Absolutely one of the best pizza places I've been to! The pizza came out hot, fresh, and loaded with toppings. The crust had the perfect balance of crispy on the outside and soft on the inside, and you could tell everything was made with quality ingredients. The staff was friendly, welcoming, and made us feel right at home from the moment we walked in. The restaurant was clean, the service was quick, and the whole experience was fantastic. I'll definitely be coming back and recommending this place to friends and family. If you're looking for great pizza and even better service, this is the place to go! read more

Great service Pizza was good sauce was ok and a good crust. I liked how they put what ever toppings on they way you want and not charge extra per topping Great food for the price And will be back read more

While we were eagerly greeted with smiles, we were NOT smiling about certain food items we ordered when we ate at Your Pie Pizza. Let's just say, stick to the BYO pizza offerings... DO NOT get the wings, unless you're looking for an easy way to GAG. I don't eat pizza but I have to join my pizza eating family sometimes... So we made our way to this spot and I was totally content knowing they have a PLAIN WINGS OPTION. I got 10 Plain Wings... I asked for them to be EXTRA crispy... But when I saw the way they were going to be cooked (they're oven roasted in a tin container), I knew that wasn't going to be achieved but I had hopes. The wings came out after the pizzas. They did not look even a LITTLE crispy. They just looked fatty with soggy skin. My husband got the buffalo ones, took one bite and looked at me disgusted. I tried so hard to be positive about this wing experience but I was basically gagging while trying to eat the tiniest bit of chicken meat found on these INSANELY FATTY wings. I felt like I was attempting to eat globs of seasoned snot. Horrible. I highly recommend Your Pie Pizza either invest in a deep fryer and get a different chicken wing supplier, or just take wings off the menu. Focus on what you're decent at. Wings are not it. Needless to say, I was VERY disappointed with my lunch and I absolutely will NEVER go back to this spot. read more

See all

I was there yesterday with co-workers for lunch, ordered a 7" Ischia Margherita. It was good. My party ordered some chicken wings that were delicious. What was distasteful was the credit card transaction. I didn't want to tip. When I hit "No Tip" on the credit card machine, the transaction was declined. This occurred three times. The cashier claimed my credit card was rejected. On the fourth try, I hit "Specify an Amount". The screen showed a numeric keypad with a numeric value on the top row. I verified that "0.00" was shown and then hit "Done". The transaction was successful. Should you encounter this issue when you don't want to tip, you know what to do. read more

See all

Well I waited 20 minutes for my pie after the couple in front of me got theirs in time, and THEN 3 other groups with 5 plus people got their food in front of me. Then when I finally got my order (25 plus minutes) I didnt get my cheesesticks. Mentioned it they sad oops. Want Ranch Dressing but didnt get an option. CLOWNSHOW HERE NEVER GOING BACK. 703 9265651 read more

From the time you walk in the staff is attentive and friendly. The atmosphere is friendly family and the food is delicious! What more could you ask for? read more

Your Pie Pizza - Personal pie - Pizza Near Me - Peachtree City, Georgia

The perfect restaurant when you are craving a custom pizza. Arrived at 1100, when they open, and there was already a line to get in, but the line moved fast. So while waiting, I debated on ordering one of the special pizzas as they looked very nice, but in the long run I went with my standard all meat pizza. My pizza was ready around 10 minutes and I was on my way home. While waiting, I did notice that they had several craft beers on tap. I will return. read more

Always great service! If Prince is here, ask him to do his "happy dance". LOL. Think the 'Target Lady' from SNL. Haha. Tried two new to us pizzas tonight over the usual topping we choose. Both the Cubano and the Hot Honey Pepperoni were fantastic. If you like a Cuban sandwich, the Cubano pizza is a good choice and a nice comparison. read more

See all

Service was horrible!!! Over charged us and refused to make it right! Pizza was good. Restaurant was clean but needed to be stocked. Restroom definitely needed attention. read more

My pizza was DELICIOUS! They have vegan cheese, which is the most important part for making a vegan pizza. I don't want a stupid no-cheese pizza lol. And they weren't skimpy with it either!! I loaded up on veggies while my husband got a large pizza for himself. The price was great for what we got. The service wasn't anything to complain about and the restaurant itself was clean. read more

Your Pie Pizza - Veggie-filled vegan pizza in the front, and regular pan pizza with pepperoni and sausage in the back - Pizza Near Me - Peachtree City, Georgia

