Heading south from Sheboygan with my family I had a craving for ice cream, so I pulled up the options around Port Washington. The "best" local place that was open in January was The Chocolate Chisel. My family and I stopped and each got a cone. I also got three truffles. The truffles I bought were chai tea milk, experimint milk (ganache with peppermint extract), and peppermint hot chocolate. The chai tea and experimint milk truffles both tasted like they should based on their descriptions, but I wouldn't wantto buy either again. The peppermint hot chocolate had some crushed peppermint on top, but other than the chocolate being in the shape of a mug, nothing about it reminded me of hot chocolate. Ultimately I don't think any of them were worth the price. The ice cream was lackluster. Both of my kids got cookies and cream in a cake cone and thought it was skimpy on the cookies part. My wife and I sprung for waffle cones with ours and were both disappointed in the excessive cone to ice cream ratio that heavily favored the cone. She got plain chocolate and it was fine. I, however, got banana-rama and ended up throwing it out because it tasted more like butter pecan than anything banana related. I even went back inside and verified with the employee that it wasn't mislabeled in the case. read more

See all

The chocolate is very good. The service is 1star. Ordered online 5/16/26 because I saw them on PBS John mcgivern. And received on 6/4. Ordered for a gift, but came way too late. No communication with company or shipping company (shop). I reached out to chocolate chisel and was told, waiting on a product for gift package and they apologized. read more

Amazing is all I can say!! On a trip to Port Washington to see my parents, we stopped at The Chocolate Chisel for some ice cream. My dad loves this place, so I'm sure the staff knows him. The girls working on the Saturday evening we stopped in were super nice! All of us got ice cream and it was great! The place is super cute and aside from the ice cream, they have a bunch of different homemade chocolates. I'm ready to go back to visit my parents so we can stop by for some more ice cream. read more

Grab a bag of the caramel corn with milk and dark chocolate drizzle. You will thank me later.

Best darn dark chocolate in the state. It's 74% cocoa and you can't find that anywhere else

Highly recommend this place! All the treats we had were delicious and the staff charming and helpful. As a mom to a child with allergies, I appreciate that they use a clean scoop each time to prevent cross contamination. read more

What an establishment. This Port Washington staple has served our family for years and given us some of the best ice cream. Don't overlook the chocolate either! Austin is especially helpful and useful. He brings a special touch to the experience. Quite the gem in the ole PW! read more

So good, the ice cream is to die for. The staff is so friendly... and courteous.. And the place is spotless and cozy even though it's small... read more

A nice place to get a cone or a treat. An especially nice place to buy a gift for someone special. They have Christmas ornaments seasonally. There are lovely chocolate bars with port Washington chiseled into them. A wonderful place. read more

Lots of places close early in the surrounding areas so we were glad to see that chocolate chisel was open a little later so we could get a treat yesterday! I tried a sample of the lavender honey ice cream, the honey flavor was really strong but not bad! I ended up getting a scoop of peanut butter m&m ice cream and it was so delicious. My sister got some chocolates and we shared with my brother. One of the chocolates was a little bland but everything else was good! read more

We were staying down the street on our way up to Door County. We got into Port Washington a little early to have dinner and walk around town. We just happened upon this place not 5 minutes down the street. So after dinner we walked over, it is a much more sophisticated place than it looks. They have a lot of homemade chocolates in unique flavors plus ice cream! So we bought some chocolate and some ice cream. I had some superb Pistachio Ginger, and not that neon green stuff either. I need to get back and try the Tomatillo. My wife had an amazing Peanut Butter something or other. What a great little local gem. It will be someplace we stop everything we are up that way read more

Delicious homemade ice cream and chocolates. Nice stop when in Port Washington Wisconsin.

Ice cream is the way to my heart. It's also the way to my dogs heart. Ice cream is important to me and I need it more often than not to maintain my life and vitality. There is no doubt whenever we go up towards Green bay you can betcha we'll swing by Port Washington and get some goodies at the Chocolate Chisel! Chocolate Chisel is a small shop with a whole lot of selection. My favorite is the salted caramel with chocolate mint in a waffle cone! I get all giddy just thinking about it. There is nothing better on a hot day than chilling in Port Washington with ice cream in hand from the Chisel! We love this place period! Check out the assortment of handmade treats if you're there too! You won't be disappointed. read more

The Chocolate Chisel - Desserts Near Me - Port Washington, Wisconsin

See all

First let's talk the people: I stopped in less than 5 minutes to close. All of them We're hopping around happily doing there jobs. They welcomed me and offered their help. It was refreshing. In a way I expected to be greeted with haste, being that they were set to be closing up. Nope, pure patience and customer service. What an amazing staff you have! Now to the chocolate: Ummmmm, wow! The Elvis Presley is the perfect combination of peanut butter and banana. The bourbon bonbon has flavor that will take you to the moon. Not to mention, their delicate decor and design is a show stopper. They deserve to be proudly displayed on a plate or tray of sorts. I took chocolate home to California and it is a hit! Can't wait to be back to grab more amazing chocolate. read more

