On the advice of a family member, we tried the Greek Salad and Greek Fries. We ordered on line and the order was waiting on us when we got there. The Salads were Outstanding!! Who would have thought?? Not just a Hot Dog and Burger joint. So glad we tried some of the other items on their menu. We will definitely give the other items a try soon. read more

I just drove 11.5 hours to have a delicious chili hot dog with everything and fries. This local hometown favorite is one of a kind. There is plenty of seating inside. The service is fast and friendly. The hot dog chili can only be found in New Castle Bills sandwich shop. Everything is fresh. The fries were fried golden and crispy. If you are looking for the best chili dogs this is the place! I highly recommend. read more

A true hometown favorite with the best chili hotdogs around! You just can't find flavor like this anywhere else -- truly one of a kind. We traveled 11.5 hours and it was absolutely worth the trip. Great food, great service, and a place we'll definitely come back to. Highly recommend to anyone passing through or looking for an unforgettable meal! read more

Bill's Sandwich Shop is a true gem. My family and I have been coming here since I was a kid, and somehow, the food just keeps getting better. The grilled chicken sandwich? Hands down, the best I've ever had. Every bite is perfection--perfectly cooked chicken, just the right amount of lettuce, tomato, and mayo, and that slightly grilled bun... wow! And don't get me started on the chili dogs. I swear, they're the best in the world. Find me a better one, and I'll buy you a lifetime supply, I'm that confident. The secret? The young man who runs the place. He's always there, always working, and keeps Bill's running smoother than a new jar of peanut butter. Can't recommend Bill's enough! read more

Bill's Sandwich Shop - Chili dogs and the Grilled Chicken Sandwich - American Near Me - New Castle, Pennsylvania

Very friendly staff. Quaint comfortable ambience. Best chili in town made fresh. My husband loves their chili dogs and chili fries. Yesterday he enjoyed the phili cheesesteak. I always get their vegetable sandwich which has grilled onions and mushrooms etc. I love the flavor of it with the Italian dressing that is not overly sour with just enough seasoning. It's our go to lunch spot. Be sure to check out the local photographs and wall decor. read more

I order online from several restaurants and usually have no issues. For whatever reason, Bill's has left out parts of my order three times in the last two and a half weeks. You will get charged for the entire order but you can pretty much forget about getting the sides that you paid for. Mushrooms especially seem to jump right out of the bag and into the worker's mouth or something. read more

Delicious soup. Great burgers hot dogs and subs. Their hotdog chilli is rhe best. Dine in or take out always fresh

Fast service, it's a Mom and Pops sandwich place. We always come here to get chili dogs since it's my husband's favorite since he was a child. Never miss that chance, every time we visit. Their serving of french fries is really big, it will feed four people. The place is small, just a few tables inside, I think people come to just for take out. read more

A New Castle STAPLE! I can't come home without stopping by Bill's for a chili cheese dog and fry. The chili is unbeatable and had permanently ruined me from enjoying hot dogs anywhere else. read more

Bill's Sandwich Shop - Chili Cheese Dog with Small Chili Cheese Fry - American Near Me - New Castle, Pennsylvania

Best hot dogs with chili in New Castle. The only place to eat hot dogs and fries. The hot Dogs are the best anywhere. I will not eat hot dog or fries with chill no where else. The Best. read more

This sandwich shop never disappoints. The staff is always friendly. The restaurant is always spotless. And the service is always quick. Love the chili sauce. If you're in the area and want some good Nee Castle chili dogs this is the place. 5 star highly recommended. read more

Bill's Sandwich Shop - 3 Hot dogs w/everything and chili fries - American Near Me - New Castle, Pennsylvania

You know I'm really not a sandwich person but when we moved here, I said we have to try bills because that was my husband's name and my husband now and I just love bills and we like every single sandwich we've ever tried and we plan on trying everyone on the menu read more

I've enjoyed stopping here for a decent grilled chicken salad. The fish bites are pretty tasty as well. Not huge portions, pretty basic, but affordable place. Quick service. read more

Bill's Sandwich Shop - Grilled chicken salad and fish bites - American Near Me - New Castle, Pennsylvania

Love bills. Super affordable and the food is great. Staff are always nice and helpful.

Love Bill's!! Great service, excellent food. Love all their soups and they have baklava!

Always a hometown visit stop, 2 with everything and fries. Was the greatest chili in the world, now it appears they've cut back on the meat, mostly sauce. Won't be back. read more

Bill's Sandwich Shop - American Near Me - New Castle, Pennsylvania

I dunno I don't get these hot dog shops. I'm from Chicago area so I know a hot dog and have yet to find a place in PA that can make one! But hey atleast they have all beef!! read more

I had a philly cheese steak and the meat peppers and onions were well cooked and tasty! Right amount of cheese. Roll was soft and not too bready. Friend had hot dogs and the chili looked pretty soupy but they sucked them down! Cheap and good. read more

Bill's Sandwich Shop - Philly cheese steak - American Near Me - New Castle, Pennsylvania

See all

Great place to get a delish sandwich...Great for lunch and early dinner. Just a.little wait..but it is worth

Very good quality, fresh, agreeable, reasonably priced food. Owned and operated by people who care about their customers.

You HAVE to try their Greek salad and ask them to make it with adding gyro meat on top. Fantastic!!! Best Greek salad I've had in a long time. read more

Nothing beats the Hot Dogs from Bill's. Always order them with everything (mustard, onions, & Chili) they have the best hot dog chili I have ever had. Get a box of fries. With chili and you'll think your in heaven! read more

Bill's has the best chili dogs in town. They provide delicious Greek and American fare at great prices and their service is fast and friendly. They are a staple of New Castle and a great place to have lunch. read more

I really wanted to like this place but unfortunately I don't. We have been here four times in two months and the breakdown is as follows ... First time, the woman at the drive thru was abrupt and rude, at the window she was no better. The philly (sandwich only) was delicious and had a great amount of meat so I was excited to find a new local drive thru. Second time, got the philly combo with cole slaw and fries. Different woman at the drive thru and better demeanor. The warm (????) cole slaw was filled to overflowing so needless to say, half of my fries were scrapped. This time the philly was mostly bread and onions with very little meat. Hhmmm ok, maybe just a bad day we'll try another time just to be sure. Third and then a fourth, we're back with the hostile woman and both times were lacking in the meat department. Unfortunately I believe today had to be the last. I can deal with attitude if the food is rocking but it's not. read more