Upon arriving, very clean and friendly. We ordered the meatball appetizer and it was very good! We ordered the "Godfather" pizza which was supposed to have ricotta, mushrooms, Italian sausage and pepperoni. Never saw it tasted any mushrooms or ricotta on the pizza. The pizza was still good, but if you're going to say it's on the pizza, we need to actually see and/or taste it. read more

I made reservations for Saturday night. We walked in and were shoulder to shoulder with other people waiting to be checked in. There were two girls working the door. You could see agitation on the other's faces. We were finally checked in and had to wait about 10 minutes to be seated. Our server came over and took our drink orders, I ordered the Hi Lo and my husband got the Italian mule. Our drinks arrived at our table 10 minutes later. My husband's mule was super sweet and hard to drink. My Hi Lo was awful, I couldn't even force it down! We ordered an appetizer that I forgot the name of, it had cheese and tomatoes with small garlic toasts. It was good, but 6 small pieces of toast, one that had a hole in it, didn't do much. This app definitely needs a few more toast pieces to make it worthwhile. We ordered pizzas for dinner, one margarita and one suprema. They were good, but waiting over an hour for pizza is absurd! Service was terrible and so slow! The restaurant was not full by any means, yet service was at a snails pace. We decided to order dessert, so we got the tiramisu. It was good, but definitely made in a factory and cut into pieces when ordered. read more

See all

Avoid Pizza & Libations: A Masterclass in Nickel and Diming and Poor Execution I rarely write negative reviews, but after last night's experience at Pizza & Libations in Bargersville, I feel compelled to warn others. This was supposed to be a celebratory birthday dinner with a group that required a reservation. What we got instead was one disappointment after another from a restaurant owned by Taxman Hospitality Group (the same team behind Taxman Brewing Company). From the moment we sat down, we were informed that there would be an up-charge for bringing in outside desserts. In over 50 years of dining at everything from upscale establishments to local mom-and-pop spots, I have never encountered this. The real issue wasn't even the fee itself, it was the total lack of transparency. No mention when the reservation was made, no note on the website, nothing until we were already seated for a pre-planned group event. At that point, leaving wasn't a practical option. As business owners, Nathan and Leah Huelsebusch, you should train your staff to disclose policies like this when the reservation is booked, not after guests have committed. Unfortunately, the dessert fee was just the beginning. The menu we were handed listed adding chicken to a salad at $6. The online menu also shows $6. Yet our bill charged $7, bringing one salad to $21. For that price, you'd expect a substantial entrée-sized salad. Instead, it was what most restaurants would consider a side portion. Tiny. The kids' menu listed a specific pasta that was not available. Rather than inform us upfront, they simply brought something different. When questioned, the waitress casually said they "no longer carry" what's printed on the menu. That's not an oversight, that's false advertising. We ordered a pizza and specifically asked for mushrooms on only half. The request was denied because they "don't do half-ingredient orders." Yet they were perfectly willing to remove mushrooms from the entire pizza. The inconsistency was baffling and frustrating. Service was noticeably slow throughout the evening. Prices were high across the board, especially given the underwhelming portion sizes. The veteran discount was another point of frustration: the waitress told us it would be 10% off the veteran's meal and soda, but the bill only applied the discount to the soda. No manager ever appeared to check on us or attempt to make things right despite the waitress being aware of every issue we encountered. For a group celebration, that complete absence of leadership was particularly disappointing. Pizza & Libations had every opportunity to deliver a good experience and instead chose policies and practices that felt petty and poorly thought out. Between surprise fees, menu inaccuracies, inflexible accommodations, small portions, and indifferent service, this was one of the most frustrating dining experiences I've had in years. Save your money and your evening, go somewhere else. read more

Pizza and Libations - Receipt showing $7.00 chicken - Pizza Near Me - Bargersville, Indiana

