Was very pleasantly surprised with the food at Ticklers! Sometimes hotel restaurants miss the mark, but I thought Ticklers was great, if a little pricy. Must try: tuna tartare and the crab dip. Both were excellent! I got the peel and eat shrimp and it was definitely a lot of food. I wish they had fish or shrimp sandwich options instead of just fried oysters or crab. I know we're in Maryland but still! The handcut fries were reeeeally good!! The wait staff was super friendly even though they were slammed. read more

See all

While staying at the Wylder Hotel, I booked two reservations for dinner both nights of my stay and Tickler's Crab Shack didn't disappoint! The drinks were delicious! The food was fresh and flavorful. The view was incredible! I can't wait to come back and try more of their menu! read more

See all

Ticklers Crab Shack was a fun and delicious experience. We began the evening sitting at the bar enjoying craft cocktails, the bartender, Lenny, was so talented, the cocktails were on par (better really) with what I have had in New York City, AND we had the comfort of a cool, off the water breeze, and a million dollar view. For the record, I did the honor of trying a couple different cocktails, but the "summer of 69" was my favorite. My husband ordered a variety of oysters from their amazing raw bar, attention to detail was impressive. All of the wait staff and bar staff were attentive. The atmosphere created by the management and staff was not only pleasant and informative, but very professional, yet relaxed. We were lucky enough to meet the Chef and thank her for the great dishes. My husband had the Angus Steak Frites Dinner and was absolutely impressed with not only the cut of meat but also with the combinations of flavors and sauces. I had the fried crab balls, a recommendation from the manager, which were amazing, the crab cake dinner which was so fresh and tasty with Old Bay mustard aioli. I found out they change some parts of the menu seasonally, and we can't wait to see what the manager and staff come up with for our next visit. read more

First experience was amazing...second experience was less than desirable. Food was just okay today - steamed mussels were dry and slightly overcooked, the burger was standard fare but the crab soup was great. Our server was unable to wrap the sticky table in paper because they were apparently running low, and it was only available if you are eating crabs. We were disappointed that several menu items were sold out due to an event the prior day meaning no bucket of corn, which was one of the major reasons for our trip down to Ticklers today and sadly, the $4 brewed tea it is no longer unlimited (only 1 refill per person) which is absurd when it is warm outside, you receive your drink before the order is taken, and you have already placed an order for several appetizers. The events staff member we met prior to our reservation was friendly and welcoming. The view is still amazing! read more

Tickler's Crab Shack - Crab soup - Seafood Near Me - Tilghman Island, Maryland

See all

We had a great dinner. The view was amazing! It was chilly outside so our server accommodated us with a heater. We started off with their crab soup which was delicious! My husband had the crab cakes and I had the rockfish. Everything was on point. I highly recommend this establishment. read more

See all

The place is loud and the scenery beautiful. The staff was friendly. The menu was okay and very pricey considering the level of finesse. Our server mispronounced a few items, and all our dinners were made incorrectly and brought-out at different times. But once the food was corrected, it was delicious. read more

Great crabs, great view of the bay. Amazing sunset. Recommend There was also entertainment. Made for a very nice evening read more

It's lovely to enjoy a new experience that exceeds one's expectations. Tickler's Crab Shack did that and more. Tickler's Crab Shack has competitors, but I believe it has a crab leg up on the competition with its waterfront views and surrounding field of dreams-like atmosphere. If the gorgeous atmosphere doesn't captivate you, the beautiful services and delicious seafood most certainly will. Our waitress was remarkable, and she made sure we were accommodated and taken care of throughout our dining experience. I could not have been more pleased with the food, staff, and views. Now, let me recommend trying the steamed crabs and their fresh oysters. I also recommend that you dine outside on the patio. A word of caution: given the nature of being outdoors and on the waterfront, you will encounter some flys, but please don't let that deter you from enjoying your seafood in the ambiance of a scenic waterfront oasis; you'll thank me later. read more

See all

So much fun and the food and waitstaff are fantastic. Be prepared for market pricing on crabs and other seafood, but the experience and setting will well worth the pricey tab. Ellie was our waitress and helped us break into the crab. She was fantastic. Highly recommend. read more

See all

Oh wow you must have the lobster bisque and crab cakes. Best I ever had. Margaritas where also excellent

This is a fun place to sit and have some appetizers and drinks. We came for dinner and found the entrees rather lacking for the price range. We enjoyed the fire-it's and the live music. On that note I highly recommend staying at the hotel. We had a great time. read more

See all

Looked online and saw beautiful indoor seating but I believe it's only for large events. I didn't know that and was surprised to see that our party was seated outside. Make sure to bring a jacket to cover up because it gets COLD. I would've much rather been seated inside. I got the pulled pork sandwich with fries which was great. I don't have complaints about the taste but for the price it was tiny LOL. Obviously a place you just sit and drink w friends with a view of boats if that's your thing. The service was slow and our waitress barely came to check on us. Wouldn't go out of my way to go here but it seems to be one of the better places in Tilghman w drinks & music read more

