This restaurant pops up while driving on Highway 89 in Utah. Don't miss it. The name implies it is a pizza restaurant, but they offer much more than pizza on the menu. I enjoyed a large 16 inch cheese pizza. The cheese tasted fresh. It really was good pizza. I went in the afternoon hours around 2pm and it was busy. Seems like a popular stop for food. They had popular old classic music playing inside from Perry Cuomo. I enjoyed the ambience. read more

See all

Such a fun, sweet, diamond in tough we have found. The staff is kind, knowledgeable, and very customer service driven. We ordered two different kinds of pizza, salads and mushrooms. The pizza dough was the best I have had in a long time. The salad was good, BUT the mushrooms...WOW! You have to order the mushrooms. I am not a big fan of fried anything. These were lightly breaded, huge and very tasty. I can't say enough about how good they were. We will be back. read more

Tomatoes Pizza Pie - Front entrance - Pizza Near Me - Marysvale, Utah

Coming into Marysvale in February (off season) there are few choices. A "local" suggested Tomatoes Pizza Pie, and we were glad they were open. Ambience was pleasant and unique and the restrooms were clean. I was told the men's restroom had a humorous sign in there. Service was good (not crowded). Many people had take-out orders while we ate. The pizza crust was delicious and I liked the vegetarian pizza the best. For dessert they had a selection of ice cream or pies. We got a slice of cheesecake to go; it was ok and probably not made by them. We'd return if in town again. read more

See all

Food superb. Garlic parmesan chicken. Yum. The crust to die for. The steak, very tasty. Service superb. Very attentive. Very friendly. Very pleasant. Ambiance Awesome. Who can beat the steampunk decor? All good. Tomatoes Pizza Pie, Marysvale, Utah's hidden gem. read more

See all

Food was great. But the service was Slow, slow, slow. So expect delays and a few reminders to the server for an ice tea refill and Parmesan cheese before finishing the pizza. They did move to a new and bigger building and was still in transition equipment from their old place. We would come back again. read more

Highly recommended by the staff at South 40 RV Park and they were right. Full menu with dinners, sandwiches and of course Pizza. Service was friendly and courteous. XXL Pizza was great size and delicious. Salads were fresh. Also hand dipped ice cream is available. Definitely recommend eating here. Support the locals! read more

See all

I as told this place was great when visiting Marysvale Utah. After going to the address listed on Yelp and the building being closed we called and were told they moved to a new location north of town. No sign yet so after finding the place it turned out to be pretty great pie. There are a lot of other things on the menu too but the pizza pie was amazing. Staff, some were friendly some were ready to go home. Lots of room for larger parties. And the ice cream was good too. read more

Who woulda thought you would find pizza THIS good, out in the sticks?! I'm not saying it's good for pizza off the beaten path.... I'm saying, it's off the beaten path, and it's good regardless. Hand made dough, home made sauce and generous toppings. Just wow. Would definitely recommend and would definitely return should the opportunity arise. read more

I am so glad I stopped for lunch. The service is fabulous, the portions are large, and the pizza was superb. The crust was crunchy, and the toppings are fresh, and very delicious cheese. The salad was fresh and the ranch was house made. Super yummy!! read more

Was driving through the middle of nowhere and stumbled upon this pizza joint. It was a Sunday afternoon and there wasn't really anything else open. When I need a pie I'll drive for hundreds of miles to get one. I was starting to go through pizza withdrawals (worse than heroin) when I finally found this place. The atmosphere was good. Typical pizza place atmosphere. The place was clean and the staff were friendly, no complaints there. Started with the bruschetta which was fantastic. 10 out of 10, definitely the best thing we ate there. Everything about it was good. Had garlic parm and buffalo wings. The wings are small, but were cooked well and were nice and crispy (nobody likes a slimy wing). The garlic parm sauce was great, lots of oil and cheese, definitely made in house. The hot sauce was your typical hot sauce, but was good. Got a cheese pizza that I wasn't impressed with. The pizza was underwhelming compared to the bruschetta and garlic parm wings. Pizza wasn't crispy at all, slices were all floppy and flaccid. It honestly reminded me of a frozen pizza form a grocery store. Get the Bruschetta and garlic parm wings and you'll love it. The pizza needs some work though. read more

See all

Excellent place for pizza. Staff is friendly and experienced. They ck on you after your food arrives too. They are very busy!! Parking is on the street Restaurant is clean...nothing fancy!Sometimes run out of items ( like tonite it was lettuce) You can see them toss the pizza...outdoor seating.with umbrellas. Raviolis are tasty; i recommend the specialty pizza... which has about everything on it. It was done in a timely manner and delicious! A small pizza fed two people. Right on the highway so very convenient if you're traveling Will eat here again read more

So while on vacation in this little town we decided to try the pizza . We ordered a small carnivore with 6 garlic parmesan wings. Let's start with the wings, they weren't super big but they weren't too bad, good flavor just wish they were a little bigger. The pizza was very tasty, I really liked the meatballs on this , had a great flavor, could have used a little bit more sauce but overall not bad . I would definitely recommend this place if your in Marysville UT. read more

Thank you for another fantastic meal, our fam bam enjoyed our delicious lunch! Pizza was perfect!!! read more

See all

Great Pizza and menu of other entrees & delicious desserts. You can't beat this amazing restaurant.

