Excellent food Changing choices & menu Good service Reasonable prices Definitely repeat customer TY read more

So this was the first time here. The pizza was flat out disgusting. The pizza was like frozen dough cafeteria pizza. The cheese and all cooked on top and the inside/bottom raw. I wouldn't eat that again. Maybe their thin crust is better idk. The chicken franchise sauce was lemony and good. The chicken quality was just okay for me. They put the pie back in the oven and only the cheese cooked more. The dough was still doughy. They offered to make another pie or take it off the bill. We opted off the bill. I'd get the same dough. I won't come back. If people like this pizza and this is normal, people need to try real Pizza. This place belongs on kitchen nightmares imo. The ambiance is basic. The waitress we tipped well wasn't her fault. Nothing else to say. read more

Steak sandwich was dry and not nearly enough meat. Plus the quality of the meat could be better considering some of the other fabulous things we have had. The meatball sliders are delicious. The rice ball special is fantastic. Also have not had a bad slice and we have had a lot. read more

Large slices. Friendly service. I love their bottled root beer. They give 3% discount for cash. I like the grandma pizza, and they also have a penne ala vodka one too. The slices are sized larger than any local spot, and the flavor is not bad. They have the line up of garlic, red peppers and oregano to top off the taste. It's a pizza joint, ok for groups and casual. read more

Mangia Brick Oven Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

The food is outstanding! I've been here many times and have the chicken Toscana, absolutely delicious! Meatball sliders were really good! Brought friends last time and everyone was so happy. Staff is always so nice. Cute dining area with big windows overlooking busy shopping center. read more

Mangia Brick Oven Pizza - Chicken Toscana - Pizza Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

Another great meal at Mangia in Toms River, NJ. Our server "Carmen" aka Carmela is really good at serving guests. We decided to try the "2 for $40" weekly specials, served Monday-Thursday, and we were very impressed. We started with a shared appetizer, Eggplant Rollatini, a Caesars salad and house salad. Our main course we decided on Chicken Parm and Chicken Francene, both very good and a shared dessert of cheese cake which we took home. Great service, Great food and we did not break the bank to go out to dinner. Thank you Mangia, keep up the great work. read more

We finally tried Mangia Brick Oven Pizza. We heard it was good. We thought it was so good, we ordered it again the next day!! We've only done pick up and delivery. Perfect crust, perfect pizza every time! Excellent service, friendly staff. We certainly found our go-to pizza spot! Thank you Mangia of TR. we love the Margherita Pizza with hot peppers! Delicious! read more

The best pizza in Toms River! I have eaten all over the area...staff was amazing Good energy and very busy! read more

Mangia Brick Oven Pizza - Palermo slice! So good! - Pizza Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

I was extremely hungry for some wings, and garlic parmesan seemed very appetizing. When I got my wings delivered they were WET, small, and extremely bready. It felt like I was eating a fried piece of breading with no chicken. Yes, chicken comes in all different sizes, but these wings were the size of a chicken nugget. Do not get the wings. The pizza & delivery time was good though! read more

One of mine and my families favorite places to eat. The food and the service are exceptional. I love how the staff are always so friendly and always helpful. I would recommend this amazing place to everyone. The best restaurant/ pizzeria in town . read more

Nice place to grab a quick slice to eat. Staff is friendly and inside is big and roomy. There are Many varieties of pizza for you to pick from. I tried the grandma slice. It was ok not the best I've had, the sauce had nice flavor mood was pretty good. read more

Mangia Brick Oven Pizza - Grandma slice pretty big slices. - Pizza Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

Best Italian Food in Manchester NJ. I come from NY and I have been unable to find anything like NY and I finally found it. Thank You! read more

Mangia Brick Oven Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

If you're in the Tom's River area and haven't tried Mangia Pizza, you're seriously missing out. The food is consistently excellent every single time -- and that's rare these days. The pizza is outstanding across the board. Whether you're ordering a classic cheese pie, specialty slices, or something loaded with toppings, it's always perfectly cooked, flavorful, and fresh. You can tell they care about quality. Their heroes -- both hot and cold -- are just as impressive. Generous portions, fresh bread, high-quality ingredients, and made exactly right every time. And let's talk about the garlic knots... absolutely off the hook. Soft, buttery, loaded with garlic and flavor -- easily some of the best around. What really sets Mangia apart is the attention to detail. The packaging is always neat and secure, everything arrives hot, organized, and looking great. Delivery is flawless, and the staff is consistently pleasant and professional -- always showing up with a smile. It's clear this place takes pride in what they do. Reliable, delicious, and top-notch service every time. Mangia Pizza is a staple in Tom's River for a reason. Highly recommend! read more

That guy Billy is the man. Pizza is spectacular. There's nothing like getting a workout in at planet fitness then slaying half a pie!

one of the workers were very disrespectful and spoke to me and my friends out of line while we were paying customers, wouldn't recommend.

