My son and I stopped in for lunch after a hike. Chose this place randomly and wow it was good. We both had a slice of buffalo chicken mac and cheese pizza (delicious and so loaded I had to use a fork, couldn't pick it up), and then I had a slice of pepperoni, sausage and onion and he a slice of chicken bacon ranch. Very filling. Kind of pricey but we would have spent roughly the same at the nearby Burger King and not been nearly as satisfied. Would recommend and plan to go back. Service was quick and seating area clean and spacious. read more

I don't have much to say other than GO. One of my all time fave pizzas not just in Pgh but anywhere! read more

See all

Service was good. I loved the meatballs but didn't care for the sauce. Pizza was was tasty and filling. Would come again. A little to dark in the restaurant read more

See all

Pizza is expensive. But when I pass by, I always stop! The food is delicious. If you have a chance try it.

Great food great service love supporting local businesses Their cheese blend is phenomenal as well read more

Love the pizza, asked if I could have a special spaghetti dish made with seafood and did Tony come through! Excellent tasting! The waitress Siria was and is always pleasant and efficient. read more

The food is great. Nice to have a lot of choices for lunch. They heat it up and bring it to your table.

Andy the owner personally greeted me, my uncle, brother, father, & our host (Family friend) before we sat to eat. Me and my family are from upstate NY, Utica to be exact, and this is by far the best Italian food I've ever had. I highly recommend you come here you will not be disappointed. From the appetizer to the pasta (The pizza and wings were also perfect.) read more

Listen; you want pizza that is a hit every single time, with a family owned restaurant? You can get both here. I'm not one to write reviews but honestly these guys deserve it. The owner is always super respectful. Very nice place to eat. The tables are always clean. Plain and simple, you want some crappy pizza, go to novotnys, you want a hand crafted, piece of love. Come here, don't listen to the Karen's that give one star reviews here, you'll regret not having their pizza for the rest of your life. Please not many family businesses are left. You won't regret buying from these guys read more

Sometimes there's nothing tastier than a prepared and reheated slice of Sicilian....so many slices to choose from, nice n crispy, alotta great fresh pies and a lot of other stuff too... read more

Tony's Pizza Café - Pizza Near Me - Sarver, Pennsylvania

We made a quick stop into Tony's for dinner before heading to a gathering with friends. What is great about this restaurant is that we always have the option to pick by-the-slice pizza and other quick food items from a huge amount of options behind the counter or have a seat and get table service. We were eating in and opted for table service. We were immediately greeted by a young man who was smiling and happy and welcomed us! He immediately asked what appetizer he could order for us (upselling ) and what to get us to drink. We were in a hurry so we opted for a 14" pizza and some sodas. Our food and dining experience did not disappoint! It is a cozy and relaxing little plaza restaurant that has ample seating and great service. It is by far the best pizza around and I need to put in another couple of items to try: frosted sugar cookies (OMG)!!, mandarin orange chicken salad!! You will not be disappointed. read more

Tony's Pizza Café - 14" cheese - Pizza Near Me - Sarver, Pennsylvania

See all

I ordered 2 extra large pizzas I thought it was a bit pricey but they were huge and really good! read more

Good food and quick service. Dine in or eat out. Never disappoints. Close and convenient. Great Sicilian pies. Wide variety of offerings. read more

Staff are always very kind , place is clean. All around feels like authentic Italian cuisine. Absolutely one of my go to's for pizza in the area read more

no stars, purchased a salad for 8.99 and kids meal for 5.99 and a caprese appetizer for 11.99, upon leaving I noticed card was charged for 54.55 and I even added a tip ...even though I called and put in the order and drove my car to pick it up ugh!! this place is the Wild West-no morals here. I called to let them know the price discrepancy as it was over half of what I should have been charged, anticipating it would be made right like any other business would do. The "manager" said he can't do nothing about it- this place has lost its rep in my eyes. good luck read more

Top notch! Service was great, food was super hot and delicious. So many pizza options as well as great hoagies and salads. Definitely recommend! read more

The best pizza in town! Tony and his crew are hard working and always friendly. Great to dine in or to go!

The pizza was greasy and flavorless. I don't know what all the fuss is about with this place. We've tried it twice and have not had a good pie yet. read more

Food is fantastic!! And they are local- and are the best! Thanks for always giving back to our community too!!

