Always fast service and employees always nice. Ice cream size is also great! Would visit again

Great ice cream! Always quick and polite service. Also, this is in such a central location! Right across from a Wawa it's hard to not stop in every time i get gas. read more

I have had Toni's Treats many times over the last few years, and a few of my favorites are the tator tots, quesadillas, and ice cream pies. I called the store on December 21st, and even though they are closed for the holidays, the owner answered the phone through her cell and let me order an icecream cake for my mom's birthday on the 22nd! She came in while they were closed, customized the cake, and even came in earlier than what we arranged for a pickup because my plans changed. Not only is it a great business that gives back to the community, but they have great food and the best costumer service! We will be getting our birthday icecream cakes only from Toni's from now on. (ps the cake was delicious!!) read more

Toni's Treats - Birthday icecream cake! - Desserts Near Me - Malaga, New Jersey

I had the foot long hotdog it was incredibly average! The rest of family had the ice cream which seemed good! Neat place though always wanted to stop so we finally did! 3.5 stars overall! read more

Toni's Treats - Desserts Near Me - Malaga, New Jersey

It is what it is: a great go-to spot when you're in the right mood. Don't cross the owner, she got really mad one time, over a misunderstanding. read more

They have the creamiest, amazing soft serve ice cream. During the "lock-down" Toni's figures out how to make it work. Nice job Tracie.

So I work around the corner from here and decided to give it a go. They advertise themselves as an ice cream parlor that serves food. Good food at that. I heard their hotdogs were on point so I decided to get 'The Boxer Dog'. I'm not a huge fan of Chili and was worried there would either be too much of it and it would soak my bun or it would have no flavor but it was perfect. The Chili was the right amount where I was still able to enjoy everything else on the hotdog but I couldnt eat the thing full on. I had to cut it up and eat it with a fork, nonetheless it was pretty tasty. The ice cream sandwich was huge! They had a whole bunch of flavors too. I would definitely come back here to try other items in their expansive menu. read more

Toni's Treats - Cookie ice cream sandwich - Desserts Near Me - Malaga, New Jersey

See all

Toni's is an awesome little ice cream/hamburger joint right in the center of Malaga. They have 51 flavors of soft serve, some I can remember are: blueberry, peach, butterscotch, grape, caramel, mocha, pineapple, lemon, apple pie, cotton candy, peanut butter and many others. They have a lot of different toppings, cones, water ice, and hand dipped ice cream to choose from.. as well as offering custom ice cream cakes, ice cream sandwiches, and cupcakes here. During the summer time this place has a line out to the street and they're open pretty late (I think until 2am during summer). They have some indoor and outdoor seating and they also serve hamburgers, hot dogs, cheese steaks, and a few other items that are good. Nice place to satisfy your sweet tooth, for sure! read more

We live a few miles away from Toni's treats. We go here often during the summer. My favorite is Malaga Lake sundae and my kids like the brownie and also strawberry shortcake sundae. We also like their sandwiches and fries. It's always busy and the owner is really nice. read more

Their large milkshakes are small and they are almost 6$ it was good so I didn't complain but then my girlfriend got a cookie cone and it was stale,possible mold. read more

I ordered delivery, the boxer dog and nachos. The hot dog was one of the best I'd ever had! The nachos were fresh and served in a chopped way; really good American food. read more

Excellent custard/ice cream food shop. Owner is very nice & remembers her customers. They use good quality custard & ingredients. Fast service & average pricing. Convenient location. Has indoor/outdoor areas. Best for takeout. Get the frequent buyer card. read more

Love this place good custard and good prices. They have a large variety of food and treats. A must try

Toni's Treats is an awesome ice cream and hot dog stand. If you are looking for over complicated fancy food, then this isn't the spot for you. If you want great, fresh, tasty and simple foods paired with great desserts then stop in, you won't regret it. I have never had a bad experience or meal here. My family frequents this establishment several times a month and we have tried most of the menu. Stand outs are, of course, the foot longs. They are grilled to perfection, topped with any one of dozen toppings and served in a fresh soft roll. We, also, come in Tuesday's for the 99 cent tacos. Great price. Fresh made. Delicious. I could go on, but you should just stop in yourself. read more

Food is just ok, prices are high, but we always wait FOREVER! 30+ mins for two cheese steaks and we're the only order here. Wouldn't left if we didn't already pay. Unbelievable, won't be back. read more

Toni's treats is an awesome place to get so mnay things. Everyone should check this place out. The quality of food is great and the menu is just right. The only real critical feedback I have is that they could organize their processes a bit more, I've had issues with orders in the past. read more

Waited over 20 minutes for a quesadilla and two ice cream cones. Very overpriced and not worth the wait.

Excellent custard/ice cream. My favorite place to go. Although they also serve food, I have only had custard so can't comment on anything else. They have a nice seating area outside and also have indoor seating. read more

FYI Tracy has been a huge part of the community from buddy weens to Toni's treats and a local pub . Tracey's mom is still alive and makes the best chili & egg salad! Egg salad is not on the menu just ask ! You won't regret it! read more

"Closed in 8 mins?" Nope not really, we just pulled off the highway to make a quick ice cream stop and they were closed 15 mins early.

We stumbled across Toni's Treats while passing through Malaga. We were looking to do a casual late dinner and Toni's was perfect! We had grilled cheese, chicken tenders, and peppers and egg sandwich. Everything was delicious! The water ice was the best I've ever had; Ice cream sandwich was the biggest I've ever seen; The key lime parfait was amazing. The whole family loved Toni's and the kids are already talking about going back even though we live 35 min away. The servers and owner were so nice with smiles all around. I highly recommend Toni's Treats! read more

Service is great don't get me wrong. However the food quality was sub par, especially for the price. 8 Dollars for an ice cream. Try somewhere else if you are more worried about food quality then service. read more

They have a food menu besides just the ice cream and a Taco Tuesday special. Indoor dining area is small but there are also outdoor tables and benches. They have an end of the year sale when quarts of their DIY hand dipped are on sale. The prices are a bit expensive for what you get. read more