We have ordered from mangia loyally and regularly for a decade. Today we ordered 2 large pies, well done, extra sauce. They came to us with the cheese and toppings slid off the pie. We called within minutes of the driver leaving and the owner told us our only remedy was to give the pies back and wait for them to send new ones. I explained the driver was welcome to come see them and asked if we could keep at least 1 of the pies for our kids to have one of the couple salvagable slices, as they'd been waiting an hour to eat. He refused repeatedly and insisted we return the pies and wait the time again for delivery. We tip well and order OFTEN. I asked if it was really worth losing our business over 1 pie that wasnt our mistake (it had clearly been tilted in delivery) and he said that it was. Luckily there are dozens of pizza places within a few miles of my home. We are SO disappointed in Mangia that this is my very first review. read more

The food was okay and found the place to be loud, but the owner definitely lacks customer service skills. His display of arrogance to me as a customer made my visit unpleasant. I would never return there nor would I recommend this place. A pleasant atmosphere and customer service can be just as important as food quality. read more

Walked in with my friend and one of the older women working there was immediately rude, scoffing when my friend said she needed a minute to look at the slice choices. All i got was a diet pepsi and they looked annoyed and it took 3 people to ring up a drink. When they gave me my drink the girl slammed it on the counter and just said, "THERE." The staff was extremely rude for no reason, can't see myself going back. Also the business reply is unfortunately completely untrue as i do have the correct place. And yes i just joined yelp to write this review because this is the first time i truly felt that i should. Maybe instead of replying with a completely unprofessional attitude, talk to your staff about basic manners. Thank you. read more

Disappointing experience. We stopped at Mangia while traveling through Tom's River. A cute pizzeria tucked into a shopping center near the parkway, or so we thought. Upon entering we saw a full staff, everyone hanging behind to counter but no smiles or greeting when we entered. We were then approached by someone and asked what we wanted, but slightly rude with no facial expressions and didn't seem to want to talk about the display case. We ordered 3 slices and an Italian hero .. for $30, paid in cash, and weren't given a receipt. The cashier didn't ask if we wanted one (which is the final step in service) or offer a pleasant closing. There was absolutely no personality, or small talk with their customer base. We waited for our hero while finishing our slices, then after finishing our slices had to ask if it was ready. To where they replied "oh yes, it's right here" Strange that they didn't bring it out after knowing it was ready AND paid for. To top it off, I asked for a box for the leftover slice, we packed it up and went to the car. Upon eating it I found a hair baked into the cheese. Which I would have seen if they allowed customers to pick any table they wanted at lunch, but they put "slice customers" in the back with no good lighting. And by then we were too far to go back. Not what we expected for $30. read more

See all

Called in my order told 20 min paid for it so I couldn't really leave. And 40 minutes later I get my pizza

I've been coming here for the past few years specifically for their paninis and they never miss! The turkey club paninis specifically are so fresh, flavorful and delicious, and last me at least two meals, making it a great value for the price. The restaurant itself is definitely more pizza-centric, and their pizza is good, but their other menu items are surprisingly good. I've dined in here a few times and it has also been a good experience. It's a busy pick-up pizzeria, so it definitely has that look and feel but their dining area is separate and cozy. The friendliness of the servers could definitely be improved but that's my only complaint! read more

Mangia Brick Oven Pizza - Turkey club panini - Pizza Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

We grabbed a whole Chicken Padrino sandwich and couldn't have been happier with it. The bread was perfect, grilled chicken flavorful, and a perfect balance of flavors between the fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers, and the outstanding balsamic. It may be a perfect sandwich. We will definitely be back! read more

I ordered the Brooklyn style pizza and it is the first time I could not eat it. The crust was so tuff I couldn't bite into it. My husband's dinner was great. But when I said something about they refunded me $3 . I'm not one to complain but it was badGrandmas Pizza read more

Mangia Brick Oven Pizza - The crust from grandmas Brooklyn style pizza. Could not bit through crust - Pizza Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

See all

The godfather grandma pie is insane! The most amazing vodka sauce and crispy chicken. It is pricey but it is a special treat in our house! read more

Mangia Brick Oven Pizza - The Godfather Grandma Pie - Pizza Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

Sauce is amazing. Pizza is delic. Rice balls are a meal in themselves. We had the shrimp and eggplant parm for dinner. Both incredible. Be ready to take food home. Definitely a five star restaurant. Jess is an amazing waitress handling orders, table cleaning and set up and all other requests. Thank you for a great night. Oh BYOB. read more

my friend abby recently left a review and the service from an older LOOKING lady was just a tad bit rude. younger people were pretty nice but an older looking lady had an unnecessary attitude when it could have been handled a lot more nicely lol it was all over a damn diet pepsi read more

