Service, decor, food, $$, & happy hour at the tables too. Happy Cinco de Mayo baby. Got here when it opened up at 1500 and got street parking in front of the restaurant. That's how PopPop does it does it. Perfect Peach Sangria & flavored Margaritas. The best tender sweet mussels we ever had. Finished up with the Termisu...... "Voila!!!" Christina was a great hostess. Very attentive and attractive too. Sorry...., EVERYTHING WAS SPOT ON!!! Nothing to complain about An easy 5 stars from Brooklyn PopPop! read more

Stopped in here for dinner the other day. The place itself was beautiful, they have indoor and outdoor seating. Issue was it was so hot outside, inside was hot as well. The staff were friendly and attentive. The menu is a little expensive but understandable. I ordered a watermelon salad, which was lacking to be honest. And my friend ordered a burger and didn't feel too well after the fact. I don't know if it was not cooked fully or the heat. But he was not really happy with that. read more

Good food overall, though the experience had a few hiccups. We came here for brunch on a Saturday. Unfortunately, our food took an exceptionally long time to arrive, and my potatoes were undercooked and hard. That said, the lobster Benedict was absolutely delicious and easily the highlight of my meal. My friend ordered the steak and eggs and requested her steak medium, but it came out well done, which was disappointing. Another friend ordered the lobster mac and cheese and said it was very filling--so much so that she had leftovers to take home. The Caesar salad was good, and the fried calamari was also well prepared and not overly oily, which I appreciated. We also missed the show, which was a bit of a letdown. Despite the service delays and a few issues with the food preparation, there were enough positives that I would return and give them another try. read more

See all

I almost feel silly for reviewing again so soon but I just feel obliged after recently having such a great Father's Day brunch. We made reservations for 1pm and sat right along the back windows, with a clear view of the rear docks and the water. I got the drunken mussels, calamari and ceasar salad. It was the perfect meal complete with incredible service and perhaps some of the best ambiance (without any bit of pretentiousness) this side of Atlantic ave. read more

See all

Decent view of the pier where boats dock/leave, however, it often smells like gas and smoke. Food was not great. Clam chowder was watery with barely any clams. Fish and chips came out soggy. Shrimp roll was a small portion with chips. Service was great. read more

Off The Hook Raw Bar & Grill - Seafood Near Me - Freeport, New York

The Service was great! We sat outside along the canal, it was lovely! The Fish and chips was so so, the breading was not crunchy. The lobster roll was skimpy and they only had buttered lobster rolls. We also had appy of Fried Calamari, very skimpy serviing and watery marinara sauce . Sorry, we might try again..... read more

The food is always fresh, prices are right. I don't have a favorite dish there because, all the dishes are always amazing.

Holy Moly!! I'm sure glad I followed my yelp elite friend's reviews to help me with dining here. TBH everything from the customer service, food and drinks was great!! I made reservations thru opentable, but when arriving I saw some availability inside and outside. We were promptly greeted and seated. Our waiter was Rich, he was friendly, funny and attentive to what we ordered. He apparently juggles apples too impressive lol but they are great at this restaurant. Food: I had the lobster mac and cheese and the not so old fashioned, both were delicious. My friends had shrimp and fries with the rum punch as well as the chicken and drink with prosecco and with a juice that made it turn purple pretty cool. I believe it came with a lemon drop shot. Appetizers we got the calamari and mozzarella Rangoon delish. We sat outside in front on the mile but I hear they have seating in the back area near the water. Definitely come here!! I will definitely come back here and try a few other dishes as well. Keep up the good work and great tasting food and drinks. read more

See all

Great food. Nice location. Definitely get the red snapper . The seafood was my favorite at this location, drinks were...niceeee. I plan to come again for happy hour. The service was fine our waiter had alot of patience with the large group we had. She also took our family picture which was very kind of her read more

