Was greeted with a friendly warm welcome. Sat immediately with an amazing view of the sunset. Our server was attentive, friendly, responding happily to any requests. And the food. We got the 50 clams in a garlic broth, with toasted bread to sop up all that broth. I got extra bread, because there was no way I was leaving any behind. I'll be back for sure. read more

See all

While I'd love to gatekeep this place, it's amazing and should be known. If you come here and get one thing - let it be the clams. Absolutely delicious, in a white wine sauce and served with garlic bread for maximum dipping. The place itself if super cute, all outdoors, when the sun is out it does get hot but they have umbrellas up. It's also a beautiful view of the dock. Service gets a little rocky but the food is really worth it. I've also tried their fried flounder and while it's good - nothing beats the clams. So fresh, the sauce is always perfect and very filling. I remember drinking the sauce with a spoon because it was so good. read more

See all

0Star - Total Scam! Beware of Polly's Pontoon Rentals We paid $600 in cash to rent a pontoon from Polly's, signed all the paperwork, and were given a quick 5-minute tutorial on how to operate the boat. During this time, a staff member repeatedly emphasized that the "brand new" propeller (or "utter," as they called it) was in perfect shape, and they even took a photo of it before we left. We were explicitly told not to go into shallow water because it could damage the prop -- which we absolutely followed. We had a fantastic day on the water, followed every rule, and even tipped the young man who helped us $80 at the end of the rental because we were so happy with the experience -- until everything changed. As we were wrapping up, someone came over to ask if everything went well. We said yes -- it had been great -- and suddenly, the tone shifted. We were told the prop was "banged up" and that we owed another $200. Total bait-and-switch. I was furious. This felt like a setup from the very beginning, especially considering how much emphasis they put on the prop at the start. To test our suspicion, we sent friends to rent from Polly's the very next day -- they were given the same exact boat, with the same "damaged" prop, and were hit with the exact same scam! Bottom line: DO NOT RENT FROM THIS PLACE. It's run by a group of young kids pulling a con on unsuspecting tourists. There are plenty of honest boat rental options on the island -- do yourself a favor and go anywhere else! read more

We recently rented a pontoon boat from Polly's Dock and were extremely disappointed with how things turned out. While the rental experience itself seemed fine at first, we were later hit with a charge for damage we absolutely did not cause. Our group was careful, respectful, and returned the boat in the exact condition we received it. There was no inspection with us before or after the rental, and no issues were mentioned at the time of return. Then, out of nowhere, we were charged for damage that wasn't ours -- with no solid explanation or proof. We tried to dispute it, but the response from Polly's Dock was unhelpful and dismissive. It honestly feels like they're taking advantage of renters by blaming them for preexisting damage or issues that weren't documented properly. If you choose to rent here, be very cautious -- take plenty of photos before and after, and insist on a walk-through with a staff member. Unfortunately, we won't be coming back and can't recommend Polly's Dock based on how poorly this was handled. read more

Wow! Absolutely amazing, loved the sunset it was so beautiful tonight ANDDDD MY SERVER FELICIA! No words can describe how amazing she was for us, she REALLLYYYY went ABOVE and beyond. She is great so I tipped her 200% . You have to request her next time you come in! read more

Polly's Dock Clam House - Felicia! - Seafood Near Me - Beach Haven, New Jersey

Beautiful place to watch the sunset. Lots of locals and frequent customers from how the staff engaged with everyone. We had mahi mahi and tuna tacos, they were fine but the sunset was the star of the evening. read more

Polly's Dock Clam House - Sunset from where we were sitting - Seafood Near Me - Beach Haven, New Jersey

See all

Polly's is all about the atmosphere. Sitting on a rustic dock overlooking the sunset, live music, with a cold beer and bucket of clams...it doesn't get more LBI. Unfortunately, the food is just fine. Clams were very small but tasty. Mahi tacos had no seasoning whatsoever. Burger, meh. The service was youthful, friendly and efficient. But I have mixed feelings about the salty owner who is always at the helm. Polly's is certainly worth checking out but mostly for the chill vibe and view. To steal from another review, the star here is indeed the sunset. Tips. Be prepared to wait as this place and always a crowd. Also, bring some cash because they don't allow you to tip on your credit card. So a cash tip or you can send money to the server's personal Venmo. Never seen that before! read more

Love the clams here. Fun to pull up to the dock and eat by boat. Kids at the doc are a big help. Last time we went we ordered the clams and shared a cod sandwich. Too bad the sandwich was inedible (half of it was some fried non fish substance). Told the waitress and nothing was done. Will come back for those clams though! read more