We stopped at this old school pizzeria on the way home from visiting Bryce Canyon. We absolutely destroyed the cheesy garlic bread which was some of the best I've had anywhere, but be advised it's basically its own pizza. The pizza is really tasty too, but suffers from the same issue I see from a lot of pizza places here in Utah - too much cheese and sauce weighs the pizza down and makes it floppy, and sometimes soggy. But it was still a great experience, and the crust was solid too. The service was also super friendly, and the inside was cozy - exactly what you'd hope for from a little gem of a pizzeria, especially considering how small and isolated the town is. read more

Best food ever ! Staff is friendly and super helpful. My daughter loves the pizza! The decor and lighting is great ! read more

We just had pizza from Marysvales Tomato's Pizza. They just opened today. Our pizza was awesome! Nice to have them opened for the year!

Just a handful of guys jamming away slinging out hot pies! Pizza and cheese sticks were awesome! Good atmosphere - was a tad bit smoky but reasonable and the staff was slammed for a Thursday evening. The pizza was amazing to say the least! Great crust, sweet sauce and perfect amount of cheese. If you are near I-70 or in the area it is worth the drive 100%. read more

Tomatoes Pizza Pie - Cheese sticks and marinara - Pizza Near Me - Marysvale, Utah

See all

Service was awesome , the food was outstanding . The atmosphere was very nice and clean .

When ever I come here or drive through town I always stop. Glad I did again! They have expanded their menu a little and added this little gem. Cheesecake! Owner operated and so so good! read more

Great food here...the pizza's are excellent, great salads and the paninis are superb! They are always busy, but you can dine in or order to go. read more

One of the best damn places to eat ever. The white garlic pasta was awesome. The cheeseburger was awesome. The roast beef pastrami panini was awesome and their version of the margarita pizza called garlic Bianca was awesome. The staff is friendly and helpful and we were lucky to get a table. The wings and salad were good. We ate until it was stupid. It was worth the trip to Marysvale. We will be back and we will be bringing more people with us. Second day experience: after a day of rafting we couldn't get back to Tomatoes fast enough. We reordered the garlic Bianca, we also ordered a cheese, pepperoni/sausage and a BBQ chicken pizza. Everything was awesome again. Plus we had ice cream and it was super good. The root beer freeze and root beer float were super yummy too. read more

Tomatoes Pizza Pie - Garlic Bianca - Pizza Near Me - Marysvale, Utah

See all

This place is a great little pizza place! See photos for suggestions. Would come back for the wings and yummy Ranch!!! read more

Tomatoes Pizza Pie - Florentine pizza. Get light or no onion... they are raw and overwhelming. - Pizza Near Me - Marysvale, Utah

See all

This is a GREAT place! Our group went here for a birthday dinner. We ordered the chicken wings, bread sticks, cheese sticks, and Meat Lovers pizza. Everything was excellent! The bread and cheese sticks were covered in cheese, and the marinara sauce had a sweet flavor. They make the pizza dough by hand and toss it in the air which can be seen from your table. Be sure to save room for the homemade, Italian cheesecake. It is light and fluffy, just the perfect dessert without being too sweet. Our server Devon was fantastic and very accommodating to our large group. I wish this place was closer to home so we could be frequent customers! read more

This is some of the best pizza you will ever have. We are camping at one of the RV parks in the area. We came for dinner and had the Garlic Bianca pizza. The crust was perfect NY Pizza crust and the cheese, garlic, spices and fresh tomatoes were excellent. We learned the owner is from NY and started at a baker, turning to pizza when he arrived in Marysvale. The day before leaving, we went back to purchase four 12" Garlic Bianca pizzas to go so be eaten in the future. read more

We are from NY and we know pizza... we had a delicious meal there. We ordered the Family which included 4 drinks, large round pizza and 12 wings. The four adults couldn't finish the pie- but we took it to go for later. The wings were cooked perfectly and delicious, we chose garlic parm and hot. The garlic parm had chunks of garlic and the hot was tasty, spicy but enjoyable. The pie we chose pepperoni it was real 3in thin sliced pepperoni, perfect amount of cheese and the sauce was to die for. They do not serve beer or liquor but not needed as the meal was outstanding. Many other items on the menu looked great and smelled great walking to other tables. We stopped for lunch or I would have ordered one of everything! The waitstaff was on top of everything, checked in on us, filled our drinks and made sure we were thrilled with the meal! read more

Absolutely AMAZING Pizza!!! Fresh, hand tossed and you can taste it!! A very small place that is quite unassuming in a sleepy little town known for RZR off road trail riding. There aren't many eating establishments available at all in the area but with Tomatoes Pizza Pie, you wouldn't want anything else honestly. As good, if not better than pizza served in downtown Manhattan New York City!! The dining room could use some help in the way of decor and they are known to close early, which sucks but if you're lucky enough to endure in one of their pizza pies, you will LOVE IT!!!!!!!! read more

The very best garlic cheesey bread and pizza around for 150 miles and there wings are also very good

