The Tavern at St. Michael&#x27;s Square

White Horse Cowboys and Indians, immigrants and pipeliners,…read moreassholes and bikers, this joint has got'em all, You know you're in a genuine great American western bar when you pee into an ice filled urinal hanging on the wall. Free pool on Sundays, bingo in the mornings, and karaoke most Friday & Saturday nights, They'll tolerate listening to your drunken ramblings but they're quick to 86 your ass if you get into a fight. I've never seen so many regulars come in and give the bartenders cheerful hugs, Don't worry about being a stranger though cause they greet everyone with warm smiles and frosty mugs. Buy a drink during happy hour and they'll give you a colored marker chip, If you don't want to be labeled a tightass then you better damn well give your server a good tip. If you ever stumble upon this jewel then you're guaranteed to have a good time of course, You've found yourself in Garden City, Colorado's world famous White Horse. Chad Jackson April 2025

Yippee! This was my go to place back in the day and I still enjoy popping in every now and then…read more Ronica, the owner, is fabulous and the bar staff are friendly and efficient. It's always a good time to be had by all.

Great all American Bar!

See all

Lucky Fins

4.0(337 reviews)

1.8 mi

Great food, amazing staff, and very clean. I highly recommend this place…read more I ordered the steak and potatoes, the steak was just right the potatoes were amazing.

So there are not many seafood places here in Colorado, let alone Greeley but this place is a must…read moreif you're passing through and want some good sushi and seafood. The service is always great and so friendly and I love the ambiance of the place too! When I go I always sit at the bar and get me a flight of whiskey. Of the many times I have at here, here is a few of the apps I have gotten and loved. My favorite and mostly go to is the crispy Brussels and cauliflower fried topped with bacon and balsamic drizzle, there is also some dippy stuff that comes with it. I don't know what it's called but I freaking love it w the Brussels. Another app I have tried is the kickin shrimp. This is almost like the bang bang shrimp from PF Changs but a little more crispier and tastes much better in my opinion. The sushi rolls I have tried is the spicy tuna, yes it's raw, and so delicious. If you like spicy this is definitely a sushi roll for you. The fish was very fresh and so tender, you almost didn't know you were eating raw fish. Now for the two entrees I have tried, I'll start first with my second favorite which is the fish and chips. The fish is battered to perfection and so crispy along with the fish so flaky and just so yummy. The sides that came w it were fries. They were good. Now onto my number one hands down favorite dish I always get when I come. What can I say I'm a creature of habit. The mahi mahi, , the way they cook it and the flakiness of this fish here is phenomenal, you can either get the rice that comes with it or how I do it I sub it for their fresh asparagus topped with a spring mix and some dressing on top. I use to not like mahi mahi but this place I will eat it until the end of time. Overall this place is a 10/10. Staff is always amazing, food is on point and fresh and the whiskey is delish!

Lobster tots

Noodle Bowl

See all

Pinot Grigio

The Kress Cinema & Lounge

4.4(50 reviews)

5.6 mi

excellent service in this speakeasy, ordered a Vieux Carre martini, it was so good, we had a light…read moresupper with the olives, a cheese board, a flat bread and a couple salads, I highly recommend!

I'm curious as to why it took the bar person a full 30 seconds to carefully carefully go over our…read moreIDs with a fine-tooth comb, over the edges and everything. My husband I are both over 30, and I don't care for the implication that we're lying about our age. On top of that, every employee there gave us the "we're tired, go away, vibes." Really terrible customer service, and for an ancient movie theatre that's about to go out of business, you might want to consider treating your customers better.

Conference

Kress speakeasy

See all

Turn the light on!

Bogey's Pub & Grille

3.9(21 reviews)

1.4 mi

Super tasty green chili burger! Great service, outdoor seating is a welcome option. Waiter was…read morejovial and made delicious recommendations. Decent prices, good beer selections, lively atmosphere.

we got here about 3:15pm. we ordered food. I ordered shrimp and here is why only 3 stars, their…read moresides suck. I wanted baked potato or tasty rice or something besides fries or steamed but undercooked broccoli. I ordered the wild rice. it had no flavor and I usually like wild rice. anyway, our waitress was great and the people I was with are great and my drink order was also great. I would probably go here again but not until at least 4pm where there might be a baked potato.

