Shoutout to the dude that works at the front! my brother and i walked in asking for 3 slices of pizza and we got into the car and he gave us 4 thanks dude for the extra slice SHOUT TO YOU MAN read more

If less were possible... Ordered and after 1 hour we got the wrong order, called immediately and were told they would send correct order. After another hour, no pizza, so we called again and they wouldn't answer our questions. Hung up on us 3 times, then said they would send again and after an hour we called and they said they didn't know about our order. Agreed to send order again and it would be delivered in 45 minutes. After 1 hour we called again and were informed pizza was on the way. 20 minutes later, no pizza and the employee now said they didn't know about our order and that we should have called her to tell her we wanted our pizza. 4 hours later, NO delivery of our order, NO explanations, NO interest in tending to our complaints. Unbelievable. read more

As a transplanted new yorker, I miss being able to get great NY-style pizza on a whim just about anywhere. So far I've found three places here in the NW part of Austin that I'm willing to order from, and Yaghi's is one of those three. Great crust, sauce, cheese - all remind me of home. Also, the Gyro's are very good, and at lunch you can get a Gyro and a drink for $3.99 which is a pretty good bargain. I am taking away one star because 3 of the last 4 times I've ordered from Yaghi's they've screwed up my order and when I've gone to pick it up I've had to sit there for 20 minues waiting for them to make me the correct order. Despite the ordering hassles, I'll be back because I like their food, and it is a reasonable value for the price. read more

Crust was delicious, value was good, service was TERRIFIC! HOWEVER, they had the nerve to bring me a pizza with CANNED MUSHROOMS on it. Canned mushrooms? This is the true test if a restaurant is committed to quality or not - particularly a pizza joint that claims to be authentic. Disappointing. Canned mushrooms... ICK!!! read more

Accidentally found this place last year. It's between Cedar Park High School and CP Middle School. The owner is from the east coast and definitely knows what he's doing. This has quickly become my family's favorite Cedar Park pizza place. Since going downtown to Home Slice is a rare occasion, when we are craving authentic New York style pizza we order from Yaghi's. read more

This is seriously the BEST pizza I've EVER had. We had the Philly Cheese Steak Pizza with extra garlic and a side of their light red sauce for dipping. The crust is absolute perfection. Delivered quickly, fresh and hot. This will definitely be a weekly occurrence for us on our cheat day!! There is no better pizza in Williamson County! read more

Our favorite pizza place in cedar park. We have never been disappointed and even our picky kids eat it! It's authentic NY style pizza. Definitely worth the price. read more

Two words: TURKEY. BACON. Thanks for the warning Yaghi's. Way to ruin a perfectly good pizza. read more

If I am looking for homemade NY style pizza I order from Yaghi's. The crust is so important to me and they've got it down. Oh and the salads are super fresh. There is one with mozzarella cheese on top I crave. The ranch dressing tastes homemade too not some weird package goo. Sometimes the wait for delivery can be long but they do have pick up. Not too much room for dinning in though if that what your looking for don't go here. Sure they've made a few mistakes but the overall quality is so good so true NY style that I'm giving them five stars. The website is almost non existent the last I checked. This is one place they need to work on and get up to par so they can stay competitive in the pizza world. This is a mom & pop place that'll surely please your taste buds. Give me a slice.............mmmmmmmmm..........cheese. read more

Great food, but if you are getting it delivered plan on making a follow up call because they will most likely forget your order. Happened to us twice in two weeks. read more

This is THE best pizza you will find in Cedar Park and maybe in Austin. The crust is thin and not tough like some pizza dough. The toppings are premium, I love the cheese and it holds up well. The prices are not bargain pizza prices because you're getting quality pizza. We order every Friday and sometimes Tuesday or Wednesday when the kids have sports. My kids at Vista Ridge like to go here and get pizza by the slice. Absolutely the best deal in town for that as well. Spoke with the owner when I had a slight issue once and he took care of it immediately. This is THE pizza for Cedar Park read more

See all

I waited to write a review of this place so I could be sure about everything. I'm going to let you in on a secret....this is the best pizza place you never heard of. I had the lunch special. Great value, delicious pizza, good service and good location. Then I had it again to be sure another time a few weeks later. Same results. Last night, wifey asked me to bring home a pizza for dinner. At this point I've only had it by the slice, but I was confident she would like it too. She did. Dinner was a success! Thanks Yahgi's pizza! Very tasty! read more

The pizza is good. Certainly better than two-stars. But they recently switched to GrubHub for their delivery, and after give-or-take ten years of delivering to my house, I'm somehow no longer in delivery range. Either they didn't bother checking that GrubHub matched their old delivery range, or they knew it and didn't care, and it's a huge failure either way. Previously loyal customer, now shopping for a new pizza joint. read more

Had 2 pizzas last night and they are awesome! It tasted incredibly fresh and not greasy. Delivery guy showed up very early and was great. Guy on the phone, john, sounded like he was having a bad day but I ordered pizza and got great pizza so I can't complain. read more

