Whistlestop Bookshop

0.2 mi

I ordered a book online from Pomfret Street Books. There was a problem with the order. The…read morebookstore handled the problem promptly, with courtesy and respect. I am so impressed! I will definitely do more business with this store.

Used book stores are a dying breed which is why I was so happy to wander into Pomfret Street Books…read morein Carlisle. Each room is packed with wall to wall and floor to ceiling books, but they also have several reading rooms with comfy chairs and couches and even a coffee table and checkers and chess sets sitting out. This place is a great throwback for me when used book stores used to be everywhere. I'm glad to discover they still exist in the hidden niches of small towns. If you're a book lover, definitely check this place out, but give yourself plenty of time as you can lose yourself for hours in their stacks.

See all

Bedford Street Antiques

This place was such a treat to explore! Two levels of thrifty fun! My husband and I came in with no…read moreexpectations. We had a great time looking at all the vintage stuff and it was plentiful: antique glassware, light fixtures, jewelry, decorations, dolls, furniture---whatever you can think of they probably have at least one. We ended up wandering around for about an hour. Staff was present and there to help, but they weren't annoying in any way. When we found a set of vintage bubbler lights, one staff member was very excited by our find and offered to plug them in to ensure they work. We will definitely be back when we have more time to peruse. The place is as organized as can be in a building this size and the prices were very reasonable.

It's an ok shop but the prices seemed crazy. We like vintage clothes but the price made purchasing…read moreanything counterproductive. I mean for a no name T-shirt, $47 , seems steep. They have a downstairs clothing selection or should I say collection since they don't plan on selling anything

Just trying to buy this record. Two people in line. Been standing here twenty minutes.

See all

Comics and Cool Stuff

(1 review)

0.8 mi

Joe at Comics and Cool stuff was very helpful when my daughter's was looking for books for a…read moredrawing class she is teaching. He was super helpful with a huge selection of books to choose from for a great value. If looking for books, I wouldn't hesitate to check them out.

From the owner: Comics and Cool stuff located at 820 West high Street Carlisle Pennsylvania Cumberland county's…read morelargest comic book buyer always purchasing records vintage toys action figures WWF Star wars GI joes Star Trek video games Masters of the universe comic books Godzilla ThunderCats coins turquoise sterling silver gold vintage costume jewelry graphic novels anime manga comic book collections. Call 717 210 1192

Comics and Cool stuff located at 820 West high Street Carlisle

He has the coolest stuff I personally recommend it

See all

820 West high Street Carlisle

Banner of Truth

(1 review)

2.9 mi

While I have personally never been to their physical locations, the books that they publish and…read moresell are top notch. Nowhere else will you find original and high quality Reformed and Puritan works. I personally have around 30 Banner books, and I can say from experience that they are tremendous in both content and quality. Praise God for their faithfulness to His Word and publishing biblical works!! If you haven't gotten some Banner books for yourself, I highly recommend you do!

From the owner: Banner of Truth is a Christian organization which publishes books, organizes conferences, and…read morepublishes a monthly magazine. Our objective is the promotion, advancement, and dissemination of a better knowledge and understanding of the history and doctrines of the true Biblical Christian Faith. We seek to inform, encourage, strengthen, and equip ordinary Christians, and have a particular concern for ministers/pastors, and those training for the ministry. We also seek to produce material that is evangelistic and in God's providence may be used as a means to bring people to repentance and faith in Jesus Christ as their Savior and Lord.

See all

The Bargain Barn

3.5

(2 reviews)

6.2 mi

I stopped in with little expectation, but was pleasantly surprised. There is a large variety of…read moreitems, not just furniture and clothing like some places. There are multiple rooms and an upstairs as well. Artwork and crafts are abundant and prices are very reasonable. As a plus, there is another shop attached. Both shop owners were very personable. I spent a lot of time there and bought a few items. What a hidden gem. Loved it!!

Went here for the first time as part of an antique shop tour of Carlisle. (I should mention that…read morethis store is rather far outside downtown Carlisle). I was disappointed. The mention of "antiques" is a huge stretch. This is a consignment store. I think I saw only one legitimate antique. Everything else is pretty much household goods and decor and lots of used clothing. I'm sure some people may find something of interest, but I certainly wouldn't describe this store as having antiques.