See all

The bartender I was looking for wasn't there smh. But! I sat at the bar . The vibe was cool. I did like the oysters. They were very good. The drink was good. I think it was a crab meat mozzerella stick? I don't know why I feel it was imitation crab meat ... read more

See all

Raw oysters were good but smaller and more expensive than I ate in chic nyc restaurant. Whole snapper was fried- not a good technique- for much too long. It was completely dry and flavorless. Smashed plantain side also overcooked, dry, flavorless. Tasty cocktail but almost virgin. Waitress was so so. Live jazz was nice but an already noisy restaurant- so minimal conversation. $85!!! read more

This place was amazing!!! We sat at the bar just to get a couple of drinks and we ended up getting oysters. The best oysters I've ever had on Long Island. They were amazing. They were fresh and we also were in the mood to try their live role. best la role I ever had definitely coming back for happy hour and to get that food again lol. read more

See all

After having many meals here in the past few years, we were very disappointed in the service and with the food was served to us. The Fried Squid was obviously an old freezer burned frozen food product that certainly was not fresh sea food. The raw oysters on the half shell were very small. The worst part was the warm Lobster roll that just was awful. The lobster itself tasted like frozen lobster and was not fresh and had a fishy flavor to and just tasted bad. Instead of the normal Butter and Garlic they put Mayo on the bread! It was awful. Mayo does NOT go on a Warm Lobster Roll! They rushed us with the meal and brought all of the food out at one time. This was a very expensive, very bad experience. read more

When I arrived I parked on the street nearby. I walked in and I was greeted and sat. The place was dimly lit and nice. I was served by Kim and she was great. I started with the espresso martini and that was good. For food I had: Drunken Mussels Shrimp Mofongo Mac and cheese The food was delicious! I really loved the Mussels the most! I really enjoyed my time! read more

See all

Went with family and the Food was great. Service was second to none. The waitress Ximena was very attentive and helpful when asked for suggestions. I love this place directly on the water and the decor was well thought out and makes it stand out. I love the rays of lights that came through the ceiling. Will definitely go again. PS. I almost forgot the drinks. Try both the passion fruit margarita and mojito. read more

See all

I was here this weekend for an early dinner with a large group. There was a parade going on so it was busy with some great music playing. We got seated right away and our orders were taken and brought out to us in a timely manner. Our waiter Richard was a riot! He had us laughing and entertained the whole time. I ordered the NE clam chowder and fish and chips. The soup was mediocre. I was somewhat disappointed there but the fish was delicious. Fresh and well prepared. I will be returning! read more

Beautiful scenery and outdoor seating with friendly staff. I ordered the warm lobster roll since the server recommended it; however, it was very chewy and not tender like other rolls I've had. The regular fries were hot and crispy. I recommend the regular fries over the yucca fries. The yucca fries were tough and dry. Highly recommend the whole fish branzino and calamari. Both were very fresh and tender. If I were to return I would try the cold lobster roll...perhaps that one wouldn't be so chewy or the whole fish again. Overall a great staple if you know what to order read more

See all

Outstanding service! Very attentive and super friendly! Beautiful ambiance on a sunny day! Super clean and the food was very fresh Chicken Cesar salad ($13 extra for chicken) otherwise the salad about $12 the New England clam chowder! Has carrots and has the best flavor I've ever had! Absolutely delicious read more

See all

Beautiful and cute little place. Husband and I stopped by on a Monday evening. The bar was empty and most people sat at the tables. We like sitting at the bar for happy hour. We had the oysters for oyster week. We weren't crazy about the local ones this year but can't beat $1/each to try. We also tried their raw clams. They were nicely cleaned but was a bit bland (none of that seafood sweetness one seek). What you really must try is their crabmeat guacamole! It's so fresh with homemade tortilla chips (I'm guessing since it taste way too good coming from a bag). I also had their island punch and it is one of the best fruity cocktail I had for awhile. D the bartender definitely don't skimp on the alcohol and it still taste good (sneaky drink). The margarita was delicious too! Perfectly made! We were pretty content after 12 clams and 12 oysters, the appt, and drinks. I would definitely be back to try their regular menu next time. read more

