The best pizza, eggplant. Antipasto and. Chicken and pasta dishes. Marinara sauce cannot be duplicated anywhere. If you like mussels, Phil's mussels are OUTRAGEOUSLY delicious! read more

Pizza way over priced for what it is. Each time we've ordered pizza it's the same thing undercooked and the cheese slides right off leaving you with soggy crust . read more

Horrible service gave attitude to a child and started to rush the child when she tried to order.

I came here every week as a kid in the 00s and always thought it was truly amazing pizza. I grew up and moved off around the country always having "the best pizza around" from Brooklyn, CT, down south, Los Angeles (a pizza haven now), abroad-- great pizza but in my head nothing hit like this place once did. After 15 years I finally made it back to the area to show my wife where I grew up and HAD to stop in after seeing it was still open-- to see if it held up as well as it did in my memory or if it was just childhood nostalgia. This pizza is seriously great and held up from what I had in memory. The simplicity of old school ingredients make it feel light but packs flavor-- and the crust takes this pie to a new level. Light, but a strong dough AND crispy. Idk how he's held that taste and crust consistency over such a long period of time but I think it proves this man is an artist. WM should be so lucky to have this up there. read more

Was running late, leaving work to catch my Son's club team ballgame up in West Milford. Needed to grab a quick bite and stopped into Vesuvio. Great slice! Hot, oily, cheesy deliciousness! Nice find! read more

Vesuvio Pizzeria - Great slices! - Pizza Near Me - West Milford, New Jersey

Generally bad tasting pizza, incredibly greasy, dirty tables and booths. But wasn't crowded with people and there was no line, so could be worse. read more

I got a veal parm and a Caesar salad. The veal was tremendous, the salad was just a bowl of lettuce. the food was ready quick and inexpensive. read more

Bare-bones, no frills, great slices. This is a charming little 49 year old business run by the same family in West Milford for its entire existence. They don't pretend to be anything fancier than they are (they're as un-fancy as a place can get), nor do they put on any airs when all you want is a slice and a Snapple. A busy man - most likely the owner - will take your order in between the conversation he's having with the other person behind the counter, and there are old, now defunct, coin-operated bubble gum machines up against the wall, and a small menu with very likely little variation from the menu that started it all for them in the mid-70's is lit up with press-letters in the standard see-through red you grew up seeing in pizza places as a kid. The place is freaking perfect. When I'm back near West Milford High school, I will definitely be dropping in again for a slice read more

Vesuvio Pizzeria - The sign!!! - Pizza Near Me - West Milford, New Jersey

Great local grab and go pizza. Staff is always friendly. Prices are reasonable. Good go to in my area.

Chilled spot. A good place for a quick grab and go pizza. Reminds me of old school pizza, nothing crazy. Chicken parm looks messy, but in a good way. read more

I'm hoping last night was just a bad night, but it was the worst pizza I'd ever had in NJ! Vesuvio's and I go way back to my childhood and there was no other pizza like it. When I called to order, it took a long time to answer the phone. Once they picked up, I ordered a "large mushroom pie, well done please", then gave my name. He asked me twice to repeat the order. He said "20 minutes". I got there 10 minutes early, so I sat in my car and made a phone call, watching people go in and out the entire time. After 10 minutes, I walked into not one familiar face behind the counter and there were at least four back there. I waited for the line to diminish then gave my name, mushroom pie, well done. He says 1/2 mushroom? I said "whole mushroom". He insisted that "the person who called it in said 1/2 mushroom". I said "I called it in and said, large mushroom pie well done". He kept insisting I said 1/2! Whatever! Just give me the pizza please. He says it's in the oven and we can make it whole mushroom pie. I said "please leave it as it is. It's fine". Going back n forth with that a few times. As I'm standing there waiting, two people were sitting at tables waiting for their order and two more people walked in to pick up their orders. One man sitting got up and asked if his 1/2 meatball pie was ready yet. The man behind the counter says "you mean whole meatball?" The man says "no, 1/2 meatball!" I said to him "they must have gotten my whole mushroom mixed up with your 1/2 meatball". He replies "I've been waiting 50 minutes!" He left with his pizza without saying a word. Another man finally brought my pizza out after about 10 minutes. When I got home and opened the box, it was a mess! Cheese and mushrooms everywhere! I picked up a slice and it was so thin, it flopped! Way too thin in the center and thick on the outside. Extremely disappointed. I'm hoping this is a one time occurrence and that Vesuvio's didn't sell their business! read more

Traveling in WM for work, I stopped at an old pizzeria that's been around for 30+ years through my youth. Quality slice like I remember years ago. Crust has that classic crunch!! Best slice in WM read more

Vesuvio Pizzeria - No flop - Pizza Near Me - West Milford, New Jersey

See all

When I was a kid, I went to no-frills counter-style pizzerias where dignified men of a certain age in close-fitting white aprons tossed the pies with a serious air. The pizza was very good. And it is here, too. So are the meatballs. The prices are reasonable, and the reassurance that those fine pizzerias of my youth haven't been consigned to nostalgia is free. Worth the drive from points north. read more

Wonderful, wonderful, wonderful!!! The eggplant parmigiana is to die for!! Pizza is great too!! read more

Always Arco to restaurant when it comes to Italian food. The food is it's consistent and delicious every time.