I went here because I was trying to stay away from bread and they offered cauliflower crust pizza. They change an extra $5 for the upgrade so I wasn't to happy about that but hey if it's good so what. The pizza itself was ok... I ordered a bbq chicken pizza (w/ the cauliflower crust) & a cheese pizza for the kids. I felt the crust on my pizza was definitely a little to crispy and a little burnt around the edges. I've had cauliflower pizza before at other places and it wasn't like that so I took 2 point off their rating for that. My kids loved their cheese pizza & they didn't give us a cookie we ordered. 3 stars overall. read more

See all

Okay, so I may actually love pizza. I've had true Chicago pizza and some of the best pizza in a city near you. This place is so legit! The prices are so affordable and they make the pie exactly how you want and just for you. The crust was grilled to perfection with some crunch and some black crisp. Definitely try this place out at least once! read more

Your Pie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Peachtree City, Georgia

Pizza is good ... service is okay. Atmosphere is okay. Good value for the price. I like that everyone can get their own personal pizza the way YOU want it. read more

Love this place. To be fair and honest I have only eaten 3 menu items there. 1. Homemade pizza of my choice Amazing, you basically watch them make the piece of your choice. Any toppings. Any amount. Oven fired in front of you. Low price. Tastes great. 2. Pasta bowls almost same set up but with pasta in an aluminum pan. Still a great choice 3. Italian ice / gellatto. Delicious Staff is always nice. Place is clean. Small outdoor area. Parking can get competitive with nail salon. Restrooms clean. Employees wear masks. read more

Nice & easy pizza place if you are wanting a personal pan pizza & want to customize it. the service is normally pretty good here. i normally get the BBQ chicken pizza & add a few veggies. definitely a good quality pizza and not too expensive. read more

Your Pie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Peachtree City, Georgia

Amazing and delicious pizza. They have brick oven which cooks the pizza evenly and gives a yummy taste to it . Will definitely be ordering again. read more

This place always has great customer service, you're always greeted upon entry. You can customize your pizza, they also have vegan options, salad, Gelato & beer. They have plenty of seating & a nice ambiance. read more

Your pie has become a a Sunday tradition for our family. It's essentially a made to order Pizza and pasta bar which is uncooked in a pizza oven. Their pizza is even better as leftovers. read more

Casual atmosphere, dirty floor, loud customer sitting close to me whom I am married to. Good choice of drinks. Friendly staff. Nice pi day special. Would not hesitate to return. read more

Your Pie Pizza - Lineage Pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Peachtree City, Georgia

One issue - online ordering does not seem to work using my phone or laptop. I could've sworn I have used it for this location before, but recently I just get an error message. read more

Great food! Fast , attentive. Everything every time has been great. Repeat happy customer!

We visited on a recent Friday evening. The process is that you queue up, determine what you want to order from a large menu-board on the wall, and then proceed to the order counter / make-table. You give your order to the person who actually makes your food while you watch. For pizzas there is a 2nd person handling some of the ingredients. Once the order-prep is done, you get a number-stand for your table and head further down the counter to pick up chips, drinks, etc. and pay. The food comes out fairly quickly. We got a pannini and a pizza. Between the two of us, we finished both. It was a good, light meal. The total bill for the food + chips + a glass of wine (and tip) was $30. We'll probably be back. read more

I'm sorry, if you like good pizza, this is not it. Grosss!!!!!!!good lor, really???It's old and tired!!! But keep voting democrat then you will be eating bugs, yay read more

I'm impressed. From the food to the staff (shout out to Jerrod for the friendly service)! I would die happy here in a pizza & gelato induced coma. I almost don't want to write this review for fear my newly discovered favorite spot will become too popular. They are located at the side of the Sprout's shopping center. Inside there's a large seating area, beer on tap, an assortment of gelato & a huge pizza oven. Their interior looks like a brewery hangout in Atlanta. It's pretty casual. They also have free wifi & it's a pretty quiet location to do some work if you don't mind rock music playing over the speakers. I originally wanted to visit for their Pi day special yesterday (3.14) but it looked like 200+ people were in line. A manager later told me Pi Day had a 2+ hour wait! They have events Monday- Thursday nights which is a saving grace since there's not much for people to do in this town. I will absolutely be back to try my best at Trivia Tuesday with a Tropicalia. read more

See all

Too many young teens working. Manager needs to be on staff at all times. Not really friendly staff

My boyfriend and I absolutely LOVE YourPie. Didn't know it existed until it came to PTC. Price is extremely affordable to make your own pizza! They get your pizza out quickly and I've never had a bad meal here. I seriously think this is some of the best pizza, I haven't found another restaurant that really compares. read more