Cheeseburger with bacon and provolone

Hamburger

See all

Burnout Grill

2.6(28 reviews)

5.2 mi

It's a great place for bike night, with live bands, a nice patio and drinks. I liked the wings a…read morelot

In a tiny little town like Milliken I think one instinctively adjusts their expectations toward the…read morelower end of the experience scale. There are very few options to experiment and hopefully call your "go-to" place whenever you're town. Unfortunately, this place will not be mine. Several other reviews have pointed out some concerning issues that this place has and sadly there are quite true. My wife and I bought a coupon for this place on Restaurant.com and decided to give this place a shot on a late Friday afternoon. We walked in to a dark and relatively empty bar. There was some sort of finger food buffet laid out on the table near where you walked in, but we decided to pass on that potentially germ ridden food trap. The place had a foreboding atmosphere which clearly was geared toward a racing theme. Since the weather was nice and eating inside would've been kinda depressing, we found a small table on their patio outside. Still hopeful and optimistic about the food (at least until I started reading some Yelp reviews) we started to read the menu and look for something to satisfy our curious appetite. Our server came over to greet us and seemed pleasant and accommodating. We're avid beer geeks and asked our server about their beer options. She said that she had mainly the macro brews such as budwieser, miller, coors, etc. But they did have one IPA, which was from Black Bottle Brewing. We settled on that option, but it ended up being kinda stale and flat, which made us wonder just how long they've had that keg on tap. We ended up ordering the cajun and western version of their beef and bacon burger. While we waited for our food we were sizing up the clientele of this dive bar. True to the quintessential nature of such an establishment, the patio was chalk full of middle aged, smoking, leathery and loud people. This is not the place to bring your kids if you don't want to expose them to second-hand smoke. One cannot honestly judge them harshly for fitting into a dive bar mold so well. Our food finally came after about 15 minutes. As you can see from the picture I posted, they aren't entirely bad looking. That said they didn't taste very good. The burgers were under seasoned, over-cooked, and just bland and flavorless. The bun was a very cheap choice, which you could probably find to be the cheapest option on the shelf at the supermarket. We were hungry and trudged through our meal. The server came around and asked how it was. I told her exactly what I just wrote and she apologized. She offered to take one of the burgers off of our tab and we insisted that was not necessary. She did end up taking one off of our bill and I again said that I didn't ask for that. Regardless, it doesn't make up for the poor experience here. Even though our server was quite nice, I cannot see myself coming back here. There's nothing appealing here for food and beer enthusiasts. If you're the biker type and love dive bars with cheap food and beer, then this is right up your alley. I wish them all the luck in their future which won't include me as a customer.

Glad to visit again. Yummy!

Cajun (top) and Western burger (bottom)

See all

Wyler's Pub & Grill

3.6(16 reviews)

3.7 mi

Holy crap these burgers are AMAZING!!! Got their mushroom swiss double and WOW!!! Best burger ive…read moreeaten in maybe forever!!

I have been there 5 times. The last will be my last time. The night shift waitress was more into…read moreputting up Halloween decorations and talking with friends than tending bar; it took me 3 attempts to get a refill of a draft Bud light, and I was at the bar. I finally turned my glass upside to get her attention. It was just not worth the effort! Too bad, its a decent place.

See all

Meeker's A Colorado Kitchen & Bar

3.4(119 reviews)

5.6 mi

Very honest review. I spent dinner with my mom, we had drinks and shared different menu items. I…read morewas having a rough few days, and this meal definitely turned things around. Very comforting, and the menu items were different and delicious. Our sever Marcey made our night. She was very welcoming, friendly, and also funny. Thank you Meeker's for a night well spent.

Chicken caprese was straight rubber. The mozzarella didn't even melt.... I was very disappointed…read more Obvious the food comes frozen and is heated up. Poor servers as well, there was not much help around.