Tickler's Crab Shack - Pulled pork sandwich - Seafood Near Me - Tilghman Island, Maryland

Came here with my girlfriend and was totally underwhelmed. The place was dead, the drinks were just okay and the food was not good. Super salty, but lacking in flavor otherwise. I've made better crab cakes myself. The prices are higher than even the touristy seafood places in Annapolis! My word of advice to the owner would be to stop being defensive in his reviews and actually work to fix whatever is wrong. The space is beautiful but without good food it's a moot point read more

Excellent food, view, and service. This is also a great outdoor location for eating since it is protected from the weather by an actual roof. The drinks were good as well. The crab soup was my favorite part of the meal. They need to get a working website: I went to the hotel front desk on a Tuesday to get their menu and find out their hours since the website did not provide any of this information. read more

See all

4.5 5. Atmosphere and venue! On the water, a cute pavilion with scattered seats around the hotel with fire pits and heat lamps. Live music! If only it had been a little warmer we would have eaten outside. But we came in time for happy hour drinks before, dinner inside, then drinks outside again listening to music. Service was also great! A little slow, but friendly to this interracial Asian/Caucasian couple. 4 - food. We had raw oysters, clams in white wine sauce (a little salty), delicious crab soup and fried oyster sliders with sweet potato fries. Very good! read more

See all

Really adorable dockside dining with great service and live music! The crab dip was phenomenal! We especially loved how dog friendly they are with a dedicated doggy menu. read more

See all

This place is inside of the hotel and it is on the water and lovely. The food is really good. I was honestly pretty surprised how good the food is here. The shrimp is good, highly recommend. The fried burrata salad is so, so, so good. Highly recommend. Everything was really good. I ate here twice in three days. Skip the tacos and the lobster roll. read more

Incredible view with great service and a laid back vibe. The menu is full of fresh seafood off the dock, combined with a great beer and cocktail list. We ordered half a dozen crabs but they threw in some extras which was greatly appreciated. Make a reservation so you can get a table right on the water. We'll definitely be going back! read more

See all

We were able to enjoy a nice dinner while fishing at Tilghman's Island this weekend. We shared the crab cake sandwich (on the smaller side but very good, lemony) and some of the smoked wings (very good, love the sauce that it comes with!) For dessert, we had the peach cobbler with caramel sauce - which was good but def sweet enough without the caramel. Only cons was that they didn't give any utensils but luckily we had some in the car. They are practicing social distancing and checking in outside for curbside pickup so that no one has to go in. read more

Tickler's Crab Shack - Seafood Near Me - Tilghman Island, Maryland

See all

My husband and I were staying at the Wylder Hotel. We went here purely out of convenience, but we were happily surprised! He got the brisket and I got fried chicken. They were both VERY good! The brisket was so tender he could barely keep it on his fork and the chicken was crunchy with great flavor and cooked to a juicy perfection. We both got drinks as well and they were strong (in a good way) would recommend! read more

Tickler's Crab Shack - Seafood Near Me - Tilghman Island, Maryland

Came for a later lunch with family at the end of June. I know that much of the country is experiencing a staff shortage but this place isn't. There were at least 8 people behind the bar/raw bar at one point. It took over an hour for us to get our food, which was very good but everyone was so hungry at that point that who really knows? Our server was great, and she was working hard, I think it's the management (or lack of) that isn't using their best resource (people!) well. Smaller parties did get served before us (we were a group of 9), larger parties seemed to be in the same boat. I have a lot of patience this summer for the many places that don't have enough staff but they visibly had enough. Even if the kitchen was understaffed, our drinks should have at least been filled regularly but that didn't happen either. It's expensive and a beautiful view. read more

Always enjoy Tickler's Crab Shack. Cold Eastern Shore Brewery Blonde Ale, flavorfully burger and sweet potato fries, and a crisp Cesar salad. Wonderful view of the water. We'll be back! read more

AWFUL SERVICE. If I could give 0 stars I would. It was my fiancé's birthday and we drove for two hours to go to ticklers crab shack. I made a reservation through open table and we got there on time at 7:30pm. We were seated by the hostess. And then received NO service for 30 minutes. The waitresses and waiters refused to make eye contact and when we tried to catch their attention they blatantly ignored us. Other tables who arrived after us were served before us. When the hostess walked by we were finally asked if we were served and had to tell her no one ever came up to us. We watched as she talked to a waitress and the waitress proceeded to come back into the indoor restaurant and make a point to ignore us. At that time we decided to up and leave. I am Asian and my fiancé is Caucasian he had to point out to me that he believes they refused to serve us because they didn't want to serve the Asian person. I'm so saddened and disappointed by that experience especially after then later that night receiving a message from open table that ticklers claimed we didn't show up to our reservations. I never expected a restaurant like ticklers to be so obviously racist and discriminatory. read more

