Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    The Perfect Cake By Shirley

    5.0 (1 review)

    The Perfect Cake By Shirley Photos

    You might also consider

    More like The Perfect Cake By Shirley

    Recommended Reviews - The Perfect Cake By Shirley

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of Josh H.
    0
    157
    1

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - The Perfect Cake By Shirley

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Bakeries 11,574 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Nothing Bundt Cakes

    Nothing Bundt Cakes

    4.6
    (128 reviews)
    3.5 km
    $$

    I ordered a seasonal bundtini from this location for my husband's birthday, advertised to contain 4…read moreflavors including oreo (his favorite flavor). My order did NOT contain ANY oreo flavors, just more of the other 3 flavors! There was ZERO communication when I placed the order, when it was confirmed via email, nor when I picked up the order in person that they opted to substitute a flavor on their own... I'm guessing they were just out of stock?? (even though I ordered in advance to prevent this issue). Had it been communicated, I would have either changed my order or added an oreo Bundt cake while in store. Instead, we opened the box hours after pickup only to watched my husband disappointed that it did not contain what he wanted for his birthday. For $32 it is absolutely ridiculous to not even get the flavors advertised. I submitted a complaint on the website but received zero response after several weeks, not even an apology. We love the product but since these are FRANCHISED locations, I would suggest going to any other location besides this one!!!

    The Bundtini's were an absolute hit for my Baby shower! Everyone loved the bite sized desserts and…read moresaid the flavors were delicious! We ordered 3 dozen: 1X Lemon, 1X Strawberries & Cream, & 1 Gluten-Free mix (6 GF Chocolate Chip cookie & 6 GF Lemon Raspberry). Ordering online was direct and straightforward and I didn't have to worry about incorrect invoices or incorrect information since I entered everything myself. Service was efficient and ready to go at the requested day and time of pickup scheduled. We tried to order through a local business that we enjoyed but were very disappointed when they tried to nickel and dime us for every detail or custom request. So we were 100% satisfied with our service from NBC! Will be ordering again in the future.

    Photos
    Nothing Bundt Cakes
    Nothing Bundt Cakes
    Nothing Bundt Cakes

    See all

    The Cake Company

    The Cake Company

    4.4
    (55 reviews)
    23.6 km

    I've ordered my mom cupcakes from this place regularly, either as treats for her office or for…read morespecial occasion deliveries. They have gluten free options so it works for everyone. I finally decided to stop in this cute little shop and try it for myself... had to do it for the Yelp! And omg I'm so glad I did. The berry tilly cupcake is absolutely amazing! Seriously I have no idea how they get the cake so soft. I'm usually a chocolate girl but every single white cake cupcake from this place is so good. The chocolate cupcakes are delicious but it's more like a dense dark chocolate cake... while it hit the spot, the texture wasn't like the berry tilly. I also tried the chocolate cream pie based on a recommendation from the staff and I was pleasantly surprised! They have a great team working the counter. I plan on going back to try more from the menu and ordering a custom cake for a bday!

    I got to Yelp in Castle Rock today. And it was for this cute cake shop in the heart of Castle Rock…read moredowntown. And it's none other than the Cake Company. I had a side hustle job assignment in the very neighborhood mid-afternoon. And I simply didn't want to go there, work, leave and get home; I wanted to discover a business I have never been to. I hence googled bakeries and this cake shop came up. According to a little research, this shop opened its doors in January of 2021 by two sisters who are Colorado natives. This element added more excitement to my quick visit I made today. The Cake Company is adorable. From the exterior signage to the interior decors, everything that decorates the whole space matches the theme of the store. Mostly pink and off-white, they not only sell beautifully crafted cupcakes, pies, rice crispies, cinnamon rolls, to name a few, they also sell some gifts such as wine glasses, t-shirts, journal books, tote bags, mug cups, I mean you name it!! I was at awe standing in front of the showcase that displays all sorts of sweets. When one of the ladies upfront greeted me with a very peppy welcoming tone, she kindly said to take my time. I thus allowed myself to be indecisive for several minutes to take my time (LOL!!) Whereas the pies and cheesecakes to the right looked amazing, they also appeared a bit too big and decadent. Since I only needed one good piece of some delicious something, I opted for a cupcake as they aren't as big as the other sweets. Upon asking the same lady which ones are the most popular, she said it was either Berry Tilly or Better Than Sex. My instinct told me to go with the latter: Better Than Sex. The different lady transacted my purchase. She carefully put my cupcake in a single cupcake box. Just so you know, their boxes are tilt-free so your sweet stuff won't tilt inside it (unless you violently shake the box!) The cupcakes are $6 each. And yet, if you buy 6 or more, each price is reduced to $5.50 up to 11. If you buy 12 or more, each price is reduced to $5.00. 20% discount will be added if you purchase 3 dozens. The shop does sell gluten free ones and yet any of the discounts I mentioned don't appear to apply to them. After the purchase, I looked to the left to discover a little entry way to the store next door. It's Lost Coffee. The customers are free to go in and out between the two shops. This means that you can take your cupcake to the next store and have some coffee or tea to pair with it. This is another store that has this symbiotic relationship with their next-door neighbor business. I always find the concept so intriguing. Businesses help each other. As soon as I got back to my car, I immediately opened the box and started to dig in. And wow....I know this is such an ordinary statement but I will say it: this is/was by far the best cupcake I've ever had. It was perfectly moist in the sponge part with the perfect sweetness. After one bite, it was simply impossible for me to stop eating it although I wanted to save some for later. The cupcake thus disappeared so quickly in a matter of 2-3 minutes. Their cupcakes are phenomenal. There is no way you'll buy cupcakes from other places once you have experienced theirs. I am already pondering as to when I should go back. Discovering great businesses bring me joy; this is why I can never stop Yelping.

