Food was amazing but our delivery driver deserves some recognition, David was extremely respectful and incredibly fast, you guys have some great employees and this is my favorite pizza in town:) read more

Ordered to go. I was actually surprised in a good way with the pizzas we ordered. The hand tossed crust is the way to go. Quality sauce and plenty of toppings. Friend my staff on pick up. read more

Very solid pizza. They will do large deliveries, pretty consistent with not messing up orders. I wish their cinnamon sticks were better, and their pizza isn't top-notch. Their breadsticks and cookies are very good though. They have a wide variety of pizza types and options to add any toppings you want and are quick with their deliveries. Eating at the restaurant is nice, too. They have free refills on their drinks, a TV which usually has sports on, and serve you at your table. If you're in Nappanee, this is the pizza place to go to. read more

Pizza has nice crust. We asked them to stop short of cooking it completely so we could finish it at home. We wanted a beer while we waited but no beer. That was a travesty ! Pizza and no beer?? WTH? But I'd go back in a heartbeat. If you get beer you would be a 5! read more

Pizza was okay. Just your typical carry out booth areas. Food, that's all. Service was friendly, but no enthusiasm.

Reasonable prices. Tasty pizza. Quick cooking. Nice cashier. Just what we needed. Went to the Nappanee location.

Many pizza choices to choose from and the bread sticks are very good, I recommend. You can call or go there in person. Whenever they deliver they're very friendly and cool. Whether you're ordering or going there in person you will not be disappointed. read more

My husband and I didn't feel like going out in the cold for dinner, decided to give this place a try. Well it didn't disappoint! We ordered a medium thin crust supreme pizza and it was actually better than what we anticipated. Good balance of all toppings, crust was slightly crunchy but not over cooked. Would definitely order again! read more

Really that's cool too but I'm just wondering what kind of stuff is this place serving? Like what did I do to deserve this for my dad tomorrow? I'm sharting my guts out and pissing my pants after eating this "pizza" Idk Good is your free day card for free mail card and your card came back??? Pizza was absolutely doodoo!!!!! Sticker cheese my bung the good man good luck I did thank ya wanna much love ya wanna ya ya I did it for a while now and!!!! Idk ‍ I mea read more

Bourbon Street Pizza - Nappanee - Pizza from the establishment "the bourbon street special" - Pizza Near Me - Nappanee, Indiana

I was in Nappanee for business. This was my first post-pandemic dine-in experience. It was an excellent place to stop for lunch. Super fast service. The wings were excellent. No shortage of sauce covering them and the heat level was perfect. Definitely would recommend if you're in the area. It's easy to park, very affordable and fast. read more

I used to work here and was sexually harassed on multiple occasions by male coworkers, many times directly in eye-sight of the manager, and he did nothing. I'm not the first or only person this has happened to while working there. read more

Best pizza in town nobody could beat they're pizza in this town thank you bourbon street pizza

Fans of Bourbon st pizza. Napennee location is way above the other places I've tried. Love the supreme. The sausage, onion & mushrooms . The Hawaiian w/regular pizza sauce instead was pretty good too. Seems like quality & love are the main ingredients. The crusts on the different pizzas were all baked to perfection. Crispy on the outside, nice & soft inside. Veggies still had a little bite to them, just the way I like them. Also had a couple of different pastas. They got lots of bacon where bacon is called for. The topper so far for me is the plain house salad. The shaved Parmesan (soft) all over is AWESOME!!! & they don't skimp on the bacon bits. Gave it only 4 stars because all I've tried is the take out. Gotta try the restaurant in person, I think the 5th star is maybe there. read more

First time here was great! Got a small buffalo chicken pizza and really enjoyed it. It came with a side of ranch and of course, garlic butter. Slightly smaller size than what I was expecting at first, but it filled me up. Really fast service too! read more

Bourbon Street Pizza - Nappanee - Buffalo Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Nappanee, Indiana

We were reluctant to go to Bourbon St pizza because of a few unfavorable reviews. Went to one of their competitors and were treated bad the minute we walked in which ended up being a favor to us. BSP looks like it was recently remodeled, it's clean and has a fun, friendly staff. To top it off their pizza was great, just needed a beer with it. read more

