I'll start by saying I LOVE their Topper Sticks. If you have never tried them, please do. You won't be disappointed in the food. However, lately you need to bring your patience to this location. Twice now I have called ahead and both times my simple order - one item, no modifications - was wrong when I arrived and they were remaking it. Great they caught it before I left, but disappointed this seems to be a theme. I asked for a discount and they said "we can't do that." This is not really a sit and eat place so plan to carry out and give yourself time in case your order is not ready when you arrive. read more

Toppers Pizza - Triple order of original Topper Sticks - Pizza Near Me - Fitchburg, Wisconsin

See all

Placed an order to go and ate some in the car before leaving the parking lot! It was so good! The crust was soft and chewy, just the way I like it. The toppings were quality and there was the perfect balance with cheese. The pricing was just right for the pizza and cheesesticks. It's too bad I don't have a Toppers in my town, but I'll be sure to order again when I'm back up north! read more

Toppers Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fitchburg, Wisconsin

I don't know why this place only gets 2 stars. Our order was fresh, hot, not overcooked. Overall well made pizza, nice doughy crust with just the right amount of crunch. The staff was courteous and friendly. Overall very good pizza. And they always have good deals on their app. read more

Toppers Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fitchburg, Wisconsin

This toppers is usually really good when I get pizza. I know I ordered late but cmon, I still ate it cuz I was hungie but cmon Where do I dm you read more

Toppers Pizza - Bad breadsticks - Pizza Near Me - Fitchburg, Wisconsin

Didn't get my pizza?! $40 for 2 salads? Grubhub voided the order, but not much of an apology either. Delivered late too.

It is the worst customer service, they are rude and disrespectful, the person of Asian nationality is disrespectful, they close the restaurant at 8 at night where it should be open, please we need you to resolve this as soon as possible. This always happens in this place. read more

The thin crust pizza was delivered when promised. Warm cardboard at best. Pepperoni was tasty, but cheese, red sauce, green peppers and tomato were sparse. read more

Food was delicious and I really loved the pizza options Had a pizza with noodles and buffalo chicken with aside of cheese curds and I was honestly surprised how delicious it was definitely will order again when I'm in the area read more

Amazing Service great deals food is amazing. The place is also clean. I'm gonna come back again..

Should be Zero stars. Pizza was overpriced, cold, and coated in oregano. Try somewhere else.

My wife and I ordered a large tator tot pizza and topperstix to go last night. First of all, when we got there there were FIVE employees behind the counter and none of them were SOCIAL DISTANCING. And, one of them was EATING and we could see them Eating on a paper plate drinking a Mountain Dew. Our pizza tasted bland, there was no sauce, only tator tots. At that point we started eating the topperstix and they were bland as well. Absolutely disgusting experience, I will never be ordering Topper's again in my life. read more

Fast and reliable. Their style is kind of interesting, a bit rustic even: toppings taste fresh and come in bigger chunks than industry standard, meat has actual seasoning, and the overall build quality is really high. read more

Ordered for delivery and was told the food would be there in 30-45 minutes. Pizza and Topperstix got here in less than 20 minutes and was super hot and fresh and delicious and I just love Toppers so much!!! The guy I talked to was super friendly with me on the phone and made sure my order was exactly the way I wanted it. I will definitely be ordering from this location again!! I saw the bad reviews on here and was a little nervous. I actually mentioned it to the guy, I think his name was Ben, and he said they're under new management now. They really are just killing it at the details!! Toppers will be my go to pizza joint from now on read more

After repeatedly calling the store and messaging and leaving voicemails for their corporate office are refund has been ignored for well over a month and a 1/2 with no follow UPS some of the worst customer service I have ever encountered. read more

Very chill vibe, and the staff were nice and efficient with getting the food to us. Prices were fair, we had a large fresh pizza with four toppings for $12. Overall, a good pick! read more

