I was waiting in line behind a friend who was taking a bit long. When I went to order, a couple cut in front of me and ordered their food so I politely told them that I was still ordering despite their rude attitude. The cashier at the front proceeded to tell me to "hold on" and take the couple's order while I stood in front of his face ready to order. I didn't appreciate that from the cashier because he knew that I was waiting the whole time and found it disrespectful so I just left. read more

I am owed a $40 which I haven't received. Don't order from here if you expect to receive your order This picture is how my pizza was left. Tony's contracts with Door Dash for their delivery. I live in a secure building. I left instructions as to how to get in. I also left my cell phone number so their delivery service could text me. The delivery person did text but only to let me know he was leaving my pizza on the sidewalk outside the front door because he couldn't get in. Seriously? I left clear instructions as how to get in. Not only did he leave it outside but at the wrong building, on a completely different street. I never received my pizza. After calling Door Dash asking for a refund, I was instructed to call Tony's Pizza because Tony's contracts with Door Dash, which I did. No one is accepting responsibility. Tony's contracts with Door Dash. Tony's is the responsible party. I even used Tony's Pizza app. After two weeks, I'm still awaiting my refund from Tony's Pizza for the $40 meat lovers pizza, 16 inch. All I want is my money back for an item I never received Tony's Pizza, if you're listening, refund my money which was stolen by way of your negligence. read more

This is my go to pizza place when I miss Boston pizza. I grew up on NY style pizza , Regina's in the Northend was my pizza connection in Boston and Tony's here in St Pete has the crust I look for with just the right sauce and amount of cheese. The service is friendly and fast, the atmosphere is relaxed. Location is great because I can stroll shops after a slice. read more

I Love it all about this place, especially THE PIZZA!. Always welcome in and leave satisfied read more

Tony's Pizza - Pepperoni Pizza 12" - Pizza Near Me - Saint Petersburg, Florida

I ordered a veggie pizza with pepperoni. The veggies were pulverized instead of being chopped, so there was barely any recognizable veggies and no crunch like you expect on a fresh veggie pizza. Because the veghies were pulverized the pizza was kind of limp and and soggy. I could not taste any sauce at all. Although I paid for extra cheese, my pizza did not appear to have any more than a regular amount. There was one piece of pepperonu per slice. Big disappointment.The crust had the texture of saltine crackers. Overall disappointing experience. read more

Giving my honest review. I got the Buffalo chicken slice and meat lovers slice. It looked hella stale and old when sitting behind the glass counter. Wasn't impressed by presentation at all but then again it is pizza by the slice, they probably cook it an hour or hours before it's served but once they heated it up it tastes great! The pizza was super crunchy, no flop to it and easy to hold with one hand. Nothing was dripping from it either so you're able to enjoy it without making a mess. As far as the inside of the restaurant it was super spacious. They had nice decorations and a good amount of tables and chairs. There was also tables and chairs outside too. Customer service was good too. Overall if I'm hungry and feeling a large thin New York style pizza I'll probably go ahead and grab one if I'm in the area. read more

Tony's Pizza - Buffalo Chicken - Pizza Near Me - Saint Petersburg, Florida

See all

This was my go to place after a night of enjoying in St Pete. The pizza and service are usually fine. Tonight was a sad. Two pieces of pepperoni pizza were 10.00+. The service was awkward. One server was massaging the shoulders of another server behind counter and then taking the pizza with their bare hands and putting in the over to warm no more than 1 minute. The pizza was barely warm. I took it home and put it in air fryer. I am unlikely I'll return given this experience and the rising the cost. You can get a full pizza up the road at Colony Grill for a little more and it will definitely be warm. read more

I dreaded to write a review like this...but this is something that could happen to others. Pizza was good. Cesar salad was a huge disappointment. I ordered through door dash. Driver had issues finding us. POnce we received our order, I opened the salad it was gross. Salad brown and wilted. Small little croutons in a container smaller than ever for the price of $12.49. I called and spoke with Chris. He gave me his phone number so I could text him pictures. He stated my refund was processed and I should see my refund in 24 hours. I gave ample time for the refund. I sent a text to Chris on Friday 8/4 inquiring to my refund. (His read receipt was on and it was read 8:50am). Next I still didn't receive my refund. I texted Chris on 8/7 at 1:22pm (read receipt). Today I am done. I sent him a text at 4:48pm knowing I am not getting my refund. I am attaching the texts for review. So disappointed ... read more

Stopped by for late-night pizza. Staff was friendly, and the pizza was quick and delicious. Good price for a quick slice! The place is decorated like a New York-style pizza shop--small but plenty of seating to eat. read more

Tony's Pizza - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Saint Petersburg, Florida

See all

I love this place, the owners are sweet and the pizza is incredible! Try their cookies too, you'll love them.

