When you walk in you are greeted by a wonderful staff and the amazing smell of baked goods. The…read morestaff is always so helpful and so inviting. My favorite right now are the blueberry scones. They're so fluffy and the blueberries are so fresh. And the bakery itself is always so clean and welcoming.

Late review as we stopped by during the Merry Christmas in July Celebration!…read more This small batch bakery in Wooster was featuring adorable sweet treats like this Aloha Sugar Cookie Gingerbread Man! We also loved the Key Lime Cheesecake & S'more's Brownie! So many good options with fast and friendly service! They share a small parking lot with a florist and luckily Ott's Coffee mobile coffee shop was parked there that day too!

It was overall really a clean restaurant. Came here for the first time two days ago. I didn't know…read morewhat to expect. The person at the front was super helpful. I ended up getting a chicken panini and s'mores custard. Only thing I would say the s'mores custard was okay. Wasn't a fan but I should have gotten something different. The panini was bomb and I ate it all. They also had games for people to play and hang out. My brothers and I played sorry and hung out for awhile. I would recommend to anyone in orrville or going through orrville

I don't ordinarily eat desserts of any kind but when I do I try and make them dairy free choices…read more This very homey and welcoming roadside attraction certainly lived up to my anticipation, I wish I had eaten lunch there after reviewing the menu. I got some mango sorbet and it was fantastic, my brother got strawberry ice cream and he said his was great as well. This is precisely what makes traveling in rural areas so much fun, serendipity and a zest for adventure is a great combination and this place did not disappoint.

Went to Stella's for ice cream with a couple friends and we are DEFINITELY going back. The place…read morewas such a joyful experience with a beautiful interior and exterior. The staff was super duper friendly and even gave comments and suggestions about flavors they personally liked. The ice cream itself was FANTASTIC and tasted like heaven. The portions is a lot of icecream and it isn't that expensive at all.

A delicious and affordable coffee shop with such a cute atmosphere! I got an iced matcha latte and…read moreit was great, and the ice cream was delicious too. They even had a gluten free cone available. Their coffee was very smooth and not bitter and cheaper than a chain store while being way better. The decor was super charming, with taxidermy and antiques that made the space feel really unique. They also sell cute merch like sweatshirts and totes, plus ice cream cakes and their prepackaged coffee and matcha. They had bagels, muffins, and other baked goods for sale too. The shop was also very clean. The employee was busy mopping and tidying while I was there, and it definitely showed with how clean it was.

Since the theme of the past week has been Eastern Europe cakes, it was imperative that I tried a…read moreDobos torte from Hungary to complete the trio (this past weekend I tried Austrian and Serbian cakes). I think Tulipan's take on the Dobos torte was probably the least authentic of the three, but it was not a bad cake. I've seen it with more layers and a caramel top. This one had four layers (still impressive and a pain in the arse to make I'm sure!) and no caramel. This bakery is very cute and the service is very friendly. My son also asked for some macarons, which he seemed to like, but he couldn't finish them because he said he was full. We were there around 12:30 PM and I think most of the items were fairly picked over in the bakery case by that time. There was an interesting raspberry thing that I wanted to try, but the person in line right before me bought the last one. The baklava looked temping too. I am pretty proud of myself for not buying too many sweets. I would return here if I were in the area and try some different items.

Cute little place! Came inside to get a little warm…read more Ordered a hot apple chai and was the perfect sweetness. Lots of delicious looking pastries too! Great service!

I have been here a few times and have loved my food every time. Customer service is always…read morewonderful and the food is fresh and perfect. I love the portion sizes that aren't overwhelming-they're just right. I have enjoyed the cheese platter, the hummus plate, the chicken Marsala and the jambalaya. The desserts are lovely as well!

Ordered this pizza for lunch, which was pretty pricey. Honestly, the food cost on this thing…read moremust've been like three dollars at best. It was a 12 inch type sized pizza with not much to it and I didn't think the taste was unbelievably different or special. Looked like they use sandwich pepperoni, which is just kind ok believe it. This is ordered as a double pepperoni pizza. Probably would never order this again.

First time visit. Excellent ice cream. Top quality. Will be a definite return for us. Keep up the…read moregreatness.

Hartzler does its job well. If you want good ice cream and milk, you're going to get good ice cream…read moreand milk. With a strong selection of flavors in both categories, you're bound to be satisfied. Tip: Don't be afraid to try the discounted milk. Though it's closer to expiration, you could not tell via smell or taste. You can get great value if you're looking to sample different flavors (ex: chocolate, strawberry) or if you're feeding a family of thirsty lactose tolerants

This place may look old but its amazing. The food is delicious and hot, the girl at the window…read moretaking our order was polite and funny. We will definitely be back..

Nice little old school walk-up diner with yummy shakes and burgers. We like to stop in when we are…read morein the area, and rhe kids enjoybthenice cream selection. The service is always great.

I was down visiting lake buckhorn and celebrating a birthday so called ahead and ordered a cake…read more They took my order and let me customize everything over the phone. The ice cream cake was so tasty and everyone working was very nice when I came to pick it up. Next time I will be stopping to try their ice cream in the shop because it is very cute!

Great service here. Was greeted immediately and the ice cream was amazing. Had the apple crisp with…read moresoft serve. Wow!! So good! After a bike ride it was just the thing we needed. Great old style retro ice cream shop ambiance too.

DO NOT ORDER ONLINE. I want to start by saying this review is not about the food itself. The baked…read moregoods are delicious and if you're in Wooster you should give them a try. My issue is with the service and never actually receiving my order. I placed an order on December 8th, 2024. My order was confirmed and my money was taken yet I did not ever get my food. PLEASE SEE ATTACHED SCREENSHOTS. If you look on the bottom right corner you can see I am writing this on February, 27th 2025 and my order still says it is in transit on Butter & Fire's website, BUT according to USPS was never brought to the site to be shipped. I was extremely disappointed because this was the second time my household has tried ordering from them. The first time we were at an apartment so we figured that it is easy to get mixed up there, but this time we ordered to a house and it was never even sent! When my fiance reached out about both orders again and the legitimacy of our concerns were questioned. If we were lying or trying to pull one over on them we would have tried to get money- WE JUST WANTED THE SCONES!!!