See all

Went on a Saturday afternoon and the staff was energetic and helpful. Sat at the bar but didn't get the bartenders name but he makes a great island punch ($17). Cute spot with outdoor and waterside sitting. Well lit inside and good vibes. Would visit again. read more

Have been here several times, first time writing a review to let others know how great it is. The food is always great with creative dishes that wow you with every bite, the drinks are crafty as well. read more

Stopped by this spot on the Nautical Mile after work for a quick drink and bite. The location is definitely a win--right by the water with a cozy view if you're sitting near the bar or outside. The aesthetic inside is super cute, perfect for a chill night out with your girlfriends. We went for a glass of white and red wine, skipping the cocktails this time (just weren't in the mood for what they had to offer), but the bartender was very sweet and attentive. Service overall was great. I had my hopes set on trying the mofongo, but was disappointed to find it's no longer on the menu and wish the online menu was updated to reflect that. That was a letdown. Prices are on the higher end, but it's expected with the waterfront location. Food-wise, the 6-piece oysters were fresh, and the New England clam chowder really hit the spot, creamy, flavorful, and comforting. I tried the warm lobster roll, which was just okay, but the side of chips was a nice touch and could have used some lemon with the roll. Would love to come back during happy hour to give the cocktails a fair shot, maybe the vibe will be different then. Overall, a nice spot to unwind, but hoping for a few tweaks to the menu and pricing to make it a go-to. read more

See all

My boyfriend and I came here for dinner one night and after this experience we couldn't wait to share with everyone. The ambiance is romantic, elegant and classy. Right off the water, I can't wait to come here during the summer I just know it's going to be even more amazing to be able to sit outside. Our server was Ximena she was kind and patient with us and also gave some suggestions on menu items. To drink we had the chance to try many options and they got better and better each time. The Rosemary lemon drop was so good served in a rock glass and was so much more than what we expected. The Dark forest was one of my favorites I def say try this. The Fresh Mojito was one of the best mojitos I've ever had. If you come here for drinks and apps alone you will be on cloud 9. I heard happy hour is amazing I can't wait to come for that ($1 oysters). The oyster shots are amazing very spicy but really good. We ordered the House oysters which are the absolute best on nautical mile so fresh, excellent taste. Cajun baked clams my boyfriend enjoyed I couldn't have them since they had sausage however he enjoyed them and said they were really good also. The Cornflake shrimp is an absolute must have delicious, fried to perfection and the sauce was a great addition. We also got the Grilled octopus which was good it comes with a small bean salad which is served cold. I enjoyed this is was cooked well and not to oily. For entrees we had the linguine and clams which had plenty of clams. It also had good flavor and the portion was good. We also had the fried whole red snapper which was fried to perfection and beautifully presented. It came with sauces and crispy plantains very delicious. For dessert we got one of the most popular items which is the pistachio ricotta cake I love pistachio so this was also a good choice. read more

See all

Was very excited to try off the hook! The decor inside is very pretty. I came here with my mom & son this afternoon. We were excited to try as I heard good things. We ordered drinks - I had the tres amigas margarita - a spicy marg - very good. My mom had an espresso martini. Unfortunately It tasted terrible. Wasn't able to drink It, very watered down. We told the waiter and he took It off the bill and she got a lychee martini instead, she enjoyed that. We decided to split entrees - we split a Caesar salad and the double stack burger. They described It as a smash burger but It was so much juicier than that in my opinion. It also had a sauce on It which was very good. The Caesar was good but It tasted like no dressing (maybe they forgot?) I asked for an additional side of dressing and they gave at no charge. I heard the lobster Mac & cheese is great and I would like to come back to try read more