Have passed this place many times and thought "what the heck do they have to offer?" Never thought about stopping to actually find out but decided that lunch today would be a meatball hogie with hot red peppers and Pecorino Romano on top. Only one word left to say "wonderful." Very cordial owner/chef and pizza chef both very accommodating. It was a perfect lunch and the tastiest meatballs I've ever had. Vesuvio's is sparkling clean inside and the aroma wafting from the kitchen tells me all I have to know. This is authentic Italian food, go and enjoy some as much as I did. read more

This is REAL jersey izza!! We've lived all along the east coast but the pizza here is the taste we remember!

For decades the best pizza around. I go out of my way to eat there. Eat it there, right out of the oven for the full flavor experience.

We love Vesuvius Pizza! ; best pizza in town; a little pricey; worth it if you can afford it. We have been going here for over 34 years. Everyone is very nice; quick, easy pick up. read more

Good pizza, good sandwiches, quick pickup for our orders. Average pricing in this area.

I consistently eat at Vesuvio's due to the Vesuvio old fashioned Italian method of making pizza and their other tasty dishes that I'm used to and throughly enjoy. The fuss is usually something Grandma would praise. read more

Great pizza and sandwiches. Only have done take out but there are about 6 tables to eat in.

Great "old school" pizza! The Sicilian is just like mom's pizza! Good steak and meatball sub. I live nearby...my go to pizza joint. Good staff, clean, and consistent. I always ask for well done, crispy pie, and it's always perfect! read more

See all

Excellent pizza ! Excellent service every time ! Wings are super good too :) very professional when you call to order as well !

Really enjoy their food, especially their Eggplant Parm. Reasonably priced and nice hardworking people.

Each week, we venture out and try our favorite pizzas - the Margarita, the Grandpa and the Grandma. Although Vesuvio's in West Milford did not have these on their menu, we decided to give them a try, anyway. We ordered a large regular pie a large pepperoni pie. Upon opening the box, the pie wasn't over or undercooked - cooked perfectly. Upon the first bite.. here's what we loved: the crust. Perfect. Crispy but not crunchy with a soft center. The mozzarella was cooked over the sauce evenly. Of course, we have been trying so many margarita style pies that we almost forgot what a regular old fashioned pie tasted like. Vesuvio's did a fantastic job in reminding us. We were hoping for a bit more flavor in their sauce but still a worthy pie to try. The pepperoni pie was the same; very greasy from the pepperoni, of course, but it still maintained the crispy crust. Vesuvio's.. I think its time for you to put a Margarita pie on that menu! Fresh mozz, fresh basil, sweet sauce, and your crust will be a perfect match. Until next time... read more

Love the pizza here and there chicken parm with vodka sauce hero is delicious and very reasonable!!!

Mediocre pizza with attitude. I have been going here since I was a little kid... at least it is where my parent's would get pizza from. I was never happy with it, and still am not today. For a while, they were really the only choice if you lived in that area of town. Now that there is more competition, they have not adapted. Even when older (and recently), when picking up a pie for my parents I rarely got a smile, a thank you, etc. I got a pizza that was not consistent (burned bottom... yuck) anytime I went there. Drive a few more miles... there are better choices. read more

When I want to stay in town and grab a quick slice, this is my go to pizza. I am a pizza snob. I like Vesuvios's

Pizza ok. Though the owner forgot he is in a customer service industry. My recommendation - go someplace else.

Hands down some of the best pizza on New Jersey! Their eggplant parmigiana is also great. I haven't tried all of their meals but everything I've had has been great! read more

One of my local favorite pizza places. Good Italian take out and friendly service from the owner and staff

Have to agree w Mark Ps review. Inconsistent. Weekends, the pizza is good. Weekdays, the pizza is CONSISTENTLY BURNT on the bottom. Not a good place if you want a sit down restaurant. The pizza is good though, and reasonably priced too. There are other pizza places in the area which are better, IMHO, but, Vesuvios is quite good! read more

Vesuvio Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - West Milford, New Jersey

Great pizza. Great calzones. Great meatball parm. Those are my go tos here. Pricing is average but at least I don't worry about consistency or quality. Always good. read more

Pizza was delicious ! Haven't tried anything else yet but if the rest is as good as their pizza , I'll be keeping this place as my go to place. read more

Ordered from here the other night while helping friends settle into their new home. We ordered a large cheese pie, chicken parmigiana meal and an order of penne vodka with garlic bread. The pizza was your average plain pie nothing special, the chicken parmigiana was cut up into little pieces and served with spaghetti. The penne vodka was interesting.. didn't really taste like vodka sauce I'm used to (pink sauce) this sauce was more red in color... over all it wasn't too bad. The garlic bread was just ok also. Over all I'd have to say that this place is good for a last minute dinner option. read more

Wow!!! Great food and good prices!!! I was absolutely amazed when they asked me what kind of bread I wanted my chicken parmigiana sandwich on. They offered three different styles, including garlic bread! Absolute genius!!! All of their sandwiches can come on garlic bread. Never thought of doing that and I can't believe more restaurants don't do it. The restaurant itself is small and has limited seating, but the menu is great. My wife had a chicken caeser salad and said it was great. Definitely worth another stop here!!! read more

Rude, and not a real pizzeria !! They have only a few speciality pizzas !!!! They give coupons to get a free pizza and when you redeem your free pizza with the coupons they CHARGE YOU TAX !!!!!!!!! Joke ! read more

I don't know how its possible to make a pizza with no flavor at all. Not that it tastes bad, it just is completely flavorless. Man, thats a lot of calories for nothing. read more

phenomenal pizza, kinda a tiny restaurant but no complaints otherwise. staff is friendly, food is reasonable priced, and it's just a short drive down the road read more