Pizza dough is really good ! Made fresh & crispy! Ordered a pizza on a Friday evening late night & the pizza was delicious. I enjoy the dough texture & cooked perfectly! Thin & fresh ingredients. Definitely impressed and 5 full stars worthy for overall dine in experience. read more

Tony's Pizza - Hawaiian - Pizza Near Me - Saint Petersburg, Florida

The inside is very clean, excellent service, and wonderful pizza! Tammy served me today and she was very very wonderful! She made the whole experience very personal and sweet. Definitely will come back because of her. read more

Worst service I've ever experienced. white woman working the counter chose to count coins instead of taking our order. This felt discriminatory. Will NOT be going here again. read more

I stopped in for a slice of meat lovers pizza. It cost a little over $4, was ready in less than a minute and tasted pretty good. The employee was friendly and the bathroom was clean. read more

Tony's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Saint Petersburg, Florida

The service is Good, the establishment is clean, and the pizzas are enjoyable. Great for a quick bite between brewery visits read more

The best place in DTSP for pizzas by the slice with a taste that always makes me think of the old country ( NJ). read more

Tony's Pizza - Fries French Fries - Pizza Near Me - Saint Petersburg, Florida

Feel like I'm being a little generous with the 4 stars instead of 3 but just my personal opinion. I wish there was more vegetarian or plant based options at this pizza place. Although the only option of pizza I could eat I guess besides plain cheese pizza was the Florentine & it was okay. Was kind of hoping they would have a margarita slice or a grandma slice but I keep forgetting pizza out here isn't the same as New York pizza. Other then that I enjoyed the friendly staff and they had nice seating inside & outside. read more

Tony's Pizza - Tony's pizza window - Pizza Near Me - Saint Petersburg, Florida

See all

Open late on the weekends perfect after spending an evening out. The pizza was hot and fresh and the crust was thin and not floppy. The sauce was seasoned well and not too sweet. $5 minimum for cards. The inside has a few tables and the bathroom was clean no complaints! read more

Decent Luke warm slice shitty gen Z at the register. Never come back here as a part time local 3/21/25 7:05 PM

What's disappointing is that the flavor of this pizza was good. Dough had a nice chewiness to it. Cheese and sauce were both solid. But the pizza cook pulled this pie waaaaay too early. The bottom of the pizza was whiter than the cheese! A minor recommendation: chocolate sauce spilled out of the Togo packaging. Maybe seal your desserts a little more delivery proof? read more

Tony's Pizza - Way undercooked - Pizza Near Me - Saint Petersburg, Florida

They delivered us a brown salad and said they'd reimburse us but never did. Will never go back!

Ordered the margarita pizza via Uber eats. It looks like a normal cheese pizza with strips of basil. The description states slices of tomatoes (see the attached pictures) and it came with a crushed tomate sauce. I know I sound dramatic (almost Karen like), but I mean no disrespect. This just wasn't what I expected after reading the reviews and menu before ordering. The crust was a nice mix of chewy and crunchy though! read more

See all

I thought the pizza here is excellent - not sure why others didn't like the pizza here. I prefer very thin, crispy dough so if you are looking for thick crust or doughy crust pizza, this isn't the place for you. But if you are like me and like the thin crusts, this is the place to go for late night pizza! The slices are large and they go heavy on the toppings. They definitely don't cheap out on the toppings like other places. read more

I was leery about even grabbing a slice of pizza for a snack after reading all of the hit and miss reviews. I'm glad I got a slice. The best looking pizza IMO, kind of looked liked a margarita but it wasn't (tbh, the margarita didn't "look" that good but I can't attest for its taste). The slice I got is full of soft and thick, flavorful cheese with spinach and tomato...and it's delicious! Thanks for reading and thank you Tony's! read more

I've eaten only NY Style pizza my whole life. Moved to NY in 99 this place has real NY Style pizza. Place is a gem you heard!