See all

We stumbled upon Pizza & Libations and I'm so glad we did. From the first bite to the last, everything was spot-on delicious! We started with the meatballs as an appetizer, and wow--tender, flavorful, and swimming in their house red sauce, which was truly out of this world. Honestly, I could have eaten a bowl of that sauce on its own. It was rich, tangy, and perfectly seasoned. For our main course, we had one of their specialty pizzas and it did not disappoint. The crust was a standout--crispy on the outside, chewy on the inside, and had that perfect wood-fired flavor that makes you close your eyes and savor each bite. The atmosphere was cozy yet lively, and the staff were friendly and attentive without being overbearing. You can tell they care about the food and the experience. If you're a pizza lover (or a red sauce fanatic like me), do yourself a favor and check this place out. It's easily one of the best pizza spots I've been to in a long time! read more

Pizza and Libations - Pizza Near Me - Bargersville, Indiana

See all

This place was a STANDOUT at a recent Indy Track Event (Rev 2026) amongst a sea of other eateries. Soooo I went here to the brick and mortar in Bargersville. The pizza isn't good- it's GREAT. The staff are very sweet and on top of their craft. Kayli was a really great server and Athena was a great bartender- their drinks compete with their pizzas- really well thought out. Go!!! read more

See all

Great patio, food & beer were delicious. The beer was in a stemmed glass that I enjoyed. Pizza was delicious. Not pictured is the godfather pizza with hot honey which my husband devoured. read more

Pizza and Libations - Beer & patio - Pizza Near Me - Bargersville, Indiana

See all

Great little place with great food and drink. It's not too far a drive for us in Martinsville and they have takeout! Everything on the menu is great, you have to have their bread sticks, they are to die for! Great pricing on everything. We dine or have takeout every week there! read more

Overall, good food, crappy service. Made a reservation for six of us. Arrived on time for our reservation, and had to wait ten to fifteen minutes for our table. Waitress greeted us. My biggest pet peeve for anyone working in food service is fake nails- they are disgusting, and I don't want whatever is up under them to get in my food (as you can guess, our waitress had them). We ordered our foodand drinks. Drinks came out quick. Man, they packed a punch, and agree about the "libations" name. Food on the other hand, did not. Waited quite a while for our apps. Our entrees took over an hour to come out. Mozzarella sticks for appetizer were okay- looked like frozen ones out of a box with some parsley and cheese over them. Short rib ragu was tasty- if I ever came back, I would get it again. Definitely could tell it was homemade pasta. Overall, expected more from this place, as we have had good experiences at other Taxman restaurants, but probably won't return here. read more

Pizza and Libations - Short rib ragu - Pizza Near Me - Bargersville, Indiana

See all

Our group of six visited on a Saturday night. We made a reservation and were seated promptly. The decor of the restaurant is sophisticated, but the dining room seems to be quite loud where we felt like we were yelling at each other all night. We started with some drinks and the mozzarella sticks and wild mushroom bruschetta that came out rather quick. The bruschetta was quite tasty and was a large portion. We had ordered two pizzas and two pasta dishes as a group. After about an hour after we had had our appetizers and other diners clearing out of the place, they brought out an orderof meatballs, as they were just starting to prepare our pizzas. The were four meatballs for six people which I found odd. I get that this was complementary, but if you're apologizing for how long our food is taking, why would you not bring one for everyone at the table? The pizzas and pasta finally came. I tried the That's My Jam. It's a sweet pizza so I found it tasty. Overall, this restaurant is quite a ways out of the way for me, and with the amount of time our food took, I probably won't be back. read more

See all

Holy sh!t this was good. The fig pizza was incredible but everything we had was outstanding. Cannoli cake and chocolate tart as well. And terrific service. Great ambiance. Idk what all the negative reviews are about, this place was dope. Will be back. read more

Can't say enough good things about this place. Second time going. First time I didn't even know they had an amazing steak place upstairs. That's awesome too. But I asked for a recommendation on pizza, she recommended the that's my jam. I was skeptical but she didn't miss. That pizza was delicious. The mozzarella sticks amazing! The pizza pinwheels were amazing! Food great! Staffs great! Ambiance is great! I also drank a full pitcher of beer which was also great! Definitely recommend! 5 stars! read more

Pizza is the thing to get here and the pepperoni pin wheels. We used to love their calzones and lasagna but they are smaller now and not as tasty. read more

Waitress was little slow but everything else was good. We will be back. I do wish the pepperoni garlic bread had more garlic read more

