Oh the places you'll go! I'm sitting here on vacation drinking my coffee early morning in my tank top I got for $3 from the Toggery. This place is the best! We came here on a sleepy Saturday afternoon and hit the jackpot because they were having a sidewalk sale with very nice prices. I walked away with Talbots, Athleta, Rock and Republic, Free People on clearance and splurged on a Lululemon sweatshirt for full price (still under $40 so no complaints there). Not only are the prices great but this store will make any organized persons heart sing! Amazing organization and flow of the store, kudos Toggery! I will be making another trip here next time in the Broadripple area. read more

The Toggery Resale Boutique - Thrift Stores Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

I found some designer jeans here for $50 that usually sell for about $200, and they are my favorite go-to jeans, so that's cool. At first, I was a little disappointed in The Toggery because it seemed like the clothes were just a half step up from a regular Goodwill, but then I found the jeans, and now I'm not so sure. I think it all depends on when you shop, and what you're looking for. If you're looking for unusual vintage gems, you probably won't find that here. If you're looking for regional-trendy clothing ... you will probably find that here. I visited on a Saturday afternoon, and the racks seemed a little picked-through, but I think that's because this place is popular and so the racks probably were indeed picked through. They buy clothing during the weekdays, so if you want to find the good stuff, you should probably visit during the week, I'm thinking. The clothing is arranged very nicely, and everything is super organized and clean. They have dressing rooms available that you can just walk into (you don't have to flag down someone!), and they also have sale items that are pretty good. Like most consignment shops, they don't accept returns or exchanges, so make sure you're happy with your items before you purchase! read more

First time popping in here and I found so many great fall items! I've been trying to shop more sustainably and a friend recommended this as one of the best consignment shops in Indianapolis. I can see why! Many higher end brands at affordable prices - I found things from Free People, Anthropologie, Skull Cashmere and others. Getting so many compliments on my purchases and thinking of making this a quarterly stop before each new season. read more

The Toggery Resale Boutique - Thrifted jacket from The Toggery - Thrift Stores Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Friendly staff, quality clothing, sale items, trendy as well as some vintage...dressy to casual...some jewelry and purses too.

I love thrifting and I'm good at it - it's true . I went to The Toggery, I think, a long time ago. On Saturday I was in the Broadripple area on a hike. Since I was in the area I decided to stop by and check it out again after so much much time. I walked in, they were not very busy, and only 3 others shopping. I believe there were 3 people working. I didn't receive a greeting and the way the store is arranged; a greeting is VERY EASY and an obvious way to conduct/promote business. The store was neat, tidy and organized. I looked throughout the store and only found one item that enticed me to pull out and look at. They were a denim Capri type pant - cute but too expensive imo. On a positive note they had some great high end designer shoes in the glass cases I thought were well priced - none my size. Parking is ample. Location is accessible. Pricing overall a bit high considering styles and brands. And imo a greeting or some sort of interaction would go a long way. read more

The Toggery Resale Boutique - Thrift Stores Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

There's just something about extending the useful life of material goods that gives me such a high. I've been meaning to go to The Toggery for awhile and now that I finally have, I am HOOKED. I've had pretty good luck at each visit, particularly with nice clothes for the office. On one occasion I was looking to add some blazers to my closet and ended up with an armful of options, almost too many to choose from. Yes, the prices are certainly higher than they would be at a regular second hand store -- but I'm willing to pay a little more for the convenience of an organized floor and items pre-vetted for their quality, especially considering I'm still saving so much compared to original retail prices. Then again, I try to stay away from simpler pieces - like cute, basic Old Navy shirts that I just can't justify $12 for because that's not the same as spending $12 for a JCrew skirt. Pay attention to the tag colors! Many of them correspond to a percentage off discount. Also definitely sign up for their texts ASAP because you'll get a 10% off coupon. I don't have experience trying to sell here yet, though I plan to. No need for an appointment, new consigners are welcome to drop off during the week. And bear in mind that they only take seasonal items -- winter/fall season runs August to January and spring/summer starts mid-Feb (right now). Your item gets 30 days to sell, and if it does, you get 50% of the sale! They also take jewelry, perfume, and some home goods. I will definitely keep The Toggery a part of my shopping routine. If you're trying to live more sustainably, definitely check this place out! A good transitional step might be to stop here before you go to the mall...to see if you can't check anything off your wishlist. read more

