Our cake was delicious and beautiful. Service was helpful and friendly. Would definitely recommend -Thank you Torta Fina! read more

Torta Fina Bakeshoppe - Custom cake - Bakeries Near Me - Babylon, New York

This is a very cute shop with lots of different dessert options. Inside reminds me of a grandmas sitting area. I ordered a bicenza, (hot chocolate with espresso and a biscotti) which although it was good, was very expensive and there are no prices posted any where. Service was slow and we were ignored for quite a while before being helped. I think I'd go back to pick up sweet treats but unlikely to get another beverage there. read more

See all

Super cute bakery with vintage vibes. Tons of options, each that look more delicious than the last and fast, friendly, service. Popped in with my family while strolling the streets of Babylon and we each got an item. Our only complaint is that everything could have been a little more moist (definitely had baked yesterday vibes but I am totally here for it because it means no preservatives or ingredients I can't pronounce) read more

Torta Fina Bakeshoppe - Bakeries Near Me - Babylon, New York

Great little bakery. Staff was so nice. I went in for a Fruit Tart and then an Apple Pie the next day and wound up getting a couple free samples of their mini Dubai Cheesecakes too. Everything was excellent. read more

Torta Fina Bakeshoppe - Caramel Apple Pie 10/10 - Bakeries Near Me - Babylon, New York

Nice staff delicious pastries would 100% recommend Right in the heart of Babylon village read more

Torta Fina Bakeshoppe - It WAS banana pudding lol I should've taken a before photo but it was too good!! - Bakeries Near Me - Babylon, New York

Such a cute bakery! The woman who helped us was so sweet and patient. We got some shortbread cookies- all were fantastic! Definitely recommend popping in this bakery. read more

I want to truly Thank You for customizing a perfect cake for my son's small private wedding ceremony. It was exactly what I requested. The cakes tasted exactly like your delicious black & white cookies which my family is obsessed with. Unfortunately I don't have a close up picture of the bride & groom cake pops but they said it was absolutely delicious. We miss you guys since your doors closed in Commack but of course when we want something delicious & sweet we always come to visit you. Thanks again! I always highly recommend you. read more

Torta Fina Bakeshoppe - a cake decorated with flowers - Bakeries Near Me - Babylon, New York

See all

Beautiful bakery! So cute inside, the decor and layout is so lovely. Everything truly looked delicious. There were items everywhere you looked. I always have a hard time finding a good croissant on Long Island, and this one was as close to a Parisian croissant as I could find (only one other on LI received this status). Flakey, buttery, slightly crispy, it was truly delicious. I look forward to coming back and trying other things! read more

See all

I ordered my daughter's bridal shower cake from Torta Fina on a friend's recommendation. As soon as I walked into the Bakeshoppe I knew I had made the right decision. The shoppe is immaculate and adorable with all their vintage touches. The cake was as delicious as it was gorgeous. Everyone was very impressed. Thank you! read more

Torta Fina Bakeshoppe - Beautiful bridal shower cake & the beautiful bride! - Bakeries Near Me - Babylon, New York

stopped to get st joseph zeppole get home and it's filled with strawberry jam????? no mention of it at all and looking at it in display none of it was showing. tasted nothing like a st joseph at all. it was basically a cream puff with a terrible jam . disappointed read more

I think is one of the best bakeries on the south shore of Long Island. From the decor, to the beautiful decorated cakes, and cup cakes. The cookies are over sized and amazing. It's hard to decide what to pick. They also so have gluten-free brownies and cookies, the can make gluten free cakes to order. read more

See all

Orders cupcakes for my daughter's bridal shower and the looked exactly like the website photo ! So delicious and well packed to transport ! Will definitely be going back! read more

Torta Fina Bakeshoppe - Red velvet cupcakes with dahlia butter cream top - Bakeries Near Me - Babylon, New York

See all

Planning a trip back to get more cake pops ASAP! Went today for some Irish soda bread and left with an additional two rainbow cake pops. The Irish soda bread was not the traditional one I was expecting but instead had citrus undertones. I think there is candied orange baked inside. It is quite good though just a bit unexpected. The rainbow cake pops are bursting with flavor. My only regret is not buying more. read more