Go on a weeknight of possible. We had not wait. Best dinner in LBI. It's no frills but the food and views are fantastic. Get the clams they are amazing. Look forward to coming back here. read more

This place is a very long wait, but great sunset views amongst a dive-y, outdoor, fisherman atmosphere. Fish chowder soup is very generous with pieces of seafood in it, hearty. Must get the clams in garlic butter sauce--very tasty and large for sharing. Scallops were chewy and not cooked well. Place is still worth a try if you get there early enough. BYOB! read more

Polly's Dock Clam House - salty clams with garlicky broth - Seafood Near Me - Beach Haven, New Jersey

Was told the wait was 40 minutes for 2. More than 1.5 hours later still not seated yet larger parties sat. Owner was cranky when customer asked status in the queue. Left with no dinner and too late to eat elsewhere. Do not recommend. read more

The atmosphere can't really get any better. The Sun setting on the dock with fresh seafood and a one man band playing the classic American favorites. We had some very saucy giant Buffalo wings to start. My daughter had a grilled cheese of which we probably stole most of her fries. Yum! For dinner we shared some lobster rolls, a salad and coconut shrimp. The place is BYOB except they sell a local vineyards wine, a nice little liquor license loophole. Definitely worth a look in Beach Haven! read more

The Best Sunset in LBI. Our waitress Kate was also fantastic and we went with her recommendations. Both my husband and I got the lobster rolls... Very yummy!!! read more

Polly's Dock Clam House - Seafood Near Me - Beach Haven, New Jersey

See all

Love this place! It has the best waterfront seats for a Long Beach Island sunset dinner and I mean THE BEST!!! This place is a gem, the food and the view are amazing, better than any of the rooftop bars nearby. The restaurant is at the marina, you can dock your boat there while you dine. Bruce and I were lucky, we got the best high top seats right in front of the ocean and they were the best front row seats for the most captivating LBI sunset. The restaurant doesn't have a bartender but they do serve a great wine by the bottle or you can BYOB. We ordered a bottle of white wine, the Thai Chili Wings, and Clam Bake to share. Both dishes were one of the best I've ever had and the house picked pinot Grigio were the perfect pairing to this awesome meal. The atmosphere was relaxed with soft live music, awesome food, awesome wine, awesome service, beautiful view, great conversations, and a friendly crowd. So happy Bruce took me there, we had a really nice time. It was a perfect dinner spot for our little weekend getaway before the end of the summer read more

See all

Great clams! Great scenery- right on the water! A casual classic clam joint on the dock.

This place is absolutely awesome! Cozy outdoor spot with convenient dock and dine makes this a regular stop for us. The clams and seared tuna are a win win if you are wondering what to order..... Food is always 10 stars and the service is off the charts. Our regular server Rose always greets us with big smile and makes us feel like VIP's every single time. We always call ahead and make sure she is before we head out.. Almost forgot to mention this is the best spot on the island sunsets while you dine! Polly's Dock is our #1 pick all summer!!! read more

Polly's Dock Clam House - Our boat at polly's dock for dinner and sunset. - Seafood Near Me - Beach Haven, New Jersey

See all

We stopped by for dinner on Monday night. The atmosphere is casual which is perfect when a bunch of kids. We got the clams in garlic and they were devoured. My only complaint is they could have given more then 2 pieces of bread so we all could dip in the sauce!! I ordered the sesame crusted tuna and it was awesome! It was seared perfectly and I have to say it was one of the best cooked and most fresh pieces of tuna I have had! We got the wings which my son said were pretty good but not his favorite and he got the cheese stake that he really enjoyed. We got the halibut sandwich, it was pretty good, but it had a little bit of a fishy taste to it and we didn't finish it. I was a little surprised we waiting a very long time to get the food since it wasn't that packed, but the food was worth the wait. read more

Polly's Dock Clam House - Seared Seseme Tuna - Seafood Near Me - Beach Haven, New Jersey

this is my go-to spot on LBI. The ambiance reminds me of the "Barnacle" restaurant from the John Candy movie Summer Rental, and in a great way. incredible sunset views, watch the fishing boats come in and out, and the food is the freshest on island. Its BYOB which lowers your cost but lets me try different dishes. Staff has always been attentive and great to be around. read more

Great food. The shrimp was so delicious. Staff is wonderful. Highly recommend. The views are incredible.