It has been a long time since I shopped at this store but I stopped in the other day. My mom and I were out shopping and stopped here as she was looking for a dress for an event we were going to. The selection of clothes was pretty extensive and they had all of the sizes it appeared. These are all consignment clothes. It appears the longer they have them in the store the lower the price gets. They also had shoes and boots and a few hats and scarves. With it being a consignment shop I imagine the selection changes quite often. We will stop again when we are back in this neighborhood. read more

See all

This is a great spot to find brand-name clothing for a fraction of the price. It's especially great if you need some more business professional clothing (aka clothing you don't wear all the time) and therefore don't want to buy at full price. The store is big and divided by categories. It's entirely women's clothes: skirts, dresses, pants, shorts, shirts, jewelry, shoes, bags, etc. They're also divided by size and the store is very organized. I didn't purchase anything this time around, but brought in brand-name clothes to trade in. When you do this, you need to have tough skin because over half of what you bring in will probably be denied. They have to match what they keep based on store seasonality and what has sold well in the past. They also do not accept any swimsuits. All in all, they kept a few of my items and I now will receive 40% of what it sells for which is pretty cool. They give you an online sign in so you can check and find out when your clothes have been sold, then either get a check in the mail or go to the store to pick up your cash. Very cool and I love that my clothes can be reused by people who love them too. read more

"The search is over..." OMG. I had so many girlfriends constantly raving about this place, but only just made it in for the first time. Hello, dear friend. I had a great time touring their well-curated and organized store. Prices were totally reasonable and I was able to score a few items I had been searching for--with original tags still attached. Gotta love that. I'm planning to make an appointment to sell some stuff here too. I love how they clearly don't accept just any ol' crap. Everything looked clean, new, or near new and this will be my go-to when I'm hunting for a very specific piece, as this is just the kind of place where you'll find that hard to find item. I'd been looking for a black bolero sweater to wear with a certain skirt and found a brand new one from Talbott's in my size. #winning. read more

See all

Nice selection coving extensive sizing with ample sized dressing rooms that are well lit.

Great place to conscious shopping. Love the idea to give a 2 chance to the clothes. Conscious shopping is a valuable way to vote for change and a fantastic place to start when it comes to conscious living. read more

I sell here and I buy here. I love popping in and when my thrifty-fashionista friends are visiting from out of town I love to take them there! Pro-tips: -For selling: Make an appointment (though you don't NEED one its helpful), put your items on hangers, put all of your items in a cart (provided) when you bring them in. They mostly take clothing, shoes and accessories, but also even some personal care items (unopened lotions, perfumes, etc.) and some home-goods (candles, decorative pillows, coasters, wall-art, etc.) -For buying: Get on the email list so you get updates about what is on sale when! -For buying:You can buy a reusable shopping bag to save extra money! My favorite items to peruse at the Toggery are the jewelry selections. I got my wedding earrings here (for $8, and I've since had 3 other brides borrow them because they are STUNNING), and almost never leave the store without something new -- often for less than $10! Bonus: Once you're on the mailing list or following them on Facebook keep your eyes open for wine and cheese nights at the store to sip, snack and shop! ;) read more

Let me admit -- I remember hearing about The Toggery waaaaaaaay back when and I had always thought it was a place for little old ladies to shop. Man, was I wrong. Recently I had a friend text me while shopping there to let me know that she had hit the jackpot on one of my favorite brands of exercise clothing. Mental note -- go check this place out. While passing The Toggery this weekend, we stopped in. Unbeknownst to me, the hubs asked the lovely little lady working if they had any of my fav brand in stock. As I caught up to him, Tiffany was arriving with an arm full of workout clothing goodness! Talk about the amazingness of having a personal shopper! WOOT! I was able to find some good stuff in good shape for about 1/3 of the retail price. Score. An added bonus is that the store is well organized -- by item and size. You still get the thrill of the hunt without having to dig as much. I would be remiss if I did not encourage you to check out the 75% and 50% off racks immediately inside the door. Scored some cute designer jackets and sweaters for like 7 bucks. Later we learned that Tiffany is the manager there and she absolutely went above and beyond for us -- despite the store being busy on a Saturday afternoon. I just wish she would have let me buy the cute hat right off her head. We will be back. Well, maybe I will leave the hubs at home next time. read more

The Toggery Resale Boutique - Signage - Thrift Stores Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

The Toggery has slowly become a staple in my thrift shopping. Although it is a little pricier (most things are around $12-$15) compared to other second-hand stores, I personally am okay with paying a somewhat higher price for well organized, name brand, high-quality clothing. I know that every time I walk into The Toggery, I will find a new piece that will become a staple in my closet. I have bought many different items here and their selection has not lacked in variety of what they offer. If you are looking for a good deal on a high-quality piece, this is the place for you. read more