Cute sweet shoppe in a cute little town (seriously, how can a coal plant be cute?). They have bonbons, ice cream & sorbet, and chocolates. The sorbets were vegan, and most of the dark chocolate bars and stuff were explicitly labeled as vegan, which made the kids happy. The kiddy scoops are adorable and teeny, but the 6yo was happy, and I got one too and it was good for both os us. The pre-tween wanted more though, unsurprisingly. In these COVID times, they only allow 4 people inside at a time. Masks required, obvi. They had a bunch of chairs and cows to sit on outside, and there are benches across the street too. Staff was super friendly and helpful. And patient. Free street parking is a plus, too. Maybe not worth a trip just for sweets from MKE, but if you're in the area looking at the lighthouse or Lion's Den Gorge, swing by and treat yourself. read more

Every time I've been here the workers have been awesome. The ice cream and chocolate selection never disappoints either.

Delicious chocolates and ice cream! They have a large selection of truffles and chocolate bark. It's honestly all super delicious - I have never tried anything I did not like. I recently tried the ice cream. We had a scoop of salted caramel and blueberry cheesecake. They were both so good! The blueberry cheesecake tasted just like it sounds and the salted caramel was "melt in your mouth" good. You can also ask for a sample of the various ice cream flavors. They are vegan and gluten-free friendly, and the staff are knowledge about food allergies. They offer a punch card as well, you get one punch per $5 spent. Definitely a good thing to have if you stop here frequently. This is a great place get a special treat when visiting Port Washington :) read more

The Chocolate Chisel - Desserts Near Me - Port Washington, Wisconsin

We went here to try one thing and one thing only, their well known chocolate chip ice cream Sandwich. Listen.... that was one of the best sandwiches I've ever had! Not to mention I really enjoy chocolate chip cookies! It is a pretty large sandwich so you may choose not to eat the whole thing at once, which only gives something to look forward to later! What's bad about that... nothing! Check it out. Kids would love it. read more

Went today for the first time. We happen to stop in the area! Adorable little place. The staff was extremely friendly and knowledgeable. My son has celiac so we typically only get ice cream in cups. They had gluten free cones! This is the first time he's ever been able to have one besides our home! We can't wait to come back. My son hasn't stopped talking about his cone all day!! The mini schools were great for our 2 year olds! read more

The Chocolate Chisel - Desserts Near Me - Port Washington, Wisconsin

See all

Quality ice cream and flavors are not your typical ones found in every ice cream shop. Nice small hometown feel with hours I'm impressed they are open every day till 8 pm read more

We visited for the first time Saturday and it was amazing! Root beer sorbet that tasted like my favorite, root beer popsicles! Chocolates that look like works of art and taste so good. Wish we lived closer to visit more often, but we will be back. read more

Riding Bikes on the interurban trail... we'd burned enough calories.. it was time to enjoy some extra treats! A small shop. The chocolate almost looks too good to eat.. bordering on works of art!. One girl working the counter that day, she was pretty busy! When our turn came along we ordered a couple of ice cream cones (.50 extra got me a waffle cone dipped in chocolate) and an assortment of turtles and other fresh chocolates to go (yes, they did survive being strapped onto my bike) My ice cream (yes, I lack control.. a double cone.. sea salt caramel and chocolate peanut butter cup) was delicious.. I don't know if it's locally made but it's pretty great. We'd go out of our way to stop here again. read more

The Chocolate Chisel - Joy is a good word - Desserts Near Me - Port Washington, Wisconsin

Awesome ice cream made locally! Great staff, very helpful and polite. We went here three days in a row we loved it so much! If you are in Port Washington you need to do yourself a favor and stop by, have a few truffles and some ice cream. I can highly recommend the PB&J, lavender honey, pistachio, salted Carmel and raspberry ice creams. We didn't try too many truffles but the Elvis dark or light, mango fire dark and the cherry bomb are great. As a side note the PB&J doesn't make the best milkshake as the peanut better won't blend but the lavender honey and salted Carmel is amazing as a shake! read more

This place is a gem hidden away in quaint Port Washington, Wisconsin on Lake Michigan. I have never seen such beautiful chocolate. Each piece looked like a piece of art. Shaped by an artist and presented polished and glazed. They have amazing flavored Truffles like: Tongo Vanilla made with Polynesian Vanilla. Vodka Lemon, Caramel Apple, Sweet Potato and Cinnamon Habanero. They have the creamiest ice cream I have ever had. I tried the Espresso Crunch on a really fresh waffle cone. I recommend this place to anyone who loves chocolate or loves someone who loves chocolate. p.s. The service was great too. read more

The Chocolate Chisel - Yummy goodness. - Desserts Near Me - Port Washington, Wisconsin

