Hands down our favorite pizza place in Butler and the ranch is amazing! The woman that checks you out is always the sweetest thing! Over all awesome place read more

Every year I visit my mom, and we get pizza from Anna Maria's. The pizza is delicious! The staff is so friendly. We were told it would be 30 minutes, and it was done in 25. The pizza is handmade, and well beyond any other pizza you can find in the area. I highly recommend. read more

I have had their pan pizza several times and it is always consistently very good. I never think to rate them because we always pick it up and take it hone to eat. This time around I tried their mild hot wings and they were awesome!!!! Just right for me, now too spicy but had a little kick. Nice big meaty wings prepared just right. I will definitely get these again! The staff is always nice and friendly and courteous. The way it ought to be. The place was packed tonight and I'm glad to see they are busy. Good for them, I think a husband and wife team run the place, hard to find these days! Give this to lace a try! Also, their just home made ranch dressing is addicting, be careful you don't get hooked!!! You can buy it by the pint, and you will want the entire thing to yourself!!!!! read more

Great pizza and more and down to earth staff! I'd advise to pick up because the wait time for delivery can be a bit long sometimes. 25minutes pick up compared to the 1 1/2 hr delivery time. read more

This is one of the best pies you can get here . Big fan of the bomb hoagie and the carry out special . The staff is great always able to acomadate special request read more

The ranch dressing is amazing!! I order the fried green beans just so I can dip them in the house made ranch! The pizza is very good haven't had one that I didn't like. read more

This tiny shop is quite surprising! Have ordered from here more than once and have always been happy with our order. Both wings and pizza are great! read more

When they first opened this place was good. The reasoning behind my rating was i had ordered a taco pizza which was usually pretty good. But something tasted "off". So i had only one piece. The next day i opened the salsa container and it fizzed like a soda and smelled like beer, it was spoiled. I called them about it and all they said was sorry. read more

Staff is extremely friendly! This is so close to home and the food is way better than pizza shop food! Pizza's are delicious and they have whole wings that are also great! read more

Anna Maria's is the only place that will deliver pizza to our location and we got pretty lucky with Anna Maria's. It takes almost an hour to arrive, but it's been hot every time and the drivers are friendly. No, it's not the best pizza and wings I've ever had, but it is tastier than any chain pizzeria pie and chicken I've ever had. read more

I have eaten Stromboli from all around . The Stromboli at Anna Maria's , although very large , are the most expensive in Butler. They are dough with cheese unless you order the usual fillings as extra' s and pay EXTRA for each filling. I suggest Pizza Joe's for half the price or Villa Grande. read more

This pizza place is very quick and always hot Pepperoni rolls are the best. Friendly service.I will be back.

I love this pizza!! Best in butler. Orders are quick food is always warm and the service is always great.

Anna Maria's is the best pizza I've had in many years. The cheese is real and delicious. The sauce is not too spicy and just right. And the crust is the best I've ever had, I do not end up leaving the crust on my plate like other pizza shops. The family that runs Anna Maria's is very friendly and they always get my order just right. If you want a side order with your pizza the french fries are awesome! If you want something different the sandwiches are OK but I have not noticed anything special. I will always go for the pizza, calzones and French fries!!!! read more

Their pizzas have been subpar lately and customer service horrible. They forgot an entire pizza a few months back that we had ordered for a birthday party. When I called to inquire they just said they'd make another but we'd have to come and get it and of course pay full price. They've also not honored nightly discounts. Not sure if they're under new ownership but something seems different the last 6 months or so. A little customer appreciation goes a long way...they should work on that. We will not be back. read more

Pizza is only ok but if you want a delicious burger they can't be beat! They will also deliver-what's not to like?!

Ordered pizza here three times. it has not gotten any better, and i am never ordering again. sauce is disgusting, tastes like cheap spaghetti sauce out of a can, only overcooked and overspiced. dough is horrible, it's like eating couch foam, and it's always burnt, floppy, soggy, and foul tasting. read more

The pizza their is delicious especially the crust.. It reminds more of a Chicago style pizza than the ones you would traditionally get at 10 other places in town. I have never had a bad pizza from them. read more

They got the last order they will ever get from me! I ordered pizza last night and gave them another chance since they are close by. I asked for the pick up specials and was told there was a large 1 topping for $10.99 I said i would take that but that I want an additional topping. The girl said if I did that it has to go to the regular price. I said cant you just charge me for the extra topping she said no. I asked "how much would the pizza be?" she said $12.49. Okat thats fine and I ordered onions on the whole pizza & half pepperoni, half mushroom and added a small order of cheesy breadsticks. When I got there the man told me the order was over $23, I asked how much are the breadsticks, he replied $4.50 they charged me $12.49 for a large cheese pizza & $1.50 each for 3 additional toppings! That's $16.99 Why? give the pizza for $10.99 & charge the additional $1.50 for the extra topping. And if your going to charge as though you topped the entire pizza with a topping DON'T SKIMP on the toppings! If you go out of business and wonder why? it's because this is what you think taking care of the customer is. I would apologize for the burden of adding more than one topping but it wouldn't be sincere. Plus I paid the penalty for it already. read more