I really like Toggery because the staff here is so friendly and helpful and have made consigning so easy. It's super easy since you just have to bring in your items (cleaned and sell-ready of course) and they'll go through your items and let you know what they'll take, why they didn't take certain items, and give suggestions on items they'd love to buy from you. I also love that they have a portal so that you can check in on your items and how much they sold for so you can keep track of how much you've sold. Also, I love that I can cash out with them easily! On the buying end, I love that their selection is trendy and current and I also end up finding stuff when I'm really coming in to just sell things. Help our your local businesses instead of going to Platos! read more

The Toggery is a great place to consign clothing, jewelry, handbags, and home goods! The process is straight forward and focuses on seasonal products. They have an online portal where you can monitor how your items are doing. Consigning hours are different than shopping hours so I usually end up taking a day off work and dropping items off as part of my to do list. Inventory is constantly changing and they have an online presence too! read more

Took a TON of clothes here and designer purses. They accepted only one item and claimed that nothing else qualified. I am absolutely shocked and disappointed. They accepted one item that I threw in the stack on a humble. While they are a great place to shop I doubt I'll ever consign with them again. I would have been better off donating everything to goodwill and getting the tax write off. I also should have waited so I could have received an explanation why they didn't take clothes purchased in 2020 that still had tags on them. read more

I've only bought from here once, but I will definitely be back!!! We browsed through the sale rack first which had some amazing finds for cheap! with this place you get nice quality clothes for a great price! Wish I would have known about it sooner. Its kinda tucked away, so I'm sure I've seen it when driving on Broad Ripple Ave, but obviously haven't noticed it enough to check it out. A friend told me about this place, that's the only reason I know of its existence !!! I will definitely be coming back, as well as spreading the word!!! read more

If you do not know Laura Walters at Style Riot you are missing out on an amazing person! She was at her usual Monday spot, The Toggery. Laura helped me style ELEVEN amazing Spring pieces for under $150! Seriously, check her out! I love the Toggery for their stylish pieces and great prices. read more

The Toggery Resale Boutique - Thrift Stores Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

This was one of the first consignment/thrift stores I found after I moved to Indianapolis 8 years ago, and I have always been able to find something worthwhile here. When I first moved here they had their selling/trading section set up a bit differently, and I just found out recently that has changed (not that it's a bad thing!) Overall, the store is a quite decent size, has loads of secondhand items to choose from, and is clean and organized. They have very nice, lightly used items from solid brands as well as a wide range of other items in all different sizes and styles. When you go to sell/consign with them, they will take whatever they are not able to sell in stores and donate it to The Julian Center (https://www.juliancenter.org/), a local support organization for survivors of domestic violence, sexual violence, and other life crises. Their staff is incredibly helpful and friendly, and parking is a none-issue as they have their own parking lot. Finding the store itself might be a bit of an issue as it is tucked away down what looks like it could be a small alley between shops. Located in the Broad Ripple area off of 62nd Street, the entrance is west of Keystone Avenue and east of Norwaldo Avenue. As a life-time thrifter, I highly recommend this one for a thrift store outing! read more

For years I have been bringing my clothes that no longer fit, are no longer my style, or in general are just taking up space in my closet to the Toggery. They go through my pile of misfit outfits and sell some of them. Once a month they give me a check. I spend check on more outfits from my favorite shopping grounds.... that will likely end up at the Toggery after a while. It's a vicious cycle. Every now and again I buy something at the Toggery with a debit card or with a credit from selling my misfits. A few purchases have become wardrobe staples. Tweed Elie Tahari sheath dress for work? Tags still on it and only cost me $14? STAPLE. JCrew A-line long sleeve wool dress with front pockets? Oh, so 1960's chic for about $26? STAPLE. This place is really top notch. Great staff too. TIP: Try it also for Halloween costumes! TIP: Shop or drop off items on Friday's for free snacks and wine. read more

I've been to The Toggery a few times within the past year and a half, and I always have a great experience. It is a consignment shop, but I feel like it has great quality items to sell, most of which are known brands and still in style. They carry all sorts of clothing, including purses, shoes, jewelry, and some household items! During my last trip to The Toggery, I bought a pair of black ripped jeans from American Eagle, a pair of Madewell blue jeans, and a GAP turtleneck, all of which were in good condition. Best of all, I only spent $42! I have been going to The Toggery about 4 times a year to ensure the inventory turns between trips, but there would be different inventory if you went more frequently! The Toggery has been a great place for me to go to add some more things to my wardrobe without spending a lot! read more

