Tony's Coneys is a west side staple. Lotsa steps to enter and exit the building - be aware if you have any challenges with steps. We visited on the hottest day in July. Their AC struggled to keep up but it was fine inside. We selected 2 coneys from the specials menu and received 2 coneys with mustard. Onion, sauce and cheese (can be customized), a bag of chips and a small milk shake for $8.50. plenty of food and a hreat deal! Tony's milkshake board of available flavors was amazing! They have thought of everything you could possibly want! Order at the counter, grab an seat and your food will be delivered. Sorry no pictures. I arrived hungry and gobbled up those dogs as fast as I could! read more

I was craving a coney dog, and thanks to Yelp I ended up here at Tony's mostly because I saw the prices compared to the other coneys in town and no way I am paying $8 for a damn hotdog somewhere else. LOL. You pull up to an older house that's been converted into the restaurant, and it could use some maintenance :) but these are the kinds of places I love to find. Small dining area, maybe 6 tables seating 2-4 people each. It was warm today (Saturday around 1pm) and it was pretty busy both for dine-in/to-go and drive through. Unlike alot of other reviews everyone was incredibly friendly and service was reasonably quick. My onion rings and my son's tenders were HOT so they were fresh. Onion rings were pretty well done, but I like them that way. Others may disagree. I had a coney w/ mustard, chili, onion and it looked pretty unassuming. However, it was a little flavor bomb. I found the chili to be flavorful, and they use the tiny diced onions that were perfect for a coney. I went back for a second one with cheese. They were a little stingy with the coney toppings, but at least is was easy to eat. Maybe a little more cheese would be nice. Like someone said, the chili needs to be hotter, it was luke warm. PB and banana shake was awesome, with real chunks of banana in it. It was a hit with my picky 10yr olds and the price was definitly right for a tasty filling lunch. I'm a native Hoosier, so I'll have to put their tenderloin to the test next time and report back. read more

Order at the counter and the servers will bring you your meal. The food is tasty and the prices are great. I love the Hershey brand ice cream. My favorite flavor is Cappuccino Crunch! I ordered the kid size dip this time. This place is always busy inside or through the drive in. Expect to wait a few minutes for your order. The teenagers working here do a great job with the accuracy of the orders. There is a tv playin the dining room. I will be back! read more

See all

This is a hidden gem on the west side. The coney's are amazing and there icecream/shakes are great too! The only downside is that they are closed on Sundays! read more

We love coming here for lunch and a treat. It is affordable with plenty to choose from (hamburger, hot dogs, pork tenderloin, french fries, onion rings, fried mushrooms, and so much more). The food is made to order and very delicious. They have soft serve and hard ice cream. there is limited seating inside. It is always clean inside and out. Everyone is always so pleasant. read more

First time at Tony's, I've passed this place a few times and have waiting to try it. It was so convient that they had a drive thru, however the food was sub par. The sauce was not super hot and didn't have much flavor. The fried pickles was good, I usually like mine in chips rather spears. But I'll go back again and try their ice cream when it comes summer time! read more

See all

They took very long and gave me the wrong order. will not be eating here again. I ordered 2 milkshakes and gave something completely different. read more

A great place to grab lunch. Always busy at lunchtime. Parking at a minimum. Dogs are good. Fries are crisp. We'll be going back. read more

Always friendly, always yummy. We love coming here for ice cream or a quick lunch. You don't see many locally owned business like this anymore. read more

staff very unfriendly, waited in line for over 30 minutes just to order with only 4 people ahead of me. The manager lady was doing nothing to help her staff except eating candy and drinking a pop while she was "training" another person. first time I have ever stopped here and it will be the last. Do not recommend. read more

Yummy coney dogs! Conveniently located right on route 40. Drive thru makes for an easy pick up experience. Friendly service!

Happy to try Tony's Coneys in West Columbus, I got 2 coneys, little extra for fries to substitute chips, got me a special Peppermint Oreo milkshake, and Diet Dr. Pepper. Delicious coneys milkshake sauce, mustard and onions; but will get cheese on it next time. Crispy fries, but next time onion rings. I enjoyed the Peppermint Oreo milkshake, but will get a chocolate or/and Oreo milkshake. Tony's Coneys is a West side institution since the 1950's. I will be back to Tony's Coneys again soon when I am in the West side of Columbus. read more

Tony's Coneys - 2 coneys - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Absolutely love this place . Prices are so adorable and I believe they should have this restaurant all over town . Get atmosphere where you can eat inside or out places always busy which goes to say they have delicious food. I would highly recommend this to everyone I must try. You won't regret it. I promise it'll be your new favorite. read more