Great Fresh Food Absolutely enjoyed it Great view Great atmosphere Great Steamed Clams Great Oysters Great Fish Couldn't find ANYTHING to complain about ! Spot On ! read more

Great clams, great view. But very disappointing service. Incredibly slow, it wasn't clear if anyone in the kitchen really knew what they were doing. This place is an institution in Beach Haven with a long history, and I hope it gets back up to speed. Service is everything and Polly's is lacking in this crucial area. read more

Wow pulled my boat up the dock the dock hand was there in seconds to help me tie up. The best way to describe this restaurant is very SALTY!! Simply tables and bar tables on an old dock with great service and vibe. I ordered the classic clams in the pan, ok HOLY S$&T that was ridiculous, also the cod sandwich and the Maddy burger was all great. You must go here, I know I'm going to regret this because Won't be able to get in again. read more

Polly's Dock Clam House - Whoa boy put your helmet on these are ridiculous!!!!! - Seafood Near Me - Beach Haven, New Jersey

We ordered the 50 / clams done in a pan of wine, butter, scallions, and garlic. A must get if you go here. We split the Mahi special with rice, pineapple. The service was very good and attentive. The ambience is why you wait. The restaurant to catch a sunset! read more

Staff is great, food is dynamite. Get the hot lobster roll, you won't be disappointed. read more

Polly's Dock Clam House - Polly's Doc - Seafood Near Me - Beach Haven, New Jersey

Come for the laid back atmosphere and the amazingly fresh and flavorful clams. Bring some beers and wine and enjoy a great afternoon.

A fun, low key, causal spot tucked away between the boat rentals and Parker's Garage. Small but inviting with some dockside seating. We have been going here for the past 5 years. Menu and selections have expanded each year. It's a BYOB. Clams are really good as are the lobster rolls. Call before going - sometimes they are closed when they should be open. read more

Polly's Dock Clam House - Entrance into Polly's - Seafood Near Me - Beach Haven, New Jersey

Have been going to Pollys for years and absolutely love it! So much so that we actually had our wedding reception here this year! Amazing food, amazing views, fun staff. read more

There is no other place like this in Beach Haven. 100% "down to earth/the beach" place. Location, food and service is the best. Young and enthusiastic people at the kitchen and providing the best service. I strongly suggest the steamed clams. BYOB. Clean. Fairly priced. Wonderful sunset views and life music. read more

See all

Very aloof person at the front who smoked a cigarette and pretended I wasn't there. He instructed the hostess to not seat me and to specifically wait for a family who has just arrived to leave their vehicle and enter. He never made any eye contact or said anything directly to me even though I was standing right next to him. The food was average and portions were small for my teenage boys. Reading other reviews an trip advisor, some have had similar strange dismissive experiences. The man who smokes at the front certainly treats people very differently and is definitely sending a very specific message to who is welcomed and who isn't. Other than that the server was very nice. Would definitely go elsewhere. The bathroom needed a cleaning and garbage removed. The reviews fall on both sides of the spectrum either poor or excellent. It's really a curiosity while some are treated quite well and others are not. Maybe the owner should put a sign up at the front like America in the 1950's about who is welcome and who isn't. read more

Would give zero stars if possible. Food is good but Owner is extremely rude and unfriendly. Questionable Hygiene practices, zero soap in the womens room and no toilet paper. How are the servers washing their hands exactly? Party of 6 spent over $200 dollars on dinner. Kept "hinting for us to leave after 60 minutes of us being there. Would have been happy to leave, but we're waiting for waitress to bring us the bill. At the end, he literally told us to get the "f@$& up. Extremely disrespectful. Would not give this guy another dollar of my money. Plenty of much better restaurants in LBI. If you want mediocre food, questionable hygiene and a horrible experience with a rude owner make sure to make this your destination. read more

If I could give this place a zero I would. Arrived and asked how long a walk. Was told it would be 30 to 45 minutes. Left our name. About 40 minutes we were seated. Our waitress came over about 10 minutes after we were seated. We gave our order and received our drinks. Kept waiting for our order and it never showed. In about 30 minutes our mozzarella sticks arrived and as you can see there was no mozzarella in the center. (How does that happen unless you over fry them). Ordered soup and it never came. About 20 minutes later our waitress came over and asked if had received our order. We told her that nothing had come out except for the mozzarella sticks that had no cheese in the center. (See picture) There was another party that came in after us and they got their order before us. We complained to management but they didn't seem to care. We will never go there again and will not recommend this restaurant to anyone. PS just look at the picture and you decide for yourself. read more

Polly's Dock Clam House - fish and chips - Seafood Near Me - Beach Haven, New Jersey