If I could give zero, I would. I had to wait an hour and 45 minutes for delivery. I called the store after an hour and was told that it was taking so long because I "wasn't the only person ordering pizza today". So, apparently they only know how to deliver on time if you're the only person ordering pizza on that day. I could've literally ordered from the toppers on the other side of town, driven there to pick it up, driven home, eaten, cleaned up and did dishes, all in less time than it takes the one 2 minutes from my house to deliver it. Shoulda stuck with Glass Nickel I guess. read more

So I had an issue with an order I placed and the guy immediately apologized and offered a coupon or a resend of the problem. It wasn't a huge deal as I had ordered extra on the side (I love the chocolate baconstix and it is a special order they don't carry it so chocolate sauce on the side) and asked me if I wanted a coupon sent out or the food remade. I did not have to prove an order number or anything. Awesome service and awesome fast response. Will definitely feel comfortable ordering from here. read more

This was my worst experience ever! My boyfriend and I have recently been ordering a lot from them at least twice a week. Tonight he ordered me nacho stixs extra nacho cheese sauce and meat. When it got here I opened it up a hair cooked in the cheese and not a drop of nacho cheese sauce. I call the store after 5 minutes a guy picks up. I ask him for a manager he says there isn't one there at the time he is by his self. I explain my frustration he proceeds to tell me I'm here by myself I know for a fact there isn't hair on it because I have a net on. I said I just opened it up there is would he like me to bring it in. He said it's nothing He can do. He than asks me do I hear all the buzzers going off and the phones ringing it's nothing he can do and hung up the phone. read more

Toppers Pizza - The nacho sauce less nacho Nachostix - Single Order no nacho sauce let alone the extra I paid for and the hair on the third stick in! - Pizza Near Me - Fitchburg, Wisconsin

Skip the delivery, go for pickup. This has to be one of the most creative lobbies of a pizza place I've come across. 4 TVs, with one always on Nick Jr. My 3 year old appreciates that. Not to mention a basketball hoop, hula hoops, and other fun things to keep you occupied. That is to say you won't be waiting forever for your pizza. Typically just a few minutes, but a fun atmosphere to be in. The food, oh yeah. It's solid. Great specialty pizzas, including the buffalo chicken pizza and the taco pizza. Not too many places make a taco pizza around here. This place does, and it's great. It's a great choice for the family. While it may not be the cheapest place in town, it's a great choice. read more

Called and placed an order over the phone, the person told me it would be 35 minutes to make it and get it out for delivery. An hour passes and I call back, they tell me they're putting it in the oven. 45 minutes pass and I call back only to be told that they are just now getting the pizza ready and it would be delivered to me on "20-25 minutes" even though I've waited for way longer than needed and I could have driven there myself in 9 minutes. I ask to speak to a manager to voice my concern over being quoted 35 minutes but having it really be 2 hours. He tells me very flatly "I just make pizza." I told him to forget about delivering the pizza, I wanted a refund and I'd drive 3 miles to Dominos. Topper's follow through with any of their promises is dismal. Only after we ordered Dominos did the Topper's guy show up with cold pizza and missing some of the extra sauce I paid for. We enjoyed our dominos instead, it was actually hot and they had it made by the time I showed up to pick it up myself. read more

Here's the thing, their food is actually really good. No really it's tasty pizza for a damn decent price. The problem here is strictly service. Whether I'm picking up or ordering for delivery, the people I deal with tend to be just awful. I ordered pizza a few weeks ago, and they got the order wrong. After sighing like I was the worst person in the world, they mailed me a 50% off my next order coupon. Ok, cool. I order pizza yesterday. They tell me it'll be 35 minutes. 1 hour and 15 minutes later I call to see what's going on. I'm told "Oh, yeah, she just left 5 minutes ago. Why don't you give her some time to arrive?". Dude, it's a good 40 minutes after you told me the pizza would have arrived. Patience was not my issue, promise. read more

I just got hung up on after listening to the person on the phone saying, people on the way home are so annoying. They made me hold for 20 minutes but then hung up on me. read more