Tony's Coneys - Menu - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

I've always enjoyed Tony's Coneys but they have gotten slower and slower over the last few years. Today I got in line at 6:09 with three cars in front of me. I just left at 6:38 two root beer floats and two hotdogs should not take that long. The three cars in front of me had orders that all looked fairly small as well. I hope the owner sees this and corrects the problem read more

Love this place. It's small. Local. Great food. Great prices. Great service. Has a little outside patio and a drive thru. Sometimes we just crave coneys and this is where we want them from. Great shakes and fries too. Always on our list. If you haven't tried it out, you should! read more

See all

Always wondered about this place so I decided to go out on limb and give them a try because there's always a line of cars wrapped around the building. When I pull up I discover that the line of cars is not because their food is mind blowing or word of mouth but because they don't have a modern drive thru system. They have a all seasons menu board or sign and then you order from your car to a person who takes your order, you pay, then you drive to the next window and pick up your food. You might as well walk in and order yourself because it's the same difference. Not too much digital, kiosk, or speaker systems going on here as the place screams serious MAGA vibes. Nevertheless the guy taking my order was extremely friendly, courteous, and professional. Now to the food. These chili dogs could be made at home with items picked up from ALDIs or Krogers which is not a bad thing but it's like for me if I'm eating out I'd like to taste something unique and not run of the mill. For example, yes you can get Skyline Chili Dog sauce from Krogers but if you order chili dogs from one of their restaurants it's something unique in how it's prepared and executed that just can't quite emulate at home. This point brings me back to this place where you can clearly pull of their dogs, and probably make them better and cheaper if you put in the effort by going to the grocery store and doing them yourself. I prefer an all beef hotdog like a Hebrew National and the hot dogs were definitely your standard fare with the filler/pork/chicken mix etc I guess to keep the cost down. The bun on the one with the works with the Krogers tasting coleslaw on top was extremely soggy. They've got other stuff like malts, fries, onion rings etc but I assumed they'd taste like Krogers or Gordon Food Services items and didn't feel like trying because my expectations were not high. I could be wrong. 4 Stars because even from outwardly appearance of the place it evokes a sense of nostalgia for the surrounding community and looks to have been a staple here for generations which is why I guess people from the surrounding community regularly patronize this place. A few years back they opened up a Franks a little further down on West Broad and nobody gave a damn and it closed down pretty quick. Although Franks is a FAR SUPERIOR and way better tasting hot dog joint, unfortunately it didn't register with the west side of Columbus area community. Moreover although brief, I got excellent customer service and that goes a long way with me. Also 4 stars for the soggy buns and overall taste. Again it's not bad, Just not unique and easily duplicated. read more

Tony's Coneys - Chilli Dog - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

I have been on this side of town a little more often due to a school rotation and drive by this place multiple times. Everyone in the office gave it a thumbs up so I decided do try. 1. Prices seem ridiculously low so I was not expecting the amount of food I got. 2. Someone else has mentioned not to expect anything but soft serve so I was extremely delighted to see hand dipped ice cream when I walked in. 3. The appetizers were much more filling than I expected. Hot dogs/Coney: About what you expect. It's a normal sized hot dog with plenty of cheese but I was missing a bit of chili for it to be a decent chili dog. Appetizers: Got the sampler and for $3.50 was expecting small onion rings, and less than quarter sized poppers and mushrooms. Much to my delight it contained full sized mushrooms, large, thick onion rings, zucchini fries were crispy outside and soft inside and poppers were a decent size. The basket of them was overflowing and well worth the price. Tony's Sub: - ended up giving this away so I didn't get to try it but I'll be back and update this section when I do. Shake: I got a chocolate, peanut butter and banana milkshake and I LOVED it. Hand dipped ice cream and fresh (non-green) bananas. I could taste all three flavors equally and the small was 16oz. Everyone I encountered in the store and on the phone was friendly and seem to enjoy being there which is always a plus when patroning an establishment. read more

See all

Slow service, but expected for small place. A lot of greasy food, but still one of our favorites for an occasional unhealthy meal day. We would return and appreciate this long time staple. read more

Great Food and service We have been there many times and never had a bad experience Would recommend this restaurant to everyone read more

I just ordered 2 large cones and 1 small cone. They all look like the same size. Such a rip off! read more

Tony's Coneys - Ice Cream Cones - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

I don't know why but their soft serve makes the best chocolate shake. I do wish they would put a little more chilli on the hot dogs but the price would probably increase if they did. I love the atmosphere in the dining room May they never change read more