Holy cow. Home made dough, fresh veggies, great staff. Worth the drive!! Historic area, lots to see and do, but the food was what drew us south from Richfield. read more

Tomatoes Pizza Pie - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Marysvale, Utah

I won't give them a five-star review just to keep the record going, but because they deserve it. We didn't have any phone or internet service when we drove through town the first time, but finally got some so we could check reviews of this restaurant. Thirteen highest reviews was a good sign that we wouldn't be disappointed. We were hungry as we'd just had snacks since lunch yesterday. The young employees worked hard to make everything right. The eating area had plenty of tables and baby chairs for young guests. There were a few flies unfortunately. The bathroom was clean with a funny sign and interesting rock art. Their house salad ($4.79) could easily serve two people. It has iceberg lettuce, spinach, sliced olives and cucumbers, tomatoes, croutons and dressing--several options available. I would add grated cheese to make it perfect. We had a split pizza with Canadian bacon and pineapple (Hawaiian) and supreme with pepperoni, sausage, onions, olives and green peppers. It was cheesy and delicious! And fast, hot and fresh. Pepper flakes and parmesan cheese shakers were available on each table. They had classic rock music videos on their wall TV. Fun place to eat in a historic mining pioneer town. read more

Tomatoes Pizza Pie - Half Hawaiian/half supreme yumminess. - Pizza Near Me - Marysvale, Utah

My husband and I stop here every time we drive through. It is our favorite pizza place ever. Please do yourself a favor and stop here. Prices are high but very worth it. It's so fresh and good, employees are always really friendly and fast. read more

Tomatoes Pizza Pie - Pizza Near Me - Marysvale, Utah

Well we always come to this wonderful place. I can't say enough good things about it. I am a pizza junkie big time. And well this is the best pizza in Utah!!! Yep I said and if you have not come here and tried this little gem! Well your missing out. It is in a small old mining town hidden from everyone. Unless you ask or if you Yelp you will miss it. They are such good dudes that works here and they are the best ever. It is clean and good vibes. The music that is playing is my favorite some good old hairbands music. As for the food I love it! I always try something new and never get disappointed in any way. But I always go for my 3 topping calzone. Always!!!! But hey you don't have to take my word for it! So if you ever want to just go for a ride down to southern Utah stop in and have the best pizza in Utah hands down!!!! read more

See all

Delicious New-York style pizza! Super good customer service and clean restaurant. What a fun find in the middle of nowhere! It was a great place to come for birthday ice cream, too! read more

Tomatoes Pizza Pie - Moose Tracks! - Pizza Near Me - Marysvale, Utah

This place is amazing. I'm a first time customer but was brought by some regulars. If you are looking for a fancy restaurant this isn't the place but if you are looking for the best pizza I have ever had this is the place. Go for the pizza! We had Buffalo chicken and Philly cheesesteak pizza with cheesy bread. It did not disappoint read more

Tomatoes Pizza Pie - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Marysvale, Utah

See all

This was a great find! We stopped here after a short hike. It was one of the only places open on Sunday and we were starving! We had their florentine pizza, hot chicken wings with Frank's sauce, cheese bread, and tortellini. Topped it off with cookies and cream, and coffee ice cream. Super satisfying and we're now in a food coma. Mmmmm..mmm. read more

See all

Amazing pizza, breadsticks, wings and atmosphere!!!! Child friendly! Great indoor and outdoor seating. read more

Tomatoes Pizza Pie - BBQ chicken pizza mmmm - Pizza Near Me - Marysvale, Utah

There are little to no options of eating out in this little town, but it doesn't matter because Tomatoes Pizza Pie is very delicious! Their hand tossed pizza was great, and service as good as you could get for how busy it gets in a tiny town with no where else to eat. I would have given them 5 stars just on the tasteful food alone but they were a bit frantic and forgetful on a few things in our order. All in all a great place to stop and grab a slice of tasteful pie. read more

Awesome pizza but one AWFUL employee ruined our lunch. We moved inside when a table opened up because it was hot outside, the table wasn't fully bussed so we helped out by wiping off the table. This employee came and chewed us out for bussing the table and moving inside. He was extremely and unnecessarily rude. One employee was looking over my shoulder at my phone leaving this review and had the nerve to confront me about it. I told him I work in the food industry and would never treat a customer the way we were treated, and that's when he asked us to take our business elsewhere. Huge invasion of privacy. We all have worked in the food industry and understand how working in a restaurant is, but the way we were treated here was unbelievable. Usually love this place but won't be coming back because of how we were treated. read more

I had the Calzone and my husband the New Yorker pizza. Both were Amazing! We can't wait to get back!

Wow! I travel this beautiful country quite a bit and love finding little diamonds in the rough and this place is certainly a diamond! The pizza is absolutely delicious and don't get me started on the cheese bread! Tons of perfectly melted cheese with a Parmesan blend sprinkled on top of homemade flaky dough. Excellent customer service, very friendly and our lovely waitress made sure our drinks were always full and checked in on us regularly. This place does get busy so make sure you stop in, wait patiently for your table then enjoy! It's definitely worth the stop! read more