See all

Been here twice. First time better than second. Service was very very slow and food didn't seem as fresh. Nice decor and vibe so Will give it another chance before writing it off. You can make a reservation and that is helpful read more

Due to self-imposed dietary restrictions, I hadn't had pizza for 11/2 years and decided to get back to "normal" just for a night. I heard great things about Pizza & Libations and decided to roll the dice. My girlfriend and I started out with the Meatball appetizer. It was freshly made and served with garlic toast and a wonderful Marinara sauce for dipping. Superb!! Next came the pizzas. Being a glutton it seemed like a good idea to get a couple pies to mix things up. We got "The Godfather" which is red sauce Mozzarella, Asiago, Ricotta, and Italian sausage. Very strong combo. In addition we ordered the "Sweet Heat" pie that had Red sauce, Calabrian chilis, Soprasetta, Banana peppers, and a great cheese blend. Marvelous!! The pies are hand tossed and my guess is they use "00" flour which is pretty high in gluten to give it a very toothsome pull while still being light and airy. After dinner we ran to their annex and got some Gelato that shouldn't be overlooked! The service was on point with everything as management insists on quality service instead of allowing other things to take precedence. The ambience is quite nice with modern industrial as the setting for the dining room. We are bar rats and choose to sit there when possible. Surprisingly the bar stools were quite comfortable and not an afterthought as most are. The bar was busy with fellow diners all night. Bargersville isn't probably on your radar for pizza but absolutely should be! read more

See all

Delicious beer from Taxman, of course. We ordered The Godfather pizza. Delicious! Crust was crispy on the outside with delicious tender crust inside. Seriously great pizza! We'll be back to try more!! read more

Pizza and Libations - The Godfather! Yum!! - Pizza Near Me - Bargersville, Indiana

This is a nice, new, hip spot located in Bargersville. It is owned by Taxman Brewery, which is located just around the corner. It is a trendy spot that has a huge dining area, a huge patio and a full bar with seating as well. There is some nice murals on the ways and they can host large groups here. There is a parking area across the street from the restaurant and there is also some free street parking available in front of it as well. They have a huge menu with salads, pasta, and of course pizza. They have a thick drink menu with signature cocktails, wine and beer. The place was packed and I was still able to be seated right away. My server was awesome. She was very helpful, attentive, and friendly. I ordered some meatballs to start off with. They come 4 to a serving and was very tasty. I got a sweet heat pizza and a Fior De Latte to wash it down. It took about 15 minutes for the pizza and they forgot about my drink so, it took the bar about 10 minutes to make it after being reminded by my server. The pizza did not disappoint. It was very tasty. I will caution you though. It had a lot of heat to it. Very spicy, but still very good. The drink was unique. It had a jalapeno taste, but was still sweet. I really enjoyed my meal here. This is a hip new spot in town and is definitely worth a visit. I admit that it is a bit on the pricier end, but well worth a splurge date night. read more

See all

I would I highly recommend Pizza and Libations. Great atmosphere with a great menu. Also, our server Grace was awesome along with the rest of the friendly and efficient staff. read more

Excellent new addition to downtown Bargersville. Biggest tip right now (November 2022) is make a reservation! Giving a little grace here for a new opening and everyone still getting their bearings, but really no major hiccups other than some longer wait times - but it's well worth it. Good selection of wine and beer and some craft cocktails - my chocolate martini was excellent. This restaurant has close ties to Taxman Brewery, so you'll see their beers on tap. Pizza itself was so good. You can build your own or choose one of the specialty pizzas put together on the menu, but be warned you can't split them. My wife and I have very different taste, but we were on our way to a concert so neither of us wanted to get whole pizza to ourselves without somewhere to put leftovers. We settled on the buffalo chicken, which was excellent. I'm not a big fan of crust, but I couldn't get enough of this. Only complaint here is that I wish there was more chicken--it's a little buffalo and ranch heavy for me. Really looking forward to coming back here, especially when it warms up and they open the patio space. Definitely going to be one of our favorites. read more

Pizza and Libations - Buffalo Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bargersville, Indiana

Stopped coming here because the pizza never seemed to be cooked thru. The dough wasn't cooked, and was definitely doughy. We gave it a shot again today, and this was the result Had to it in the over just to get it be cooked. Pro:staff is amazing and the decor is nice read more