Mhm mhm bussin bussin good vibes good pizza 10/10. Love coming here to get a fulfilling meal of pizza. Yummy in my tummy although can cause gas sage read more

Love Tony's for the food and the atmosphere. Sarver is not a bustling town, but go into Tony's for the feeling of being in a big city pizzeria. Authentic, great food. read more

I say this without hyperbole, Tony's is the best ny style pizza I've had in the Pittsburgh area there's no close second. It's legit ny style. They have delicious specialty slices. Tasty Sicilian. Delicious garlic knots. I bet anything you get from this place is gonna be delicious. I felt like I walked into a Brooklyn pizzeria. I was very happy to find this gem. Anyone looking for a legit ny pizza shop. Try this place out. You probably won't be dissatisfied :) read more

Tony's pizza cafe looks like a regular old pizza place with crappy pizza and fake Italian food. But once you walk in you are hit by an immaculate smell and faced with delicious pizza. I got the regular cheese pizza and sprinkled pepper flakes on it. I took one bite and realized it was one of the best pizza I had ever had. But the second slice was better. read more

Tony's Cafe is so friendly & is truly Authentic Italian owned. The food is so good everything is home made. It's worth the drive to Sarver. Plus you can bring a Nice bottle of wine with dinner because it's BYOB. read more

See all

Hardly any safety protocols being followed. If it were a hardware store or retail and I saw no mask I wouldn't think anything of it....but prepping food during the spread of Covid no thank you. They do have great spaghetti though but I will hold me urge till this pandemic clams itself. read more

Delicious food!! Lots of choices that you can buy by the slice so that you can try different kinds. I love chicken bacon ranch

This is the best Pizza you will ever have. The family that runs the restaurant are all so kind. You are made to feel like family as you walk in the door. My favorite is the white pizza. But really everything they have is just wonderful. We like to meet there at shooting at the gun club. Tony's keep the menu fresh with new items added. If you don't stop when you are in Sarver you are missing!!! Marie read more

Tony is a chef that owns a pizza shop!! Crazy delicious pizza and the catering is awesome. Try it all. Staff also fantastic

Very good pizza. Only thing I don't like is they never have any specials, otherwise good pizza and lot of variety

I've frequented this place since they opened. It's under new ownership and it's gone down hill. I placed an order for 2 slices to go and they gave me the wrong order. I realized after I left , so I returned it. I received a extremely negative attitude from the owner himself, as if I were the one who messed up. I left a review on their facebook page and it was erased. I left another one, only to receive harassing PMs from an employee, then have another employee attack my review, saying I was lying! There's enough other pizza places around that don't stalk or harass their customers when they mess an order up. I honestly wish I never went here. read more

Really good pizza and sandwiches. The young woman who takes the orders is delightful. Go and try them!

We absolutely love Tony's Pizza Cafe. They serve the best New York-style thin pizza in the area hands-down. Another favorite that we have tried is the "Grandmom" which is a specialty pizza made tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella and basil. I have never ordered a slice from the premade slices, as I have often wondered how long those pizzas sit there. The fresh pizza is the way to go for sure! The garlic knots are also amazing. You can also BYOB which is a nice touch. read more

We had meat lovers pizza and the grandmom pizza. They were both very good. The meat lovers had just the right amount of meat and the sausage wasn't too hot, the garndmom is fresh mozzarella and basil. Not overdone with basil, just enough. We also heard that we had to try the cookies. The day we were there they only had iced sugar cookies. Good if you like your cookie soft not crispy. I got the chocolate mousse cake. It was very good. It was very light. Chocolate mousse on bottom whipped cream in middle and chocolate ganache on top. I would eat here again. I might try their dinner or salads next time read more

No masks by staff...no business from me. Also sometimes the food is sub par. And a few unfriendly employees.

We drive 40 minutes to come here! Their pizza is phenomenal. It would be our absolute best and fave if they started providing vegan cheese! But for now, it is still surely worth the drive!! And they sneak extra goodies in your order for free! Dont think I didn't notice Tony! read more

always good food! we usually get takeout and it's never been bad. wish they were open on sundays

The pizza is out of this world in the taste and the proportions. Well worth a few extra bucks. No shortage of options. read more

Tony's Pizza Café - Pizza Near Me - Sarver, Pennsylvania

I will never go to Tony's again. Placed an order to pick up two large pizzas. The order was to be ready in 40 minutes. Show up in 45 minutes pay for my order and I am waiting. To my surprise I see them grab a pizza out of the glass case that has been sitting for God knows how long, put my toppings on it and place it in the oven and we're trying to sell me that Pizza. That's a shame for what you pay for pizza. I would have expected a fresh pizza made specifically for me. Will never go there again. Who wants o read more

I love the NY style pizza and their hoagies are on in house, homemade rolls that are wonderful. Service was fast and friendly.

With a variety of gourmet pizza by the slice we didn't bother ordering anything else but we did have 4 different enormous very well made slices and I can absolutely say this is in the top three pizzas in Butler and Armstrong County. read more

Tony's Pizza Café - Pizza Near Me - Sarver, Pennsylvania