Very fairly priced records in many genres and although the store is very small the owner or the person that was working there was very nice and was very helpful in helping me find some records that I was looking for on a recent gift purchase. It seemed to me that the records were priced based on the quality of the condition. read more

Went in a few hours ago to sell some record players and other items and it was a very positive experience. The man was very respectful and gave a fair amount of money for my items. No, he didn't buy everything but he was able to have a conversation with me about the items. Actually was at a place just before this one where the worker was rude and I didn't want to do business with them. Much happier with Record Reserve anyhow, they understand how to talk to people. read more

Nice shop. Organized. Bargains to be had. Plenty of selections of new, pricier vinyl. Worth visiting. Easily could spend an hour looking and money. Friendly owner. read more

I don't know how I never knew about this place, but I know now. Great, great pricing, the dude is solid and will talk to you about metal for 15 mins if that's your thing, which it is. I got a bee gees record that no joke I didn't know existed for $2. Wall had some real gems and my buddy grabbed an executioner record before I did so good for him. Check it out for sure if you're in the area. read more

Record Reserve - Vinyl Records Near Me - Huntington, New York

I speak for all locals... Huntington is so happy to have this store in our town! Love supporting small shops like theirs and they always have a great selection to choose from and so affordable. Definitely going to add this spot to my hit list on my run-around-town days!!! read more

I liked the store very much. It has very good vinyl stock! And what a pleasant fellow Tim is. Visit this business!

I went back on forth a few times on how many stars here, but ultimately settled on 3. Better than average, but not nearly as good as many of the others I've visited recently. The shop is located in the very lovely downtown Northport area, surrounded by other great shops and scenery. It's a great place to go for a walk, shop for some records and have some dinner. I was surprised upon arrival that there were tons of records outside. I'm guessing it's to draw attention, but records due tend to warp in the sun and heat... I looked through the lot and they did have lot of interesting titles at very reasonable prices. So I walked away with 4 titles in the $2-$3 range so I was willing to take the risk. I'd been following them on Instagram for a couple of weeks to watch the incoming inventory before traveling to the area to get a sense of what may be in stock. The LP I was hoping for was unfortunately sold. Or was it? The clerk didn't seem so sure, but thought it probably sold. Bummer for me.. either way I found a couple of other premium used titles in the $17-$20 range. Overall, prices seemed in line with other shops with decent quality and organization to the stock. I would say they are heavily focused on classic rock with a small section of heavier titles, an even smaller selection on blues and about 5 rap LP's. So if you're looking for a good but not mint copy of Bruce Springsteen or done Zeppelin, this is your place. Not much by way of rock newer than 1986, maybe two bins of modern rock or re-releases. So bottom line I left with 7 records for a little over $45. It's a small place but definitely worth stopping in and searching through the bins. read more

Record Reserve - Vinyl Records Near Me - Huntington, New York

See all

Cute little record store down Main St in Northport village. I was spending the day with family, popping into random shops along the way, and stumbled upon this gem that I honestly didn't know was there. Tons of great vinyls wall to wall, as well as some books, collectibles, etc. I wish I had had more time to browse (my family was anxious to leave) but I will definitely be back often. read more

Record Reserve is the type of place I love to give my business too. Tim is genuine and takes the time to care for the music and his customers always. His shop is warm and inviting. I've been coming here for years, and always leave completely satisfied. Easily one of the most hidden gems. If you love records, make sure you stop by Record Reserve. read more

Is Father Bob from the ulc church I got to say these guys are great prices are fair extremely confident friendly help really good selection I have 4000 records now and I'm not a huge by I have most of what I want but I stopped in from time to time and I pick up something here in there and whether you're looking for a rare album from Sun kill you want to buy a copy of Abbey Road I find these guys are about as honest as they come really really good company Fair place to buy albums a lot of us tend to buy from their website on the internet and the club is a good deal but I actually like to come in and say hello to the fellas actually put my hands on the on the product look at the artwork very highly recommended I bought about a hundred guys and I've never ever had a bad experience highly recommended read more

Record Reserve - Vinyl Records Near Me - Huntington, New York

See all

Excellent selection, excellent people; plenty of music shops have one or the other but not many have both! Always surprised at how reasonable the pricing system is, and how Tim has that gift of steering you in the right musical direction every time. read more

