Stopped in about 20 minutes ago. Stood there for a good few minutes. No one asked if I needed any help. There was someone behind the counter and someone sitting down (not sure if he worked there). What kind of customer service is that? I walked out of there without anything. That is definitely not the way to run a business and the owner might want to reconsider who they hire. read more

The spinach Alfredo roll is my favorite. Great to share or you can have it for a couple days. Reheats nicely. The Mario salad chopped is perfection. I have to say Tony makes the best cauliflower pizza on Long Island. His regular style pizzas are great too. Great staff and super friendly. He has about 4-6 tables for sit down. Order in, take out, or delivery food quality remains the same! read more

See all

I tried here twice. Once on last month and today. Their pizza itself is great. So I want to give five stars for the taste. However their customer service needs to be improved. The last time I went there to pick up, boys were chatting. Even they saw me coming, they did not end it. Finally one boy decided to help me after a few minutes. He did not greet. Boys are like my son's age so I can be careless about all those. Like "Kids being kids". Whatever. Then this one guy in the back asked me how many cuts did i wanted for Upside Down Sicilian Pie, which is rectangular shape. I wanted just regular square cut so I told him "I have no preference". I came home and checked the pizza excitedly and found my Sicilian Pie was cut into triangles. Same way you see when you buy regular cheese pie being cut triangles. I was super confused. However I thought I should give a second chance so I did today. Again, pizza was great and bad customer service. Even their pizza is good, I am not going back any time soon. I hope grown ups train kids better and numbers of customer will double. I just hope them good luck. read more

Still great. Went LN and the man behind counter was telling jokes making my kids laugh

Picked up a vodka pie to go. Crust was more of a bready style. 8 slice, rectangular shaped pie was $25. There was a delay with our takeout order. read more

BEST PIZZA! Had a great interaction with the guy at the front who was pleasant AF. I will also say that I love pizza and wouldn't give a review unless it actually were not a waste of money in this economy. We can thank Donald FACIST Trump for lowering the GDP. Guess eggs must be less expensive so it was hella worth it. read more

Stoped by here on the way home only because the reviews here on Yelp. I am sorry to say it wasn't a great pie. With new pizza places now making great pies with great char and crispy bottom I was disappointed that this was just another ordinary pie with no reason to come back. Came back tonight again to give them another chance. I called in my order and ask for the pie to be charred. Got them told the guy I called for a pie make it charred. The mistake I made is I believed he actually listened to me so when I got the pie I didn't open it. When I got home I saw the whitest flimsiest floppy pizza I saw in many years. If the owner is there and he lets kids run this place to the ground than it's his fault. Will not giving them another try. read more

Ordered Super Bowl Sunday waited and never got my order it was canceled like an hour after I put order in

Pizza , Pasta , Service Owner Employees are the best. This pizzeria is well run. We need more pizzerias like this. My favorite pizzeria. !!! read more

We got the "Meat Lovers Pizza" yesterday for dinner. It was honestly the best pizza we've had in a while. Delivery takes a long time and I've had a few minor issues with them in the past regarding delivery. This is the only reason they get 4 rather than 5 stars from me. read more

Tony D's pizzeria - "Meat Lovers Pizza" - Pizza Near Me - Hewlett, New York

See all

Nonnas drunken vodka was only 6 slices (not a full pizza to fill the box). A lot of dough. Probably won't order again

I've only ordered To go from here twice and each time was better than the last! Their sauce is very rich and tasteful. They are no strangers to taste and quality. I absolutely love that they put loads of sauce in their pasta and it's not dry. Very tasty! Also side note, they deliver!! Order via slice. Grub hub's prices are slightly higher than through Slice. read more

Tony D's pizzeria - Rigatoni Alla Vodka - Pizza Near Me - Hewlett, New York

Decent pizza FINALLY. It's literally the only pizza place in the entire 5 towns area that I would pay to get pizza from and it's decent, I'm far from blown away. It's pretty clean in there, doesn't seem like they allow bathroom for non paying public because someone asked and they said it was broken. I've been disappointed by every single pizza place around Hewlett and the rest of the 5 towns and finally I can get pizza around here instead of driving all the way to Queens, Elmont or Valley Stream. read more

Best pizza around. Sauce is authentic. Everything is fresh and delicious. Priced right. Great variety of pizza-to-go and friendly staff. I won't order pizza or Italian from anywhere else. read more

Best pizza and Italian dishes to take out in area.All varieties are excellent including the new cauliflower crust.