Excellent service. Very friendly staff. Nice setting and clean. Food is less than desirable which dose not match the prices charged. Not a good value. Drinks is okay. Prices if the drinks do not reflect the quality of the drink. If improve quality of food and drink, would be a gem. read more

I just had a crab meat po boy sandwich and it was fantastic. Great flavor, lots of crabmeat, crusty bread, ripe tomatoes. Retry much sandwich perfection. And the view is amazing. Good service, too. read more

Tickler's Crab Shack - Seafood Near Me - Tilghman Island, Maryland

See all

We got takeout from this place tonight. Our order was ready in 20 minutes, and the food was exemplary. The cream of crab soup is probably the best I've ever tasted. Portions are generous, sides are carefully prepared, and entrees are fresh and delicious. Easily the best place we've eaten in the area! I picked up my order in the warm, clubby bar area; looks like a comfortable place to hang out. read more

We just stopped in for a couple of drinks and to check out the resort so we could come back to stay another time! What a neat family resort at the end of Tilghman Island! Very family friendly! Staff was so much fun and so attentive to everyone! We can't wait to come back to stay! Crabs & food we saw coming out looked very good! read more

See all

Fun, casual environment, great cocktails, fantastic fresh oysters, delicious cheese board. Enjoy read more

Tickler's Crab Shack - Seafood Near Me - Tilghman Island, Maryland

See all

I was really excited to go here and really disappointed. It was empty, the service was really underwhelming (it was clear they had not been trained adequately), and the food was way too salty and not anything exceptional. Such a cool location, I wish they were trying harder. read more

Crabs were clean and fat! Loved the jumbo lump crab cake platter! Great mashed potatoes and sautéed spinach/ Swiss chard.

Wow I do miss Buddy Harrison We had two "dinners" both totally weak. The best thing was the Oysters...how can you screw up oysters Well all i can say if you want a "top" shelf meal do not come here. Pure waste of time!! Please ...do not call something dinner that is really small plate read more

Both food and service were poor and food prices varied depending on various menus presented. Both soups and hamburgers were extremely salty, almost uneatable. First menu presented showed a price of $22 for a half dozen steamed crabs which seemed reasonable. However when the bill arrived it showed a cost of $55 which was way over priced for small crabs. When questioned, we were first told the crabs were charged at market price and then the manager showed us a menu we had never seen that showed the crabs at $55 for a half dozen and $100 for a dozen. Bot totals are well above the norm for the Chesapeake Bay Area. The waiter never offered us water when we arrived and he failed to initially submit our order for dessert. Bottom line this is a restaurant we would never recommend to family or read more

Well. The place is amazing. Venue is superb. And then. Lights are too bright Alcohol selection is too slight read more

Lovely setting and view. Good service. Good food, but the prices are over the top. Had three children with us....a child's burger was $16. Child's pasta and nuggets were only slightly lower. We had a party of 9 (including the 3 children) and they did tell us in advance there would be a gratuity added of 22%. This is way above the norm and it was added on an after tax basis. So, the problem isn't the food or the service but a lack of value given the other venues in the area for good seafood with good views. Was once a regular customer but will in future go elsewhere. read more

Wonderful crab cake sandwich with fresh hot French fries and a panoramic view of the Chesapeake Bay is what we found this Sunday afternoon. We chose the breezy covered outdoor deck. The crab cakes looked so good we each had our own. Rebecca, the hardworking server was polite and attentive. We'll be back for lunch again soon. read more

If there was one word to best describe this restaurant it would be underwhelming. Servers were not very attentive, the kitchen was slow and the food was average. We had a large party but we had made a reservation so they knew what to expect. Took about 15 minutes to get a drink and after the food was ordered it was another 30 minutes with no drink refills. When the food came, all sides were cold. Sad to say that at a restaurant that charges premium prices( which I am more than willing to pay) the best item we had was the bucket of corn on the cob. We were warned when we made the reservation that we would be charged a 22%, no problem. But I feel like I was totally fleeced based on the quality of food/ service and experience. Feels like the kitchen was understaffed, again, which is fine but you need to not seat a full house or you are setting the wait staff and kitchen up for failure. We witnessed a table of two older adults get up and leave because no wait staff had attend to them after 15 minutes. Hate to leave a bad review of a local establishment, but honesty is the best policy. read more

Great experience at Tickler's! Foods great, views are spectacular and of course the people are great! Service is always top notch and we are very happy to have The Wylder Hotel, Tickler's Crab Shack and Bar Mumbo on Tilghman Island! Keep up the great work, and we'll see y'all again soon! Ian read more

This place has some good food and the staff is great! I enjoyed the crabs and the other food items!

Great food , good service, beautiful view, and wonderful live music . It was a perfect evening.

What a pleasant hideaway! On a little boat getaway weekend from Annapolis, we were pleasantly surprised by Tickler's. Cozy, clean, outdoor dining. Super friendly staff, and thoughtful attention to detail. Local, farm fresh food. Not your usual bar fare. It is clear that these guys take pride in their attention to detail. Great job! read more