Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Tomatoes Pizzeria

    3.3 (43 reviews)
    InexpensivePizza, Cheesesteaks, Burgers
    Closed 11:00 am - 10:00 pm

    Order Tomatoes Pizzeria Takeout or Delivery

    Tomatoes Pizzeria Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Tomatoes Pizzeria

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Some of the best food around, every time I order in never disappointed, love the specialty slices.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Judy W.
    12
    50
    8

    10 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - Tomatoes Pizzeria

    Review Highlights - Tomatoes Pizzeria

    A family member told us we had to try the grandma pizza, and it actually lived up to our expectations!

    Mentioned in 5 reviews

    Read more highlights

    You might also consider

    The Waterfront - Salad served with the Lobster Roll

    The Waterfront

    3.8(134 reviews)
    2.3 mi
    $$

    excited for the jersey shore restaurant week! hubby selected…read morethe waterfront! extensive menu options for a fixed menu for $42.26 person! philadelphia filet tips (5pc) caramelized onion, provolone cheese, demi-glace ala creme, garlic bread! this is a must have!! so delicious! asian calamari sweet thai chili, side ranch blackened grouper napoleon cajun grilled, pan seared crab cake, sauteed spinach, lobster cream sauce, wild grain rice, chef's vegetable gnocchi michaelangelo shrimp, chicken, prosciutto, peas, roasted red peppers, potato gnocchi, vodka sauce! such a large portion- i took the leftover home! bourbon bread pudding chocolate lava cake!! beautiful views overlooking the bay! our server kim c was great! thank you a lovely dinning experience! indoor and outdoor seating rooftop lounge plenty of parking! highly recommend!

    I can't say for sure whether snow on New Year's Day brings good luck, but it certainly brings a…read morewhole lot of joy. Waking up to a fresh snowfall is always a gift--made even better after an exceptional New Year's Eve at The Waterfront NJ Restaurant in Lacey, NJ. This year marked our 35th consecutive celebration with our best friends the Fays, a tradition that grows richer every time we gather. The ballroom was beautifully decorated for the holidays, and the band "Slap Happy" delivered an outstanding performance. With the drinks flowing, at one point, we even found ourselves at the microphone, adding our own spirited contribution to the night. While our table was a bit close to the stage--and the volume certainly matched the energy--the music, dancing, and drinks created a vibrant, festive atmosphere. Angolina, our server, was outstanding, helping to elevate the evening from the moment we arrived. Warm, attentive, and effortlessly efficient, she kept the celebration flowing. We began with our first round of drinks, and I made sure to savor my final dirty martini of the year. After three rounds and plenty of laughter, Angolina returned to take our dinner selections. Jeanne Marshall Schrader chose the jumbo shrimp stuffed with crab, finished with a luxurious lobster‑sherry cream, and served with rice and vegetables -- $35. I opted for the Zuppa D'Pesce: a beautifully prepared combination of jumbo shrimp, sea scallops, crab meat, little neck clams, and mussels in a spicy marinara over linguini -- $42. Carolyn Fay and Bob both selected the GF filet -- an 8oz center-cut topped with compound butter, accompanied by creamy mashed potatoes and a side of demi‑glaze -- $42. It was a flawless New Year's Eve--excellent food, exceptional service, lively entertainment, and the best company to welcome another year together.

    Photos
    The Waterfront - Table decoration

    Table decoration

    The Waterfront
    The Waterfront - Bar

    See all

    Bar

    Caffrey's Tavern Backyard - Berry Fields Salad

    Caffrey's Tavern Backyard

    3.5(191 reviews)
    1.9 mi
    $$

    I have been to this establishment probably half a dozen times in my life, never once had a bad…read moreexperience. Tonight specifically, I went to dinner with my girlfriend for an early Valentine's Day dinner, and had yet another pleasant experience! I ordered a ribeye steak, it was cooked perfectly, which is something that rarely happens at restaurants. It was also very good, one of the best steaks I've ever had, which is especially impressive for a non-steakhouse! I was overall very impressed tonight that it prompted me to leave a review. Not that I haven't been impressed the other times. Our waiter, Chris, was also exceptional. Very speedy and proficient in the serving process. Very accommodating and constantly asking to help. Went above and beyond to ensure us a good experience. The atmosphere every-time I go is great, I always love the southern-like feel with the country music playing, and the clover leaf to highlight Irish heritage! Would recommend this place to anyone, they always deliver a great experience. Look forward to returning as I always do. They have never disappointed! Of course, nobody is perfect besides Jesus. My only critique is how long it took for us to be seated when we first arrived. This, of course, is a good sign for the restaurant, as they're busy! I'm just nitpicking, but I did get impatient while waiting to be seated. After that, I had yet another tremendous experience as always! I wish I was able to give 4.5 stars, because I don't like to give out 5s as nobody is perfect besides Jesus, however 4 stars is too low! Think of this as a 4.5 star review! Well done to Caffrey's as usual, and waiter Chris!

    I must say, the sushi selection is better here, at an Irish bar in NJ, than where I live in Florida!read more

    Photos
    Caffrey's Tavern Backyard
    Caffrey's Tavern Backyard - Burger with porkroll.

    Burger with porkroll.

    Caffrey's Tavern Backyard - Mermaid Water ~ Grey Goose vodka, Bacardi Coconut, Bacardi Pineapple, Blue Curacoo, Pineapple Juice, Splash of Sprite

    See all

    Mermaid Water ~ Grey Goose vodka, Bacardi Coconut, Bacardi Pineapple, Blue Curacoo, Pineapple Juice, Splash of Sprite

    The Lacey Diner

    The Lacey Diner

    4.2(59 reviews)
    0.3 mi
    $

    Food great. Staff great…read more Sadly I'm not down there much but I highly recommend. Dont blink or you will pass it.

