Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    West Gate Inn Nyack

    2.4 (43 reviews)
    ModerateHotels
    Open Open 24 hours

    West Gate Inn Nyack Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - West Gate Inn Nyack

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Award-winning cheesecake year after year.
    Renee L.

    Overall, it was a good experience. Definitely served the purpose for overnight accommodations. We arrived later than expected. Desk clerk couldn't find our reservation, but with a little research and determination, he figured it out. Thankfully, he honored the original room rates, so 2 stars for that. The room was dated, but we already expected it. We were glad the room was equipped with a fridge, microwave, and coffee maker. The other bonus is that the property is 100% smoke -free. Rules at the front desk stated fines/ fees would be assessed if a violation occurs. Complimentary full breakfast. Make sure you try the award-winning cheesecake. It's worth the stop for this alone, plus their lounge features live entertainment.

    Stains on the covers. Nasty old bathroom . All for $200.94 for one night

    The hotel appears not to have been updated in over 40 years. The room I stayed in stunk. It smelled like a smokers room. There were stains everywhere. The bathroom was old and not updated. The stairs were taped with duct tape.Whatever they are doing with the money they bring in, it doesn't appear they are putting it into the upkeep of the hotel. My kids were mad at me for keeping them in this room. I paid$200 for one night!

    Food
    Rosa A.

    We stayed for one night. Double bed! We time travel to the 80s, rug can definitely be replaced the air was difficult to breathe no filter! Bathroom was decent but when taking a shower it was a roller coaster ride of the temperature from hot to cold. We received voucher for breakfast buffet! The lady behind the counter needs to check her customer service attitude serves our food, didn't listen to the questions and did as she pleased. Nunca más!! Never again! That's what we get trying to save a few bucks.

    Chanel F.

    What a depressing stop on our mini vacation. This place was recommended on a Sleepy Hollow tourism page. While I do love a good scare, the headless horseman has nothing on this dump. Grimy handprints and streaks on walls, rips and mysterious stains on bedskirts, a carpet that felt..oily while walking barefoot. Dented lampshades, busted hairdryers, peeling wallpaper. If all of these things aren't enough, this motel is in the mosh pit of of a metal concert featuring 'Freeway traffic' alll night long You know it's bad when you can't even bring yourself to take advantage of a free breakfast for fear of what horrors lie in the kitchen The only positive thing I can say is that we appreciated the courtesy and efficiency of the young lady who checked us in

    Penny C.

    I love it here. My husband and I have stayed here in this is my third time this is my go-to place for now on when I come to visit my grandchildren here in New York. You cannot beat a family-owned business. Everyone here is so friendly accommodating not to mention Lisa's number one ranking cheesecakes. I will be back again this time my husband shall come with me thank you for all that you do and please keep this business going

    Janira H.

    I'm usually not too picky about hotel, give me a clean room and decently comfortable bed and I'm good to go but this place?! No, no, no this place is terrible. It smells like cigarettes and mildew, that's quite odd since there is a $200 deep cleaning fee if you smoke. It wreaks of old cigarette smell, it must be embedded in the walls and carpets. Beds were very firm, like a board! Also we arrived 26 minutes earlier than check-in and they wouldn't even take our information, they told us to return at check-in time. The process was fairly easy once we returned though. To top of the dingy scent of this place, the lighting is very dim, it's only lit by 3 lamps in the room, there are no lighting fixtures on the ceiling. There's one outlet extension that hold about 4-5 plugs and no other plugs aside from the two in the bathroom. There are basic amenities which are the only positives here, an ironing board, an iron, a closet with hangers, desk with a mirror and a hair dryer. Check-out is at 12 sharp, the housekeeping lady started banging on our door at 11:59! If I stay in the area again I would most definitely go back to the Hilton garden inn even though it's further from my destination. Btw - this is a shady area & a shady hotel if you can't tell by now; the kind that you would see criminals in movies use to stay out of the public.

    Dirty bathtub

    My family travel a lot. This is by far the worst place I've stayed at in my life, which includes hostels. The only pros are: friendly front desk and cleaning staff, and location. Every other con you can think of applies. This place was filthy. The sheets were stained, walls stained, rugs stained, furniture was beat up, no smoke detector, dirt on all light switches and doors, the A/C doesn't work, beds and pillows are the most uncomfortable available. Do you and your family a favor and BOOK ANYWHERE ELSE.

    See all

    9 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Gregory P.

    Gregory P.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Gregory P.

    Gregory P.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Gregory P.

    Gregory P.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - West Gate Inn Nyack

    Review Highlights - West Gate Inn Nyack

    Great value, wonderful breakfast and a comfy room.

    Mentioned in 2 reviews

    Read more highlights

    You might also consider

    Hotel Nyack - JDV by Hyatt - Bar Lounge

    Hotel Nyack - JDV by Hyatt

    (81 reviews)

    $$

    I truly truly don't understand how this place (as of Dec '25) has such a low rating, let's go!…read more Being a Hyatt Globalist living in the NYC Metro area, I was always intrigued by the pictures/vibe of this place and had no reason to ever be in this area- turns out tonight because of an emergency here I am. - The look and vibe of the lobby area is great - Person at the front desk was friendly - Had a drink at the bar and service was solid as was the pour of the wine - I like the look and feel of the room I travel all over the country and I strive for objective reviews....and don't get the hate for this place on yelp! If you are in this area, give this place a shot and oh- the rates are very reasonable!

    This trip started off bad 2hrs before I arrived. I received an email saying that I was being…read moredowngraded from a king suite with a balcony to a king room with balcony. Strike one. Upon arrival, I notice a wedding party is also at the hotel. I can't confirm or deny but I'm pretty sure that's where my downgrade came from. Get to my room and no microwave. I called to have one brought up....something I've done here before. "Oh we can't do that but we have one at the front desk you can use." Strike two Next morning, breakfast is typically a buffet but not today. You know why? You guessed it, the wedding party had a full spread buffet while the rest of us had to order from the menu. The french toast looked so sad. Strike three. Its safe to say I wont be returning here again nor recommending this place to friends.

    West Gate Inn Nyack - hotels - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...