Currently waiting for our order to be delivered. Estimated wait time was 40 minutes and now we're going on an hour and 40 minutes. We've ordered toppers sticks before from other locations and it's never taken this long. This location must be awful. The company should try to give a more accurate wait time, we live 5 minutes from the store! Very disappointed so far. read more

They just left the pizza in front of the door no text no call didn't even ring the door bell until I come out 50 minutes later and it's just sitting outside cold. read more

Bunch of losers. I was out drinking so I didn't expect much from my local toppers. I ordered at 1:15 am on a Friday night. I got the ETA of 1:43 am, not to far off from what to expect. Here I am at 2:22 am with no pizza. I called a little after 2 am and was on hold for about 8 minutes. When they picked up, they said they were on the way. The location is about a 3 minutes away. Here we are over 10 minutes from the call and they aren't here. Like I said, a bunch of loser. They probably shit on you pizza. Just get dominos or something. read more

I just bought a pizza to take home. I got in the car and opened the box.. the pizza was a Toppers Classic but mostly cheese and marinara sauce. Couple of topping on it, enough probably toooings to put just on a slice and not the whole pizza. they are some cheap ass pizza place!! My entire pizza is marinara sauce and cheese! I'll never buy again from them!! They used to have amazing pizza when they open the store but lately they are below even a 0 star rating!! Don't buy from them!! read more

My wife and I ordered this a bit later than dinner time one night around 8:30pm. We just wanted something somewhat light so we ordered the triple Original Topperstix accompanied with three sauce cups. First off, the Topperstix were pretty good and I would say they were better than Pokey Stix. Glass Nickel cheese bread which is really akin to Stix, is the best bet for your wallet and taste buds. If you haven't tried that, you should. I must mention that the PD location can't be too busy on a Tuesday night, but they still managed to be about ten minutes later than their stated delivery time. Consequently, the Stix were not the freshest. In addition, two of the three sauce cups were only filled about half-way - without sauce, I'm sorry, the Topperstix are a bit bland. It's like buffalo wings without the buffalo. So guys, FILL THOSE SAUCE CUPS!!! With such competition, Toppers should be careful or the competition will wipe them out. Toppers was a somewhat empathetic three-star experience. read more

Online ordering is only ok. Ordered tonight and had an ETA of 7:05. Didn't hear anything at 730. called and said it would be there by eight. Arrived at 750, only warm and rubbery. Done ordering from this location. read more

We have had nothing but good luck with them. Quality food, super fast delivery, and everyone is very polite. I was surprised this time that the specials were gone and a delivery fee was added, but the guy on the phone was up front about it. read more

Food is fine by toppers standards, but don't order delivery expecting it to arrive in the near future. Ordered one pizza and one order of sticks yesterday and it didn't arrive until 30 minutes past the estimated arrival window for a total time of 1 hour and 15 minutes after I ordered. I live only 10 minutes from toppers, so it definitely wasn't the drive time... Don't waste your time. With places like Sugar River nearby, spend the extra dollar or two, get fantastic pizza, and be eating within 40 minutes of your order. read more

It's pretty good overall but they were too light on the sauce and the music inside was disturbingly loud. Pretty good.

Do NOT order a THIN crust pizza from here! Just finished returning a thin crust smoky BBQ chicken pizza to the manager. Wish I took a pic of this pathetic looking pizza! Lots of BBQ sauce, a few pieces of chicken you could count on one hand, no cheese and a very browned crust. And it tasted like ... cardboard! My husband asked if he ordered another one right now would it look like this? And he said yes!! Wow!! Simply amazing the attitude on this guy. My husband pointed out the burnt crust and his reply was it's a thin crust pizza! Managed to get him to make us another pizza, our usual order with a REGULAR crust! Other pizzas we have ordered in the past are always amazing and the new one he made looked delicious as it should! But customer service was very disappointing today. He needs to check out their competitor's thin crust pizzas! read more

Giving it three instead of four because of their inconsistency. Sometimes there has been almost a complete lack of sauce on the pizza and other times almost no cheese. When I'm in the area and I want some food packed with carbs and cholesterol they're all right. read more

