Excellent service and delicious food. Clean and fun atmosphere. We will be back again soon.

Unbelievable, little pizza place. The pizza was meltin your mouth and your breadsticks as well.

Not exactly on the way, but this served as our stopover lunch spot between Cataract Falls and McCormick's Creek State Park. No way we would have found this without Yelp. You order at the counter and they bring your food to the table. I'm guessing most people carry out because the restaurant is very small and even a bit run down. The food, however, is fabulous! We ordered the breadsticks with the jalapeno cheese. Somehow the breadsticks were both airy yet chewy, foretelling of the excellent pizza we were about to enjoy. We shared a medium Ultimate which was more than two of us could eat, so we happily took some home. Nice craft beer selection and pleasant service. Are food arrived relatively quickly considering that it was baked fresh for us. With a 20% tip our bill was nearly $40; some might consider this expensive for pizza and beer. read more

See all

This is located a little bit of 67. You can't miss it when you drive into Paragon. It's on the right with a neat painted on logo on the building. The building has character and it's nice inside. The employees were friendly and they had a steady flow of people picking up orders or coming in and having a sit down meal. They have a spot on check in area if you earn points. I keep the tag on my keychain and scan it whenever I see a spot on area. The breadsticks were warm and fresh. They aren't dense they're light and delicious. You could see all the employees rolling dough and adding toppings. All hard at work! The lasagna was made with their house pasta sauce and have a lot of flavor. I liked how they had a stack of to go boxes and lids to take home with you. The servings are big and it's nice they thought of that. They also had gelato available and numerous beers. It's a great place to stop! read more

See all

What a find. First, the service is impeccable. Carol greeted us at the door and took care of us. I've never had better breadsticks; the salad is enough for two. I expected a ho-hum salad, but this salad was a work of art. The pizza was certainly worth the drive from Martinsville. There was a constant flow of carry-out customers, but this summer, we'll take our car clubs there, and they can seat about a hundred on the patio. Everyone at the Tomato Pie likes what they do, which certainly shows in their friendliness and product quality. read more

Good pizza Great selection of toppings Outstanding bread sticks Excellent salads Really good sandwiches Local owner Local staff Open for lunch Open till 10:00 One large pizza 3 soft drinks $34.00 You choose.... Dominos??? Or great pizza at a local spot read more

Great flavor in their pizza if you like cheese! Until 2 pm, you can order pizzas by the slice made to order. Although the staff said it would only take about 5 minutes, I realized that it would be more like 15 to 20. And when they say slice, it is more like a quarter pizza! Huge servings, loaded with cheese and a reasonable wait time is okay by me! I was getting my order to go, so I didn't partake of the Quaff On or Sun KIng craft beers available, but it's nice to know they have those. Each slice was so large that they were each placed in their own styrofoam box for transport. The pizza itself is the real soft bottomed (almost soggy) crust that is meant to be folded if you don't want any grease from the meat to drip on you. The one negative I noticed was that the toppings I requested were more densely packed near the outer crust than the center. They don't slice the mushrooms or pepperoni any smaller to fit down into the point of the pie slice, so the first bite or two are mostly the cheese and sauce flavors. But nearer the crust they have plenty of toppings. Still, it would be nice if they would take that one extra step to make the quality the same throughout the pizza. Review #1778 read more

See all

O. M. G. If youre looking for amazing pizza and breadsticks tucked away in a tiny town, youve found it. People travel from greenwood just to get this pizza!! (Thats us lol) Worth the drive yall!!! And we're picky with pizza, so this place is aaaamazing!!! read more

Delicious overly cheesy pizza with the best breadsticks and marinara! Currently offering pick up only due to COVID. read more

Tomato Pie Pizza Joint - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Paragon, Indiana

See all

Love Tomato Pie!! Have their pizzas and Sammies quite often. Breadsticks are awesome too!!

Delicious gem hidden in a small town. But that is part of what makes it so special. Great food at a great price.

The pizza is really good and flavorful. THEY HAVE BREWERY BEER HERE! Major plus for me! Staff isnt terrible, just not as friendly as everything else around. Only reason i gave it 4 stars. Good pizza though, no doubt about it. read more

Tomato Pie Pizza Joint - Ultimate pizza. Super good! - Pizza Near Me - Paragon, Indiana

Clean, dining room, outdoor area, and restrooms. Friendly staff. Generous portions- a bit pricey. Founded by owner of Greiner's sub shops in Indianapolis. Great legacy. read more

Great old style pizza. Great service. Highly recommend. Nice little drive to enjoy this family owned pizza place.

