Best pizza place in Amherst!! Will only serve pizza slices, not whole pies after 9:30pm but it is…read moreonly to increase their service speed for drunk and hungry college kids. My boyfriend and I love getting a large pizza with mushrooms, sausage, and pepperoni. The pizza is soo good and will fill you up for multiple meals. The restaurant itself doesn't have too much room for sitting, especially with a whole pizza so most take it to go. The staff are always kind and patient as well. Once we called for a whole pizza close to their cutoff time and the guy on the phone said that they were about to stop making whole pies but if we ordered over phone right there, they could still make it for us!

I went in expecting very good if not great pizza. What I got was meh. A slice of mushroom and a…read moreslice of pepperoni. Very tasteless. I knew I should have left when the pizzas looked like they had been sitting around a while. Why have so many choices when you cannot deliver on quality. The crust was the most disappointing part of the pizza. Not very tasty and it was like cardboard. I guess they count on the college kids who are used to eating frozen pizza. Too bad for everyone else.

Was looking for a good Greek Pizza and definitely found the spot. Order at the counter and in less…read morethan 10 minutes you have a pizza. Not just any pizza but an exceptional Greek pie from crust, sauce, cheese, flavor and taste; you have one of the best Greek pies around. But wait these guys aren't Greek, no matter the boys provide an excellent product, a fair price with good quality ingredients and a Greek style pie to remember.

Attended a UMass event with the expectation of receiving pizza. What I was not expecting was to be…read moreblown across the country with the flavor that came from each slice. Do I know what they ordered? No. But gosh darn this was one of those most delicious pies I've put in my mouth. The crunchy crust and the soft cheese put a smile on my face and stopped the rumbles in my stomach. Dare I say, this may be better than Antonio's of Amherst.... To Athena herself: this is delectable.

Always really good -- sometimes out of this world (love the crust on S pizzas) -- fresh, hot, and…read morereasonably priced.

I'm surprised that Sibies doesn't have a much higher rating. We've been customers for 17 years and…read morehave never been disappointed by the quality of the pizza. Here it is 2026 and we've just enjoyed a delicious Veggie pizza and added pepperoni. Everything--the crust, sauce and toppings--were fresh and delicious. Sibies was wonderful during the pandemic, Thank you Sibies for always being here for us!

Everything on the menu is made fresh and always delicious. Great assortment of slices reasonably…read morepriced and ready to eat in or to go. Fonzie (owner) and his staff are fantastic and go out of their way to be sure you are satisfied. Weather it be a party sized pizza or one of their famous grilled chicken salads (served with those amazing garlic knots). You can't go wrong. Give them a try.

Primo Pizzeria Too is a humble pizza joint that consistently makes a good slice at every hour. The…read morestaff has been patient with me, keeps their pizzas warm for pickup, and convinced me that each pizza will be beyond adequate and delicious. Do you know how hard it is to make pizza and have it come out looking "like pizza?" and tasting well? If you don't, you might believe it's easy by how Primo Too creates a pizza to your order. Don't rest on your laurels, Primo Too, finals are only a few months away and you know you still get graded on every pie's first impression. Being ready for demanding pizza season surprises like the Sox getting through the playoffs means we still want good pizzas for when the game goes bad!

10/10 pizza Service…read more And a food was so good Pricing was pretty good too 4.50$ for a slice with lots of toppings! Steak taco was my fav

Serviceable pizza that hit the spot. I ordered ten inch meat lovers and caesar salad which fed two…read morehungry men well. Dough had a slight chew which made for a delicious treat. Toppings were just right.

I've been a semi-regular customer for several years. This time will be my absolute last. I had a…read moreserious complaint about my order, called and asked to speak to the manager, was told they would call me back. They never called back. Now I notice they are looking for employees in almost every category. What used to be a great place to get food and drinks has gone so downhill it's disappointing. To not call a customer back is inexcusable. Due to the nature of my complaint I will never order food from this establishment again - it was that bad.

Mill River Tavern did not disappoint! Their bubbly flights of mimosas were absolutely amazing --…read moreso many fun flavors and super refreshing! Perfect for a brunch date or a girls' day out. Highly recommend!

Pinocchio's gets my vote for areas best pizza. And I'm a znob. Great staff. Solid biz.read more

Basic, no frills pizza spot with a variety of slices. The cheese slices came out pipping hot but…read morewere slightly devoid of flavor. They had a nice chewy crust with just the right amount of sauce. A little bit of Parmesan and pepper flakes improved things. I'd try some of the other slices next time and maybe the spinach pie.

We loved the food, cocktails, and the service…read more My wife and I had different seafood dishes, and the pizza bread app, while the kids had chicken fingers and spaghetti and meatballs. The inside is slightly dingy, but the food and service make up for it. Would happily recommend.

Food is a 4. Service drags it down some. Took some time to look for a good beer and had the…read morefirst two not available because "someone has an update updated the list yet". If you can't update the list then don't publish it. As far as the food goes. The rice short rest were delicious.

I am so sick of their garlic knots that we can't even order them anymore. Sometimes they are…read moredrenched in oil and garlic... good! Sometimes they are almost dry...bad. Last time they were raw in the center. Time behind that they were almost bone dry and almost inedible. Too bad too. Because when they make them well, they are fantastic.

ive come twice and both times gotten the chicken bacon ranch pizza with vegan cheese & no ranch…read more its just so good. i love the vegan cheese option.

Times are tough, and I was glad to see that The Shack 181 is operating again after being closed for…read morethe winter months. Menu was simple and on the smaller end (basically just wood fired pizzas, burgers, steaks, etc.), but portions were plentiful and food was fresh and made with care (no Sysco in this joint). Hoping that when business picks up, beer prices can come down a little (currently $9 for many of the local cans! too rich for my blood).