I visited here in my search for banana pudding Hershey Ice Cream. Haven't been to a coney island since I left Ann Arbor. They had banana pudding ice cream but not now!!! One server did think they still did, but NO. Ordered a BBQ beef sandwich and a large drink. Nothing special about the sandwich but they only have Pepsi products - there goes a star. No A/C at all - there goes another star. Should have taken another star for not being handicap accessible. How in this day and age can a business get away with THAT. By the interior, they have updated since the 1950s so that might be the answer, but that is no reason. EBS would have DEMAND JUSTICE. Will call to see if they got banana pudding Hershey Ice Cream before I go back. That would be the only reason I would come back. read more

See all

Good coneys great price fast service few tables to sit at inside and a great milkshake.

Love the concept of this place. Cheap food, made relatively fast (they can get busy at times so there can be a wait). I've tried their coneys and they're the typical coney (a small hot dog and choice of toppings). The prices are up to par for the casual type of place it is and they have a lot of menu options. We come here a lot for this ice cream. The kids soft serve cones are $1 each and are a nice size. They have vanilla, chocolate, or twist. I've tried it once with the chocolate dip shell and it was delicious. It's convenient that they have a drive thru as well, so I can get cones without having to take the kids out of the car. read more

Tony's Coneys - Soft serve cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Decided to check this place out this evening. Ordered 6 Coneys, onion rings and fries for $15. Bargain City. Coneys came with chili, cheese, mustard and onions. Coneys are pretty good with plenty of condiments on them. Onion rings had a nice crisp coating to them and were delicious. As you can see a good portion of fries. Went through the drive through and it was super quick. Staff was really friendly. read more

See all

Decent ice cream and food and go food! The staff there was patient with us exploring the menu via drive thru and even came with some good recommendations. I ended up with a butter pecan shake, a classic coney and some fries. Skip the McDonald's and branch out to a local establishment! The food nostalgia hits the spot and trumps being told "our ice cream machine is down again" at the Golden Arches. read more

A Westside staple that has survived decades of change. Tony's has never lost whatever it is that they have giving me that happy little kid feel into my old age. Honestly, when I taught at Westland, I'd throw my keys and money to a student to go grab lunches for us. I felt my students needed to have experiences they might never forget. How many coneys will you eat? Throughout the years anyone employed there seems to have come from the same mold... Kind, hardworking, dedicated, conscientious, and super sweet. I know prices have evolved over the decades but why is it I still feel like they haven't. After being away from the Westside / Lincoln Village / Galloway for years, I made a U-turn in life and came back. I get to have my Tony's pretty often and I appreciate everything they serve and do not equally I appreciate how I feel while there. Thank you! Where are my Coney Dudes and Coney Dudettes? Gotta go to New Rome and chow. read more

Good food for the price little eating area very friendly I felt like I was eating at home at my dining table

I will NEVER again in life come to this place. We ordered our food and it took almost an hour for us to get our order. Not only did we wait, patiently (on the ouside) I might add, but we done so as we saw customer after customer order and have their food given to them and leave. We even waited so long a whole family came in, ordered, ate and left before we got our less than $20 worth of food (receipt attached). My wait allowed me to witness the staff attitude towards customers while they were there, but the nasty stuff said when some left. They did not seem excited to work there or have a job period for that matter. To add to the disappointment, we got home to food that was not tasty and a sandwich so soggy it had to be thrown out. My suggestion would be to go somewhere else. There are plenty of westside treataries that are happy to serve their customers a quality product. read more

See all

I love Toney's Coneys. I've been going here with my family all my life & even took my children as they grew up. Now they are taking my grandbabies!. If you like/love coneys & a great dessert of many kind in the ice cream, slurping way & love to make friends & reminiss about the old days over a cup of coffee then this is YOUR PLACE to go & enjoy! Open year round in hear of New Rome at 5266 W Broad St, Columbus, OH, United States, Ohio. read more

Tony's Coneys - The menu hsn't changed "MUCH" over the past 30+ years, which makes it a great place to eat, get a refreshing dessert or beverage - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Great coneys and peanut butter shakes, great service as always. Can't go wrong with this west side classic

First time here. I ordered a coney with the works, which had coney sauce, slaw and cheese. The bun was fresh and the coney tasty. The onion rings were a bit oily and greasy. They were thin onion rings and I prefer a thicker cut. Overall it was a good experience. Our food order came out rather quickly. read more

See all

I ordered a Sierra Mist and they gave me seltzer water.. The service was not great either. read more

Tony's Coneys - The fried pickles were small and over cooked - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