The best pizza in DTSP (probably all of St. Pete) for sure, the crust is amazing with a buttery flavor and a great crunch while still be foldable. So good! read more

Tony's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Saint Petersburg, Florida

We were just about to meet some friends for drinks and my girlfriend mentioned she was hungry for pizza. We were walking downtown, so Tony's seemed like a good option for a quick slice. My buddies had mentioned it being decent in the past and it was very good according to my girlfriend. She ordered a pepperoni and mushroom slice that was fresh out of the oven. The service was fast and friendly. She said it was quite tasty and that we should try to order a take out pizza from them soon. The restaurant was clean and the food looked good. We will return or try some take out soon. read more

Tony's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Saint Petersburg, Florida

They actually had the audacity to upcharge me 50 cents for mayonnaise for a sandwich, and then I didn't even get any mayo! That's a red flag that the place is cheap and skimpy right there. The sandwich looks good but it just wasn't unfortunately. Barely had any chicken on it, was dry and bland. The jalapeno poppers were just ok. The side salad was decent. read more

See all

This place is nasty. This is the salad I got when ordering an 'antipasto'. As a customer, I expected better. I am still hungry. read more

Tony's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Saint Petersburg, Florida

Go there now and then for a slice. Usually acceptable but today not so. The owner herself served me two slices that were as limp as it gets. Drooped straight down when you picked up the crust. I brought them back for a refund. She was lackadaisical and unconcerned. I told her I would never be back and I won't. I suggest a trip to customer service school 101. The reason she is on the counter there is because business is slow and there's a new cook every few days. Pretty soon she'll fail and it will be good riddance. I wax the Sous Chef at Gratzzi for 15 years. I know what pizza is. read more

I'll go with 4 stars because this pizza spot is named after my brother. Is that acceptable? This is a New York pizza spot. Not my thing bc I'm a born and Chicago gal, so we decided on the steak and cheese panini. Panini's in my world are not on hoagie type bread rolls but these were. That's fine. It was good, cheap, and adequate for a snack shared between my hubby and I. They have $2 pizza by the slice. Check it out inside! It may float your boat, or keep you from paying an arm & a leg elsewhere. Who knows you may want to save money for alcohol which highly surrounds this area. If so, come here and get your cheap eat. This place looks quite nice inside and clean. Outside, they have tables so it is dog friendly. It is alright. No complaints!! read more

See all

Some of the best pizza, in the area. Used to literally visit just about every day. Try the chicken bacon ranch with buffalo sauce!

Excellent pizza. I'm surprised Yelp didn't show it on my search when I was looking for a restaurant. Price is really good. If you just want really good pizza and great prices, then it's is it read more

Tony's Pizza - Pizza and beer - Pizza Near Me - Saint Petersburg, Florida

Surprised to see all the negative reviews. I ate here before looking at the reviews, late on a Friday night, and me and my group really enjoyed our food. Got a couple slices of buffalo chicken pizza, and someone else got pepperoni. Both really tasty and crispy with a nice crust. Also ordered the garlic knots and they were amazing. They had fresh parmesan shredded on top and the marinara sauce it was served with was fantastic. Excellent spot to fulfill your pizza needs. read more

Pizza by the slice as well as whole pies is worth mentioning because not so many places offer slices. Nice selection of a half dozen interesting variety pizzas available by the slice. Not a thick crust, not a thin crust, something in between but quite good. Of course, go in and look at the slices first to see how if they are looking fresh and tasty. They offer a tiny discount if you're paying cash. read more

Rude. Made order wrong and just removed ingredients instead of remaking it. Won't be back.

Order a Sicilian pizza very under cook called the restaurant to tell them not much of an apology. NEVER AGAIN

Ordered a cheese slice and buffalo wings. And the food was just okay. The wings were soggy. And the pizza was . I would try another pizza place before going back. read more

Excellent pizza! Just the right amount of sauce. The dough is incredible. Crisp. Delicious. Done perfectly. Great, great service! Ice cold beer! read more

Very disappointing. The Italian barely had any meats. The antipasto came with no meat at all. read more

Tony's Pizza - Italian Combo - Pizza Near Me - Saint Petersburg, Florida

See all