Your Pie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Peachtree City, Georgia

I was at Sprouts late and did not want to drive anywhere else so this was perfect in location. I was greeted when I entered. The ambiance is upbeat and lively. But best of all, the food is made fresh to order. Well, not the salads (premade) but mine was good. I ordered a Caprese panini and a Greek salad. Simply delicious. I will definitely go here again or maybe just try the one by my house next time. read more

I have no idea how this restaurant actually has so many stars. It's literally like the subway of pizza joints. Just not very appetizing watching your ingredients being dumped on a pizza dough right in front of you and getting mixed up with other ingredients in a messy cafeteria way. Customer service was pleasant but this poorly lit pizza restaurant with no soul is a huge pass for me. Sorry. If you hipped up the interior and lighting to make it look more appealing and cleaned up the Subway like pizza making area it would help a bit. Until then...Pass. Oh yeah, and the actual pizza, a notch above something you'd find in a school cafeteria or Buffett. Harsh but true! read more

We came here solely on reviews and proximity to where we were. We designed a pizza and also had Chicken pizza off of the menu. The gelato was tasty and we enjoyed our late afternoon meal. Definitely recommend. read more

Your Pie Pizza - Location & cute sign. - Pizza Near Me - Peachtree City, Georgia

See all

I come about once a month and I haven't been disappointed. The store looks like it's staffed by mostly young high schoolers and they are AWESOME!! They are attentive and friendly. Make tasty pies. I would recommend this place for takeout!! read more

Lotta great times going here with my daughter making her own pizza. Hard to get a glass of wine. But the pizza is good.

My family and I have been to this location several times. Each time it was wonderful. However, tonight we came into the store at 9, they close at 10. So an hour early and people are still in the store. So my daughter was eating and gave me a piece of her pizza, and the pizza dough want cooked all the way. The lady who took our order was more worried about eating with the boy in the booth then making sure our food was all the way cooked. Then I got the chicken bacon panini and the chicken was cold. Luckily it's already cooked, but it wasn't the same as the previous times I have been here. As much as I've enjoyed this place in the past, this was quite a disappointment. read more

See all

I'm visiting from California and this place reminded me of Pieology/Blaze pizza so I had to stop in. I got the veggie pizza and friend got a meat lovers. Pretty good for the price. If your near by come and check it out. read more

See all

Pizza is good and the place is clean. What made this visit great is the fact that the manager was scooping my daughter's gelato and when I asked if any of them had nut it she told me yes and then went to the back and scooped my daughter's gelato for a fresh container just to be safe that there was no cross contamination. As a Chef and having to always be worried about that when I am cooking for people it was nice to have someone show the same care for people. read more

Personal preferences. Servings were small. Wasn't really a place I would visit again but it was quite busy so might be your cup of tea

I love this concept, not that it's unique but the only of it's kind near me. Single serve pizza, made to order in front of you and for oven baked. What could be tastier! Staff is always great and super friendly. More than willing to pile on extras till you say stop. read more

Went to eat here on a Monday and kids Meals are less than $2 and it includes a pizza, drink and dessert! The pizza I got was BBQ chicken and it was so delicious it had such good flavor! The crust to the pizza was sweet and had a glaze on it that paired so well with the other flavors. This is a great family friendly place to check out if you in the area. The parking lot is very large and private. The staff were all very friendly and polite. This is a great place for some local beer as well. read more

See all

My friend recommended me this place and I had a good first time here. The restaurant is nice and open. I placed my ordered and by the time I poured my drink and sat down the pizza was ready! The ingredients were fresh and the pizza was perfectly cooked and crispy. I had the white dough pizza with basil pesto, basil, feta, mozzarella, spinach, and bacon. The employees were nice and helpful. Pricing is pretty good as well. Mines came to a total of exactly $11 which included the pizza and a drink. They also have other delicious options as well like gelato, brownies, etc. Its a great spot to hang out with friends and family. read more

Your Pie Pizza - White dough, basil pesto, basil, spinach, feta, mozzarella, and bacon bits. - Pizza Near Me - Peachtree City, Georgia

Your Pie has a great menu and I've always enjoyed the food I've had from them. The service is fast and the restaurant always seems clean. I highly recommend for anyone! read more

I'm updating my review as we returned to Your Pie in Peachtree City today. The service we received was fantastic. We received hot pizza in a timely matter. The staff was friendly and attentive. The food was great. We will be returning. read more