I'm in sales and was driving up Peninsula Blvd and realized I had to eat lunch soon. I stopped in a little strip mall and went to this pizza place. Doesn't look like much from the front but what a great surprise! They have a really nice selection of specialty pies. I especially love the one with tomatoes and onions chopped on top. The size of it is insane and it's delicious. I also got a regular slice which is as good as any pizza I've had on Long Island. What I really like is that the owner was behind the counter and he has a great way with people. Sadly, I go into delis, pizzerias, Chinese places, etc. on a regular basis and I'm often times treated like I'm a nuisance. Not here. They have great pizza at great prices and they treat you like they value your business. Highly recommend. I will be back. Looking forward to checking out some of the other things on the menu. read more

Saw that a new pizza spot had opened up in the King Kullen lot and decided to check them out. We tried the regular slice; the sauce was solid and the crust was nice as well. We also got their vodka slice and yum! It was larger than a normal grandma-esque slice, no complaints there. The vodka sauce was also seriously good. I'll be back soon! read more

Tony D's pizzeria - Giant vodka slice - Pizza Near Me - Hewlett, New York

Ok so went in to try the pizza at the new pizza place that opened up in the Hewlett King Kullen shopping center. Walked in and it's a very nicely decorated small place with a few tables and pizza counter. I was having a seriously hard time deciding on a slice because they all looked awesome. No legit I was standing at the counter for a good 5 minutes. At the owner's suggestion I ate a Mac and cheese with bacon slice while I waited for my pepperoni pie to be made. I ate that Mac and cheese slice too quickly to even think of taking a picture but it was sooooo good! The pepperoni pie was also really good. The pizzas ingredients tasted very fresh, came out hot and quickly, and tasted fantastic. The staff was very friendly with everyone that walked in. I will definitely be a repeat customer! read more

Tony D's pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Hewlett, New York

Pizza is a 6 Place is not clean Person taking orders on the phone is a Joke and the owner doesn't care.... Walked in last week guy making the pizza NO Mask 2 delivery guys standing over the pizza display No Masks read more

Ordered a Heart shaped pizza for Valentine's Day from Tony D's Pizzeria. Nice and crispy. Delicious and tasty! The sauce and cheese was amazing! A 10 in my book. Would happily recommend this pizzeria to anyone. The owner and staff very pleasant! read more

Tony D's pizzeria - Heart shaped pizza. Valentine's Day.. - Pizza Near Me - Hewlett, New York

Love this place. Ordered the most delicious Italian food tonight from Tony D's. Everyone raved about the food. Anthony really knows how to take care of his customers. We got delivery to our beach club in Atlantic Beach. They deliver to the 5 towns and all the beach clubs in AB. Everything we ordered was amazing. Mario's salad, Caesar Salad, garlic knots, OG pizza, Drunken Nonna Vodka pizza, chicken parm, chicken bruschetta, penne garlic and oil, sautéed broccoli and spinach, shrimp Oregonata, Eggplant, and penne Vodka sauce. We asked for 5:30 and they were exactly on time. Would totally recommend for a casual dinner or catering for a party. Food is top notch and so is the service. Well done, Anthony! read more

Tony D's pizzeria - Drunken Nonna Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hewlett, New York

See all

The pizza here is probably one of the best in the area. I love it. The reason I am giving 3 stars is because of two reasons. The girl that takes the order at the register needs better customer service. She doesn't acknowledge or show she does at least what your saying and I feel she ignores me. Secondly, we have a virus going on, and in any food establishment you should be using gloves when handling food ESPECIALLY after you just touched money. Very unsanitary. Again the food is good but with these factoring in, I don't think its worth it. read more

Picked up a quick lunch of four slices and sodas and was pleasantly surprised at how great the slices were! Two were upside Sicilians for my husband I had a mixed veggie slice and a bruschetta slice ( both flat and square) they were crispy and delicious! Definitely Try them out read more

