The most delicious cake ever! The Bride is not a "cake person" and will pick any dessert over cake, so I was surprised when we were at our first bridal show and she tasted Caitlin's cakes and came to me and said, "Mom, I have found our baker!" One taste and the decision was made. Caitlin invites you over for a taste test and she prepares 4 different mini cupcakes based on the bride and grooms choices of 4 different cake flavors and icings to assist you in your decision. We ate every bite and even got to sample some of the fruit flavors as she had another taste testing earlier in the day. I am not a fruit flavored cake person or really a cake person like my daughter, but they were all absolutely delicious and there wasn't a crumb left on anyone's plate! Caitlin is so great to work with; a pleasure and a delight are my adjectives to describe her. She decorated both the wedding cake and the grooms cake exactly as the bride and groom requested. Both were simply beautiful. She can take any design you send her and bring it to life on your cake. She arrived on time and then decorated the cake with the flowers that we had ordered. People who have had a wedding will tell you to order significantly less cake for than the number of people who are attending the event as you will have so much cake left over that you will be giving it away and bringing it to work the next day. Well, we had 215 people attending the wedding and took a chance and ordered cake enough for 200, as we ordered an extra sheet cake from Caitlin. After the wedding, I went home with not enough cake to offer to the 8 people who came over the next day to dinner. More guests commented on how delicious the cake was and how they couldn't resist trying all 3 layer flavors! I would absolutely recommend The Posh Cakery and Caitlin to anyone who needs a cake for any occasion especially one as important as a wedding!!! read more

The Posh Cakery is absolutely incredible! I highly encourage you to use the Posh Cakery for your wedding and for other special occasions! I have a huge sweet tooth, but honestly I have never been much of a cake (or cupcake) person. I even thought about finding some kind of alternative dessert for our wedding. I met Caitlin (owner of the Posh Cakery) at an open house at our venue. When I tried one of her sample cupcakes, it was absolutely delicious (and I really am very picky when it comes to cake)! I looked at some of her sample books, and was immediately sold! Her cakes are unique and very well-executed. They are also really fairly priced. She has a really lovely bakery area where she welcomed my then-fiance and me and my parents for a tasting. Every flavor combination we tasted was amazing (even my now-husband who is not typically a fan of fruit-flavored desserts enjoyed every one of the flavors we tried). It was hard choosing from so many wonderful options! Caitlin is very flexible and really can do anything! We had three different cake flavors in our wedding cake with various icings and two additional cakes (groom's cake and an extra sheet cake). I sent her descriptions and some images of ideas for the cakes and knew she would do a great job, but I am still amazed at how perfect the cakes looked! She literally made our visions come to life, and the decorating is PERFECT! (I used to decorate cookies at a store and am picky about the execution of decorated baked goods--Caitlin's talent amazes me!). I cannot rave about Caitlin and Posh Cakery enough! Caitlin (and her grandmother/ assistant Helen) are so kind and organized, and her cakes are incredibly delicious and, again, truly perfect! I will encourage everyone I know looking for wedding cakes in the future to absolutely order from the Posh Cakery! read more

LOVE, LOVE, LOVE, this bakery!!! So cute and the owners are the cutest couple that you have ever met! I called them and another bakery in Monroe (Hoosier Girl), Hoosier Girl was so rude and they told me we could not do a tasting because we were not having a wedding. When I explained it was for a 50th wedding anniversary for 100 guests, they still didn't care. When I called Posh Cakery, they were so nice and accommodating and had the table all set up for when myself, sister in law and mother law came in for the tasting. They delivered the 125 cupcakes on time, which we were able to choose 5 different flavors (trust me it was hard to pick). Everyone raved at the party about how great they were! I will definitely use The Posh Cakery again! read more

The Posh Cakery did the wedding cake for my son's wedding this past weekend. He had a three layer cake with three different flavors, fillings and frosting. One of the flavors was even one that we requested. All were delicious meaning that the cake was moist, the fillings added flavor and the frosting had the correct balance of sweetness. They are also the sweetest couple to deal with (very service oriented). We tried many different bakers in the Athens, GA area before going with this baker. The fact that they make sure the decorations are done correctly on the cake even if it is flowers makes an impression. It not only tasted great, it was beautiful. I would say that they are the best!!! read more