Their Margherita DOC is right up there with the best New Haven has to offer and I have tried them…read moreall. I only wish I could be returning soon. The service was prompt and friendly but don't expect too much in decor. The food is what you are here for so don't worry about the small stuff.

Wow! What delicious pizza! Fresh and huge salad with lots of slices of fresh cheese. My truffle…read morepizza was excellent!! This spot opens at 5:00 and people were lined up to get a table. Well worth a visit!

This evening (4/10/26) we went without a reservation, but they were nice enough to seat us at 5:15…read morein anticipation of their 6:30 reserves. Service was marverlous and the food excellent! We were warm in the outside room and well taken care of. Mr. Phenomenal

Walked in expecting a small Town pub feel and got exactly…read morethat!!! I loved the feel and vibe and the food was yummmmyyyyyyy.... Our server was amazing and super friendly!! Definitely a spot for us to come back and visit!

2.5, maybe. We were…read moreso disappointed in this food! We got our pizza to go, so I can't comment much on interior or what the dine-in experience is like. We ordered the garlic bread- and it's quite possibly the most bland garlic bread we've ever had. Where's the actual garlic flavor? Cheese? Italian seasoning? It needs... something! We ordered two pizzas and for the first time, probably ever, we didn't even finish half of either one. The pepperoni pizza was insanely greasy. I couldn't hardly stomach it. My husband loves a good chicken, bacon, ranch pizza and this just wasn't a good one. The chicken seemed frozen, he felt like there was too much ranch- the flavor was just off. We did try calling and speaking to a manager to see what they could do for us- which was nothing. No desire to go back.

The pizza was amazing! We got a cheese pizza with a garlic parmesan flavored crust and it was…read moredelicious; the garlic parm crust was definitely a hit. The trivia cards at the table are a fun touch as well and we loved playing with them while we were waiting for our food.

Great local place with the freshest ingredients. Service is VERY friendly. Atmosphere is modern…read moreand cool. Beer Cheese - $6.99 - Very good and very filling. It may cause you to have leftovers of your pizza. 5/5 stars. Chicken Bruschetta Pizza - $13.35 - I thought the balsamic vinegar would be overpowering, but it was not. Good balance and good amount of toppings. 5/5 stars. Mushroom Medley - $13.35 - Love this pizza, but I'm also partial to mushroom pizzas. 5/5 stars. Cheese - $11.25 - This one is just fine. Not a whole lot of cheese pull and it's boring to me, but hey, people seem to like that. 4/5 stars. They get their cheesecakes from Pixie Pies: Neapolitan Cheesecake - $7 - Very good cheesecake. Similar to an In-and-Out Neapolitan milkshake. 5/5 stars. My only complaint about this place is that sometimes the dough has a nice fluffy crust and sometimes it's flat. I do prefer the fluffy crust. Not sure why that consistency is overlooked. Highly recommend this place.

Walked in with 8 people not realizing they closed in 12 minutes and was greeted with "can we help…read moreyou?" Yes we came to eat like everyone else in the restaurant and the employee very sarcastically says " at 850, yeah sure let's do it" So we asked if they had any other recommendations and she says "sorry not from here but go ahead and sit down." I let her know she was very rude so we wouldn't be sitting down and went somewhere else that was very eager to take a table of 8 and a 200 dollar check!

This is a little Gem! A must if you are in the Amish Country! Matter of fact, most of the people…read morewho work here are Amish. They are super friendly. The food is good. I love the old sodas. They have an old bar with stools, and a old record player ( save your quarters!!)

No frills, old style, somewhat rundown, soda fountain type store that is also the local pizza…read morejoint. Not as welcoming as I had imagined it.

Pretty cool place and great to watch a game in with friendly staff. Cold beer! Good pizzas.read more

We got 2 pizzas to go this weekend. One was a deep dish and the other thin crust. Both were burnt…read moreto a crisp and dry. The so-called deep dish was as flat as a pancake. Never again.

The Bent Prop Pub is a great little restaurant located right on Coldwater Lake. It has ample…read moreparking across the street and a boat dock that can accommodate ~6-7 boats for lake access. We dined upstairs (Pub on lower level) and had some excellent food. The Garlic Breaded Cheese Curds are amazing (cubed cheese) and recommend either/or Marinara and Ranch. The Pretzel was also very good, but the standout was the bar cheese sauce, which appears more of a creamy fondue than straight cheese wiz and was very flavorful. Main dishes were the Pollock Fish Basket with Fries, Chicken Quesadilla with Lime Rice and the Steak Bites App with a side of Broccoli. Everything was very good,l and the food was hot and service super fast. Staff was extremely friendly and knowledgeable and dining right on the lake is always a plus. Plus we didn't have a wait arriving at 6:30ish on a Saturday evening. Bent Prop Pub earned a five star review due to its food, ambiance, staff and being a nice little gem of a restaurant and pub tucked away in a sleepy section of the Eastern shore of Coldwater Lake. Would definitely go back when we are back up in the area.

Awesome ambiance! This is right on the water. If you go downstairs you can sit outside in the…read morescreened section looking right at the lake. Or you can choose to sit inside. The food was good! For our appetizer, We got the Prop Bites (Cheese Curds) they were good but quite salty. My husband and I both got the Grouper strips. They were really good. The breading was a little thicker than we like but it was good, as were their chips and coleslaw. Anna was great! The service was very quick! We had our apps within 5 minutes! Our meals came shortly after! Our server was very attentive too!

We had a pepperoni and sausage pizza delivered on a Friday evening. Pizza arrived hot in the time…read moreframe they quoted. We like the pizza from Pepperoni's better than anyone else's in the area. Delivery to our home is an added bonus!

Food was amazing! Arrived right at open and phones were already ringing off the hook. I knew I made…read morethe right decision when the woman behind the counter went above and beyond to make us feel welcomed. I drive past this place often and finally decided to pop in when the snow was getting bad. I ordered the chicken spinach deluxe pizza and it was so cheesy and delicious, the seasonings on top were a really great touch. My partner got the slammer sandwich, toasted to absolute perfection! He said it was fresh and savory with a nice touch of spice from the pepperoncini. This place was off the hook! Will 10/10 be returning.

Great price for salad, soup, Italian sandwiches, pizza buffet. Salad bar is pretty small, but had…read moreitems I like, only iceberg lettuce however. Pizzas were good, not too much sauce, which I like. I really like the Italian subs they had on the buffet. They do quite a business. It was pretty busy, there were 8 of us we lucked out that 2 tables opened up as we ordered. Cashier was helpful since we'd never been. They do a large takeout business too. They have different salads and sandwiches on their menu too.

Nice variety of pizza. Hot and fresh. Small salad bar but very good. Reasonable priceread more