Ordered Margherita pie for delivery. I'm always weary of doing that, but it was delivered with care and tasted amazing! :)

Don't understand the wild rave reviews for this place. Ordered a large Sicilian pie - was a small super dense ultra thick circular pie, cut cross ways to make square slices but you ended up with two large awkward half moon shaped slices at the ends. Crust is dense and at least properly baked - but you end up with a very weird ratio of sauce cheese and crust: just absolute crust overload. These issues could've easily been solved by making an actual Sicilian pizza. Sauce and cheese were nothing to write home about and not good enough on their own to warrant any improvement on the overall impression. I've been looking for a new pizza place, this ain't it for me. read more

Love the pizza at Toscana it's always tasty and the crust is the best around. We always do take out although there are some tables and seats around for a quick bite down town. read more

NEW OWNER!!! ‼ What a difference, William is a nice guy & makes a great pizza No flop, nice char on crust sauce yummy! Right amount of cheese,, & place clean & cozy now read more

Toscana Pizza - Margherita Pizza, regular pie - Tuscan Near Me - Allendale, New Jersey

Crust is amazing. Perfect ratio of cheese to sauce. Old school style. Mom n pop feel. My favorite pizza in the area.

We ordered a pizza and eggplant last night. Both were great and prompt delivery. My kids can eat two slices each and everyone in the house always loves their pizza. First time trying their eggplant and asked for an appetizer portion. Was great! read more

Toscana Pizza - Eggplant Rollatine - Tuscan Near Me - Allendale, New Jersey

We ordered a meat lover's pie and mozzarella sticks. The sauce is nice and fresh and the crust is the perfect mix of traditional and thin crust. There was chicken cutlet inclu8in the meat lover's...a hearty pie read more

See all

New to the area. I ordered pizza,a chicken salad, a chicken wrap, and chicken finger with fries. Very bland fried chicken in the wrap and Cesar salad. Pizza was good The chicken fingers were made with a different breading than used for the wrap and salad. I would order the pizza again. Thin crust and the sauce was very good. read more

We stopped ordering from here a while ago because the pizza just wasn't as good as other places. But we got a gift certificate and figured we might as well try it again. We ordered a medium veggie pie without peppers or mushrooms, and got a bland, undercooked pizza with onions and a little bit of spinach on it. No tomatoes, no olives, and barely any seasoning. The pepperoni pizza we ordered for the kids was also anemic looking, but at least the cheese was more melted than the veggie pie. It was a good reminder on why we stopped going here, and we won't be returning. read more

Toscana Pizza - Veggie pie, hold the peppers. Apparently it means hold everything else too... cheese barely melted. We won't be ordering from here again. - Tuscan Near Me - Allendale, New Jersey

Awesome place! Called ahead of time this past Saturday and I formed them a group of us were coming in. They had pizza, garlic knots, chicken tenders and tables ready for us! Great service, delicious food and clean place. Definitely a must! Street parking. read more

Great service, the owner was super friendly and nice even when they're was a crowd in there. Also awesome prices for such great food. Lots of different types of great pizza. read more

After our last pizzeria burned us, we decided to support another local business by not cooking. The pizza here is super thin crust which makes it exceptionally delicious. They deliver and pre-COVID had dine-in. Maybe they'll have it again one day. The mushroom pizza was robust but the Sausage was kind of skimpy. I'd definitely get mushroom or Margherita next time. How could I not love a pizza place right next to a liquor store? read more

See all

Just ordered delivery for the first time. Pepperoni pizza, vodka pizza, combo appetizer were all delicious! Got a salad and chicken wrap for lunch tomorrow...everything was fresh and delicious. Will be ordering again! read more

Excellent food, more than just pizza (which was great) wonderful staff especially Sabin, friendly visit.

It was good. However The small pizza is one step from a personal size. Yet it was just enough for my family. But if I had more to feed I recommend the large size. read more

so good and fast, amazing vodka sauce, pizza. all my friends are obsessed. Service is great. Everyone is nice and the restaurant is so cute.

absolutely amazing pizza/italian food and service. we have been enjoying toscana for years. owner billy is so kind .. the food is excellent pizza and penne alfredo with sauteed chicken and broccoli awesome. .they deliver and you never wait. any issue billy corrects it "yesterday". affordable and always so very kind .. best little pizza place in allendale. .. great staff.. cannot say enough about them and i do not write reviews. thanks billy and your team. !!!!!! read more

Best Vodka pizza in a 50 mile radius. The employees are super nice and the will forever be my favorite pizza spot

We ordered a thin crusted cheese pizza. Lots of sauce & cheesy. It was delicious. Another time we ordered a sausage & mushrooms pizza. Just as good. Going to be our go to pizza place. Deliveries was fast. read more

I'm sorry but the Linguini w White clams sauce had no clams. Onion rings were mushy Margarita pizza was good but warm Sorry-wanted to love this place! read more

This is your classic pizza, deli spot. Everything was good and the customer service was great. They went out of their way to make sure we were taken care of. read more

Toscana Pizza - Tuscan Near Me - Allendale, New Jersey

Mushroom pizza is amazing. Definitely a must try. And very friendly staff Mushrooms Pizza read more

Good pizza, and garlic knots. And mozz are like when we were kids. Good local spot. Always consistent.