I've changed my star rating to a 1, if I could give them a zero I totally would and here is why... We bought 2 pizzas a chicken bacon ranch medium and a 2 topping medium 1/2 pineapple pepperoni and the other sausage and pepperoni. An order of small breadsticks, two cheeses and a small salad for my Moms birthday. We went to pick it up (20mins away) took it back home (20 mins back) sat down to enjoy the pizza and ate my part and theres sausage instead of jumping to conclusion that they just didnt it wrong I called to ask if their red sauce had meat in it. It doesn't. So I told them it was wrong. Well if you bring it back we will make it again. So we cut our visit short with the birthday girl and left (another 20 mins there) waited 15 minutes for the new pizza. She comes out I'm like ok, wow.... we can go home to Greenwood (about an hour away) here's the pizza but they made it wrong again theres pineapple on the entire thing. I cant eat a whole pizza and he doesnt like pineapple. So then she said shed take it off. So I asked her if shed be refunding me the difference when I gave her my card. She came back and said no I'll need you. The first transaction hasnt gone through so I'm going to delete that one and do it correctly. So from 47.07 to 31.30. I said ok. I'd assume she knows her system more than I do. This was all on a Sunday. Monday I look at my account and I have almost $80 bucks tied up in this company! I called them lady took all my info said that the lady that handles this is not in but she will call me. No call Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday or Friday (I'm checking my account each day. $47.07 is still pending and tied up. Saturday morning it's gone, it's fixed! But I called the company back and asked to speak to owner so he knew what was going on with his company when he wasnt there. That's a joke too! Its know Tuesday. No phone call. So apparently he could care less as well. Please please please, if they mess up and they fix your transactions beware!!! They do not know there system like they think they do or else someone just messed up. She could have just refunded the difference but instead wanted to charge me again. Not cool. And for the owner to not call someone back... Not cool. And I'll make sure the places that have worked with him know this! They will not want to give them theirs or their patrons business, if they were treated like this... itd look bad on them as well. read more

Tomato Pie Pizza Joint - Pizza Near Me - Paragon, Indiana

Best pizza in Indiana. Everything is top notch. Pizza is incredible and so are the breadsticks. Salads are fresh and plentiful. Worth the trip to Paragon! read more

Love this lil place ! One of the best breadsticks and pizza in the state! I wanna see them add some new things to the menu because with the quality ingredients they use im sure they can make something special. read more

I've been to this great Pizza restraunt a few times. The breadsticks are beyond compare!! They are the best I've ever tasted. The pizza's are yummy too!! A very dear friend told me about this "Pizza Joint". :) He highly recommended it. Mark KNOWS what good food is, so I just had to check it out!! He was 100% right! Even if you have to drive a good distance to get to Paragon, IN, I promise you that you will not be disappointed with the Tomato Pie Pizza Joint. read more

This little pizza place may be a good trek, but is well worth the drive. Sure it's small, you won't find ambience or over the top service, but you will get phenomenal pizza and even better breadsticks. There are no words for these breadsticks. They are fabulous! Strombolis and salads are great, too. (Try the honey mustard!) Make the drive, and order extras. You'll want it for breakfast the next morning! read more

Tomato Pie Pizza Joint - The best breadsticks around! - Pizza Near Me - Paragon, Indiana

Called in order in advance to be ready when we arrived. Pizza was burned on arrival and they asked if it was ok! I had then re make the pizza. We had to wait 30 minutes. Not happy and will not come back again!! read more

Pizza is great and they toughed it out through Covid so I'm glad they're still around. Small town pizza joint but great quality and friendly people. Get some and thank me later. read more

Now that I've been a couple times, I can't miss this place when visiting my parents who live in the area. The breadsticks are outstanding, and the pizza is freshly-made! They have a ton of topping choices, and that's really nice when you're craving something a little different than your ordinary pizza. They now offer delivery via a third-party website, but it's worth the drive if you happen to be anywhere near! I have yet to try their "sammies", but I hear good things from others so I will have to remedy that soon! Seriously, get the breadsticks. Best decision you'll ever make. read more

This is the best pizza I have tasted in Indiana. I am from NJ, and pizza there is amazing. When I moved to Indiana I missed the taste of the NY and NJ style pizza. I haven't been able to find something as delicious as at home. This place did it!! I'm leaving full and all smiles! read more

Hidden gem in Paragon! Awesome food, awesome staff, great beer selection! Highly recommend!