    Photos
    Free samples! (While supplies last)
    Free samples! (While supplies last)
    Chuck's Peanut Butter Cake
    Chuck's Peanut Butter Cake
    Display case of various cakes and some cupcakes

    See all

    Display case of various cakes and some cupcakes
    Milk & Cake

    Milk & Cake

    3.8
    (310 reviews)
    9.0 km
    $

    We're always on the hunt for great cupcakes, so we decided to check this place out since it's so…read moreclose to home. Unfortunately, it didn't quite live up to our expectations. The staff weren't especially welcoming, but honestly, that was okay. We were there for cupcakes, not a red carpet rollout. The inside was nice and exactly what you'd expect from a cupcakery/ice cream shop. We tried a variety of mini cupcakes along with two regular-sized ones. The icing was definitely the highlight - good, but nothing extraordinary. The real letdown was the cake itself, which was dry across the board. The minis were especially dry, which made the overall experience less enjoyable. On top of that, the flavors just didn't stand out. Nothing really wowed us or left a lasting impression. After seeing so many people leaving with only ice cream, we kind of understood why.

    Enjoyed some froyo and a mini cupcake (wedding cake flavored). They have several choices of flavors…read moreand labeled for dietary needs (dairy, vegan, etc). They had sample cups to try flavors so you don't commit to something you don't like. I went later in the day so several of the mini cupcakes were out. Appreciated the associate and shared a bit about the differences in flavors. The restroom was clean and plenty of parking. There are only a handful of tables inside, but several tables and chairs outside on the patio.

    Photos
    They have cupcakes
    They have cupcakes
    More cupcakes!
    More cupcakes!
    Toppings for frozen yogurt

    See all

    Toppings for frozen yogurt
    Posh Cakes

    Posh Cakes

    4.0
    (185 reviews)
    15.9 km
    $$

    I ordered a gluten free cake and it was so amazing! Most guests couldn't even guess it was gf! The…read moreattention to detail is incredible. They nailed the design I wanted and it was perfect for my sisters baby shower! The service is always friendly and fast. They have cupcakes throughout the week and I LOVE stopping by and grabbing one!

    *CELIAC / GLUTEN FREE REVIEW…read more I recently got a birthday cake from here and had a no-issue experience! When I called to place my order, they warned me about it being a shared kitchen, but that they do what they can to avoid cross-contamination risk. Normally I would not risk it, but this place was very highly spoken of in the "Denver GF" Facebook group - so I gave it a try! I ordered a GF small white rosette designed cake in the GF better than sex flavor. Everyone at my party loved it (both GF and non-GF folks) and nobody got sick. upon picking up the cake I also had a GF maple glazed donut and GF chocolate chip scone - the GF donuts are held on the top two racks of donuts, and the scones have their own jar. The cupcakes are with the other cupcakes in a display case, but are in front so likelihood of crumbs dropping it lower - they have their own tower / stand within the display. I asked the woman to wash her hands before grabbing my items and she happily did! I did not get sick from any of the three items I tried! The cake is nice and moist, donut was a little dense but good flavor, and the scone was superrrr dry and dense but that's pretty common of GF scones.

    Photos
    Our seasonal German Chocolate cupcakes!
    Our seasonal German Chocolate cupcakes!
    Iced Christmas Sugar Cookies! Only available in December.
    Iced Christmas Sugar Cookies! Only available in December.
    Posh Cakes

    See all

    The Perfect Cake By Shirley - bakeries - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...