Torta Fina Bakeshoppe - Irish soda bread - Bakeries Near Me - Babylon, New York

The following is a letter I wrote to the folks at Torta Fina Hi Folks, I want to say a HUGE thank you for what you did for our daughter. A while back we had a house fire and found out last minute we had to get out of the trailer and move back into the house, though unfinished. In the chaos and confusion, we forgot to order a cake for our 13 year old daughter. The night before she presented us with a photo of what she wanted. We came down as you were closing and yet you took care of everything and created the cake just as she imagined it. It was beautiful and delicious. I can't thank you enough for going the extra mile and doing a special thing for a special girl in a world where so many people say, "sorry can't help you" We are very grateful for your kindness, and you have a customer for life. Chrissy and Matt On a side note EVERYTHING in that store is amazing. Ive not seen a bakery like this before. The shortbreads are amazing and so many different types. You can get lost in all the goodies. read more

I hate to give bad reviews but when it comes to food I think it's important to give feedback. I had a pastry. Looked delicious. Tasted not great but then stomach cramp. I don't know it it might have been old or needed refrigeration but something wasn't right with it. I don't think I'll go back because once this happens I find another place. I hope this helps management check their baked items for freshness. read more

Torta Fina in commack was amazing - I'm not sure if they just stopped caring in Babylon or people really eat with their eyes only bc to put it simply - "the juice ain't worth the squeeze" !! So sad to say this but , the price point is that of Manhattan and the quality has plummeted in our opinion - scones used to be delicious , now a mouthful of dried up flavorless nothing - especially the blueberry , which used to be delicious !!! Cakes are beautiful , prob the best to order what you desire , they're ok but expensive , you'd like to believe you got what you pay for - I'll leave that to you ! We look a lot and frankly have been leaving , a lot !!!! Ps it's TORTA FINA ! Idk why it will not take edit !! read more

Torta Fina Bakeshoppe is one of the best bakeries around. There is such a wide variety of options. It is the go to place if you're visiting and really want to impress the guests. My favorite is not available all the time, but I would imagine you can special order it. I love their caramel, pecan, and chocolate torte. It's almost like a giant candy bar. It's readily available around the holidays. If you try it, you will be back for more (and more). I also recommend their Hummingbird Cake. It tastes like a bite of spring. I tried the chocolate cake pops and would say they were the best I've ever had. The staff is amazing too. read more

There's too many good choices here! I've enjoyed everything I've ever tried. Highly recommended.

They had a shop at the Christmas Market and I had bought the chocolate chip cookies along with the dark chocolate brownie. They were soooo delicious! Chocolate chip cookies were thin and crispy just how I like them. The brownie was so decadent and rich tasting. They also had Christmas donuts and my daughter had one. It was okay, not impressive but just festive looking. If I'm ever in the area again, I'll def get more cookies and brownies! read more

This is a really good bakery, located in Babylon. I used to patronize the one in Commack until it closed doors several years ago. Yesterday I ordered the banana pudding. It was just ok, nothing like the one sold at the Magnolia Bakery in Greenwich Village. I also had the yellow cupcake with chocolate icing. That was also okay. Nevertheless, the bakery is basically the best in Suffolk County. It has plenty of City-fied goods to offer. That is why I am giving it four stars. read more

Sausage pie Made only around Thanksgiving time, it contains sweet Italian Fennel Sausage, Mozzarella, Ricotta, and Parmigiana Cheese. The look of this pie is quite striking, a work of edible art! I didn't know what to expect when I heard they made such a pie, and what it turned out to be was definitely different than anything I imagined. Essentially it's similar to a quiche lorraine, with crumbled sausage instead of bacon, and less of an egg texture for the filling. Instead, it's savory, creamy and rich. A slice would be good with breakfast, accompanied by an egg. If I had one complaint, it's that it doesn't have enough sausage in there. Dulce De Leche Chocolate Fudge Cookie A dollop of soft caramel atop a thick chocolate cookie, drizzled with chocolate. Decent, and while the caramel is a nice addition, the cookie was not quite as chocolatey as I wanted it to be . . . Upper West Side Chocolate Peanut Butter Chunk Cookie A veritable mound of chocolate cookie with a decent chocolate taste, with lots of peanut butter chips that unfortunately weren't as peanut buttery as one would like. . . read more