The pizza here is GREAT. the 3 stars are solely due to the garlic knots. It looks like cinnamon rolls, but alas, these are burned garlic knots. It didn't look good and it didn't taste good. It's unbelievable they saw these come out of the oven and still chose to serve this to a customer. Never get the knots here. read more

Tony D's pizzeria - Burned garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - Hewlett, New York

Knowing Anthony since elementary school thru high school, I couldnt wait to try his pizza when I saw it in the paper. Living an hour away I went to my parents house to finally try the pizza. Now being keto I went for the caulifower pizza. I got the cauliflower marinara and the ricotta pesto which I forgot to take a picture. They were both delicious, nothing was left. I couldnt believe it was cauliflower. I also got the burrata which was just as good. My parents got the cheese and sausage, pepper, and onion. Everyone loved it. I wish Anthony all the best of luck. read more

Tony D's pizzeria - Cauliflower marinara - Pizza Near Me - Hewlett, New York

My chicken roll's dough was not cooked on the inside. I know pizza places slightly undercook dough and it's not flaky entirely, but this was the absolute worse I've ever had. At first I thought it was cheese, but then I realized it was dough. I've made pizza dough at home soo many times that I know the consistently of it very well. You can see in the pictures that in the bread, there's a layer that's a little more white (that's uncooked) and in the other picture- the left is the uncooked part and the right piece is cheese (you can tell because cheese gets oily when cooked). Gave 2 stars because it still tasted really really good, I just had to pick it apart and only eat the cooked parts. read more

Tony D's pizzeria - chicken roll - Pizza Near Me - Hewlett, New York

See all

Good food and service. Always enjoy their cheese pizza and their grandma. Also good chicken cutlet.

Great pizza , friendly and clean . Probably the best on Long Island for sure the best in Nassau county

Absolutely superb! It's all about the little things done right. Tony and his crew knock it out of the park! The Drunken Nona will leave your tastebuds in euphoria as it's unlike anything else you've ever had! The overall hospitality made me feel as family. Good people, great, food, beyond satisfied! read more

Right next to King Kullen, this pizzeria makes a great pizza. Tony has a great selection and if you want something they don't have all you have to do is ask. He made me a spaghetti pie that was fantastic. read more

Friends and family recommended this place. Its excellent. The pizza is delicious and fresh. We got sever different pies and they were all very good. Highly recommend read more

Tony D's has a unique regular slice. Different than all local pizza. Terrific sauce, awesome crust. Also try the Mario salad, it's one of my family's favorites. I've had the chicken rolls and they are excellent as well. The owner is very friendly and makes everyone feel welcome. Definitely try this new local pizza, they deliver too! read more

I stopped in for lunch one day and it was ok at best. Its super thin pizza with thick crust if you're into that sort of thing. The regular slice I had did not pass the fold test. I wouldn't advise anyone not to go here, but I most likely will not be back read more

Wow!!!! Absolutely delicious!!! We ordered regular pies, pepperoni and Sicilian pie. Soooo good!!! Delicious!!!!

The best New Pizza place in town, with a large variety of different types of pizza plus appetizers to full entrees

Nope. I had hopes for this new place. Under seasoned meatballs. Untoasted bread despite specific order.

Tony D's has turned that pizza shop rite side up since the last owners. the food speaks for itself. it's amazing and FRESH. My family and I have not been disappointed since we stated getting food there. everything from the pizza to pastas to salads is delicious. Not 1 complaint Tony and his crew they will do anything to meet your needs! Deff stop in and grab a slice!! read more

Great pizza. Grandma was fresh and on point, and the regular pie was well done and crispy. Dough was tasty and flaky, and almost a little sweet like a savory zeppole. read more

Had my Christmas dinner catered. Best food ever. Ziti, chicken parm, veal Marsala, sausage and peppers. Great price, delivered as promised. I will def use them again. I highly recommend Tony D's. read more

Ordered the grandma pizza like 4 weeks ago n it was really good pizza.abd the pizza came pretty quickly.staff was nice on the phone.will def order again read more