I'll start with the food... it was good. Some of it was excellent. We had an appetizer and two…read moreentrees. NY strip wrapped Asparagus was good but not something I'd get again ... kind of bland. My SO ordered Pork Parmesan over spaghetti but didn't like it as much as I liked the smothered chicken. It had great flavor and texture with mashed potatoes and green beans. With the new ownership, I was hoping for an upgrade in the dining area. We went on a weekday for a special occasion... my SO's birthday. They gave him a card which was a nice gesture but service was slow for a slow night. The room was freezing... the door opens and the cold rushes into the basement-like dining room. It's still too dark (couldn't see the menu without using our phone flashlight). The chairs are not comfortable. Overall it's too expensive for me and it'll be a long time before I go again. (We tend to drive to Fortville for dinner and are never disappointed with multiple restaurants to choose from. ) The reason I gave a 3 is because of the service, the room temperature and the fact that we only really enjoyed the chicken dish. They also might serve a piece of cake for a birthday if they wanted to impress me... lol.

We had two family birthdays to celebrate and wanted them to see the new Burgess restaurant…read moreCarnegies. The service was fantastic with much attention to the birthdays and our choices of food. Our server Bryce was great and helpful with our menu choices. He was spot on to recommend the pork Parmesan which featured a large Bonges pork tenderloin on a bed of spaghetti Al limone with basil. It was amazing to say the least. The price was moderate and the serving was huge. I had enough to make it into three servings and believe it or not my serving on day three was as yummy as days one and two. I need to mention my cocktail too. I had a guilded sour which seems to be similar to a New York sour, my favorite. It looks as good as it tastes. Carnegie' is great for a quick lunch and equally good for celebrating a special event.

A disappointing visit after reading so many great reviews. In hindsight, I should have filtered by…read moredate. I waited a while at my car after flipping the button on the menu board. The young woman who came out told me she only came out because they weren't busy. I told her it wasn't an issue and I was fine ordering inside. Maybe this was obvious to everyone else but if the in-car ordering wasn't available they should remove it from the menu board. It seemed odd to have customers walk in to order then have food carried out to my car, which is what happened. The patio seating is enclosed so there is seating "indoors". I think that would've been a better option. I was excited about their sourcing from Tyner Pond but don't think they do this anymore. The fries definitely did not match any description I read and I definitely was not expecting a small bag of crinkle cut fries. These are not worth ordering for $3. I ordered a double burger but a single would've been fine-it was quite large. It was good, but I wish the onion was sliced thinner- it made the whole thing difficult to hold and was just a lot of onion. The root beer is Sprecher's on tap. Overall a disappointment. Check out the more recent reviews.

Food was great, had triple smash, amazing. Onion rings were very tasty but they must have been out…read moreof onions, produce truck showed up and heard them saying someone was gone to get produce already. Instead of not selling them, must have just charged me for a full order and gave me what scraps were left... Service was good otherwise, friendly young lady took my order. Quiet atmosphere, not much going on for a dreary Friday.

Best tenderloin in Indianapolis…read more Servers are so friendly and sweet.... There was a long wait to be helped and served because they were short staffed but honestly it was worth it! We had been here before a few times before Covid hit and the service was awesome. Food is fantastic !!

Came here with my adopted mom cuz she came here before when it was a different name. We came during…read morelunch hour. We were not impressed with the sandwiches we ordered. I ordered the Philly which the meat was chewy & no flavor. And my mom had the tenderloin. She said it was ok with it said she won't be coming back.

Our server Ben was absolutely amazing. He was the most personable, funny and kind server we have…read moreever had! We recommend asking for him! The atmosphere was perfect for a date night or a quick dive bar aspect with your friends The Bone Marrow fries were fire along side some great entrees! We'll be back very soon

I go here every chance I get, and usually forget to take photos of the delicious food!…read more I am so glad i took the advice of the earlier reviews to entice me to try it out the first time (now years ago). This place has been a hit with my "21+" family due to the great food, great location, and usually good service. Minors are not allowed. Our most recent visit yesterday had less than awesome service but maybe she was having a bad day. The building is old with lots of wood paneling ... very comfy. There are several other wonderful restaurants in Fortville which is great for me as I have several choices. I never would have guessed that this tiny suburb would have such epic cuisine!

