Kind people, delicious sausage, easy parking. What more could you ask for? Highly recommend a visit.read more

Amazing sandwiches. Best kept secret in Rye, NY! Super-friendly, fast, quality ingredients. Have…read morenot tried their butcher shop proteins yet, but they look as delicious as the locals claim!

Went to get some steaks for the holiday bbq on 5/24/24....and again, the food looks fantastic, but…read morethe customer service is awful. The place is clean, and everything is neat. The varieties of food look fresh. You can't go wrong with any choice. Chicken is delicious and so is the teres major steak ($15.98 new to me). However, I seem to get the most miserable employee, Joe. Not even a hello and slaps the food on the scale. Doesn't make you want to return.

The guys that work there are very friendly and knowledgeable. I ordered a prime rib roast, the meat…read morewas perfect! Have been going here for years for many other items such asstuffed wings, skirt steak, and pork chops.

Wow what an unforgettable Birthday Dinner! Quality Meats…read moreabsolutely delivered for my birthday! The service here is always top-tier, which is exactly why we always request our favorite waiter Mike, whenever we dine here. Once again, he went above and beyond, making the night extra special by surprising me with two birthday desserts! The manager Carlos, was also incredibly attentive and took great care of us throughout the evening, ensuring everything was flawless. As for the food, it was spectacular. We started with the meatballs a must try, and for the main event, We had the Bone-in Dry-Aged Prime Sirloin topped with truffle butter incredibly flavorful and cooked to absolute perfection. Pair it with the corn crème brûlée sweet and savory side dish. Incredible food, unmatched hospitality, and the perfect place to celebrate. Thank you, Mike and Carlos!

Their website made me put it at the top of my list. The steak looked phenomenal. And then I had it…read more There are a lot of epic steakhouses in NYC so you may as well be getting your money's worth. I did not. Perhaps it was a fluke, perhaps it's the norm. I don't know.

Beautiful 10lb bone in rib roast seasoned and vacuum packed recommended by Andrew with simple…read moreinstructions. Turned out perfect with 10 happy guests . I will definitely return for my next engagement. Great way to start 2026

What a great place! We were going out to the Hamptons from NYC and stopped at Basil and Prime for a…read morebunch of Prime Ribeyes. We met the owner Andrew and he is such a nice guy. The steak was a 10/10 quality.

The store is your typical Italian store with sandwiches, ready made food, There are Italian goods…read morelike cookies and bread. I bought a ham sandwich it was very tasty. They packed the sandwich with loads of ham. Staff is very friendly and fast.

The shopping experience starts when you walk in the door and see Fresh Produce illuminate followed…read moreby a display of home cooked prepared salads and gourmet dishes made with love. Lastly is the service butcher counter featuring prime meats and marinated options. On my last visit out from the kitchen came pounded Pork Chop with Martini sauce and veggies. Well needless to say it was dinner that night. Restaurant quality served with a smile ! Cant wait to see what they have for my next visit

Oh man, I wish I discovered this place sooner. I stumbled upon this place shortly after my return…read morefrom London/Berlin. The steaks look amazing and I wish I got to try them before we left NY. I did get guanciale here which is rather hard to find in Westchester so I promptly made Pasta Alla Gricia and it was fantastic!

Amazing quality stuff. Literally everything in there is top tier stuff. The service they provide…read morefrom knowledge to friendliness is everything you could hope for. The prices are very fair for what you're getting. Being a Italian American transplant from north jersey it's been hard finding certain products and they have it all. You feel comfortable in there and will be very happy with what you get. Highly highly recommend to all.

Good selection. Door was open. Not enough shopping carts. Only 3 on busy Thursday before Passover…read more But were restocking shelves.