View of Meeker's from inside the Doubletree at Lincoln Park

Wild Alaskan Cod

See all

Bar area

The Paragon Family Restaurant

3.6(25 reviews)

4.0 mi

•$$$

Fabulous food, fabulous service, at a reasonable cost. Who you been going here for years and will…read morecontinue to do so. Highly recommend.

Paragon Family Restaurant has a variety of breakfast offerings. I was here for the Eggs Benedict…read more My review is only of the Benedicts, nothing else. The staff was polite and helpful. They took good care of me. With that in mind, I will let you know that have a "top ten" list for Benedicts. My rating is based on 3 weights : 70% = taste 20% = presentation 10% = price #1 - taste: They do use a thick piece of ham. The eggs were an almost perfect easy. The Hollandaise sauce was made from scratch and had a very distinctive flavor and taste but not just a plain yellow sauce. The reason I review Eggs Benedict is because of the difference in the flavor of the Hollandaise sauce. They do not have hash browns but have call "boiled, sliced and fried potatoes." They were browned like hash browns. #2 -presentation : It was great. #3-price: $13.59 is right in line with Bennys with hash browns. Coffee for $2.79 a cup which is lower then a lotta places. I also tried the biscuit and gravy. One of the best ever. Although it did not make my top 10 Eggs benedict list they are very good and worth the try.

Eggs benedict

See all

Greek omlet

The Dugout Bar-B-Q

4.0(26 reviews)

4.7 mi

I can't say enough good things about this place, but especially about our server, Danny. She's the…read morekind of person who makes you feel like a regular from day one. By my second visit she had already memorized my drink order, and from then on it was like she knew exactly what my friends and I needed before we even asked. Danny has this rare balance of being personable and professional--always checking in at just the right time without ever hovering. She made sure our group felt taken care of every single time, and honestly, she's a big part of why this spot became my everyday hangout. If I hadn't moved out of town, I'd still be coming here just to have Danny as my server. She's one of those people who turns a casual night out into something memorable. 100% recommend asking for her if you stop by!

We came in to watch the Broncos game and had an amazing experience! Jenna was hands down one of the…read morebest servers we've ever had--even with the bar completely packed. She was always checking on us, super attentive, and made sure our beers were never empty. Outstanding service and a great game-day atmosphere. We'll definitely be back!

Burgers and Sandwiches

See all

Texas Roadhouse

3.4(142 reviews)

3.5 mi

This place is my new favorite steakhouse. We didn't know too much about this place before going…read more We found everything to be great. Next time we are are in town. We are surely going again

Couldn't even get seated for 2. First dinner night out without the kids in a long time. Checked in…read moreright after receiving the text saying see the host. Told to stand by the sign as directed. Stood there for 35 minutes and saw multiple parties seated first that arrived after me. Restaurant manager and floor manager passed by me 30 times and not once noticed I'd been standing there well after multiple new parties had been seated. Checked in with the host and was told they accidentally bumped us from the list but would seat us next. Four more parties after us we check in again and are told by the same host sorry, don't know what happened(we were already told this) but they can't move us ahead of people. We go to leave the building and are stopped by a supervisor who tells us to not leave and go check in with the teenage host again. We declined and left. Before we even got to the car we get the notification we've been removed from the waiting list. We go here often for family parties, went often with pick up orders during COVID. We will be making an easy choice to never go here again.

Definitely undercooked

Hurricane margarita

See all

Dead fly

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

16 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Chris C.

1 year ago

The tavern used to be one of my favorite spots to eat and have a drink. My brother and I went in Sunday for brunch. The bartender named Danny seems to have a "god complex " she had a bad attitude and not a very good bartender. No people skills whatsoever. The building has no air conditioning, no fans, and refuses to open the doors. It was unbearably hot. The bartender was obviously tired of the complaints and just said "tell my boss." The bathroom is nasty they have these orange things they use as air freshener but it's awful. The bathroom is falling apart. The brunch was horrible I had the biscuits and gravy to my horror they make it with chorizo. My ultimate advice is do not go here. The staff is horrible, the food even worse, it's hot and stagnant and they don't care that their patrons are spending money in the establishment to be uncomfortable, treated poorly, and horrible food. read more

Jessica C.