See all

Puff & Bean

I love this place and have always gotten amazing customer service every time from the owner and…read morenight staff - since my first visit there! I need Kratom for severe back pain and have moved back home recently after living in Los Angeles for 14 years. This guy has the stuff! Great prices, great variety, direct from farmers! You buy per ounce capsules or powder and I have to say his red maeng da doesn't make me feel anxious or sick like my usual online vendors product has been recently. Bring cash - it's cheaper! His prices are competitive to what i was paying in la too where you can find Kratom at almost any smoke shop. They've got cartridges for my vape pods I couldn't find anywhere but online for great prices too! More Ejuice and nicotine salts than you can imagine and good brands - an experience I haven't really had elsewhere in the area. Rolling papers, Cbd, cigar room, cigarettes at low prices, snuss, chewing, disposable vapes, glassware, it's like a wonderland!!! I stop by here pretty much every week and have great convos with the owner- a great place!

My husband and I stopped in this morning to buy e-cig juice, (I waited in the car) My husband told…read moreme, the older man that was working was very rude to him. Every time my husband tried to ask a question he snapped at him and was very short. He also told my husband that they don't do taste test and if he didn't like the e-cig juice he bought, then too bad he can't return it. We just moved here from Washington State and we were looking to find a shop near his work and our new home that was convenient. We definitely will NEVER be coming back to this shop.

See all

Knisely's Pet & Farm Center

Friendly staff, excellent inventory, good prices. Parrots will greet you with whistles and chatter.read more

Knisely's is a wonderful store where I purchase my animals food and supplies. I also pick up some…read morenew baby chickens from the store every spring. Love the people who work there and they are always helpful when I have questions. Will be stopping by for resupply shortly!

Triple Crown Horse Feed Dealership

Store Front Eagle - Hand Carved by local Chainsaw-er

See all

Stop in and Check out our nursery and Lawn & Garden Section

The Carlisle Antique Mall

2.9

(7 reviews)

0.3 mi

This place is endless! There is endless things to look at from older clothes to floors and floors…read moreof furniture to an artisan variety store in the rear! Truly epic! Prices vary on items so know your values when shopping! Staff are very friendly!

This antique mall has literally thousands of vintage men's and women's clothes! The Underground…read moreMarketplace has clothing from the 50's through present. Coats, sweaters, dresses, jackets, shirts, tee-all beautifully displayed. Vintage lingerie on the second floor. Vintage designer name clothes. Great prices and a beautiful place to shop.

Great record and cd selection!

See all

Women's vintage clothes Underground Marketplace.

Cole's Bicycles

After calling to ask if parts for my bike were available I was pleasantly told to come talk to the…read morebike mechanic who was very helpful (wish I got his name). After replacing two tires, brake pads, a tube and a full tune up, I paid just under $200. My bike rides smoother than when I bought it new and I couldn't be happier. A gentleman even helped my grandfather by lifting it into the bed of his truck. Amazing service, Cole's. Thank you.

After our bikes took a tumble on the Verrazano Bridge during our Road Trip. We stayed in a…read morecampground near Carlisle. The next day we took a trip into town to the best bike shop in Carlisle PA, maybe America. It's COLES BIKE REPAIR Shop. It has been a family business for many decades. It wasn't too promising that they would have what we needed, but low and behold they had everything we needed to get our bikes back on the road. Karen and Kevin siblings (our guardian angels on earth) that were raised in the shop were extremely helpful and knowledgeable. They gave us some advice on what we needed and prices were extremely reasonable and fair. The silver lining of our trip. Shout out to the SMALL BUSINESS OWNERS OF AMERICA, don't think we would've gotten the service and advice we needed from the box stores.

Biking in the State Park thanks to Cole's and Karen.

Like nothing ever happened.

See all

Fixing the bikes with the supplies from Cole's

Basehore Farm Market

4.4

(9 reviews)

11.0 mi

5 star reviews. It is a pleasure to our guests. They just embrace this amazing …read more The family farm business is rare . They are the embodiment of down to Earth family farm people that care about the consumer.