So far, so good!! Went here for the first time and I'm really impressed! It's a small place but size really doesn't matter here. We ordered their ice cream on this trip- their salted caramel, birthday cake and classic vanilla bean- and they were divine! We also got to sample some of their other flavors (lavender coconut? yes, please!) and they were just as delicious. The texture is super creamy, velvety, silky, and packed with flavor. You want salted caramel? You get the kick in the back of your throat from the salt then the sweetness of the caramel to soothe your soul. The birthday cake tasted like a dream full of rainbows and unicorns. The vanilla bean was a wink from your crush... seriously, ya'll. The girl at the counter was extremely helpful and polite, as well as super warm and welcoming. Made us feel like we had been long-time friends. I did take notice of the variety of chocolates and sweets they offer, which were super pretty and displayed neatlbut we didn't purchase any on this trip. Maybe next time, cus for sure, there will be a next time. This place deserves 5 stars. read more

See all

Great chocolate and ice cream. Always very prompt service from a very knowledgeable staff. Highly recommend the chocolate bombs and peanut butter cups. read more

I used to be a fan. This was 5 stars. I simply don't agree with the new policy of only 1 flavor per scoop. So it js now 3 stars. It used to be that for the 1 big scoop you can have two flavors. I don't want two big scoops because the portion js too much. Then they offer mini scoops and I would be open to that only they are super mini and not worth the money. This place will always be successful yet it is doubtful I will return after being a fan for many years. By the way the chocolate is yummy yet pricey. I like the dark chocolate orange. It's cute inside. Yet to the owner ice cream is about being fun and when I see a scale being used for everything that comes out of the case it's a bit much. read more

Service is slow. Girls had to walk back and forth from making cones etc to the register. Older guy was sitting in the back just watching, didn't bother to step up to the register to have the girls focus on the line that was out the door. Some very 'interesting' flavors, including ginger pear, orange chocolate, and Pina colada. Ice cream is good, but nothing to write home about. Also, perhaps when the line is out the door, limit samples to one... read more

This place is great. Small, good ice cream and lots of chocolate options. Sit outside and enjoy the nice night in this small town. Really yummy flavors and a great stop for the kiddos. read more

It's a little shop with a lot of selection. The cases of truffles will keep your eyes occupied for quite a while. Then your taste buds will love your choices regardless of what they are. The staff is very friendly and accommodating. Try the hot chocolate with cinnamon and hazelnut...YUMMY! They also serve Sassy Cow ice cream and use Sassy Cow milk, so that's another bonus. This place saved an otherwise disappointing trip to Port Washington. read more

How does this place taste only 2 $$? When you're paying $5 for each piece of candy, you would think it's $$$$. I mean, it's good, but unless it's for a little thank you gift or something, not worth it. Tourist trap. read more

We went on a Friday around 5 p.m. on a 90 degree day. The line forms outside because of covid rules. Waited 25 minutes!! and then left. There was only one young man working and he was responsible for taking orders, cashiering, and then scooping the ice cream. To say he was overwhelmed would be an understatement. More help is needed. It should be easy to predict that hot weather will equate to long lines. Can't comment on the ice cream as we never had a chance to try any. read more

Great service. Great ice cream and a huge selection of chocolates made at the store. Even has ice cream separated from others for those allergic to nuts- which is huge for me. I plan on coming back a lot read more

If you're in the area and have a sweet tooth, this is a must-stop. It's a cute, tiny shop dedicated to delicious ice cream and various kinds of chocolate. I can only speak to the ice cream, but their chocolates looked amazing (and pretty!). They had at least 12 different flavors and you can get it in a dish, standard cone, waffle cone, and both chocolate dipped. The ice cream was fantastic - I went with strawberry and vanilla. But all their other flavors looked promising. My only complaint was the wait. However, it was a hot summer night - so what else should I expect. They only had 3 people working and the line was literally out the door. However, you know you have a good thing going when people are willing to wait awhile for a few scoops of some ice cream. read more

VEGAN FRIENDLY The nicest and most knowledgeable staff. Normal pricing for premium chocolate. Worked very hard to accommodate everyone. Vegan, nut allergies, gluten allergies. One of the best surprises of Port Washington. read more

The ice cream is great, but this place always mysteriously smells like trash. I'm not saying it has a vague, bad smell. I'm saying it truly smells like week old trash every time I've been in there. Ice cream is decent, though. read more

The service was very slow and the ice cream is nothing special. I got a milkshake and it tasted like they put loads of syrup in it. I took 2 sips and placed it properly in the garbage. It was also over priced for what I got. They also had zero flavors available when I was there. They advertise all of these ice cream flavors and had maybe 8 to try. I would never go back nor recommend this place to a friend. If someone asked me where they can get average ice cream with slow service I would recommend THE CHOCOLATE CHISEL. read more

We stopped in here the other day during our walk downtown. We were offered a free sample upon entering which was delicious! Prices are a little too high for my taste, but the chocolates would make a great specialty gift. read more

3 had waffle cones and 1 has a shake. Generous and tasty all. The store made chocolates looked perfect so I took a flyer to use when I order Christmas gifts for family, friends and colleagues. I'll be back. read more

I love this place! My son and I often go here for hand dipped ice cream cones. I love that they have a little cone for under a dollar! They always have a great selection of flavors you can sample. We are also big fans of their organic gummy candy selection and chocolates. read more