provided and we were offered more. We shared 2 bottles of Cavit moscato. It went well with my meal. I ordered the seafood assortment. It included 2 small pieces of sea bass, 2 scallops, 2 shrimp, 2 stuffed clams, a crab stuffed shrimp, assorted vegetables (zucchini, yellow squash, carrots & green beans) I chose rice with my meal. The French onion soup was wonderful and just what one would expect. My seafood assortment was average. The scallops were cooked but there was no real sear on either side but, they were moist. The shrimp were cooked but really had no pizazz to them. The clams were tasty but one had a bit of grit. The sea bass was nicely cooked but also bland. It is like someone forgot to properly season the food. The stuffed shrimp was also decent. The rice and vegetables were also on the bland side. Lemon was provided but did not added enough for the blandness of my meal. A little pricey for an average meal. I expected more as my family was raving about this place. For me, the company was better than my meal! I read more

I had my 60th birthday here and i can't say enough good about this place, everything from the private room, food, service, price was exceptional. I want to thank the owner Sal for making my special day so memorable read more

The staff was very helpful and accommodating. My party consisted of 13 people on a Saturday night and they did the best they could to make sure it was a comfortable experience. The food was enjoyable I.e. Hot wings, mozzarella sticks, spaghetti, pizza, and chicken finger platter. The honey dipped chicken platter was a bit dry and overly crunchy. Overall it was a great experience and even had live entertainment. read more