10 years ago

This place should have 5 stars it was wonderful. The burgers were excellent and the club sandwich was beyond anything I've had in town! Our server Danielle was wonderful pleasant and on point with service never had to ask for a refill. The martinis are on point so good I loved the apple Carmel it was so good. Please go ignore the stars and the bitter people who go to a pub style place and expect a setting that is not pub style. read more

Josie W.

11 years ago

Not a fun place to have a beer. If you laugh you are told to stop by the rude staff. The food is below average if you even get it within an hour of ordering it. The craft beer selection is only the standard local crap from New Belgium and other colorado breweries. They never get any local beers that are limited release just the breweries flagship beers. Oh did I mention that the wait staff is rude? read more

Terry M.

10 years ago

Don't really know where to start with how bad our visit was there the other day. The bartender did her best to ignore us while she flirted with every guy in there. We tried to get our check for over a half hour because we were never offered a second drink let alone a menu. We finally got our check and went to eat some place else. We will never go back!! read more

Rick S.

115

8 years ago

I remember this place used to be a fun place to meet. My latest experience was a creepy guy standing in front of the bar dancing and singing. It was not karaoke night and he is dating or married to a female employee of the Tavern. The people I was with thought the same thing. Nobody comes there to see or hear that. Annoying!!!! read more

Carol M.

9 years ago

Love this place! Went to a high school graduation party there today and my husband and I were thoroughly impressed! The wait staff (Morgan and Chandler) took excellent care of us, the food and drinks were delicious, and the restaurant was beautiful! My husband loved the meatballs! Two thumbs up! read more

Char A.

8 years ago

Visited the Tavern tonight and we were very disappointed. They have taken what was pretty good pub food and made it new age artistic garbage. A very sad development for the neighborhood watering hole.... read more

Fred F.

10 years ago

The wait staff and bar management are the worst in town. The beers selection is weak and you wait all day for your food if the waitress even puts your order in. read more

Douglas B.

9 years ago

I hope as this area grows they are able to keep up the service. Great casual spot for grub on the west side of Greeley.

MD S.

8 years ago

Was ok. Nothing to write home about. Their green chile was pretty good. Service was a little slow

Marita S.

5 years ago

Food was not flavorful. Service was good, though. Server was attentive. Not worth the price.

Clifton E.

4 years ago

Great little getaway in our neighborhood! Good food and nice atmosphereColorado was great!!!

J L.

11 years ago

Was here once for evening drinks and received excellent table service. Will surely be back.

B S.

16 years ago

I will not support this establishment based on the unprofessionalism of the owner.

Mike S.

12 years ago

such a great place tucked away from the busy highways and shopping malls!

Lesly M.

13 years ago

Good service, fresh food and nice atmosphere. I'll be back for sure.

The Tavern at St. Michael's Square - newamerican - Updated September 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Greeley, Colorado Things to Do near The Tavern at St. Michael's Square

BEST of Greeley, Colorado Desserts near The Tavern at St. Michael's Square

BEST of Greeley, Colorado Restaurants near The Tavern at St. Michael's Square

BEST of Greeley, Colorado Coffee near The Tavern at St. Michael's Square

BEST of Greeley, Colorado Cocktail Bars near The Tavern at St. Michael's Square

BEST of Greeley, Colorado Brunch near The Tavern at St. Michael's Square

BEST of Greeley, Colorado Breakfast near The Tavern at St. Michael's Square

BEST of Greeley, Colorado Shopping near The Tavern at St. Michael's Square

BEST of Greeley, Colorado Thrift Stores near The Tavern at St. Michael's Square

Best of Greeley

Things to do in Greeley

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed The Tavern at St. Michael's Square also viewed

CJ's Patio Grill

3.6

(111 reviews)

Food was awesome! I had the Reuben and the meat was so tender! Wife had the cheeseburger and it was…read moremade perfect! The place has a pub flare but def sports bar vibe - no complaints! The place is great to watch events on TV - we were watching sweet 16. We will be back to try more of the menu!!