My Mom brought me here for my birthday dinner since we were in town doing some shopping. It was…read morestill early in the afternoon, so we were seated right away. Waitress was friendly. Not very many people there at the time so it was quiet. Rolls came out first. They look "wilted". They were warm but kinda seemed old, hard/stale. Food came out fairly quick. Steak was very gristly. I feel like there was more gristle than meat. Salad was good. Only one tiny cherry tomato and one small slice of cucumber in the salad. Green beans were good and it was a pretty nice portion really. So overall it was ok. Not something I'd drive to Greenfield again to come to.

It felt like they were cutting corners the last three times I was there. Price increases too…read more.. same menu for the most part. Service is always good but I was disappointed with the food. I don't know if they have a new meat supplier or what has happened but I get the steak salad every time because it's the perfect amount of food for me and I can get it without cheese and croutons. And I have no worries about my allergies. Plus it is normally yummy! And perfect. I have to remind them that I want the bacon though? One server said cheese was pre-mixed with the bacon and that's why they keep forgetting it? Anyway, the steak has been chewy to the point where I don't enjoy it. Gristly I actually sent the last one back. The one before that I just set half of the steak aside after I couldn't chew it. My husband thinks I need to ask for a different cut of steak because sirloin is notoriously inconsistent cuts of meat and I just need to pay an up charge for a filet or something. Anyway, I panicked about getting a bad steak salad again last week when I was there and I ordered a burger. Who can mess up a burger I thought, right? I forgot about the bun. I think they toasted it with butter so I took it off. I still got sick though. Blast it. Why can you tell a server you are Allergic to dairy and they don't understand that butter comes from a cow!!!! I'm telling you this is my girlfriend's favorite place to meet up for girl talk so go and enjoy yourself. The atmosphere is nice. Seats are comfortable and if you linger to visit the servers are wonderful to keep filling your drink glasses. But after three bad meals in a row and getting sick after eating that burger... I'm going to talk her into going elsewhere. At least when I'm her tagalong.

My family was out and about. Our friend said she knows of a great place. We meet up with her. It…read morewas lovely. Food was all amazing. Customer service wasn't bad, but a little confused. We asked questions and she was a little unsure. But alas, she went and found the answer and we were rolling. I got the Mother Clucker chicken sandwich (just because of the name) and it was delicious. Everyone loved their food. I'd for sure come back.

Redeemed themselves by providing a great steak and mashed potatoes. They also brought back the good…read moregreen beans. The homemade steak sauce is something I'd like to buy a bottle of to take home. My friend has the chicken and it was juicy and flavorful. Taking away one star only because the cut of meat was a bit tough - I can't be sure of the cut but it wasn't high end. Flavor was excellent.

Loved the whole concept of this restaurant. The building itself was super unique. I love when…read morebuildings are repurposed. I was also super impressed with the menu and the prices. We did have about a 30 minute wait, but it was a Saturday and we didn't make reservations. So a wait was expected but wish there was more of a waiting area. But waiting allowed me to check out of the food. I did struggle making a decision. I ended ordering the Tater Kegs. They tasted like loaded potato skins in a tater tot form. They were delicious. For my main entree I ordered was a pulled pork sandwich with a side salad. The sandwich was massive. It had a good amount of sauce and pork wasnt dry. It was a really good sandwich. Overall, really enjoyed the food and be back because everything on the menu looked good!

It was our first time here and we enjoyed the restaurant's vibe and the service was great. The…read moredrinks were good and the price was only $10 a martini with tons of selection! The food was so-so. I ordered a grilled chicken BLT wrap and the chicken was... weird. Very stretchy, wet and like the weirdest texture so I couldn't finish it. Chips were good, and we liked the 'tater kegs' app.

Excellent customer service, good food, like always. The manager, Victor, came out to ask about my…read morefood allergies and made accommodations for me. They were able to cook my food on a different grill to avoid the butter and oils! Nicole was a great waitress, took good care of us and made sure the kitchen knew about my food issues. Thank you!

The food was awful. Nothing was fresh. Even the hash brown casserole was awful. Couldn't eat it. We…read morewent without napkins for 15 minutes. I won't be going back to that location