Well organized, fair prices and great quality. I ALWAYS find something here but the trick is to go often, things fly off the rack here. Great designer selection in shoes, handbags & clothing. Other consignment stores could take a page from the Toggerys playbook, fer sure. read more

The Toggery Resale Boutique - Thrift Stores Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

I am the type of person that doesn't like to pay full price for clothes, especially because I am a college student. I found The Toggery by mistake one night after dinner. Ever since then I have been there more times than I can count. As a consignment boutique, it has very lightly worn clothes for an extremely reasonable price. I always get compliments on the items of clothing I have purchased from here, and I never fail to get excited to tell the person where I got it and how it was "only $15". To make this place even better, I go and consign my own clothes here. I have made almost $500 from simply selling my clothes, and whatever the staff does not take they donate to a local charity. It has an easy to access online platform that lets you follow your clothing items and see what has sold and what has not. You can then either use your account balance as store credit for purchases, or they will write you a check! From Free People, Kendra Scott, David Yurman to Gucci, the Toggery really has it all and I fully recommend it for when you are looking to improve your wardrobe. read more

This place is frugalistas heaven! If you're patient and know the brands you are looking for, you're bound to get a deal at The Toggery! I've been so pleased with the range of Tory Burch and Lily Pulitzer that I've managed to scoop up at the Toggery over time! One thing to note- persistence is key here. Sometimes its a hit and sometimes it's a miss when you come in, but check in often as their inventory is constantly rotating and new gems are brought in daily! In comparison to other consignment shops in the city, this by far has some of the nicer high in brands, however, tends to lean towards the pricer side. read more

The Toggery is a great place to go snag a cute find. I have found multiple items here that are decently priced -Hunter rain boots -IMS Fleece -Le cruset kitchenware -little black dress -Vera Bradley My mom and I have a fun time when we go here. They usually have sales from day-to-day and it's fun to kinda search for them. Local business, cosignment (I've never done it), and great clothing! read more

Such a cute store. Had a great time in here looking around. Prices were very good. Staff very friendly. Wish I lived here so I could go all the time. read more

Whoever they have picking these clothes isn't the brightest. I brought all of my boutique, free people, and lulu lemon clothes and they couldn't buy a single thing from me. Meanwhile I was shopping and three of the shirts I found have holes in them. But you can't accept any of the 30 clothes I just trying to sell to you that have been barely worn. Ok. Laughable. read more

Love this place. Great quality stuff and a great selection. I found so many gems including wheat Timberland boots that were gently used for only $28 (Timbs are $160 brand new). They also have really great styled outfits on their mannequins to give you an idea of how to style basic or unique pieces. read more

This place has gone down in quality big time. Used to be my go-to for quality consignment, but as they've gained popularity they have become more concerned with quantity rather than quality. Not sure how someone can think $32 for a dress with a rip like this..and let's not forget it's consigned so it's used...is appropriate. Not much to find in there anymore. read more

The Toggery Resale Boutique - Thrift Stores Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I find awesome deals on designer and mall brand clothing, accessories, and shoes every time I shop here! They always have several clearance items. I usually only shop clearance and always find lots of items. On my last trip I came home with 1 sweater, 3 shirts, 1 dress, 1 bra, and 1 make up bag all for $20.33 with tax! I love The Toggery! read more

The Toggery Resale Boutique - 1 sweater, 3 (1 new with tags) shirts, 1 dress, 1 new with tags VS bra, and 1 Yves Saint Laurent bag $20.33! I love The Toggery! - Thrift Stores Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I love bringing my clothes to sell at The Toggery. You can make an appointment, or you don't have to, and while you wait, you get to browse around and see what they have. It has always been easy to sell here - doesn't take more than five minutes and you're out the door. You can call whenever you want to check your balance, and you can either get a check or use it as store credit. Win win! I have actually never purchased anything, but they do a good job of only selecting clothes that are current styles and are in good condition. You can really get a good deal here - I've seen multiple dresses from Banana Republic, Loft, Ann Taylor, etc. for less than $20. That's a steal! I would definitely recommend this place if you're looking for a consignment store to sell your clothes to. I've had nothing but great experiences. read more