Good pizza & friendly staff, quick, good value, will try again when passing through Nappanee

Friends and I were traveling when we found this restaurant. The food is so fire that they should relocate to across the street from the fire department. Food was so good that I awakened my third eye from its eternal slumber. By the way, the staff was very friendly. read more

Bourbon Street Pizza - Nappanee - Food so fire I'm surprised they're still standing - Pizza Near Me - Nappanee, Indiana

We are having our MH serviced at Newmar and this is in close proximity to Service Center and offers great tasting pizza, cooked to perfection! read more

The best pizza in Nappanee, ask if there are specials available. Great quality of pizza. The seating and dining leaves much to be desired. There's one 23" flat screen TV usually playing Sports Center. (not HD) read more

Like this place a lot, it's actually affiliated with the Bourbon Street Pizza's in North Webster and Bourbon. They're dining room is sorta awkward but enough tables to seat maybe 30 to 40 individuals, and their pizza is delicious, kinda like Papa Johns but way better, I just love how buttery the crust (and bread sticks) are. Plus their baked pasta with the cheesey bread is my new favorite. Had their delivery only once but it was in good time and the guy was very nice, only thing I dislike is their semi small menu, and no dessert pizza, what's up with that? read more

Bourbon Street Pizza - Nappanee - What was left of my medium Italian pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Nappanee, Indiana

See all

Having rv warranty work done here in Nappanee and decided to stop in. Ordered thin and crispy tomato and mushroom pizza AND IT COULD NOT HAVE BEEN BETTER. Flavorful with no disappointments. read more

Bourbon Street Pizza - Nappanee - Thin and crispy tomato and mushroom was DELICIOUS! - Pizza Near Me - Nappanee, Indiana

We have been coming to the area for approximately 13 years, staying at a campground close to the Nappanee area and enjoy going into town to the local restaurants, about 3 years ago we first tried their pizza and loved it, fresh ingredients different styles and they deliver to the campground. read more

Good pizza & great breadsticks! My daughter also ordered the baked pasta dish which was delicious as well. I'm impressed by their prices. However I was unimpressed by their salad options. It's nice to have some healthy options on a menu. read more

I was in Nappanee a couple of weeks ago. Over the course of a week I had their pizza delivered to the Hotel room three times. Every time the delivered quicker than they said. Every time it was less than 30 minutes. Pizza was super hot and very good. I'm a pizza snob and these guys nailed it every time. Great crust, cheese and lots of toppings. Could not ask for better pizza. I will be back in June and will visit again. read more

Great pizza and friendly service! Jesse and his crew do a fine job. Pizza is hot and delicious; bread sticks are awesome.

Good cheap pizza, but their staff needs to understand delivery areas!!! Wouldn't deliver to my road cause they didn't know where it was!!

Traveling from Ky to Rv business. Stopped for pizza. Blue ribbon pizza. Crush was perfect. Top 10 of all the pizza places I've eaten. Quick service and clean. Wonderful Pizza. We ordered the Supreme read more

The pizza tasted good. We live in Wakarusa and wanted to try something besides Pizza Hut and Cooks. We ordered a pizza with mushroom and sausage and ate there at the restaurant. It was small but nice inside. Unfortunately about 4 hours after eating my husband and I both had the worst case of food poisoning either of us have ever had. A good 12 hours of straight vomiting and then diarrhea. We couldn't eat normally for days. We will never eat there again. AWFUL!!!! read more

This is my favorite pizza in Nappanee! Its really yummy and good prices! We eat here like twice a month!!

30% less than Pizza Hut and tastes pretty much as good / the same. Very clean, new and nice.

I really do like the pizza, but depending on who answers determines whether or not they will deliver to you. I am 0.6 miles out of the area, most times they will deliver, but sometimes not. After my last "No I won't send one of my drivers that far out of the area" from a Manager, I am done. read more

Not just a pizza place! Penty of Pasta dishes and much more. If you have not ate here then it is worth the stop! Small town food with small town hospitality. Beats out all other local pizza joints hands down. read more