The crust is ok but I have had better, the salads suck compared to some of their local competitors and their pies are too greasy. Seems like somebody wants the pies to be grease bombs. I cant rate the place well because the pie just isnt that great and neither are the sides. read more

Out of all the Yaghi's locations in Austin, this one has been my favorite! I started going here every Friday for almost 2 years with a kid I would nanny for and the people were great! They put up with the occasional fit as well as everything form spilling a drink all the way to the entire lunch ending up on the floor. They even made us another 2 slices and a salad for that one, all for free! The pizza is my favorite style of pizza! The dough is somewhere between hand tossed style and thin crust in thickness but has a sweeter flavor to it rather than more salty. The dough comes out perfectly toasted with a nice golden brown finish on the bottom and not a single burn! The sauce is just perfect! Lightly spread so you know it's there but you're not overwhelmed by it dripping everywhere or overpowering the other flavors. The cheese cooks evenly and isn't clumped anywhere. It's true mozzarella and doesn't have that fake stringy quality about it. They have top quality toppings! Everything from pepperoni to gyro meet! All evenly spread out and the toppings are thin so you don't get a sudden shot in the mouth by one topping at a time but all of them to create the taste you were looking for! Their salads are great and fresh. I personally love the Greek salad but I'm not an onion person so I ask them to leave it off and add extra olives, which they've always been great about. The house dressing is absolutely amazing! Can't place what they put in it, and they won't tell me, but it is wonderful! They are very well priced for what you get. They are cheaper than a few of the Chicago style places but more expensive than Pizza hut and for good reasons! They are priced just right for a New York style pizza. They have really fast delivery even tho they always say an hour. The only time it took that long was on Super Bowl Sunday, one time. The rest of the time it's about 35 min. The lunch special is your best deal. $7 gets you 2 items and a drink. Wonderful! And there is plenty of counter space to eat there and a couple tables outside if you prefer that. My only advice, is if you do delivery tip the drivers in cash. If you do in store pick up or eat there, give the cash directly to the person at the counter. Do not write it on your charge slip or put it in the jar. After about a year of going there, one of the employees let me know that they don't actually get the tips that are added to the charge or put in the jar, they all go to the owner. I wish they would change this policy but whatever. A great place to grab a bite! read more

Not sure if I went in on a bad day or what... but the pizza was very average. The calzone was awful. Their prices are strange. Some items are priced fairly, but others are not. The Large (not XL) Works pizza was $19.99! The huge calzone was only $6 (although it didn't taste good). Hate to say it, but Papa John's is MUUUUUUUUCH better. read more

My favorite pizza place in Texas hands down! This is our to go to place for take out or delivery and we haven't been disappointed. The prices are a little steep with delivery but we still find it worth it due to the quality and taste of the food. read more

If I could give it zero stars, I would. Last night, we ordered 2 calzones and some sausage rolls to be delivered. The website states that they have dine-in, pick up and contactless delivery. After waiting for an hour, we called to check on our order. And, yep, it was sitting there getting cold. no delivery...no call back that they could not deliver..not even a kiss my arse. This, after my husband gave them a tip for doing ABSOLUTELY NOTHING but their job. When he went to pick it up, they were smart mouthed and rude...They even laughed at him because he wasn't pleased with the service. If I thought it would make a difference, I would call the manager or owner. But seeing the other reviews, I doubt it would make a difference. We will not be ordering from them again. And we will certainly let everyone we know of the crappy experience we had with them. read more

The pizza is delicious and the delivery is on time. I highly recommend the Mediterranean pizza.

I have this Love/Hate relationship with This Yaghi's NY Pizzeria. This is some of the Best, cheesey-pizza-cheap-eats around. Great pizzas~for the price & a excellent Lunch special : 2 Lg Cheese Slices & Soda = $ 3.99 Great taste, lotz of cheese, tasty sauce. Sprinkle some Parmesan cheese & red pepper flakes = Perfect. Only complaint: It seems ..Hard..for staff to show up on time. 10 am (opening) rolls around & their mostly just getting there for work & look like they just got out of bed 3 min ago. read more

Place is trash.... ordered a calzone, I took two bits and was done. While picking it up togo you'll notice only one person is working whom is a Latino chef and of course the other 4 employees all being white guys are just standing around socializing with one another. Not inviting at all I regret spending my money here. read more

Not bad, an alright place to chill at every now and then. They have probably the greasiest pizza I've ever had; you hold up one of their slices and the grease literally flows off. Their pizza's okay and the calzones are alright. read more

Underrated. Way underrated. New lunch special = $3.99 for ANY 2 slices + drink = AWESOME. Great non-chewy thinly crusted pizza. Friendly. Not many spots to sit. Gourmet pizza style means they have a showcase of available slices that they heat up. Best place for the price. And fast! =] read more