Regardless of where you live, this place is your new local pizza joint. Their food is so good. I'm pretty sure it's all handmade, as far as I've eaten--except the cheese sauce for the homemade breadsticks (which is delish). Excellent craft beer selection. Super friendly staff! They are very supportive of their local public servants. Must visit! read more

Saw a spot about this place on the news quite awhile ago and added it to my to-do list. On a recent football weekend in Bloomington decided to get this one done on the way home. SO glad I did. It's small, it's in Paragon (?), and it's fabulous! The place was basically packed after the game, so we quickly grabbed two seats joining two characters who were polishing off a couple of beers and telling hilarious stories. It's that kind of place. We ordered Breadsticks right away - we were starving! So good! A good sized portion, super yummy with their garlic butter baked in and a side of marinara. Totally hit the spot! Next came a Veggie Delight Pie - absolutely packed with lots of veggies and cheese and cheese and cheese. Delish! This is the kind of place where you put your order in at the door, grab a seat, get your own drinks and refills, and just enjoy it! They had plenty of beer options available, but we had a long drive ahead so none for us that day. Definitely will be back! read more

Great lunch special here. The bread sticks were so good and large! I couldn't stop eating them so wasn't very hungry when the pizza finally came out. The pizza was great too. The building is a bit on the small side so large groups are a little hard to seat but not impossible. Will be stopping by aai read more

Tomato Pie Pizza Joint - Pizza Near Me - Paragon, Indiana

The Only reason We go to Paragon This is my Absolute Favorite Pizza!! Nice Ride on the Bike to an "Off the Beaten Path " Local Spot and Beer...Yay Beer!!! read more

Expensive but worth it, definitely give it a try if you are in or around the paragon area.

I wish they had a "Joint" here in Bloomington! I've been there four times now and tried four different pizza's and was never disappointed. Great flavor, plenty of toppings and wonderful service. Please open another Joint in Bloomington. By the way the bread sticks are the best! read more

Where the heck is their "People Love us on Yelp" sticker?!? This place is nothing short of amazing. Yes, it's located in Paragon, Indiana. But try them. They have incredible pizza and breadsticks. There is a reason they have a near-perfect rating on Yelp. Outstanding people as well as ingredients. Pride in ownership abounds! read more

See all

Looking for dinner options tonight and of course started with YELP. Once restaurants came up I immediately saw The Tomato Pie and the reviews. Browse no further. This place is amazing! The breadsticks were delicious and the pizza the best I've had in a long time! Can't wait to go back and try other options!! read more

Take the time to check this place out! We visited here about a year ago and can't stop coming back! Excellent service! Amazing breadsticks and pizza. The place is small but they have an outdoor seating area and also a place next door if it is crowded- and it will be, so plan on it. read more

Worth the drive. A friend showed me this little hole in the wall in high school, and I love bringing people here. The food is great and the service is, too. Love this place! read more

Oh the breadsticks. Amazing, doughy, buttery goodness. Worth the drive to Paragon alone. Pizza is good and the local beer options are a nice touch. Martinsville residents can have it delivered on ArtesianMenu. read more

I think I have eaten the perfect pizza! Seriously the best pizza I have ever encountered. It was an off menu item recommended by our friendly waitress. (I wish I would have noted her name!). She called it the Mama Mia. Blueprint: Meatball with double cheese and tomato sauce. We found this place on Yelp on our way to McCormick's Creek State Park. Thank you Yelp! They also gave us complimentary breadsticks when they found out it was our first visit. I also highly recommend the breadsticks. The only negative about this place is we live in Houston and can't eat here again soon! read more

Tomato Pie Pizza Joint - Interior - Pizza Near Me - Paragon, Indiana

We were on our way north from Bloomington and checked yelp for a place to eat. We drove a little out of our way to try this place. I have to say, I was pleased with experience. Looking at the place from outside, I didn't think my wife would even go in. Thankfully we did and found a very good meal. Twisted breadsticks were awesome, chef salad was very fresh and the chicken was a nice touch. We sampled the hot and barbecue wings which were good and hot, and finally the pizza. The crust was light and the toppings plentiful and the cheese covered it all. Very happy with the meal especially if you can get past the business appearance. A lot of people are going to miss out on a great meal because they will only see a less than commercialized building with no frills or fancy actors pictures. Thank the Lord, America still exists at its finest in Paragon. read more

See all

Lackluster at best. Pizza was just okay, but nothing to write home about. A pizza joint that only has crushed red pepper in packets? Weird. I expected friendlier service given its location. "Sorry, we don't allow customers to use our (multiple) WiFi networks." Unwiped dirty tables too. Won't be back. read more

Well worth the drive. This place has the good stuff. I haven't been there for about a month, just thinking about it I've decided to head that direction. read more

Really good pizza!! You simply cannot go wrong here. Their breadsticks are amazing - best I've ever had! Yum! I come here every time I'm "home". read more

See all