If you are on this side of town, this is a MUST place to eat before you leave town. This place is located in a house that has been remodeled to be a restaurant. The family room or maybe the all season room with a fireplace is where you eat. Take a look at the paper menu at the counter, place your order/pay then go have a seat. They bring the food out in a few minutes to your table. They even have a window outside that you can walk up to and place an order. From the menu to the food, even the restaurant itself, it has that old fashioned feel to it. The food is so good here! They have coneys, hot dogs, hamburgers, shakes, ice cream, smoothies, and sides. I recommend the fried mac and cheese - I'm addicted to these things! read more

Tony's Coneys - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

YIKES This place is one block away from my mom's house. I can't really say I'd heard anything good about it. The best recommendations I got were "it's been around forever!", "small business!", and "cheap eats". Not exactly promising when the few times my brother ate here he ended up with some unpleasant digestion issues. Okay so any how, I was in the area to pick something up from my mom and was like "hey, small business that's been around forever and is cheap". Sounds like the perfect yelp experience. And what do you know, this place has a high yelp rating. Y'all. I went in there with my 11 year old. It is not a clean looking place. A man is saying, so loud that it practically reverberates, something about the n-word. The tone suggesting something along the lines of "I don't like these n-words". Someone else, I think another customer laughs of like "oh haha that's just Dan the owner he's crazy like that". I walk right back out the door. I forgot to post about it when it happened but after a 25 minute drive back home and a good dinner, the experience got filed away in that "typical racist shit in Lincoln Village that I can't deal with" box I keep suppressed somewhere in the deep corners of my memory. But my youngest brother just informed of some nonsense he witnessed go down there so it inspired me to write about what happened when I went. I also wanted to confirm that the racist yelling guy was actually the owner, and after being shown a picture I can confidently say yes it was the same man. So, if it's all the same I'll be getting my coneys from a place that isn't owned by some guy who wistfully wishes for those good ol' Jim Crow days. read more

Well if you are looking for a spot to get a coney or a milkshake this is the spot. Tony's Coneys is open Monday - Saturday. This place is a great West Broad tradition. Just past the Hospital and a stone throw away from DQ. Can't go wrong with a foot long and a shake for less than $7. Great service and they have drive thru and a walk up window. This Friday 6 shakes 1 malt $21. Can't beat that price. We will be back. I'd prefer daily but that may not be best for me. read more

Tony's Coneys - Menu - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

So good! A hidden gem on the west side. Coneys are amazing. Ice cream is delicious. Great prices too!

If you're looking for good food at affordable prices with straightforward working class service, this is your place. I loved it. Cheeseburgers and onion rings, Italian Sun with fries solid simple and tasty. Service is quick. Place is comfortable. read more

It had been a long time since we'd been to Tony's Coneys. We used to live pretty close to it and visited more often, but since we moved, we haven't been back. So we were over on that side of town one Saturday and decided it was time to revisit. My husband and I got a 5 coneys with cheese deal for $7.50. The sides are a la carte, and we ordered fries and mac n cheese bites. The cashier asked if we wanted sour cream with those, and we both thought it sounded odd, but we both really liked it. The fries are seasoned nicely and don't require any assistance from ketchup. I'm not a fan of ketchup, so this is the kind of fries I dig. The coneys were great! I ate 2 of the 5, leaving 3 for my husband, which was a perfect amount of food for us. Every time we go, we think we should try the ice cream, but then we forget to leave room for it. Again this happened, so I have yet to try the ice cream, but the flavors sound enticing, and one day we will go in there just for that! This is definitely one of those places that you won't want to miss. read more

Tony's Coneys - Two cheese coneys, fries, and mac n cheese bites! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Arrived at Tony's at about 8:35pm (they close at 9). The drive through lady, Susie, seemed upset that we arrived 25 minutes before closing. To be fair, I'm only off on tuesdays and Wednesday's so this was the only time I had to get shakes for my family. We ordered 1 small hot fudge shake, 1 small cookies and cream shake and 1 large cookies and cream shake. We got our shakes and only the hot fudge shake was correct. The other two were cookie dough shakes, no biggie right I can go explain and they'll fix it. Wrong. My wife took them inside and dealt with Susie repeating over and over about how we got it wrong and it's all our fault. Another female remade the shakes but this time they came out like water. Crappy customer service by Susie. That was an embarrassment on how to treat your loyal customers. We have been coming here for years and no we'll never return. Great job on losing future business and I'll be sure to tell everyone I know to spend their money elsewhere. Shame on you Tony's Coneys read more