The building is very nice. The people who work there weren't overly helpful or friendly. The dog…read morewas very nice though. They don't have a big selection of fresh produce, but it's a nice place.

See all

Double Vision Acres

5.5 mi

I've got to hand it to Double Vision Acres -- they know how to make farm life fun. Their Facebook…read morepage says, "I'm Megan! I am a young farmer in Carlisle, PA. We specialize in providing local meat, eggs, and agritourism." And honestly, Megan's doing a phenomenal job bringing the community together around agriculture. I first stopped by Double Vision Acres over the summer just to check it out and was impressed with their farm store and selection of butchered meats. But when I saw they were hosting an event called Flannel Fest, I knew I had to make a return trip. I mean... free parking, free admission, free live music, and free petting zoo access if you wore flannel? Challenge accepted. I got there around 1:30 p.m. and found plenty of parking in the field just a short walk from all the action. The parking attendant was super helpful and friendly -- always a good sign. The place was hopping, with families, couples, and plenty of folks in flannel soaking up a perfect sunshiney fall day. Cody Ross Smith was performing live, the music was great, and the overall vibe was exactly what you want from a fall festival -- laid-back, cheerful, and full of small-town charm. Fire pits were burning, hay bales had been turned into makeshift couches, and kids were running around between the petting zoo and the play areas, having a fantastic day! The farm store was open too, selling baked goods, meats, and handmade soaps and lotions. It was the kind of afternoon that makes you wish fall could stick around forever. Huge kudos to Double Vision Acres for not just running a farm, but building a sense of community around it. Well-organized, family-friendly, and totally worth the drive. If you're looking for a place that serves up wholesome small-town fun with a side of s'mores and livestock -- this is it. I came for the flannel, stayed for the vibes, and left smelling faintly of hay and happiness.

What a great small local business I really enjoyed talking to the owners they are very friendly, I…read morealso love the farm so many different animals to see. They have a wide range of local meats, milk, paintings, crafts, breads , and honey just a small list of things to mention, a place you just have to check out!!

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

2 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

David P.

6 years ago

Jeff's bookstore is my number one place to purchase my books. I have bought many books from him through the years and have never been disappointed with his excellent service. I am also quite impressed with his encyclopedic knowledge of various subject both fiction and non-fiction. If you are a bibliophile and book collector like me you have to establish a relationship with this man and his wonderful bookstore. David P. read more

Aaron K.

13 years ago

This is my favorite independent store - of books or otherwise. Jeff and his staff are always very friendly and knowledgeable about what's on their shelves. In most areas of commerce I'm a fan of the internet -- click and wait for UPS. But not books and this is the reason why. 8 thumbs up. read more

Whistlestop Bookshop - media - Updated July 2026

People who viewed Whistlestop Bookshop also viewed

The Bookworm Bookstore

(9 reviews)

•$$

What a joy to have a bookshop above a farmer's market! Lady Matilda and I schedule our quarterly…read morevisit to the Farmer's Market when the store is open. Check the days and hours before you visit. Lady Matilda and I come to the market for our meats and spices, grab a soft pretzel or three from the Amish kiosk, and see what the Bookworm has to surprise us. It's a friendly shop where they remember you and your tastes. I've converted a lot of clients and friends in the area who were quick to dismiss it as just another dirt-mall book dump. Absolutely not. The store carries the professionalism of classic independent booksellers with the fun of a friendly mom-and-pop store. Take a break from the busy market on your next visit.

This little gem of a used bookstore can be found inside the delightful West Shore Farmer's Market…read more You might think at first that there isn't much to see, but when approaching the store inside the market, you come to discover that what exists in the hallway is only the outside of the Bookworm Bookstore. There's so much to see inside, with all kinds of book genres all well-organized and easy to search. The staff was incredibly friendly and approached me twice to ask if there was something they could help me find. They knew where everything was and knew sometimes even before they'd look what was on the shelves and what wasn't (or what just sold a couple of days/weeks ago). Very insightful and their kindness made the experience even more enjoyable. Highly recommend for the used book lover!