For late night delivery it is pretty standard. Nothing really spectacular, nothing really crap. If glass nickel pizza isn't delivering or if you're a third shifter look for something other then the vending machine special, this option isn't to bad. read more

We were quoted $9.48 on our pizza online but they upcharged us when we went to pick up our order ($11.59) saying that more sauce and less cheese counts as "extra toppings". The pizza was made on time but it's frustrating on principle that they would do such a thing. read more

The food was fantastic. I had a Buffalo Chicken grinder and a small order of Topper Stix. The sandwich cam piping hot and toasted to perfection. It was delicious. The stix were as they always are...amazingly fattening. read more

Let me start by saying I'm a New York native and I'm generally not satisfied with the delivery pizza options in the Verona area. That said, Topper's is very good considering its competition here on the south side. I ordered the 2 medium pizza deal for $7.99 (3 toppings) which is a very good price compared to Glass Nickel and AJ's. I also ordered hot buffalo boneless wings. The crust on the hand-tossed pizza is superb, compared to every other pizza joint in the area. It has that super chewy mouth feel with a foldable slice that I have been hard-pressed to find outside of New York. The cheese is decent low moisture mozzarella, not bad but not spectacular either. It's the same cheese everyone else uses and it's head and shoulders above the plastic, sickly sweet stuff that Pizza Hut throws on their pies. The tomato sauce is pretty standard too - the dipping sauces, while not my preferred way to eat pizza, make up for otherwise slightly bland tomato sauce. I could not stop dipping once I tasted the parmesan garlic sauce though - it is absolutely fantastic. Fresh toppings round out the four stars - no canned mushrooms here and the onions were obviously sliced recently, not sitting in cold storage for two days. As far as delivery goes, Topper's will be my first choice for value, and for that amazing crust that makes me feel like I'm 16 again, walking to the park after school and buying a couple slices of pepperoni from that pervy old Italian guy that ran the corner pizzeria. Glass Nickel is a close second but far too expensive for my preference. The boneless wings? I'll have to revisit them another time. They had a nice hotness to them without too much fire, and were cooked well, but the breading was soggy with buffalo sauce by the time they arrived at my door and I missed out on the crunch factor which is the only reason I really ever buy boneless wings. All in all, Topper's is my new favorite in the Verona area, but they don't really have any decent competition. read more

This is the first time I have ever posted a review, but felt it necessary. We stopped for a late lunch this afternoon, and while waiting for our order, the delivery guy came in to pick up orders. I watched him pick up food off the shelf, eat it, then lick and suck fingers of both hands. Then starts packing food orders in boxes to be delivered. Didn't even bother to wash his hands. I about threw up. Needless to say, we will never stop here or order from here again. read more

From the second I walked through the front door I knew the 2.5 star review was inaccurate. Very clean store, very friendly staff and great customer service. I was in and out in 10 minutes. Pizza was warm and well made. I would always be Leary of a 1 star review from someone who was complaining about a few dollars on a website that may have had data incorrectly entered by the user. I would definitely order from this location again. I wish people would take a little bit of time and think your review through before posting. This review may have cost someone their job. read more

We ordered sandwiches for delivery on a Tuesday night. The ordering process was smooth, professional and polite. The order arrived within the stated time, so that was another plus. Now the minuses...when ordering the person taking the order offered me a deal of two sandwiches plus two 20 oz. sodas for $12.99, then proceeded to tell me the total would be $16.46. That's a hefty delivery charge if you ask me, and sorry but that reduces the tip! I understand the driver does not receive any of the delivery charge, but jacking the order from $12.99 to $16+ makes me not have much left for a tip. Now the sandwiches...we both ordered the Philly Cheesesteak. They were both covered heavily in cheese, making the bun a soggy mess. Cheese seemed to be the main ingredient in the sandwich, very sparse with the meat and veggie toppings. Bottom line, would never order a sandwich for delivery again, would never order the Philly Cheesesteak at all and probably wouldn't bother with the pizza after reading other reviews and having better options available. read more