Pizza and Libations - Godfather pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bargersville, Indiana

See all

We came to P&L for the first time on a whim. we have been to Taxman several times but decided to try their pizza place. We are glad we did!! The pizza was fantastic. The crispy potato's with banana peppers were so good. The Mac & Bolognese was decent. The noodles were too Al dente for my taste, but over all the food was good. It is a large space. It was busy because they were celebrating their one year anniversary. It was loud, but that wasn't a problem. We found a seat at the bar, so there was no wait. The only thing that kept this from being a 5 star review is the service. When we sat at the bar, it took more than five minutes for anyone to even greet us. Now, when Tony finally saw that we hadn't been helped, he was on the spot the rest of the night. I recommend this place for good pizza, mixed drinks, and taxman beer! read more

See all

My family and I traveled around 30 minutes here for Mother's Day, and were disappointed. We had heard great things but it did not live up to the expectations. The service was great and especially with our large group. We ordered two appetizers including the pepperoni pinwheels and chicken parm bites. The chicken bites were all panko crumbs and were more on the burnt end. The pizza overall was okay. I enjoyed the ricotta on the Godfather otherwise the pizza didn't have much taste. I think the ambiance was good but the food didn't match up to the overall aesthetic. read more

See all

The food is great and the service is excellent. We love popping in during the week for a quick bite and we like the option of pizza, salad, or an entree in a relaxed atmosphere. read more

We decided to go here for devour , my daughter met her girlfriends the night before and highly recommended this place . We were not disappointed.... Even though it was a slow start when we arrived - the waitstaff made up for it later. We ended up with the mushroom gnocchi and a sweet heat pizza to split. Both delicious. Also we split the house chop salad, big enough to share . The restaurant is decorated nicely and laid out very well , outdoor seating is available in season with a nice fireplace out on the patio. Our friend got the spaghetti and meatballs and loved the sauce - it is a bit spicy, which is our favorite kind. Highly recommend going -this is a great addition to to town if Bargersville read more

See all

We came back for a 2nd visit. Service was much improved & our server Izzy was awesome! But the restaurant was out of pizza dough so the only things left on the menu to order were salads or entrees. This was a disappointment because the entrees are significantly more expensive than splitting a pizza! Our entrees were awesome! The food is really good! But I do wish we could've tried the pizza again & that we would've been told they were out of pizza before we ordered drinks & apps (we would've cut back on those to allow for the spending of the entrees) We were looking forward to trying a different pizza this visit. Hoping this place can get everything worked out & we'll try again for a 3rd visit, maybe 3rd time will be a charm! read more

See all

If you're tired of franchise pizza place and cookie cutter menu, this can be a new alternative. Inside is very spacious, new, clean and modern. It has a bar sitting area. I wanted to try something fruity cocktail but menu didn't have one. A bartender was so kind to craft the one not on the menu for me. We ordered Hen of Woods pizza. It was very fresh and delicious. On my way out, I noticed that it has a spacious patio sitting area outside. I would like to dine outdoor when it gets little cooler. Staffs were kinda and helpful and you can park across the restaurant. read more

Pizza and Libations - Hen of woods pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bargersville, Indiana

See all

I'm sorry, but I'm not a fan of this place. It should be called Garlic & Libations. I really don't know if the chefs or owners have ever had decent Italian food, but they don't seem to know how to prepare it, at any rate. The "marinara" that comes with pretty much all their apps is NOT marinara--it is salsa. It looks like salsa, has the same texture as salsa (CHUNKY), and tastes like a marinara/salsa combo. I ate there with my husband and son and every single one of our dinner meals was so crazy garlicky we could hardly stand it. And I LIKE garlic--but no one likes garlic this much (or this much garlic). We ate there weeks agao, and I swear I still taste it! lol. I just can't imagine paying this much money for food this bad ever again. read more

Great pizza and cocktails on a very nice patio that is dog friendly! Great service. We'll be back!