See all

Two starts only for the lobster mac n cheese and the avocado mouse appetizer (ask for chips because for some reason they won't come with them). If you're looking to spend money on a "decent" meal and want gimmicky service, def come here. If you're looking to get the most out of your money and more of a conservative dining experience, stay away! My wife and I were looking for more of an upscale dining atmosphere apart from the bars along the strip. We walked by Off the Hook and already, one of the waiters was cracking cheesy jokes to pull us in. Eye roll, but this was the only place that seemed like it would be our vibe. As soon as we sat, I hear someone coming up to our table asking, to some degree or another, how much respect we would have for someone with an extra long toothpick hanging out of their mouth. Right away, without even looking, I said, "not at all". Unfortunately, as I turn to shoo this clown away, I realize he's our waiter. Already, these were two hints to leave asap but we regretfully stayed. The third was the beverage I ordered. A Hugo Spritz. He brings a purple drink over and as I'm abt to drink it, he said that this extra shot he's holding will make it change color. Eye roll! I ultimately had to send it back because of how sugary it was and tasted nothing like what I ordered. For the main dish, he pushed the seabass special, even going to far as to show me a pic of it on his phone. Classy... I chose the branzino from the menu and he insisted on the special so fine. Once it came, you could tell it was a fish on its way out. Any whole fish you receive as an entree that has cloudy eyes, you know it wasn't the freshest fish. It was also tiny and flavorless. My wife liked the lobster mac n cheese so kudos to the kitchen for that. As we were halfway done, a family of 5 was seated extremely close to us where we had to move our table over. Meanwhile the place was EMPTY! This waiter again, was pitching this fish to this family but going so far as repeating how amazing it was and showing the pic of the fish to every single member of the party. We had a headache once we were ready to leave. read more

See all

Off The Hook was a Yelp find that definitely didn't disappoint. The three of us had salmon, halibut and steak, all of which were perfectly prepared. Service was spot on with our waiter Colin. We sat outside right on the water. This place will be on our return visit list for our next trip to Long Island. Highly recommended to give it a try. read more

Went here on a Saturday night. The host was kind and welcoming! The waitress who served us was nice but made it clear that the kitchen was closing soon which was strange that we could make a reservation so close to closing time. The restaurant itself is nicely decorated but the music was a bit too loud. The food overall was unremarkable, but not bad for a casual restaurant. read more

Just happened to stop by this place for a last minute date night and it really hit the spot. The grilled oysters were delicious and crab mozzarella Rangoon were delicious. We got a lobster roll and fish and chips both were so good. And also had a mojito and the lava cake for dessert. I definitely will be back here! The service was also on point ! read more

Off The Hook Raw Bar & Grill - MOZZARELLA RANGOON - Seafood Near Me - Freeport, New York

See all

Off the Hook Raw Bar is everything you want in a seafood spot--casual, fun, and fresh. The oysters were top-notch, and the shrimp and crab legs were loaded with flavor. You can tell they care about quality. Staff were super friendly and made us feel right at home. Great drink selection, laid-back vibe, and a perfect spot to relax after a long day. Whether you're local or just passing through Freeport, this place is 100% worth the stop. We'll definitely be back! The drinks were delicious! read more

Wow ! Was a pleasant lunch ! Stopped in to try this new gem on the Nautical Mile and my mouth is still watering. Clam chowder was by far my favorite. Beautiful decor and lighting, attentive staff & great food. I highly recommended trying this place I will be back ! read more

Off The Hook Raw Bar & Grill - OFF THE HOOK - Seafood Near Me - Freeport, New York

- indoor and outdoor seating - good for families - service is hit or miss - some of the servers are excellent, some are regular, at baseline - TVs for the games - cute car art in the bathroom - strong cocktails - well made mocktails - wonderful warm lobster roll chips are a great complement coleslaw is another perfect compelement I thought it could have been bigger - pistachio cake was a delicious and perfectly sized dessert - fried snapper was large I felt it could use more flavor the pickle ions was a good pairing - tostones were perfect - crab/guacamole dip was good and a perfectly sized app - macaroni and cheese looked good but very filling and hearty - spacious read more

