This is the best record shop on Long Island. Trusted, Knowledgeable and Passionate about crate…read moredigging! Highly recommend!!

My favorite record shop on Long Island! As soon as you walk into Buddha Belly Records you will feel…read morethat it has a different vibe compared to other record shops. This record shop is also a spirituality shop and sells crystals, natural remedies, teas, and tinctures. The owner of the shop, Mike, opened Buddha Belly Records in January 2024. The records, both new and used, are carefully curated, organized, and fairly priced. Great selection of jazz, soul, rock, and everything in between - there's something for everyone here. I could easily spend hours digging here, but with my wife waiting in the car - I had 30 minutes to dig. Dig through the "New Arrivals" section and you will find a ton of gems - I saw a few Japanese pressings in there. The inventory here is priced to move - if you see something you like, I would jump on it before someone else does. There's a lounge in the back where the shop also hosts tarot card reading classes. Suffolk County residents are truly blessed to have a record store of this caliber in Sayville. (hey - this is my 100th Yelp review! )

Extremely unprofessional conduct by owner. Unable to maintain a proper inventory and pricing system…read morewhich leads to public freakout on a new employee and "experienced" customer.

Amazing place and the owner is just such a nice a cool person. Great if you like vintage things,…read morethere is so much variety and it is sold at an amazing price.

One of my favorite places on all of Long Island!! You can find anything here. Toys, records, y2k…read moreand vintage clothes, horror items, autographed memorabilia, you name it!! Everything is priced fair and the owner is the sweetest person! Definitely recommend it here.

Came here 3 times with a problem. Bought a cassette deck that was supposed to be serviced but it…read moredidn't work at all. Wouldn't turn or play tapes. Returned it and got another one just for it to have only one channel playing. Paid $75 plus tax for it. When I went to return it I used $60 for records and the rest was to be paid out in cash yet I didn't receive back the tax I paid in my refund so they profited $8 and change off me. Really not happy I had to drive an hour 3 separate times to return a tape deck twice that didn't work when everything is guaranteed to work and I didn't even get back the full amount I paid. Never coming back

Really neat record store has a bunch of good stuff for good pricing people there are really helpful…read moreif need be but let u browse alone. Sick collection. My new go to

Very fairly priced records in many genres and although the store is very small the owner or the…read moreperson that was working there was very nice and was very helpful in helping me find some records that I was looking for on a recent gift purchase. It seemed to me that the records were priced based on the quality of the condition.

Went in a few hours ago to sell some record players and other items and it was a very positive…read moreexperience. The man was very respectful and gave a fair amount of money for my items. No, he didn't buy everything but he was able to have a conversation with me about the items. Actually was at a place just before this one where the worker was rude and I didn't want to do business with them. Much happier with Record Reserve anyhow, they understand how to talk to people.

Door is always padlocked and does not reflect their hours of operation time. I question if they are…read morestill in business

A great place to buy records! A great selection, fairly priced, and very friendly staff. I've been…read morecoming here for years and it's been a great addition to the neighborhood. You don't see a ton of record shops out on the island...so it's wonderful to have this nearby. Highly recommend!

This place has not changed since I was a kid. If you want records this is the place to go. Great…read moreselection and something for all musical tastes. They also have old school games, DVDS, you name it. Service was polite though we didn't buy anything. Value certainly depends on what you're buying - some items seemed super reasonable while others pretty pricey (ie. A Tupac record for $70).

Great finds. Welcoming and willing to help you find your preferred choice. They're a library of…read moremusic, and great knowledge. Take a trip and enjoy yourself.

I saw something come up on Facebook about this store so I wanted to check it out. Only problem is…read moreas the store is named, it's only open on Sundays! Luckily I was in the area on a Sunday.....or did I somehow trick my wife and make that happen? Haha! It's a very nice store. Very organized. More about records but there was some CDs as well. I think the prices were mostly fair. I was able to find a few things and was happy with my purchase. I talked to the owner a bit because he noticed I had a triumph record in my hand and he was going to see them. Definitely worth a stop if you're in the area cause you don't know what you will find. I mostly look for heavy metal or hard rock and there was plenty of both there. I will definitely go back when I'm in the area or accidentally end up in the area

Cool local vinyl shop just built for some chill, leisurely browsing. Ample assortment of records…read moreacross a diverse array of genres, some new releases along with a ton of used records. Seemed like fair and well thought out pricing---had multiple copies of several albums with different prices based on condition. I could have browsed for hours, but only had time for a quick find or two before I had to catch my train back to the city!