Record Reserve is a hidden gem! I've tagged along to dozens and dozens of record stores with my collector husband, and while he combs the vinyl sections, I usually end up in a conversation with the shop owner. Talking to Tim, the owner at Record Reserve, is always a pleasure. He's such a humble, down-to-earth, interesting guy. When a customer tells him they love his shop, he is genuinely touched each time as if it's the first time he's ever received such a compliment. He's an honest guy and always values his stock fairly. I'm always happy when my husband purchases vinyl here because we help a truly wonderful business man live his dream! Stop by this fantastic shop. You won't be disappointed! read more

I went in looking for Bo Didley and guess what? I found Bo Didley. Great condition. Great place. Plays records while you shop. He also has old record players, I will be back. read more

This is a pretty good record store & NO!! You won't find any cd's Just Vinyl records, So if your into cd's this is not the store for you!! The owner Tim is a real nice guy & always gives you the best deals. On my walk around town I always make it a point to stop here. There is a good selection of used records w/ a $1.00 bin in the back & new records as well. Most prices are ok nothing too crazy there were a few that weren't worth the price he was asking but, for the most part I give this store 3-1/2 stars out of 4. It's right in front of the Kings pk train station on Main Street a few doors down from Ralph's Italian ices across from the Bagel shop, So if your coming from the out east or from the city take the train & get off at the Kings Park stop & walk North to main street. I'm sure you'll find what your looking for if not Tim will get it for you. read more

I was so glad that Tim decided to rebuild after the fire closed the old shop down. The new store is in a great location and, as always, the prices are great. Tim is a cool guy and the new shop will be rocking in no time! read more

It's one of those places that seems to be in business for music over money. Tim's a real nice dude with very reasonable prices and selections. This has become my favorite store on LI; the owner is great and he easily has the fairest prices around. ***He make and sells his own record cleaning fluid that's pretty awesome. I clean all of my records with a Nitty Gritty 1.0 vacuum. There've been occasions where the Record Reserve fluid removed a contaminant that Nitty Gritty Pure 2.0 couldn't. It's only $10 w/ free refills. Don't leave the store without it!! read more

I really enjoy going here. Looks of inventory, helpful, treats everybody well.

Whether I'm looking for something specific or just shopping to get away from life, the Record Reserve is where I go. Fantastic selection! Always something new coming in. Great prices! Awesome atmosphere and vibe! My favorite of all the Long Island record stores! read more

I came to the record reserve today. I have to say, this was one of the best vinyl shopping experiences I've ever had. I loved be vibe of the store. The owner Tim inviting and totally fair on pricing. The stock and selection was absolutely choice, and the prices were aces across the board. This is now my new favorite record shop. You guys have a customer for life. The best shop in Long Island bar none. To add onto my review, if you aren't buying Tim's cleaning solution - do it. Its better than anything you will buy commercially. My records never looked so clean, and sounded so good, than after I started using his cleaning fluid. read more

Record Reserve made a name for itself among my friends when it was located on Larkfield Road in East Northport. After a fire gutted the building in January 2014, the store sprang back up the next month in Kings Park in the train station parking lot, and while it's a smaller space, it's the same record store we'd come to know and love. I try to pop in whenever I'm thirsting for a new variety in my vinyl collection, and if there's anything the Reserve has, it's variety. I've never seen such an eclectic assortment of jazz, classic rock, varying degrees of heavy metal, classic pop and new vinyl releases in one place! Tim, the owner, has a very expansive knowledge of his stock, and has been renowned among my friends for his ability to acquire hard to find records- a friend of mine interested in an obscure vinyl by an even more obscure American Primitivism guitarist named Robbie Basho had it in his hands within a week's time. The prices at the Reserve are more than reasonable, the condition of the records generally being the deciding factor- for example if something is still in shrink wrap, it's gonna be upwards of $30. If something is a bit more worse for wear, it'll be cheaper. I've snagged records there for as low as $3 that still sound good. Tim is always apt to play new music on his turntable, as well as play records for you before you buy them, which is always a plus. I have yet to check out his Huntington outlet- Record Reserve West- that has an even more expansive collection of music, but for now I don't mind going around the corner to the Kings Park store and perusing the shelves for something new to me. Definitely my go-to vinyl shop, much more affordable than the (somewhat ironically named) Mr. Cheapo's in Commack. read more

I've missed Tim and RR terribly since moving to Texas, so I make this one of my first stops when I visit family. This store is awesome...great prices, excellent selection, good vibe. Tim is passionate and knowledgeable about his product and music in general. If you don't come to RR, you're missing out. read more