Kathy has always provided wonderful food at her places. I will separate my review between food and…read moresweets. I don't fully understand the merger between Kathy and Spoonful of Sugar - but I'm glad it happened. Maybe Kathy does the hot food and the original person still does the bakery - I'm not sure. Before Kathy took over, I do recall Spoonful of Sugar being closed during court day and I had messaged them to ask when they would be open. Courtday is only the biggest tourist attraction in our area and as a local business you would think they would want to be open during the heaviest foot traffic of the entire year, but they responded they wanted to attend court day so they were going to be closed. I thought that was very strange. I hope with the new structure - they will be open during court days going forward. Food - I love Kathy's salads, breakfast, grouper fingers, and so much more. Literally everything I have had has been wonderful. She makes amazing homemade ranch dressing and beer cheese as well and you must try them both. I highly recommend this place for lunch or dinner. The steak salad is amazing and I ask them to keep the fat on, cause that's the way I like it. The coleslaw is so creamy and delicious, I have purchased a large container to take home for dinner sides back when she was still at the country club. There are some breakfast sandwiches that you have to try! And I am not a big breakfast lover, but the croissants here are to die for. So buttery and soft - and then pile it high with ham, egg, and cheese - oh lord! Sweets - Before Kathy took over Spoonful of Sugar, I was never a fan of any of the sweets here. Sadly, I have to say that is still the case. I have tried nearly everything in the store, but have yet to find a sweet treat that I love here. Let me go into more detail: The mini pies - I attempted to purchase a mini butterscotch pie and when I got it home, it was a chocolate pie even though it was labeled as butterscotch. I tried it and wasn't crazy about it but I still wanted to try the butterscotch pie so I tried again. I was quite disappointed in the crust, it was very tough and you could not get a fork through it. The pie filling was just ok and the topping was just ok. Not something I would buy again. Cookies - I have tried several of the cookies on many occasions but each time the cookies are very crunchy. I know some people like crunchy cookies, but I am a soft and chewy kind of cookie girl. When I say soft - I mean SOFT like nearly falling apart and gooey. If you can hold it upright and it doesn't start to lean a little, then it simply isn't soft enough for my liking. I gave up trying to get a soft cookie after a few purchases and realized these cookies were just not my style. Chess bars - I love a good chess bar - but each time I tried these they seemed to be overcooked and slightly burned. Cupcakes.- ok, cupcakes are my absolute favorite thing. There used to be a wonderful place in town to get cupcakes called Swirlz and I was a regular there. When they went out of business I was hoping there would be some sort of collaboration because those were the most delicious cupcakes I've ever had in my life. I want to see creative flavors - chocolate peanut butter and butterfinger were my favorites. I'm not crazy about the cupcakes here, both the cake portion or the icing. I guess I keep comparing it to Swirlz and it doesn't compare in my opinion so I guess I'm disappointed in anything that doesn't come close to those. As you can see - I've tried the sweets on many occasions - but after so much disappointment for me I had to stop trying the sweets. I think a lot of people in town love them - but none of them seem to be my personal style that I like so unfortunately I can't find anything in the sweets area here for me.

Friendly service. Good variety. The churro dulce de leche was fantastic! We also ordered the oreo…read morecookies and cream, chocolate chocolate chip, and vanilla confetti. I definitely recommend this bakery.

Red velvet, baby! A student brought these in as a treat for a competitive team and they were a…read morehuge hit. They traveled well and were still super moist and delicious hours later. Great flavor variety on offer. A little pricey but what isn't these days?!?! Looking forward to making a visit to the store to see what else is on offer!

The shop was clean and the cupcakes were pretty. We ordered 5 and unfortunately only enjoyed one…read more The banana pudding cupcake had a great flavor. The turtle cheesecake was ridiculously heavy and completely unbalanced. One bite made us sick to our stomachs. The red velvet was edible but almost flavorless. The midnight magic had an odd taste to it. The cookies and cream was ok. Happy to check this place off of our list but overall they did not have a product that we really enjoyed and the pricing was high.

Been here twice. The cupcakes are wowsers!!!!…read more I have a massive sweet tooth and have tried lots of cupcakes from different cities, different states and they can be so hit and miss. Some bakeries have a few good flavors, some bakeries have cupcakes that are too dry. Every single thing we've tried from this bakery is just outstanding! From the black forest cheesecake ones to the red velvet, strawberry or peanut butter every single one was moist and flavorful. The other outstanding thing we've had is their stuffed cookies. They are literally to die for. A soft, chewy chocolate chip cookie with sweet buttercream filling dotted with chocolate chips on the sides. Or a sugar cookie with just sweet buttercream filling.

Got take out with my friend. We each got the lasagna bowl special they had that day, since my…read morefriend recommended it. I ordered 2 desserts, cheesecake and a danish. After paying and waiting at a table, a worker told me sorry they're out of cheesecake, gave me cash back, and let me get pick a dessert for free! I got a cinnamon roll (which was the same price as the cheesecake and was very big) Everything tasted good and this was a nice gesture. It was a happening little local place.