See all

Went in with mask on to browse and buy some delicious items for friends dinner. Chocolate eclairs, walnut butter cookies, cannolis of course!, and sfogliatellas (lobster tails) filed with custard. All a hit! Friends really surprised by the non-traditional walnut butter cookies and were raving. I cannot have ANY of it because I'm Gluten Free, but they did have some Gluten free items...specifically there were some amazing brownies I got awhile ago that are off the charts! My sister has requested I inquire about having them somehow create a a gluten Free brownie cake for her 40th! I'll try! Lol. Didn't see the brownies there this time but there were plenty of choices for my non-GF friends. read more

Torta Fina Bakeshoppe - Bakeries Near Me - Babylon, New York

See all

Stopped in today because I was at a nearby Chinese food store. The ladies behind counter were very nice! Everything I tried I really liked .. I will be back read more

Cute bakery and seemingly great desserts based on the look and mix of interesting flavors but my only experience was buying a candied apple there today. Unfortunately it still has the sticker label on the apple when they candied it. Just a poor experience but I would still consider going back to try something more traditional from their selections. read more

Torta Fina Bakeshoppe - Candied apple - Bakeries Near Me - Babylon, New York

This place is very good. I've NEVER brought these products to a friends house and had someone take a bite of the goods and spit it across the room in disgust. In fact just the opposite. They gobble it down like gavones on steroids. This is my go to place for bread and cakes and cookies! Staff is friendly. Place is clean also. read more

I just called to order a cake for my daughters birthday, they advertise on Instagram about cakes daily, I call 2 days in advance and they said they can't make cake to order, it even says right here on Yelp custom order cakes, it was only a typical rainbow cake, two years ago I ordered a cake and there was mold in it and ruined the birthday, do not deal with this place, I called today to give them another chance being Instagram looked so upbeat but they're still a complete failure . read more

Nommm nommmm nommmm I want everything every time I come here Prices are great & everything is delicious read more

See all

I love the bakery Torta Fina. They have delicious Italian cookies and some of the best rainbow cookies on the island. The real magic is on Sunday when they make fresh crumb cake. It is definitely some of the best I have ever get in my life. Torta fina is definitely worth the trip whether your a local, visitor, or from another town. read more

Extremely happy with our two custom ordered cakes. One was with a white chocolate cage on the outside with black and white cake and cannoli filling inside. Fresh, beautiful and delicious. Only negative was the flower which was fake so we topped with our own fresh sunflower. Beautiful! The second cake was a "naked" cake. Bananas foster inside. Delicious and absolutely beautiful! We added our own cake sign and candles. From ordering, to pick up, displaying the cakes, and most importantly eating these beautiful cakes, everything was perfect! Even the price! I wouldn't hesitate going back. read more

See all

Stopped by the bakery today to pick up a strawberry shortcake for my mom's birthday. Quite possibly the best strawberry shortcake I have ever had. I felt it was expensive, but honestly it was so delicious.! Definitely recommend! read more

I stumbled upon here by accident. On Saint Patrick's Day another shop in Babylon Village posted that Torta Fina dropped off *gluten free* irish soda bread as a present. 1) I love local businesses having a good relationship with each other and 2) Gluten Free Irish Soda Bread!! I haven't seen any since I went gluten free years ago. I called and they kindly held a loaf aside for me. When I arrive I decided to get a second loaf for my fiancé's family as well (his mom and grandma are gluten free). My family, his family, and I all loved the bread. My mom doesn't like a lot of sugar so she would have liked if there was an option without so much sugar on top, but she brushed off a lot of it and still enjoyed the bread. Torta Fina's prices were definitely steep, so I can't frequent here as much as I'd like, but I can't wait to come back and try something else. I would definitely suggest that they advertise their gluten free treats a little better, since it was a fluke I found them read more