I just moved to Loveland. I do love this place. I have to tell you a secret however. I have a 11.5…read moreyear old Westie dog. We both are co-dependent and I thinks she is worse than I am. Why? I don't pee on the carpet if she is away from me. Going out to eat can be a challenge, I'm picky I want a nice meal, you know good food. I often need to bring her with me to avoid total home destruction. So when I found CJ's Patio grill I was delighted. The place is clean, friendly and they love dogs. The food was great. They have shaded out door dining. They even gave Ms Diva dog a water bowl and offered her a biscuit. I will be back and maybe my dog will accept the biscuit next time. I told her she should think about it because I am not sharing any of my yummy food with her.

Bulldog Pub & Grub

3.8

(95 reviews)

I've been coming here for a while now, and there is no question Covid sucked. They did their best…read moreto accommodate everyone, including the employees. Things are back open again and I come here almost daily (a benefit from working from home which is a 10 min walk.) and the quality and taste of the food has not changed. (This means they never cut back on the quality of their ingredients to cut costs during the lock down.) There are many items on the menu I have yet to try as I am a pizza guy and theirs is THE.BEST. As I'm writing this review, the owner is taking orders, helping the bartender and even interacting with the kids that want to see all the Star Wars stuff that is all over the place. :) This has always reminds me of the small pubs back home where community is key and people really do "know your name.". Never stop doing what you're doing. :)

Service was sparse, but understandable for a collegiate football game...our neighbors were cordial,…read morewith great mannered kids. Lacking two draft beers, when this was a planned event, is not what I consider to be quality management of a resturaunt...ill prepared to take care of guests. Will not consider a return trip. After the news that a second requested glass of beer would not be available, we opted out of attempting to order that pizza....not sure we would have gotten that, so instead went home, drank our own beer...not one glass at $6.78/ glass! Our homemade pizza sure did hit the spot, tho!

The Border Restaurant

3.8

(46 reviews)

Ok...I don't understand any reviews that are not 4 or 5 for this place. First, the food is on…read morepoint. If you like Carne Asada and Carnitas...amazing. The Carnitas is special. We were waited on by two servers both were awesome! The salsa so good! The green chili is amazing. Guacamole is so good! Margarita was good. The place is clean with 9 tables, so if you have a big group call ahead. Food comes fast and take out is easy to do. I wish we lived here to make this place one of our weekly staples! 100% recommended!!

When it comes to Street Tacos, my wife and I "go to" place is The Border Restaurant. Today, Friday…read moreNov 21, we went to The Border for dinner. We always have great service and great experience every time we go eat here. My of course ordered her favorite Carne Asada Street Tacos with a side of rice and beans. As for me, I decided to order their Friday Prime Rib Dinner special. The prime rib meat was so huge, juicy , tender and delicious! It was cooked perfectly. Plate comes with mashed potatoes & gravy, string beans vegetables, toasted buttery bread and au jus sauce for the meat. All these side dishes were delicious. I enjoyed this meal very much and I highly recommend it. See picture attached.

Pourhouse

3.7

(381 reviews)

This is one of my two favorite places in downtown Loveland for dinner. They recently opened a…read morerooftop part of the restaurant so that is a much needed plus around Loveland. We can always count on the Pourhouse for a great meal and they have a great offering of on tap beers and the bar itself is very well stocked and gives you the selection of just about anything that you want. I was there on Tuesday night, so it was a little slow in addition they're dealing with some street construction which is probably had a huge effect on them. But the staff was friendly and helpful. The food was spot on and they happen to have some of my favorite beers on top as well so all in all it's a home run for sure.

Stopped for lunch after finishing some shopping. We showed up about 12:30 on a Thursday and we were…read moreseated immediately. Servers were attentive to you and the food was served quickly. Food was good brew pub type food. They have many beers on tap many local as well as big time brews. We sat inside but was told they have seating on the roof as well.

Meeker's A Colorado Kitchen & Bar

3.4

(119 reviews)

Big City Roadhouse

3.5

(8 reviews)

Andrea is a freaking diva and she was amazing. Was really funny and joking around and made us feel…read morelike we're regulars. She was a great time!! The food was so good too! Pizza was tasty!