Need a set of coasters with birds on them? Yes. Yes you do. Need some shoes? Need brand name (J Crew, Banana Republic, Gap, Arden B) hand me downs.... Oh, how about a horse lamp? I know I want a horse lamp. Or a solid steel dish? I'll fight ya for it! Solid customer service at this joint... we roll up at closing time and she let's us in with our story, "we just wanna shop." True Story. We just wanted to browse, try things on, consider candle holders, etc. Of course the man wear is minimal... no problem. If I were a gal... I'd be all over places like this... it's just an endless sea of dead people's clothes for cheap. I'll just hang out in the corner and read these James Patterson novels, while the ladyfriend shops. Oph! Wait! These clothes are fun (like houndstooth pants with moose on them). I'm all for consignment. I'm not sure how they make money, and do they really follow up with everyone with their "we'll pay you when it sells plan?" Why wouldn't they just buy it from the person then sell it -- like other pawn shops. Either way... I love they do the consignment route because it ups their inventory like mad! read more

Awesome finds here! Make sure to take advantage of the tag-color sales. I've gotten designer jeans for $15 here. Nice people, great rotating selection. read more

I am quite thrifty. I brought clothes in to sell. I felt weird for being there because I guess I had to have an appointment. They only took two items, which was kind of disappointing. I looked around at items in the store and found that it was pretty pricey for used clothing. I think I could find the same quality for cheaper at Goodwill. read more

I love this store! I moved to Indy a month ago and enjoy exploring unique places that tend to be on the down-low, which is how I came to find this place. If you are looking for a women's high fashion consignment store, you've hit the jack pot! The majority of their clothes look unworn and are in great shape. The prices are not as cheap as Goodwill of course, but I thought it was worth it for what I went home with. I purchased a black genuine leather Guess jacket that cost $32, a White House Black Market jacket/light coat (resembles a Chanel pattern) for about $35, a J Crew cardigan for $16, and a silky white tank for $8. The reason I gave this business 4/5 stars was for their customer service. There were quite a few people working when I came in and shopped for 2 hours, yet not one person approached me. It would have been great to know more about their business and for them to let me know where to find specific items, clearance, and any other helpful information. Also, there are not any baskets or shopping carts and so in my opinion (coming from a fellow retail employee), they should have asked to free my arms when they saw me struggling with about 30 items. It does take quite a while to search through all of their items and so a bit of assistance goes a very long way. read more

I went to the Toggery for the first time on Friday! I was kinda overwhelmed walking in and I'm not someone who likes to dig through racks to find something. It was super crowded with clothes but I had to look through several things to find something I would even consider wearing. The quality of the clothing was very varied, some high-end designer and some things that looked very cheap. I did find a great pair of Banana Republic dress pants for $18 and a pair of DKNY fun pants for $14. I was proud of my steals and have already worn both pairs of pants. I will definitely be back! read more

The Toggery Resale Boutique - The toggery - Thrift Stores Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

I'm impressed that I've lived in the area for so long without checking out this place. I stopped in yesterday after my visiting sisters requested to go thrifting and was pleasantly surprised with the selection. Awesome brands, like J. Crew, Ann Taylor, Talbots, etc. for a fraction of the price. Everything appeared to be in good condition with a pretty wide selection. This definitely is a great, once-a-season stop to stock up on brand name goodies without the high price tags. The store design and set-up is pretty bare bones, as are most consignment stores and the plus size selection is basically non-existent, but I'm happy to know this place exists and will be making return visits. read more

Out of all the consignment stores I've been to, the Toggery is my favorite. I brought an armful of practially unused clothes, few purses, wallets, and they were sold in less than a month. More money in my pocket to buy things I won't wear...doh.. And of course, I never leave without buying something, like the Burberry cardigan I purchased for under $20. If I didn't have Dillon trying to herd me out the door, I could probably spend a few hours looking through all the clothes and shoes. Oh, that brings up another thing that's so great about this place; the smell. Is it me, or does this place NOT smell like a consignment store? With all the hundreds of clothes and shoes from multiple people you'd think it would have that Goodwill-ish, musty smell. Or maybe my eyes are overloading all of my other senses that I don't smell anything. I will definitely be making another trip; I found 3 space saver bags of clothes I brought from California. You'd think I would be all unpacked by now. read more

I need to lead in by saying, I think I got my expectations up too high before going here. I knew I wanted to visit after seeing the Yelp reviews and then I liked them on Facebook. Their Facebook site makes it seem like they only carry high end items but that is not the case. Don't get me wrong, they have a great selection and everything is in good condition, but for the most part it is your run of the mill consignment brands, J. Crew, Gap etc. There were a few pairs of high end jeans, a small rack with the really high end designer items (10 or so items), and the items behind the glass case but that was about it. Prices are right and there is a pretty good selection, especially the dresses- I really found a lot of cute dresses that I liked. I was just expecting a lot more high end stuff based on what they post on their FB page. It's certainly a notch above Plato's Closet though so I would recommend if you are in the area! read more