Yaghi's is OK pizza, for delivery I have to say it is probably the best. we ordered the Gyro, and the Tomato and Garlic. the gyro was really good, and I was mixed to use the gyro sauce or ranch dressing ..... I decided Ranch was far superior to the gyro sauce and went with it. The garlic was minced, WTH? It was obviously the generic brand from HEB ... and it was spooned on so it had packets of super garlic and parts were there wasn't much taste just the juice. We would really have preferred sliced, fresh garlic. Crust was really good and the pizza sauce that they use was tasty. the pizza wasn't as greasy as other places, we'll be using them as our pizza delivery of choice, since it is so much better than pizza hut. They were really quick as well. The delivery arrived and we were expecting to wait a little longer. read more

Delicious pizza and great service! Easy to order online, and both pick up and delivery is a breeze. The guy at the front desk was very polite and professional when I last went to pick up my order, and it was cool seeing the guys in the back making the magic happen! You can tell they've been doing this for a long time. read more

Our food was not warm at all. We picked this food up and only live five minutes away. Very disappointed. Order was not ready when we arrived, had to wait in car 25 minutes and it was supposed to be brought out to car. Had to go in, they said pizza was ready. Must've been sitting for a while. This was for a birthday dinner. So disappointing. read more

I found this place through DoorDash and the pizza exceeded my expectations. As far as New York style pizza goes, you can't find much better. I'm not sure how their other items are but I definitely recommend the pizza. read more

Hard to rate pizza in Austin, there really isn't a great pizza shop around so the bar is low to start. The best pizza in town would only garner 3-4 stars when compared to just about any pizza up north yet alone the killer stuff we got walking the streets of Rome and Florence. Anyway pizza in Cedar Park is miserable... I rarely even eat it anymore, but a couple times now for game days of football we have ordered from Yaghis and I have to say their pizza is pretty good, toppings are fresh and plentiful, dough is not bland and not too thick or thin... And there is a huge variety. I strongly prefer their non tomato sauces (or what I have had of them at a friends house)... Which bring up where they lose a star, the last two times we have ordered from there once over the phone and the other I think my wife used their online system both times we asked for a non tomato sauce on both pizzas for our family and both times that was ignored.... Not sure why they offer other sauces if they don't use them. Can't say how good they are with the Alfredo or garlic sauces because they have yet to make one for us. May try it again... But I will have to explicitly state to them that I don't want their red sauce (it's not that bad.... Just not that good either) read more

This is excellent pizza. The crust is unbelievably perfect, and everything is fresh. Best pizza I have had in Cedar Park.

Zayd and his Dad run this pizza place. The pizza is second to none!!! The service also, is second to none! Highly recommend it!!!

Best pizza in Cedar Park. The crust is delicious and they're always generous with toppings

I've tried Yaghi's over the years and have been generally pleased. I think their pizza and chicken parm is some of the best in the area. I hadn't been here for a while until a week or so ago, and have to admit I've been back a couple times since then. OK, I will slow down now that I've had my fair share, but will definitely consider Yaghi's whenever I'm in the mood for pizza in the future. My opinion of them went from generally pleased to oh so satisfied. I don't even consider myself a huge pizza eater, but it's the quality of their ingredients from the cheese to the sauce to the dough that is to me above the norm. I just wish they had fountain drinks as I don't like drinking out of a can. Good quality for the price, consistent and yummy!! read more

Loved their pizza and that's saying a lot since I am not a pizza person. They used light sauce which I always order and focused on their toppings. We had just a plain cheese and also a pepperoni pizza. It was so good and I will definitely order from them again! read more

worst excuse of NY STYLE pizza I have ever had...horrible flavor, crust was soggy. It's an insult to NEW YORKERS who know what Pizza is supposed to be. Mamma Mia! è orribile!!! Non ho mai mangiato nuovamente!!! read more

Incredibly disappointed. We love Yaghi's and want to support local but the last 2 times we have ordered it has taken 2 hours to get our pizza even though we were quoted 1 hour. When we call we are out on hold and just ignored until we hang up and the process continues until we give up. I know it's COVID and we have so much grace for this strange time frame but 2+ hour for a 1 hour delivery and phone calls being ignored and no apologies or explanations is just not ok. We are still waiting for our 6:45 order at 8:30 w 3 starving kids and have received no pizza and no answers after phone calls. Do not order unless you order 3 hours in advance. read more

Customer service well below that of Travis County Jail....employee did not know how to sell a slice of pepperoni pizza... Said none were available as another employee placed sliced cheese pizza on counter...had to suggest to him to add pepperoni to it...no customer restrooms available...wtf? I read more

Fantastic pizza. I moved to Texas and have been search for a long time for a good one! Very pleased with pizza and subs! Will and have order many times! Fast delivery and friendly read more

Excellent service and the food was great! Lasagna actually has real vegetables in the sauce and not just sauce. And the kids loved the Pizza! read more

Possibly I need to give this place another try, based on other's reviews, but being a former New Yorker looking for a great pie, was extremely disappointed with both the service (took nearly an hour for a pick-up for one cheese pizza) and the taste of this pizza. In NO way does Yaghi's even come close to beating out Saccone's. If you're wanting a more authentic pie than those at Domino's or Papa John's, then Yaghi's might be a good option, but only until Saccone's reopens their doors following their recent fire. read more