Torta Fina Bakeshoppe - Gluten free Irish Soda bread. Delicious! - Bakeries Near Me - Babylon, New York

We bought birthday cake a few time bcuz my daughter love how the way they looks but taste was horrible no taste at all doesn't worth the price read more

Yes, five stars for aesthetics. Absolutely well appointed inside and out. Makes you want to come in and spend your money and get fat doing it. So much to choose from and it all looks fresh. Lots of loaves like lemon with icing, pumpkin, chocolate babka, etc... also love their pink boxes. Can't speak to much else as my purchase was a gift so not sure what they thought. read more

Visit Date: August 2, 2013 I've been here before but I didn't feel I could review it until today. I walked into the bakery this morning before getting on my train, I was in desperate need of a good cup of coffee. I knew I could get a great cup at the Babylon Bean but I had limited time and was passing torta fina on the way to the train station. I walked in and ordered a cappuccino with skim milk and took a linzer tart with me to eat at some point during my work day. The cappuccino was just what I needed after sipping two cups of terrible coffee, torta fina provided the good cup I needed to kick start my day. I ate the linzer tart on my lunch break, it was absolutely divine. If I could take a bite of heaven this could be it! The tart was so fresh, the crust a perfect proportion of slightly buttery flavor and sweetness. The jam inside was perfect and the powdered sugar was an awesome final touch to complete this favorite tart of mine! I've sampled many linzer tarts and torta fina definitely makes an awesome one! I will be back here once in awhile for occasional sugary treats! I think this bakery is expensive my coffee and tart price wasn't all that bad but even though the goods are worth it if you are on a budget just beware, unless you allow a good budget for a nice cake than come here and get it! read more

See all

Ordered a cake (#3) for my baby shower and stole the show, it's gotten so many compliments not just for the looks but it tasted heavenly as well. It made the event 10x better for sure. read more

Torta Fina Bakeshoppe - My babyshower cake, stole the show - Bakeries Near Me - Babylon, New York

See all

My favorite go-to bakery. Everything tastes so fresh and delicious. Friendly staff. Fair prices. So many treats to choose from. I love the pink boxes. Beautiful decor inside and even better quality of the products. 10/10 recommend read more

I was walking by the place and the aroma made me walk in. I walked into this place and the aroma was absolutely amazing, i had to order a cappuccino and a delicious cookie. I wasn't having a bad day at all, but the woman behind the counter was the sweetest and def brightened up my day!! I assumed she was the owner because of the the way she was and was greeting everyone, later to find out she wasn't, complete shock. She was awesome and saw was my cappuccino & Cookie. read more

Torta Fina Bakeshoppe - French vanilla cappuccino - Bakeries Near Me - Babylon, New York

Stumbled upon this neighborhood gem after dinner. I love local bakeries. Torta Fina has beautiful looking cakes, cookies and pies. We went with some black and white cookies of which they had 2 varieties. The traditional one with hard icing and a freshly frosted one. My daughter chose traditional. She said it was delicious! She also enjoyed the rainbow cookies. We took home a bumble berry pie. Apple, blueberry, raspberry, tart cherry, blackberry and whatever other type of berry you can think of. It was still warm and that was at 6:30pm so they make fresh all the time. More to come after we cut into it tonight with company. read more

Torta Fina Bakeshoppe - Bakeries Near Me - Babylon, New York

They do have some delicious items I will buy again but be warned, do not waste your money on a cake. We paid $60 for a birthday cake that no one enjoyed. I'm not sure if it was old or what the issue was but you're better off going to a small family owned bakery to spend half the amount on something you will enjoy eating. They make Great biscotti, cookies and cake pops but stay away from their cake. It's beautiful but gross read more

My friend bought a cake from here and surprised me with it at my birthday gathering. It was a chocolate-covered cheesecake. Not only was it gorgeous, but it was absolutely delicious!! read more

Torta Fina Bakeshoppe - Chocolate-covered cheesecake - Bakeries Near Me - Babylon, New York