This is your classic pizza spot (think pre-made pizzas behind glass waiting for you to get slices reheated, some stools, a few benches, but mostly a take-out/delivery place). If you're looking for a non-fancy classic pizza in the area, Toscana does a very good job. The prices are reasonable and the service I had was perfectly fine. I do wish they were a bit more generous with the sausage and used hot Italian rather than sweet but that's a minor criticism. I'll definitely be coming back here. read more

I ordered a large pizza, 1/2 pepperoni, 1/2 cheese through their online ordering using GrubHub. Also ordered garlic bread with cheese. Got the pizza in 20 mins. Great! No. The pizza was barely warm, missing the toppings. Garlic bread was barely warm also, missing the cheese. I checked my order and it very clearly noted the toppings for the garlic bread and pizza. Disappointing... read more

In an area that has a pizzeria on every corner boasting "Real" Italian Pizza, it is very to stand out in a crowd. Toscana is certainly up to the task! Nestled in the middle of Allendale, Toscana is a true gem in a market of imitations. Crispy crust, fresh ingredients and friendly staff make this one of the best options in the area. Eddie, the owner greets everyone with a smile and the friendly service does not end until you are stuffed! Do yourself a favor and grab a true taste of Italy in the heat of Allendale. read more

Toscana Pizza - Classic Toscana Pizza. - Tuscan Near Me - Allendale, New Jersey

See all

Love their grilled chicken sandwich very refreshing and yummy, also there's a variety of delicious foods checking this place is a must !!! read more

Toscana Pizza - Tuscan Near Me - Allendale, New Jersey

Love this place. Everything I order from pizza to salad is fantastic. Delivery is always fast and food is hot. Thank you!

4 min drive from Sky Zone..so perfect stop for dinner after a high impact trampoline session. The staff are super friendly and accommodating. Ordered a veggie thin crust and it was ready within 13 minutes. 6 slices for under $12= I'm sold! Mmmmm delicious crust and yummy flavor! I highly recommend. I come to this area often so I now have my new fave pizza spot and looking forward to trying all the different flavors they have to offer. read more

Toscana Pizza - Veggie thin crust...delicious!!! - Tuscan Near Me - Allendale, New Jersey

Pizza is good with fast delivery. We order all the time . They also offer thin crust pizza too

The pizza is fabulous. Well done, thin-ish crust (thicker than a bar pie but much thinner than a typical NY/NJ pizza shop). It's a bit crunchy. Not too overwhelmed with toppings. Reminds me of pizza in Italy. Ambiance is not great. But, it shouldn't be. It's a simple pizza takeout spot in a town with some great Italian food. read more

Toscana Pizza - Perfect crust thickness and crunchiness. - Tuscan Near Me - Allendale, New Jersey

Great Pizza They use Simolina Flour the crust has a yellow tint and the. Crust is Crispy

great crunchy pizza! I live in the town over and wanted to try a new place, Toscana was definitely the right pick. highly recommend, ingredients like no other! read more

Never disappoints me! Great pizza! My favorite is vodka slice. I've ordered an entire pie a couple of times and my co-workers also enjoyed it. OMG! it is delicious! Fast delivery & arrived warm! Thank you!! read more

Toscana Pizza - Tuscan Near Me - Allendale, New Jersey

We ordered through Doordash and our Doordarsher said the restaurant was still making our food and so we had to wait a while to get our food .We get it and this is what my husband's cheesesteak looks like. Very disappointing read more

Toscana Pizza - Burnt food - Tuscan Near Me - Allendale, New Jersey

Hands down best slice of sausage I've had in recent memory. Just as good as when it blew my mind in April! Kids said they have the best sauce they've ever had! read more

Pizza was really good, the guy working behind the counter showed us that the dough was made of semolina flour, told us about what makes a good pizza... very friendly conversation and delicious thin crust pizza. Cozy "pizza joint" vibe inside. Recommended! read more

Sevice and delivery are excellent. They make a decent Cheese steak, but I really like their Grilled Chicken Hero. Very reasonably priced. Cool lunch spot. read more

Toscana Pizza - Tuscan Near Me - Allendale, New Jersey

See all

Placed a large order with a specific delivery time and everything was absolutely perfect! The phone rep was very friendly and helpful, the food arrived exactly on time and the pizza was excellent. Thanks so much! read more

Great little pizza place in Allendale. This crisp crust, vodka pie is outstanding. Similar to a good bar pie. Always my go to.