UPDATE: we went back to Polly's dock and were extremely disappointed with this experience. It was not consistent with quantity or quality. We ordered shrimp platter and the size and amount of shrimp were completely different than the last time we ordered last month. Not worth the price for the amount of shrimp we received. Other than that; still good service and atmosphere! read more

The only thing salty about this place are these wack reviews ! This place is AWESOME! First of all the clams, holy shit. Amazing even the dumb garlic bread on top was literally the best garlic bread I have ever sank my teeth in. My coconut shrimp was perfect and the sauce you dip is soooo good spicy sweet. This is my new spot. the owner isn't disrespectful he's actually really kind and very funny; Johnny Parmesan is the man! See y'all soon! read more

Guys the salt cap is loose or somethin love this place so much amazing food but salt shaker is loose!!!I know if I didn't know any better and it was my first time there I wouldn't of been back because of the salt issue the meat was almost inedible. And figure out a way to make the clams not just 50 very hard yo eat fifty was gonna ask the strangers around me if they wanted to split read more

This place is located right on the bay. Good food and a very casual eating environment. Eating is outside only but has a great view of the bay and sunsets. Prices are much lower than other restaurants in the area. Plan for a wait to be seated as the place is popular but has limited seating. Bring along your own wine and beer it makes the wait not seem so long. Staff is young and inexperienced but are polite. Recommend this place for location, and price based on food quality. read more

See all

PLEASE DO NOT GIVE THIS OWNER ANY MORE BUSINESS. Please please please do not rent a boat from this owner! We had a reservation and went out along the route they suggested for about 15 minutes and the engine started sputtering, it was throttling on its own without us touching the controls. Very scary so we brought it back into dock and asked them to give us a working vessel. The entire episode took 45 minutes of us going very very slowly back into Harbor. It was only a two hour trip so when we returned at the end of our trip on the new boat, I explained that I would like to rebook with them for another date but maybe they could give us a discount since over a third of our trip was due to engine troubles from their boat. The young guys who work the dock are attentive and nice and offered to get the owner and here is where it gets odd and awful. The owner comes "at" me and shoulder checks me on the way to his office and then sticks just his hand out of the office and tells me to "get in my office". I'm a 50-year-old female, I said, "Excuse me? Are you talking to me that way? I was just asking you if I could have a discount because your boat didn't work and it took up a third of our time". He got in my face pointing his finger saying "how EXACTLY was I inconvenienced" over and over again yelling in front of a FULL restaurant. I said he could have a conversation with me instead of pointing and poking at me, at which point he laughed and said he could give a shit and I should get the f*ck out. I told him he could have approached this with kindness since he was in a customer service-based business but he just said that I caused the problems by letting a bunch of grass get in his blades, when we never left their proposed route, so that could not have happened. This guy was such an incredibly aggressive and condescending jerk. I don't understand how he is in business with this attitude. So much anger! Please do not give him any business. There's so many other great small business owners on this island that work hard and do business with great integrity and treat their employees with some decency and respect! read more

Unfortunate this restaurant has a horrible and disrespectful owner that degrades women and his staff. I've never been treated so rudely. My wife inadvertently wrote her name down on the wait list when told to do so which resulted in her being screamed at and embarrassed in front of everyone. Given all of the wonderful and hospitable folks that work in Beach Haven, spending your money at Polly's is condoning the mistreatment of women and wait staff. They have no right to be in business. read more

I wish my experience at Polly's was close to what these positive reviews espouse. Our trip to Polly's ended in disappointment after waiting nearly 45 minutes to be seated. It seemed only friends of the owner were accommodated. Many empty tables and plenty of waitstaff so not sure what the problem was. If you're in LBI for a limited amount of time, spend your dollars elsewhere. There are so many fine establishments, other than Polly's, that would appreciate your business. The owner is rude and distracted. You can get the same sunset view by standing on the dock next door. read more

Do not get the "clam chowder"...the place has really gone downhill over the past few years. read more

Polly's Dock Clam House - New England Clam Chowder - Seafood Near Me - Beach Haven, New Jersey

See all

We walked in at about 830 where 2 children who looked like they were waiting for their parents on a bench stood up and seated us. We waited 10, 20, 30 minutes before a waiter finally came over asking if we had been served yet. We hadn't even ordered drinks. In the time waiting we noticed workers eating while cooking and making salads with their barehands like a group of hippies. After putting our drinks in my girlfriend and I got up and left and went to Chicken in the Egg which I would recommend. Spend your time away from Polly's Clam House in New Jersey. The view was cool tho. read more