Delicious food, clean eat-in area, big cookies, service with a smile and easy parking...read more

Solid bakery on the corner of Catfish Alley and Main Street. They make cakes but what is in the…read morecase is predominantly cupcakes, and cookies. The cupcakes were presented well. Had a good frosting ratio and had fun flavors like pistachio and oatmeal cream cookie. They seem to have weekly rotating flavors maybe even daily. We got the oatmeal cream cookie and it was crazy yummy I was very impressed with the cookies. They were a good size. The price point was nice. You don't get gouged for a cookie here. I bought the Nutella, which seems to be a chocolate hazelnut cookie with Nutella filled in the middle. Wow wow it was delicious. I also got pistachio cookies and those were amazing. That's so good that I went back and bought six to bring home. The guy that help me select cookies was very helpful in describing which flavors he thought I would like, and he was spot on. Thank you whom ever you were. Very helpful! As far as ambience has a spooky theme, which is fun. I liked the bakery. I would definitely come back. I would definitely recommend it.

These guys were stars! I ordered these the day before we went for a client. I had the chance to…read moretry the pineapple upside down and the cheesecake. I was devastated to mot get to try the strawberry or pistachio but when we went back they were almost sold out (rightfully so!). Definitely check out their website it is so fun!

**Update: I received a very heartfelt message from the owner explaining their tough situation due…read moreto Covid, and asking that I please give them a chance to make this right..... in the end, all we want is to be heard and appreciated if we are choosing to spend our money and support a business- and after this message I felt both of those things. So, they may not have the rum cake I ordered, and they may be having some issues with their technology... but it seems like they have really delicious baked goods (according to other reviews), and they are working to solve the other problem. So, I'll give them the benefit of the doubt.** I wish I had pictures to prove this..... but here is my experience. I placed an order for their rum cake ($45 for a Bundt cake). I did this through their website and it said it would be available to pick up at 11:50 a.m. I paid using their Squarespace website. I got a confirmation email, and was so excited because this is what my hubby wanted for his bday. I was just about to leave to pick it up at 1:15pm, when I got a call from the bakery saying "we don't know what your ordered, but you need to cancel the payment because we don't use our website. We only take orders over the phone or in person." What???? If you don't use it, why is it active? Turn it the eff off. It's very simple to do- I know bc I have used several Squarespace websites. This should be the end of my rant- but wait! It gets so much better! I proceeded to give them my order over the phone.... They told it would be ready in 30 minutes. I should have asked myself how they would bake a cake in 30 minutes- but, I'm a glutton for punishment.... And instead drove 30 minutes from my house to go get the desired rum cake. When I got there to pick it up- it was a 9" two layer cake with frosting. That is not a rum cake, nor is it what is pictured on their website! When I said, that isn't what I ordered- the response was "well, this is our rum cake". I left without the cake. And, now I have to contact my credit card company to dispute a charge that they claim they won't receive. Also- in case you're looking for quality, freshly made cakes..... they have 5 gallon buckets in their cooler at the front with long stem roses in them..... the buckets have labels on them that say "Sam's vanilla whipped icing". What a joke!

Ok here's my updated review after we ate it. It was DELICIOUS! So moist and not too sweet. I truly…read moreloved the cake but I am still upset at the quality of my "custom" experience and lack there of on my cake. I was charged too much (more than regular off the shelf cake) and was given a less than customized product. I didn't appreciate her saying that the cake I chose from the Yelp picture was what they "used to do" but the picture was from 3 months ago. I have made future customers from everyone I had try it but I hope they don't receive a bad experience because I truly believe in this company and their product.

The company I work for brought in cookies for appreciation week. When I saw it on the calendar, I…read morechecked out the review. The reviews were not good. My coworkers and I decided to give it the benefit of the doubt and at least try it. I mean it's a free cookie. "Tastes like cardboard", "tums taste better", and as a home baker myself...it was the worst short bread cookie I have ever eaten. it was dry, chalky, and tasteless. How this bakery is still in business I do not know. I do know I would never recommend them to anyone I know.

Ordered Dutch apple pie. Ingredients seemed low quality and not fully cooked inside. Top was…read morehard. Staff was nice.

Apparently, they have gone out of business and are not returning their calls as of February 10 or…read more12th I wanted to order cupcakes for a party and no one would call me back

This place is basically an adults only candy shop…read more I was a little skeptical at first, because it's REALLY hard to cook with alcohol and not let it absolutely over power the food, but these would be good cupcakes even without booze, but add that in and it's magic. The cocktail flavors are spot on, you the cupcake texture is great and the frosting is delicious. The hardest part of the whole experience was picking which to try (but luckily, the owner gave us some samples to help narrow it down!). We ended up getting two jumbo cupcakes and a "standard snack pack" which comes with two standards and 4 gummies. The chocolate spiced rum cake is rich and delicious and the jumbo is a huge cupcake. I had to eat half and come back for the rest a bit later heh. The Pumpkin (seasonal flavor) tasted just like a delicious pumpkin pie. I already know where I'm picking up cupcakes from for our next grown ups birthday party. And they take orders online! And can do gluten free if you order ahead!