This place was phenomenal. My husband and I lived in DC for 20+ years and have a very high standard for food. This place blew us away and we will be back many, many times. Food, drinks, and service were all A+. Go, you won't regret it. read more

Great new pizza place in Bargersville. Worth whatever drive it is to get down here for this pizza. Unique menu for sure! Bar menu looks incredible. I can't wait to see this place in the summer with live music. Local parking available out front and to the side. Be sure to make a reservation. When on a wait there is nowhere to sit. Excited to be trying this for the second time! read more

Pizza and Libations - Hen of the woods. I can't recommend this pizza enough! - Pizza Near Me - Bargersville, Indiana

See all

Went to dinner on 12/29/22 with friends to try P&L for the first time. Pizzas were good. The fig jam one was my fav. The burrata cheese appetizer was delicious The garlic knots weren't garlicky, but the texture was awesome, who doesn't love fresh, hot bread?! Service was friendly and helpful. We'll be back. read more

Living where I do, we are quite shy of decent restaurants, so we were super excited to see this place open. I want to love it, I really do. But we have been here 5 times and every single time, they bungle something. The first time, I got risotto, and it was a SALT AND GARLIC BOMB. Literally the worst thing I've ever tasted. I cannot believe any self-respecting chef would let that leave the kitchen. The 2nd time we came, they were out of all of the ingredients to make the two specialty drinks (that are on their menu) that we wanted. The 3rd time we came, the pizza took FOREVER to arrive, and they had burned the bottom so bad that it was inedible. The list goes on... I really wish they would pull it together b/c it would be so nice to have a go-to spot near our home. read more

So at 2:30 pm our party of 8 was informed they were totally out of a entrees, it was pizza and salad or go hungry. But to top it off we had brought along a birthday cake. The manager informed us there would be a $25 charge if we ate our own cake. So they are out of food and want to charge us $25 to eat what we brought Will never return read more

Food was fantastic. I had the "It's My Jam" pizza and it was everyone's fav. The crust was amazing. Our server was excellent. Atmosphere was way too loud. We had to shout at each other. I would prefer to come back when the patio is open so we can socialize. read more

Came in for our first time yesterday. Tyler was our waiter and he was amazing! We ordered all his recommendations and the food was definitely worth the price!! It's definitely a neat place and our family will be back for sure. Thanks for the good service and delicious food! read more

Menu is straight forward and done right. Currently my vote for best pizza in central Indiana Service is outstanding Impressive wine selection Modern clean cut layout is comfortable and inviting the only negative is we did not go there sooner read more

Met some friends to try out the new location. The fried mozzarella was pretty good as a starter. We split a pizza and got the buffalo chicken pizza. The pizza was ok, a little greasy in my opinion, but the flavor was pretty good. Our friends got spaghetti and meatballs, the meatballs were really good, but the pasta was very overcooked and gummy. Service was ok, nothing to call home about. The whole restaurant is a really nice setup though. I believe that we will go to the original taxman location down the street from now on though. read more

This place is relatively new so I hope to come back again and try it when more established and not a holiday. Went for gluten free as I was just diagnosed with Celiac. The gluten free pizza was excellent and they state they use a separate oven which is amazing but they were out of gluten free pasta. Now I understand that places run out of things but the manager was like... we don't have it and walked away. I am sure a lot of people do gluten free for health but for me this was the main reason we went so would have liked a little bit of, I am really sorry, here are some other options. Also the pizza took forever to be made (over 45 min). Beware, ask about all the toppings as gluten was hiding in several things. read more

Pizza and Libations - Big bar ... lots of seats - Pizza Near Me - Bargersville, Indiana

See all

3rd time here. I generally stay away from the pastas because I am picky regarding how pasta is cooked. So we usually order the pizzas. The dough is super stretchy with the perfect amount of bite to it. They really have the dough down! The crust has some crisp but is also chewy. Here's the rundown: Hubs: pepperoni and basil - delicious Me- Margherita adding pesto- a one word review...amazing! Daughter- That's my jam- delicious. The sweet fig jam mixes perfectly with the ricotta The arancini appetizer was bomb. Best we've had since in a long time. Our server Izzy was so sweet and attentive rice. Her easy nature and funny commentary added to our overall experience. Keep up the good work, we will be back again! read more

Super cool place in cute downtown Bargersville. Beautiful restaurant and bar space. I got takeout here. Salad, chicken caprese sandwich and pizza. Very very good. read more