This place is an absolute dive but so fun. Came here for karaoke on a Thursday night and the place…read morewas popping. They charge a cover to get in, but it was worth it to be entertained as hard as we were by the people taking the stage here. Drinks were actually not as expensive as I thought they would be. The bartender here was super fun and in a great mood which really added to the vibe. Karaoke here is on a stage which adds to the performance value in my opinion. They have lots of songs to choose from, and everyone was really supportive. It's definitely an older venue, so don't come in here expecting things to be pristine. That said it has a lot of history to it and I'm glad it's still around. My only complaint was that karaoke ended so abruptly - I wish we had gotten a heads up that it was the last chance to sign up for a song when it was closing down. Lots of fun at this place.

EJ rocks so friendly and great service really the best. he waited patiently while i ordered…read more !!!!!!!!!

As frequent visitors to the North Fork we are grateful for Silver Sands' newest addition, The…read moreBoathouse. Open throughout the winter it's the best kept secret for locals, as well as us perennial summer dwellers. Great food, delicious beverages, pleasing atmosphere. We love the brilliant collaboration with McCall Vineyard's Burger Night which we attend in season. Now we can enjoy it off-season as well. Thank you!

Unique setting and seating. Food reliable. Service good. Fun place and nice beachey settingread more

Absolutely rock solid dive bar in Hampton Bays with everything you could want…read more Darts? Check. Pool? Check. Giant jenga? Check. Juke box? Check. Drunk food? Check. Came here on a random Tuesday night and nonetheless was greeted by an enthusiastic bartender who upsold me to a double and took great care of me and my parents who had apparently been here 40 years prior on a date? The vibe of this place is super fun, lots of eclectic artwork on the ceiling that my mom swears was here some 40 years ago. They do have some selection food options but we did not partake. Don't let the semi sketch exterior of this place fool you, it's a welcoming atmosphere at reasonable dive bar prices - honestly maybe the last affordable bar that exists in the Hamptons.

This place is a dive bar. Not a good dive bar, a bad dive bar. Liquor prices aren't cheap, they're…read morefairly expensive for a shitty dive bar. When you ask for a check after you're done drinking, they just tell you the price without giving you a check.They go over to the cash register and they hand you a check that is not itemized.It just gives you a total without an itemized summary of how many drinks you have. They told me my total was $49.95. I was gonna pay with cash but decided to pay with credit card and they told me if i pay with a credit card it was $4.00 extra. All bars and restaurants charge either 3 or 4 percent for using a credit card which should amount to $1.50. What a rip off. STAY AWAY FROM ThIS RIP-OFF bar.

If you're looking for good food in Montauk keep looking…read more My girlfriend and I recently decided to take advantage of a deal for a hotel in the offseason in Montauk. We were looking for dinner Saturday night and of the limited options this place looked potentially good. I was terribly wrong. We walked in to see one other table occupied. Sure, it's the offseason, whatever. We ordered a couple of frozen drinks and the problems immediately started. The bartender used way too much ice in the blender. The drinks were obviously undrinkable but served anyway. The drinks did not melt by the time we left. Maybe the food would be good. Wrong again. The lobster in the lobster pasta was tough. I almost hope it wasn't fresh because it would have been a waste. The linguine with clams was no better. At the end of the meal my girlfriend remarked that she had never seen me not finish my dinner. We both knew why I hadn't. Awful restaurant. The owners should be ashamed.

Food was basic, mostly apps. Probably would not order full dinner. Service was mediocre. Outdoor…read morespace is nice for a little music

Had an excellent time here with my mom. I love a good movie theater, and Sunset Theater does not…read moredisappoint. Going up the stairs to the Social Club through the Theater gives it speakeasy vibes. Once you arrive upstairs there's a sprawling, opulent bar, along with velvet booths and chairs along the wall. We decided to sit at the bar, and loved how extensive the cocktail menu was. I went with the whisky sour, which was artfully made. It was light and delicious, the topping gave it a nice touch. We were also offered a little bowl of movie theater popcorn which made me so happy, a nice touch. We ordered cheese as well which was cubed and easy to eat, served alongside mustard. We made friends while we were here, along with an employee who was here on his off day enjoying the bar. He told us that this space is meant to feel like a second living room and be welcoming to anyone who doesn't have somewhere to go - they stayed open on Thanksgiving this year to welcome people who had nowhere to go, and those people have since become regulars. I left here feeling like the world was a better place.

What a surprise! This is a lovely, charming, gloriously decorative bar above the Sunset Theater…read more There's a good-size bar, a very nice and friendly bartender, and velvet seating. There's a small piano. The decor is elegant! I was gobsmacked by the liquor and spirits selection. WOW. I'm impressed. I saw so many wonderful and unusual bottles! There were small bottles of various syrups, like rose and lavender, on a tray near me. I ordered a Sazerac, and (Josh?) didn't have to look up the recipe. It was delicious, and very strong for such a small drink. I only had one. Two would have made me tipsy, and I had to drive. Apparently, the bartenders and GM brainstorm cocktails on a regular basis, looking for new drinks to add to their repertoire. This is the perfect choice for drinks with someone special, or with a group of friends. Definitely a dressy kind of place. I would feel comfortable in a cocktail dress here, or leather pants and a silk top. However, I don't think that there's an actual dress code. Drinks are not inexpensive, but are very well made and served with a smile.

The Chequit Restaurant is a true gem on Shelter Island. The atmosphere is warm, inviting, and…read moreperfect whether you're looking for a casual dinner with friends or a relaxed spot to meet for drinks. The food was outstanding--especially the Chicken Parmigiana, which was absolutely delicious, and the Rigatoni, which was packed with flavor and cooked to perfection. What really made the experience exceptional was the staff. Everyone was incredibly attentive, friendly, and genuinely focused on making sure we had a great dining experience. From the excellent service to the delicious food and welcoming ambiance, The Chequit Restaurant exceeded expectations. I highly recommend it and look forward to returning soon!

Best meal we've had on Shelter Island (Leon was a close second). Apparently they have new…read moremanagement as of May 2026, and we could not have had a better meal. The oysters were great, the sea bass was incredible, and the pastas we had (linguini with clam sauce and the pesto burrata) were unbelievable. They were able to accommodate two Celiacs in our group. And the bread pudding dessert was the best dessert I've had maybe ever.

OK. First things first. Fishermans Quarters is not a motel. Its a bar. A rocking bar! With a…read morephe-nom-e-nal jukebox!! And cheap drinks and darts and foosball. It was a small slice of civilization, or at least population (!) for this city girl who's been stuck in the woods for the past few weeks. If you find yourself also isolated, give this dive-ey bar a shot.

Classic local small town bar with history and character . Friendly bartenders who hustle to get you…read moreyour drink fast. Well done

Murph's is the real deal -- the only true bar in Sag Harbor. No frills, no scene, just cold drinks,…read moregood people, and a vibe that feels untouched by the rest of the Hamptons. It's dark, divey, and perfect. There's even a cigarette machine, which feels like a relic in the best way. The kind of place where locals and visitors blend, the jukebox is always playing something decent, and no one cares who you are -- just what you're drinking. An absolute gem. Long live Murph's.