Beautiful inside and out. Service was great. Drinks were on point! Food was delicious. Will definitely return. Oysters were perfect. Drunken mussels were yummy!! Shrimp was delicious and lobster Mac n cheese to die for. Margaritas were made to perfection. Loved it here. read more

See all

Awesome place! We went during a weekday so it wasn't very crowded, although I can imagine during a weekend this joint can get packed. Ordered the crab meat guacamole to start and immediately knew this would be a good meal! I ordered the Snapper which was amazing and my wife got the shrimp mofongo. Both were delicious. It was a very enjoyable experience and our server Ximena was fantastic as well. Highly recommend coming here. read more

See all

I came here for lunch today with my daughter. We each enjoyed a cocktail: my daughter had the tres amigos margarita and I ordered an espresso martini. The margarita was on point but the espresso martini tasted watered down. And it was a very light brown color. It was awful. Our waiter took it back and brought me a lechee martini, which was very good. I also want to mention their lemonade is refreshing and delicious. We shared a Caesar salad and a cheese burger. The salad arrived without any dressing on it. We asked the waiter for a side of dressing and he brought it right away. It was delicious. I loved the anchovy flavor and all the Parmesan cheese. The burger is actually smashed, so it is served well done and never rare or medium. We didn't miss that at all. It was juicy and full of flavor with the melted cheese and grilled onions on top. I can't wait to go back for dinner. read more

Came across this place from a Facebook post. Was a real nice surprise on the Nautical Mile where so many of the places have so-so food. This place did not disappoint. Grilled bread with olive oil served upon arrival. The oysters were Wellingtons from Massachusetts and I've never seen oysters shucked so perfectly that they were full of brine. Also super full sized! The ahi nacho app was quite exceptional. Full of flavor and, despite calling it a spicy remoulade, it was robust and not hot at all. The fish and chips were cooked to perfection and seasoned ideally. A hint of curry in the fresh cod gave it a unique flavor and the fries didn't need salt or ketchup. Nicely decorated and a welcoming owner. Just the sort of regular place one wants on the water. read more

See all

Ate there tonight and it was great. Temperature felt like it dropped 20 degrees in 10 minutes and the staff managed getting everyone set up inside eventually. All of the food was great, had to order dessert just because even though we were so full. Only slight nitpick is I wish they had a more robust beer menu. read more

Off The Hook Raw Bar & Grill - Grouper catch of the day - Seafood Near Me - Freeport, New York

Tried this spot for a lunch date with my girlfriends! Loved the food & the server Danny as he was very receptive & accommodating to us. We had the shrimp mofongo, grilled skirt steak with fries & the lobster Mac & cheese. We also had the pistachio ricotta cake. Everything was tasty & the atmosphere was nice! read more

See all

Must have been a bad day for the kitchen. Tasty clam chowder had NO clams; they said they "forgot them" when they made a new batch yesterday. Biscuits and gravy special was sent back as soon as it hit the table. See the photo! Ambiance and service was top notch! read more

Off The Hook Raw Bar & Grill - No clams. Seriously, none! - Seafood Near Me - Freeport, New York

See all

Amazing! I'm from California and this place is worth a drive all the way from California! Great drinks, great vibe, great owner and great food. I double highly recommend. read more

Off The Hook Raw Bar & Grill - Our amazing owner and a very happy customer - Seafood Near Me - Freeport, New York

Bad experience at the Freeport location. Appetizer never came, waitress pleaded ignorance. Entree took 45 minutes -$38 for small fish portion with cold "garlic" mashed potatoes that had no flavor. Creamed feta spinach side order came swimming in melted cheese soup. No offer to make amends, just lame excuses ("it's getting played now!"). Huge rip-off read more