Cupboard Maker Books

4.2

(44 reviews)

•$

I drive by this bookstore all the time, so today I decided to stop…read more As soon as I walked in that lovely old book smell reached me, and then I met a local author! I browsed through the books & finally landed on the true crime section, which peaked my interest. I grabbed a book & took it to checkout, they were polite & offered me a bag. The book price was very affordable & I even got a discount! Unfortunately the cats were hiding so I didn't get to say hello to them, but this is such a gem of a store & i recommend that you visit!

The cats were nice, but once me and my family entered the business the staff were very judgemental…read moreand kept staring at my kids as if they were gonna start trouble and when my daughter tried to pet Oden the one lady scared him away, we went there for the cats and they were kinda rude. When I found a book and bought it the lady at the counter was being pretty rude. I went there before and no issue but I dont think I will be going again due to how uncomfortable me and my family was, especially when they are supposed to promote the cats for adoption.

Between the Covers Bookshop

(1 review)

I recently popped into Between the Covers Bookshop, and it was honestly the cutest little…read morebookstore. It's set up in a shared space, which I actually thought was really unique, you walk in and the bookstore is to your right, and there's another shop to the left. Even with that setup, it still feels like the perfect amount of space for browsing without feeling cramped. The shop itself is small and intimate, but don't let the size fool you they have a great variety of books. I was just casually browsing this time, but I found myself really drawn in by both the collection and the decor. It has such a cozy, thoughtfully curated feel. Even on a quick visit, I could tell this is the kind of place you come back to when you want to slow down and really enjoy the experience of book shopping. I'm already planning to return so I can take my time and dig deeper into everything they have to offer. Definitely worth stopping in if you love a charming local bookstore with a cozy vibe. I chatted with Audra who was helping out in the bookshop and she was helpful and informative. There are bathrooms inside the shared space both upstairs and downstairs. Parking is in the side of the building.

Funky Finds and Grinds

(4 reviews)

You can find what some local stores sell on Facebook Marketplace. Funky Finds and Grinds is one…read moresuch store in Lemoyne, PA. My daughter purchased a stunning mid-century modern brass bar cart from Funky Finds and Grinds, which she found on Facebook Marketplace. My daughter called to show interest in seeing and purchasing the lovely bar cart. The owner held the item until her arrival, and of course, she was grateful when she saw how lovely it was. It pays to shop on Facebook Marketplace for quality pieces at great prices.

I miss Atomic Warehouse but this place is a smaller, easier to navigate very similar store. Found…read morethe coolest things. Great jewelry too!

Comics World

4.2

(6 reviews)

•$$

Comics World is located in the Lincoln Way East Shopping Center near AAA. Do not let the size of…read morethe storefront fool you, they have a lot to offer. Excellent selection of new pull comics, which at some shops these days is hard to find. Back of the store is mostly comprised of longboxes on tables, with a large selection. Better longboxes are on the tables with some budget longboxes located on the floor. The good selection of toys and collectables just makes Comics World even more well-rounded. This might be the best kept secret in the southern Pennsylvania comic book shop scene and I would absolutely return here.

they have great items, prices are about the same as everywhere else. They could be better with…read morecustomer service but they're the only book store in town so...

Cherie Anne Designs

•$$

tea prices were great, cozy store, always felt welcome! very…read morepersonable staff, community oriented they have weird hours but definetly worth going to

Locally sourced handspun yarn. It is expensive but you are getting what you pay for. Staff is very…read morefriendly and helpful. Well talk to you about knitting, felting and spinning all you want. Teas are amazing I have enjoyed all things that I have ever gotten here. A must stop when in the area!

Heartfelt History

(2 reviews)

Stumbled into this place randomly and it was one of the best experiences I had in the town. Cute…read morelittle shop! And amazing customer service! 100/10 experience!

Such a cute gift shop! Found better quality items and better prices here! Owner was super helpful.read more

Treasures On Main

(4 reviews)

Great finds, good memories, and bargain prices in a walkable district of a cool area; so glad we…read morefound it.

So much fun! There's so many different things to search through from vintage dishes, furniture,…read morejewelry, home decor, toys and so much more! The people who work there are knowledgeable and friendly. They know where to find that specific specialty you might be looking for! Check them out for that fun Treasure Hunt experience!

Pomfret Street Books

KT Media