What an amazing dinner we had tonight! Thank you to our server Vincent. He was amazing polite and…read morevery attentive to our needs. Vincent recommended the fish and chips along with an amazing cocktail the purple haze margaritas.... Wow topped off the night! Me and the wife will be returning and requesting Vincent moving forward. Thank you for the amazing night to our date night.

The G O A T Sports Bar

3.7

(104 reviews)

Server was attentive. We sat on the patio with four dogs and couldn't been happier. A couple of…read moreus ordered the fish and chips and the description said 3 pieces and only two pieces came with the dish. When confronted, they said they had new fish that it was bigger that's why it's only two pieces. They haven't had time to change the menu.

The wait staff needs to be trained on how to attend to their tables better than they do, except for…read moreone. Taylor is amazing and the rest of the wait staff could learn a lot from her. The last couple of times that I have been there the server comes to our table to get drinks, our order, and pay the bill. Never comes back to see if we need refills or how the food is. It's a shame because their food, especially their hamburgers, are decent.

The Lodge

3.9

(37 reviews)

Service was very pleasant and the food was exceptional. It's been awhile since we were here but…read morecould not be more pleased with the thoughtful menu and the beautiful plating.

One of the more disappointing dining experiences I've ever had. We visited last night for our first…read moretime and our last time, unfortunately. Decided to try something new and took my father-in-law there for his birthday. We had reservations for 6:30pm and as we arrived, a large bus full of 50 college hockey players also arrived. It took us over 30 minutes to have somebody take our drink order and another 15 minutes for those drinks to arrive. We were seated with a happy hour menu, which was over and I had to ask the bartender for a drink menu and wine list. My water glass was very dirty and nobody ever came by the table in 90 minutes to refill our water. We were seated right next to the bar too. We were continually informed by our waitress and a barback that things were slow due to the large party in the other room. After 90 minutes passed and we still had not received our food, we asked to speak to the manager. When the manager came to our table, she did not introduce herself, so we had to assume she was the manager. Rather than own the mistake, she proceeded to throw our waitress under the bus. Our waitress was great and doing the best she could, but the restaurant was severely understaffed. They offered us free bread. We finally decided to get up and walk out and leave without being served our food. The manager chased us out the front door to bring our food in to-go boxes and as we were leaving, the entire hockey team was also leaving and getting back on their bus. So in the time we arrived for our reservation and after 90 minutes without being served, they came, ate and left. We were told this was a learning moment for her waitress, however, should be a learning moment for management to staff appropriately or just close the restaurant down to feed 50+ hockey team members. We won't be back!

CB & Potts

3.2

(90 reviews)

Stopped in for lunch. Food was good. We had the sliders and dry rub wings. Burgers were overcooked…read moreand a bit dry. They just lacked some WOW, maybe too little sauce on them? Cheese and onions were add ons, maybe onions need to be standard. Onion straws would really be WOW. Also had dry rub wings, very good. The one star ding was mainly for service. Waitress was inattentive slow to get requested condiments, refills, to go boxes. Waited far too long to settle bill and depart.

I remember CBP from my old college days at Colorado State. This is not the original location, but…read moreit's the only one remaining and it's a good one! It's on the south side of Ft. Collins. It seems to act as a clubhouse of sorts for the Collindale golf course. You can't go wrong with anything you order here. The quality is good. The french fries are perfect! You'll love whatever you order here! I had fish and chips because that was the special on the day I was there. Loved it! Perfect!! My dad and his friends had burgers. High five reviews from both of them. This is a great place to meet someone for lunch or a casual dinner. It's a pretty big place. Looks like they can handle large groups for special occasions. My dad is 93 and there was no easy way to get him up the stairs. I was really surprised that it's not very accessible for those with limited mobility. Maybe there's another entrance for that, if so, it's not near the handicapped parking. Just be aware of that if you are with someone with limited mobility. One star off for that. Otherwise, glad to see "Potts' is still there representing CSU and the Rams!

Charco Broiler

3.4

(202 reviews)