    OMG! Somebody call Guy Fieri, this diner is small but mighty. You might miss it, on the opposite…read moreend of a strip mall from a 7-11, and that would be a shame. You don't want to miss the funky and eclectic offerings and "if you're here you're family" atmosphere. Our first visit was for a late breakfast at about 11am on a rainy Sunday of a holiday weekend, so it wasn't surprising that the was a short wait. When the hostess said 20-30 minutes someone else in line immediately responded "it's worth the wait" and I agree. I had the The Waffle Slamwich "alternating layers of bacon, sausage, pork roll, egg & cheese between Belgian waffles with bourbon butter maple syrup." I ordered has browns because I saw an order come out and they looked really good. They were, but we're also unnecessary. The Slamwich was more than enough and I'm a big eater. My wife had French toast and a side of bacon. The portion was also generous but she ate it all som it must have been good. I forgot to ask because I was so busy enjoying the many flavors of my meal. The sweetness of the waffle and syrup perfectly offsetting the salty breakfast meats. Coffe was good, too, and obviously fresh. And my cup was 'magically' refilled every time I set it down. We're planning a trip back for lunch...but not today...still full. Guy says "if it's funky I'll find it" but do yourself a favor and find Lacy Diner first, before word gets around, or you might not get a seat.

    Photos
    The Lacey Diner - Coffee Flight

    Coffee Flight

    The Lacey Diner - Another amazing breakfast special at the Lacey Diner.  "Nutty by Nature"

    Another amazing breakfast special at the Lacey Diner. "Nutty by Nature"

    The Lacey Diner - Closeup of menu front page, showing brekkie sammies.

    See all

    Closeup of menu front page, showing brekkie sammies.

    Captain’s Inn & Tiki Bar - Steak , lobster baked potatoes and onion rings.

    Captain’s Inn & Tiki Bar

    3.8(428 reviews)
    2.1 mi
    $$

    Food was great! Atmosphere a bit dated…read more We dined with you guys and sat near a table of 2 men and a child that were not very nice to the waitress. The waitress handled herself with such grace and kindness after the man continued to give her a hard time. Later, I listened as he requested for her to ask the manager to take off a percentage for him being he was a veteran. After she walked away, they started laughing and the one guy said, you're too much. It was clear that he wasn't being honest. He certainly wasn't a veteran and sadly the couple we were with has a son serving in the military. Unfortunately, this man took advantage of this opportunity and I was upset to see that someone would lie about serving our country. I did compliment the waitress for handling that table with dignity after being treated so poorly. She did say they honored a 10% off discount for him and it wasn't warranted because he lied. Kudos to your wait staff for dealing with rude customers and liars.

    My best friend for over 35 years treated to my favorite spot. We wanted to go somewhere local that…read moredoesn't disappoint. The food is always delicious and always friendly service. We are so privileged to live by the Jersey shore. The views from the windows are beautiful! The blueberry pie Martini is a must, not too sweet. My favorite dishes are the crab cakes, crab cake Panini, salmon Panini no bread extra salad as a side, escargot, shrimp and scallop scampi, artichoke Frances, jumbo carrot cake, and the ahi tuna. When in the area definitely go.

    Photos
    Captain’s Inn & Tiki Bar - Prime rib night

    Prime rib night

    Captain’s Inn & Tiki Bar - Delicious dessert

    Delicious dessert

    Captain’s Inn & Tiki Bar

    See all

    Diesel's Subs & Wraps

    Diesel's Subs & Wraps

    4.2(69 reviews)
    2.5 mi
    $$

    I placed an order online through DoorDash for pickup ASAP and it said it would be ready by 12:55…read morePM. This happened last sunday and there were no customers inside. Since we had a little time, we decided to stop at Walmart first to grab a few things before picking up the order. When we finally arrived, we let them know we were there to pick up. The two girls at the register looked at me and my friend like they had no idea where our order was. After I showed them the order confirmation, they suddenly realized and said, "Oh, it's the big order." Then, instead of resolving it right away, they told us that someone else had already taken our order because they gave it to the wrong person. What really frustrated me was their reaction; they just stood there looking at us like, "Okay... what do you want us to do?" Eventually, they asked if we wanted them to remake it. Of course I said yes, we had already paid for it. We ended up waiting even longer while they remade the entire order, which completely defeated the purpose of ordering ahead. What's worse is that they never called or gave us any kind of heads-up about the mistake. If they knew the order had been given away, why not contact us right away? That way, we would have known when to come, or at least they could have started remaking it immediately. On top of all that, we were not compensated in any way; no apology beyond the bare minimum, no discount, nothing for the inconvenience and extra time we had to wait due to their mistake. It just doesn't make sense that they waited until we showed up, confused and looking for our food, before deciding to fix their mistake. The lack of communication, urgency, and accountability made an already frustrating situation even worse.

    Firstly time customer today. Ordered the meatball sub special. 10/10, loved it. Roll, cheese, sauce…read moreand meatballs all on point. Definitely will be back. Old school deli vibe and friendly service.

    Photos
    Diesel's Subs & Wraps
    Diesel's Subs & Wraps
    Diesel's Subs & Wraps

    See all

    Tomatoes Pizzeria - pizza - Updated June 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...