Pizza here is delicious! My favorite slice was the Palermo. The rice ball was huge, definitely enough to share

Unbelievable 11.50 for this salad. I know there is inflation but this is unacceptable. This salad used to be cheaper and almost double the size. Never again. If my wife and kids didn't like your pizza I'd never order again. read more

Mangia Brick Oven Pizza - True blue salad - Pizza Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

I had the Buffalo Chicken Pizza. Great! More importantly, the owner said "thank you", and "have a good day" when I left. It may seem like a little thing, but those simple courtesies can really make the bad day. I was having a little better. I will definitely be back. read more

This place used to be amazing. I'm not sure what happened. We ordered a cheesesteak and two slices. The cheesesteak was was cold and the slices looked like this.... That's supposed to be a chicken bacon ranch slice. read more

Mangia Brick Oven Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

Food was delicious. The gravy/sauce was excellent. Two issues: 1) I have never been to an Italian Restaurant where bread was not provided with an entree and 2) there were a few empty tables that needed to be cleaned and used dishes were piled on top of the garbage receptacle instead of having someone bus and clean the tables. Just leaves a bad impression re cleanliness. read more

Always fresh, generous portions. Yup I drive 35 minutes to get pizza and dinner here. read more

Best pizzeria in Toms River, they do an amazing job every time. Meatball sliders are of legend, pizza top notch, I love the Sicilian with half eggplant. Salads are always fresh, I can't say enough good things about Mangia, my go-to delivery since we moved down from Bergen County, keep up the great work! read more

The grand ma pizza was good, except for the edge of the crust was a little too crusty. i would give it a 3.5 stars.

We ordered lasagna and Caesar salad to go. My Italian New Jersey family eats her all the time and swears by the food. The owner is from Sicily and is very engaging and a delight to speak with. He'll talk for hours about his trips to Italy and has plenty of travel advice for those of you planning a visit to Italy. Don't be fooled by the strip mall appearance - it's an awesome restaurant inside with a huge brick oven. I can't wait to come back and try the pizza!! read more

Mangia Brick Oven Pizza - The pizza oven! - Pizza Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

The food, service and complete atmosphere is top notch. They always make you feel like family and management will go out of their way to make sure you have what you need. They are known for their pizza but we love the spaghetti marinara. Unreal! read more

Stopped by because I was early to an appointment that was in the area and I'd been eyeing them every time I drove by. I wasn't sure what to expect, if it was a sitdown type of place, or if you order at the counter and then pick your food up when your order is called. I still can't tell ya- it seems to be some mix between the two. I was feeling a little pasta with marinara, but once I saw their self-proclaimed famous penne vodka, I figured I'd give that a shot. Also ordered some garlic knots since I can never resist those at this sort of place. I ordered at the counter and sat down at a nearby table. The garlic knots were smaller, and came as an order of 6. I appreciate the smaller size, because I didn't have to worry about getting garlic on my face. They were soft and garlicky and tasted great. The penne vodka came out quickly. At first I thought it was okay- there was something else in there that they use, but I just could not identify it. The portion was a little smaller than expected. The taste grew on me, but I wouldn't say I loved it- although, the leftovers tasted great. It came with a piece of bread and butter, which I only had a little bit of, as I did not particularly prefer how they spiced it. I was also a little confused about tipping. I've always been told that you don't tip at a place where you order at the counter because they're not "waiting" on you, but I feel bad when the option is on the receipt. I tipped a few bucks, thinking I'd pick up my food and sit down and be done with it. But the guy was really friendly and kept coming over to check on me and bring me/offer me things. I wish I'd tipped more, but I didn't know I was going to get some sort of service as well. Kind of confusing. I'd come here again, but I think I'd try either the pizza or pasta with marinara sauce (my go-to). read more

See all

Here goes one of my very infrequent one star reviews. I will try not to rant, but rather to keep this review as useful as possible to someone interested in ordering pizza from here. Their delivery service is not reliable. In my instance today, the pizza never came after an hour and forty five minute wait. This is despite the fact that my apartment building is located right behind their store. I never got my pizza. I had to argue with them to cancel the order at that point, but I don't want a cold one delivered to me close to 2 hours late. If they were in fact slammed, they could have just told me before I ordered. I don't recommend to order pizza delivery from here. read more

Great stop for a quick pizza. We were driving on the turnpike. Called 15 minutes ahead, pizza was ready and hot. Crunchy crust and tasty sauce! Pepperoni is my favorite. read more

pizza tasted a few days old and we called and ordered a pie. crust was chewy and took forever to chew. antipast was pathetic for the price super disappointed. this place keeps going down hill read more